5 ms·
Are We Prisoners of Geography?
- gsich 4y agoAnswer: no.
- bheadmaster 4y agoSeems like a classic rule of headlines: If the headline is a question, the answer is most likely "no". If the answer was "yes", the headline would be a click-baiting statement ("We Are Prisoners of Geography!").
- esja 4y agoIt is: Betteridge’s Law of Headlines. "Any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headline...
- stackbutterflow 4y agoThere's also "No, we are not prisoners of geography".
- bheadmaster 4y agoThat would sound a lot like: "No, the aliens have not enslaved the Earth" "No, the atmosphere is not on fire from nuclear testing" "No, 2 + 2 is still not 5" I wonder if that would count as news. Paraphrasing Dr. House: I ask you what is two plus two, and you tell me "it's not 15"? If converted into a question, the headline creates the tension, which is then released through the non-informative article. Equally not-news, but that way they at least get the clicks.
- llanowarelves 4y agoYou can also rephrase anything to be a question. Or even a question that sounds silly, so that people say no.
- hikingsimulator 4y agoI knew that Zeihan would pop up before opening the article. Since the start of the 2022 Russian invasion, I've seen him and similar analysts rise in fame and it doesn't sit well with me. It isn't the Stratfor origin, or the blazenly pro-American optimism per se that concern me. It is that these analyses feel like oversimplifications, to not say dumbing-downs -- talks of geographic predestinations. And they are taking some center stages in lobby circles. I fear that they [these types of analyses], however enticing and conforting to a Western ear they may be, might obfuscate realities. Them monopolizing the ears of politicians and business leaders alike can only bite us back.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoOn the contrary, I'm surprised that geography and climate took so long to take center-stage in understanding and analyzing our world. The previous ignorance of something as fundamental as where we live and what climate we live in seems hubristic, if nothing else. Land and climate shape our access to food, shelter, clothing, and security. Food, shelter, clothing, security shape everything else.
- hikingsimulator 4y agoI disagree. These lines of reasoning have always been there. Logistic thinking, and thus geopolitics, has always [i.e. for at least the past century] taken terrain and climate into account. Selling the old as new is a basic marketing ploy. And geopolitics isn't immune to this. Clausewitz talked about logistics and terrain, Sir Lawrence Freedman has too, W. Gardner did, Robert E. Pape too (in the optic of air power).
- mrleinad 4y agoMaybe the previous post meant widespread reasoning? I doubt any of those you mentioned are known by many people.
- hikingsimulator 4y ago
- quickthrower2 4y agoIf it is flatlands you need to invade? I don’t buy it.
- tromp 4y agoAs inhabitant of the Netherlands, I certainly don't either...
- t0rt01se 4y agoI don't buy the "flatlands to the west" either. I'd sooner buy they want some more coastline with warm water. I imagine Canadians on average will be less pleasant if they're stuck with a hostile U.S. to the south.
- gherkinnn 4y agoI don't like geographical determinism. Yes, geography is important. No it is not the sole determining factor. It is very good at confirming pretty much anything but is awful at predicting future events. Pseudo-scientific tosh akin to Freud.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoI can't think of any nation state that was able to surmount its geography on a long-enough timeline.
- paganel 4y agoThe US is the exception that confirms the rule, but mainly because it managed to basically conquer/occupy a continent-size territory, from ocean to ocean. Russia did try the same thing, that's why they managed to reach the Pacific pretty early on, comparatively speaking, i.e. in the late 1600s - early 1700s. It was on the Western side and partially on the Southern side where that wasn't achievable. Late in her life Catherine II (or people close to her, anyway) did dream about having 6 Russian capitals scattered around the Euroasian continent, including in Berlin and Vienna, but that was not achievable (and still isn't, I'd say). Stalin immediately post-WW2 came pretty close to it, though. On the Southern side there were the issues with the Caucasus, Iran/Persia and present-day Afghanistan, which had conflicting results and outcomes for Russia/USSR.
- pydry 4y agoThe US is hardly an exception. It conquered the west, invaded Mexico and even tried to invade Canada once precisely because of this geographical determinism. Its later stability is a testament to just how geographically secure its borders are. If, in an alternate timeline, America was a weakened ex super power and Canada joined the Warsaw Pact I imagine it would take all of 5 minutes for the tanks to roll into Vancouver.
- paganel 4y agoThe US became the US after all the events that you mentioned, I’d say that after 1865. As I said, Russia has been on the same quest of finding insurmountable natural borders that would have defined for it for good, but geography doesn’t help it. And during that quest it also tries to re-define itself in order to reach its final form, so to speak, again, much as red US had done.
