3 ms·
The question is whether or not you can ever morally coerce someone to inject something into their body.
by nonethewiser 4y ago
The question is whether or not you can ever morally coerce someone to inject something into their body.
- shadowgovt 4y agoIt's an interesting question but (at least in the US) a culturally very well-settled one. There's an extremely long history of vaccination being required for participation in various aspects of society, from the military to public education. During the pandemic, it broadened to "presence in office." The three tools a society has to defend against rampant disease are hygiene, vaccination, and quarantine. Those who cannot or will not participate in the first two may, if necessary, be handled via the third, and this is pretty bog-standard "How not to have a whole city suffer from typhoid" stuff. As we're talking morality and not the law: there's nothing immoral about "No shirt, no shoes, no service."
- nonethewiser 4y ago> It's an interesting question but (at least in the US) a culturally very well-settled one. The fact that people disagree means that it is not.
- shadowgovt 4y agoHistorically well-settled. This is just the first time this generation of Americans had to deal with an airborne pandemic like this. Many were surprised at the authority government has during a disease crisis (I blame a lack of civic education), but the questions had been asked and answered before they were born. People chafed at the restrictions during the 1918 flu also, and many died who flouted them. Philadelphia saturated the city's capacity to process corpses.
- scoofy 4y agoThis was never in question. What was being debated was "Can we coerce people to inject something into their body if they want to continue to have normal day-to-day interactions with their community. We live with a social contract. The entirety of the state is build on mutual trust. There are avenues to people who are willing to put their neighbors at serious risk because they don't want to inject something, and that's fine.