6 ms·
IBM LinuxONE Emperor 4 servers can reduce energy consumption by 75%
- Andys 4y agoWhen it must be so expensive its not even "call us", but "Schedule a Consultation". You fit in with their schedule, not the other way around?
- nix23 4y agoPff it's IBM you buy the Consultant with it, he sits in the lower rack and has spacefood rations for 5 years, then you have to do maintenance and the consultant get exchanged and retired. But!! No shutdown needed.
- Our_Benefactors 4y agoCan they be put on a generator bike? I’m concerned about their carbon footprint.
- hyperdimension 4y agoWhat carbon footprint? The consultants are not much more than sequestered carbon! (A fancy insult, now that I think of it. Nice.)
- nix23 4y ago>carbon footprint. They have zeolite in the rack (like in the ISS). The food is also non methane producing.
- broodbucket 4y agoNonsense, there would be at least one more redundant consultant if not two. Seriously though, these machines call home when there's a hardware failure, they'll fail over and someone will show up to replace what failed. Enterprise tech is sometimes cool.
- nix23 4y ago>Nonsense, there would be at least one more redundant consultant if not two. Gosh you are right i always forget him. >Seriously though, these machines call home when there's a hardware failure, HP's EVA Device did that too, so sometimes a Engineer calls you and ask's if "we" have time to update the firmware, not even HP engineers are allowed to do EVA updates...just specialized EVA ones.
- xhkkffbf 4y agoThis is pretty standard across much of the enterprise world. The sales team just has to earn their commission. Indeed, even when they have publicly listed prices, it's usually possible to negotiate a substantial discount by dealing directly with the sales team. Like 50% is often possible.
- Andys 4y agoYeah, I know. Just poking fun of their level of hype being such that they make it sound like you are one of a privileged few if they even take your call and allow you to buy this apparent masterpiece.
- broodbucket 4y agoThe general rule of thumb is if the product page says "contact us" instead of a price, you can't afford it. It is a shame though. IBM has no idea how to sell to anyone other that gigantic megacorps - which, fair enough, but they could probably pick up a lot of sales to medium-sized businesses if they weren't so old-fashioned about everything
- wmf 4y agoMedium-sized businesses can easily buy IBM stuff through VARs. (If your VAR does not recommend any IBM products, that's a different situation.) If you're smart enough to buy IT directly then you're probably also smart enough to realize that very few IBM products are good.
- artificialLimbs 4y agoOur IBM was the ONLY thing that didn't get vaporized when we got ransomwared. Tens of linux boxes, MS servers, 3rd party who knows what the f they are, all gone. Poof.
- Stranger43 4y agoTo be honest you should not be buying this level of equipment "off the peg" without a serious pre-sales process of evaluation and sizing unless you have significant prior experience, and the people with that experience will already have some kind partner agreement in place. It's much more like placing an order for an container full of severs based on an reference design from an OEM then going to HPE or Dell for a commodity x64 system.
- wmf 4y agoIf you buy an IBM mainframe you'll have a very attentive full-time account manager for life. I did a ride-along with such an account manager once when I was working at IBM and it was eye-opening.
- christophilus 4y agoWhen the cloud was first really taking off, I had a friend who swore by his mainframes, touting high reliability, great performance, excellent customer service. It would be interesting to do a cost comparison.
- wmf 4y agoI'm going to channel the efficient market hypothesis (I apologize) here and say that people have done that cost comparison and not one of them bought mainframes. Heck, Google ported their entire monorepo to Power but not to z.
- bombcar 4y agoMainframes can still be "cost effective" for, well, the type of companies that buy mainframes heh. It's companies who don't treat ANY of their IT as anything but a "Someone else deal with this, oh, and never let it fail".
- hestefisk 4y agoLots and lots of banks (and non banks) rely on IBM mainframe still and will for years to come. They have done this calculation on whether to replatform and migrate several times. It’s very hard to stand up a positive npv for such an idea unfortunately. I guess greenfield is very different.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dillab2 4y agoThe thing is, there aren't really any successful greenfield developments in these types of business spaces. So either these are industries that are exceptionally difficult to break into (which I think is at least partially true), or the type of computing they do actually benefits from being done on a mainframe (which is also true given that there is a lot of record processing for these industries, and not too much serving lots of web requests to users). Of course, all of these companies also have x86 servers that run the customer facing web apps and stuff. You really wouldn't want to waste your MSUs running web servers, although I'll admit I don't know if these new Linux mainframes are charged by rolling avg MSUs or other MSU metrics. Traditionally, Linux on Z has had more favorable pricing due to the ability to use IFLs and basically just declare that a cores MSU usage doesn't count towards your licensing since it's been locked to only running Linux.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rch 4y agoIt's not immediately clear either way, but I'm guessing this is based on composable / software defined infrastructure components, like e.g. CXL memory.
