3 ms·
So from PayPal's perspective you signed up for an account willingly, used it happily for ten years, tripped some fraud detection or other where PayPal now think
by Spivak 4y ago
So from PayPal's perspective you signed up for an account willingly, used it happily for ten years, tripped some fraud detection or other where PayPal now thinks the account may have been compromised and locked it, asked for proof of ID to restore access, and you refused, and asked them to close the account.
What else do you want them to do? There's a bagillion compromised PayPal accounts actively scamming people. It's why PayPal G&S is the gold standard for buying stuff from people online. Like I get that closing the account seems like a safe action but letting someone who isn't the account owner do anything with the account is bad move.
- gaadd33 4y agoWhy is Paypal G&S a better standard than normal credit card protection? Also if part of their offerings is something that is the gold standard in fraud detection and similar, why are there a bagillion of compromised accounts?
- SXX 4y agoNormal credit card protections vary from country to country depend on regulations. E.g it's much easier to get chargeback in US than in many other countries. At the same time PayPal is almost aways side with buyer no matter where account was open.
- Spivak 4y agoMostly because individuals don't take CCs. PayPal G&S is some financial fuckery that can give CC like protections to two randos exchanging goods or services ayyy. Like if you buy concert tickets and they never show or don't work, get your money back. Venmo (which is PayPal so not surprising) and FB Marketplace do the same thing.
- judge2020 4y agoBeing able to dispute online, for one. AFAIK no CC I hold offers a web-based dispute portal.
- bgro 4y agoPayPal created an account without ID, they can close an account without ID. Using your logic, couldn't people just open a fraudulent account because they didn't present an ID? That is a much worse outlook. The account (email) that created the PayPal account is requesting it to be deleted, that should be sufficient. If both accounts have been insecurely breached, that's really the user's fault. PayPal could even mark the account as pending deletion after 30 days if we're really worried about this. You shouldn't be able to stand around and blackmail the user for even more personal information to sell or "accidentally leak" to advertisers under the guise of "security."
- benatkin 4y agoI understand but that reason/excuse only works to a point. They might not need to close it right away but should still close it soon. They should lock the account attempt to contact the person using their contact methods and give them perhaps 30 days (90 at most) in case: - The person asking to close the account isn't the same person the account belongs to, and the person who created the account is on a vacation or something - There is some nefarious activity in progress and closing the account would hamper dealing with it ...and after this they can close the account without demanding the ID.
- harry8 4y agoDo you work in PR? Because that is 100% grade A PR damage control spiel and seems completely plausible and reasonable unless you know better, which both I and they do and so will you shortly. There was no fraud detection, no flags, no payments to me ever. None. Paypal demanded, out of the blue copies of drivers licenses, passports, bank statements etc that they have no right to, claiming they needed them to comply with law. Suspicious much? Well I sure was and am. They have only ever been an online click-clack machine for my credit card and nothing else. Ever. I have the _right_ to refuse to do business with them if they unilaterally change their rules. I have done so. There /can/ be /zero/ fraud possible by closing the account because I don't trust them and going elsewhere to get my credit card processed. From their point of view it would be a negative metric. Better to not have declining account numbers you have to report so just block them. They are just crooks from top to bottom. It's their default response. They are arrogant, obnoxious and deserve to be prosecuted and should be. What I want them to do is repect my wishes not to be associated with them in any way and not to have an identity theft vector avaialble with people and an organisation I have justifiably decided don't trust when I have told them that is what I now want. So f%#k them and anyone sticking up for the crooks they are.
- lomoeffect 4y ago> Paypal demanded, out of the blue copies of drivers licenses, passports, bank statements etc that they have no right to, claiming they needed them to comply with law. I stopped reading your rant here because it's clear you are not familiar with financial regulations.
- screamingninja 4y ago> I stopped reading your rant here because it's clear you are not familiar with financial regulations. I think the issue is with shifting expectations with no clear way to terminate a business relationship. Not sure how being "familiar with financial regulations" would change that. For what it's worth, harry8's post inspired me to close my Paypal account while I still can. Done.
- HaZeust 4y ago
- maxk42 4y agoSigned up willingly? No. Paypal automatically created an account for me when someone "sent" money to my email address 23 fucking years ago.
- ilyt 4y agoBut they have no way to verify the ID is actually him as it was not required to create the account > What else do you want them to do? There's a bagillion compromised PayPal accounts actively scamming people ... actually check using humans and not "algorithm told me it's a fraud, therefore it's a fraud" ? I had dumbassery like that trigger (not on pp) just because I didn't use account for few months then used it once...