3 ms·
It can be easily reconciled if there are far more instances of false positives than true positives. Remember that a 99% accuracy for a condition that 0.1% of t
by tsimionescu 4y ago
It can be easily reconciled if there are far more instances of false positives than true positives.
Remember that a 99% accuracy for a condition that 0.1% of the population has still means 10 false positives for each 1 early diagnosis.
I don't what the numbers are for the conditions that the Apple Watch can detect, just discussing the general principle. Whether it's more useful or more harmful depends crucially on the real numbers.
- dagmx 4y agoTheir post said “nothing positive”. That’s different than “not a net positive”.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThere's some amount of luck and marginal effects that need to be discounted, otherwise you couldn't say "nothing positive" about a diagnostic that always says "you are dying", and you couldn't say "nothing positive" about a strategy that has you pick the opposite route and then repeat as many times as you want. And I think such a conclusion would be very dumb. I'm not making a statement on whether the apple watch in particular is close enough to that line.