- rob74 4y ago> Last year, Russia was at peace and enmeshed in a complex global economy. Would it really sever trade ties – and threaten nuclear war – just to expand its already vast territory? Er, no? This article too chooses to turn a blind eye to Russia occupying Crimea and supporting the separatists in Donbass well before last year, just because the West failed to react appropriately at that time. Which of course emboldened Putin to go all in and try to occupy all of Ukraine.
- f6v 4y ago> occupying Crimea > the West failed to react appropriately at that time As someone born in Crimea I always failed to understand why it’s the West’s business.
- twixfel 4y agoIt's Europe's business when a European country launches a European war of conquest. See: WW2 for what can happen when you just ignore fascist wars of conquest.
- f6v 4y agoWhat’s fascist is to ignore what people living in some place think about it.
- twixfel 4y agoYes, and the Sudeten Germans loved the Nazi German annexation of the Sudetenland, but it was still a criminal and deplorable act that led to WW2 and innumerable crimes. Ethnic nationalism as an excuse for wars of conquest doesn't really fly any more, we've learned it's a dead end, and that's why Europe cares, especially as Russia is clearly a fascist state at this point! Hope that helps.
- f6v 4y ago> clearly a fascist state I think everyone is very confused with what “fascist” means. Some say not having a gender-neural bathroom is “fascist”. But anyway, it seems you’re very set on not liking someone, so it’s better to leave you alone.
- rvba 4y agoPutin invaded Ukraine to secure his own rule (or rule of his clique). It has nothing to do with geopolitics - it is about staying in power. After the Orange Revolution Ukraine started moving towards the West, approached European Union (lots of Ukrainians work in Poland and rest of EU) and started to fight with corruption. This 'westernization' process started to slowly make Ukraine richer. A rich Ukraine is an end of Putin's rule, because average Russians would realize that Russia could be a normal country too and they could be rich too, instead of living without toilets and being robbed by oligarchs. But in order to do that they would have to get rid of Putin and his clique. So Putin tried to conquer Ukraine and when this failed, plan B is to ruin its economy. This way Ukraine is as poor or poorer than Russia. This way Putin can secure his power.
- f6v 4y ago> This 'westernization' process started to slowly make Ukraine richer. I don’t think Ukraine reached even the pre-2014 prosperity levels by February 2022. You need to separate wishful thinking and hard data.
- akoncius 4y agowhere is your hard data?
- f6v 4y agoComparing the data from Ukrainian ministry of finance for late 2013 and late 2021, the average salary is about the same when accounting for UAH/USD exchange rates and inflation.
- agapon 4y agoThinking is good, but why "think" when you can just check the facts? Follow your own advice on hard data.
- roey2009 4y agoNot necessarily correct. The reason of the invasion might be because of russian adherence to the heartland theory, creating defensive depth. Might be Putin's megalomania, need for approval rating back home, maybe the oil prices rose and they took the opportunity, maybe to prevent Ukraine from joining the EU/NATO. Could be a thousand and one differing things, or all of them at once. What is correct? No one but Putin (and maybe not even him) knows.
- amelius 4y agoVisiting this link gave me a consistent "Gah. Your tab just crashed." in Firefox (tried 3 times). And it seems to be happening more often lately. Is this just me?
- glomph 4y agoFirefox Android seems to often crash on the Guardian for me and I have not been able to work out why or find anyone else talking about it.
- just4Acomment 4y agoI have this exact problem. I think there is some sort of memory consumption problem and the Android version of the oomkiller jumps in Only see this on the guardian and only on mobile
- bmacho 4y ago(Works for me on firefox, windows 10. Although Firefox is ridiculously unstable for me in general)
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y agoIn general, or just on the Guardian? Anyway, doesn't happen here on FF 107 und Linux with µBo. With always fresh cookies.
- Kaibeezy 4y agoWhy Russia is invading Ukraine, RealLifeLore, YouTube, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33019630 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33019630 I thought this video explained exceptionally well. Also includes analysis of oil-and-gas as a contributing factor. I posted it a few weeks ago. It was published before the start of the war.
- nuccy 4y agoSam Harris in his Making Sense podcast interviewed Timothy Snyder [1] about this topic, they had a decent dive into the history, relationship between the countries and meaning of the war for both sides. 1. https://www.samharris.org/podcasts/making-sense-episodes/301-the-politics-of-unreality-ukraine-and-nuclear-risk https://www.samharris.org/podcasts/making-sense-episodes/301... the interview starts at about 13:30.
- k__ 4y agoWe obviously are. I have more in common with the punks in Poland than with the conservatives that vote with me here in my city.
- m0llusk 4y agoIt is interesting that changing military capacities have changed the impact of geography on politics and war. What really gets me are some of the things that have not changed. Resources make nations weak. Interconnection with other nations in trade, research, and development makes nations strong. Now more than ever Russia has the potential to leverage its lack of resources and connections with European and Asian countries to become the kind of major global power that it wants to be. But the only way to do that is to give up on old ideas about geography, power, and wealth.