- wmf 4y agoNo, because that stuff does not exist.
- dragontamer 4y agoIf its from IBM Telum processors, this is the weird processor where a processor's L2 cache serves as the L3 and L4 caches of other processors. The processors network with each other, notice when they're not using all of their caches, and shares that cache with things far away (ie: in side the box, or even outside the box). This way, IBM can overprovision L2 cache and "not worry" about it going unused. Remote L2 cache is slower than local L2 cache, but its still SRAM and should still be faster than DRAM to access.
- rch 4y agoMakes sense. I'd seen Telum in the description, but I guess I was inferring too much from a note about 'changing workloads'.
- datameta 4y agoThere is even L4, which is accessing the L3 of another drawer - which in some cases is faster than accessing DRAM in the same drawer!
- webmobdev 4y agoSharing the cache is innovative. What architecture do these processors run - powerpc?
- wmf 4y agoz/Architecture
- 4y ago
- treis 4y agoThis is the fine print: >Compared 5 IBM Machine Type 3931 Max 125 model consists of three CPC drawers containing 125 configurable cores (CPs, zIIPs, or IFLs) and two I/O drawers to support both network and external storage versus 192 x86 systems with a total of 10364 cores. IBM Machine Type 3931 power consumption was based on inputs to the IBM Machine Type 3931 IBM Power Estimation Tool for a memo configuration. x86 power consumption was based on March 2022 IDC QPI power values for 7 Cascade Lake and 5 Ice Lake server models, with 32 to 112 cores per server. All compared x86 servers were 2 or 4 socket servers. IBM Z and x86 are running 24x7x365 with production and non-production workloads. Savings assumes a Power Usage Effectiveness (PUE) ratio of 1.57 to calculate additional power for data center cooling. PUE is based on Uptime Institute 2021 Global Data Center Survey (https://uptimeinstitute.com/about-ui/press-releases/uptime-institute-11th-annual-global-data-center-survey https://uptimeinstitute.com/about-ui/press-releases/uptime-i...). CO2e and other equivalencies that are based on the EPA GHG calculator (https://www.epa.gov/energy/greenhouse-gas-equivalencies-calculator https://www.epa.gov/energy/greenhouse-gas-equivalencies-calc...) use U.S. National weighted averages. Results may vary based on client-specific usage and location.
- nisa 4y agoWondering how a dual socket AMD EPYC™ 9654 system with 2x96 cores would compare. It's not clear how many 14nm+ Cascade Lake machines were used and it's also not clear how many 32core machines were used. 10364cores/192servers averages about 53 cores/server. It's apple and oranges anyway because I guess if you consider this you have different priorities but I'm skeptical that x86 couldn't come close in terms of performance/watt
- adrian_b 4y agoIt is certain that the new 5-nm AMD Genoa CPUs have a better energy efficiency than the 7-nm IBM CPUs, for the applications that are executed on the CPU. Nevertheless, for certain workloads this IBM server might have a better energy efficiency, when they can exploit some of the many accelerators that exist in the IBM server, for offloading some tasks from the CPU. Intel pursues now the same strategy, because the soon-to-be-introduced Sapphire Rapids cannot beat AMD Genoa in a CPU vs. CPU competition, Intel stresses now the advantages offered by the accelerators that they have included in Sapphire Rapids, following the traditional IBM model.
- throwawayacc4 4y agoSaving a click: this is with IBM Telum processors that use the z/Architecture instruction set (versus x86-64).
- robotnikman 4y agoI didn't even know IBM was still designing their own processors.
- dragontamer 4y agoIBM has at least two processor families being made. POWER10 (and multiple versions of that), as well as this Telum chip.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- miohtama 4y agoWhat is the Linux distro powering this beast?
- wmf 4y agoRHEL, SLES, or Ubuntu.
- radicaldreamer 4y agoMore info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linux_on_IBM_Z https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linux_on_IBM_Z
- pabs3 4y agoDebian supports s390x, hopefully it can be used too.
- _davide_ 4y ago
- datameta 4y ago15 years would fit about 5 generations of POWER servers and Z mainframes...
- oneplane 4y agoLots of numbers, but no price or COTS delivery speed comparison, so what's the point here?
- kstrauser 4y agoFrom the pricing link at https://www.ibm.com/blogs/systems/announcing-ibm-linuxone-iii-express-and-tailored-fit-pricing/ https://www.ibm.com/blogs/systems/announcing-ibm-linuxone-ii... : > Starting at $135,000 USD*, the single-configuration LinuxONE III Express is designed as a new cost-effective offering for the most popular workloads, including data serving and Red Hat® OpenShift®. IBM internal tests show that a 12-core IBM LinuxONE III Express server running WebSphere and Db2 workloads requires 18.7 times fewer cores when compared to x86 servers and delivers a 57% lower TCO over three years. They go one to explain their benchmark in the footnotes. I don't know how to translate from IBM units to something that an organization with a mortal-sized checkbook would already be using, though.
- LoganDark 4y ago"Cost-effective"
- StillBored 4y agoIts worse because as I read it the base system isn't the config they are actually comparing. So based on personal experience with low end z/series machines in the past, basically the base price quoted ends up doubling by the time disk/software/etc all get added. Then what you have is a machine which is intended for DR situations, so the CPU "capacity" is limited to the point where its enough to boot the machine and little else. Then in order to match the named perf, what happens is that you cycle to a higher capacity tier (for $$$$$$$ of course). These marketing materials basically need an IBM decoder ring, and its on purpose because if they just published the TPC-C/$ numbers everyone would be able to compare the machine vs the competition, and it likely wouldn't look good. So the benchmarks are contrived the same way apple was contriving altivec/photoshop benchmarks in the early 2000's. Sure with this one benchmark the machine is 10x faster than the competition but for these other 99 benchmarks its 1/2 the speed kinds of thing. I'm sure buried in the IBM license there remains a restriction on publishing benchmarks. Which maybe at some point I will post my own personal results running on an older machine when I don't think IBM would be able to trace me... but that said, lets say, in the past these numbers were cooked in such a way that the absolute top of the line machines were roughly equivilant to a mid-range x86 server available for about $40k. Now that said, if you can use all 40TB of redundant ram, and your workload needs 100 PCIe slots that it can only drive at about 1/100th of the total bandwidth (aka you need them for connectivity with the ability to burst at line rate) then sure, the zseries can come out ahead. But frankly your probably doing it wrong if you plug in 20 100Gbit adapters that average 10Gbit each. I'm guessing a large part of the posted efficiency of these machines comes from the ML accelerator they now have, which gives them the ability to optimize some ML+DB type of workload that requires a big fat nvidia GPU under normal circumstances but doesn't make good use of it (or they are just comparing it to a x86 without a GPU...).
- hsnewman 4y agoThat is some marketing wank.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- midislack 4y agoBut is it worth the enormous additional cost over something like SuperMicro? You could pay 1/3rd and give the rest of the money to Earth First.
- hinkley 4y agoMy dad the data processor told a story decades ago about how when they swapped out the mini computers at work for new machines, they started getting condensation in the server rooms because the AC tonnage so outclassed the BTUs of the servers that the temperature would drop like a rock when the units cycled on. "Reduce energy consumption by 75%" sounds like exactly that sort of, "Remind the customer to call their other vendors to schedule an appointment" situation.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoMight be misunderstanding something but wouldn't the condensation happen after the AC shut down (presumably after over cooling the room)? A _cool_ story nevertheless
- hinkley 4y agoDon't think I've ever thought too hard about it. Thinking 'out loud': If you heat or cool a whole room by changing out the air in it, then the humidity or dew point should be whatever was in the heat pump, so you might get condensation on glass walls between rooms but you shouldn't get any in the room. But in general you're pumping really cold or really hot air into a room and doing only a partial air change and the blower is supposed to stir the room up to even out the temperature. I had to look it up because I wasn't sure, but the amount of humidity air can hold is in fact a curve, not a flat line. So if you mix one unit of very cold air (below the dew point) with four units of ambient air (also below the dew point), it does seem like the dew point of the resulting air might be higher than the temperature. Some server rooms get too dry and moisture has to be added back in to prevent static discharge damaging electronics. That might be the sort of thing he wouldn't have been aware of but was part of the equation. There's also the possibility that he was fucking with me.
- toast0 4y agoYou don't generally exchange air with the heatpump, you're blowing the conditioned air through a radiator and the heat transfers from the air to the coolant which evaporates; the coolant is piped (pumped) to the outside equipment where there's a condensor and another radiator where the heat is transfered to the outside air. Anyway, if everything is working properly, you more or less get a fixed delta T between the inlet and the outlet of the air handler while the system is running. If you eliminate a lot of the heat load, your inlet temperature might not get as hot, also even if it does get as hot when the A/C is off, when it turns on, it may cool down much quicker and then you may overcool; especially if the A/C has a minimum cycle time. As you say, when you cool air, the humidity capacity drops. Most air handlers have some capacity to remove humidity, but it's no absolute. If you drop the temperature too much, relative humidity will be really high and it will condense on all sorts of surfaces.