4 ms·
> Email is the example I give people of how federation could work... You can't get banned from email. Except e-mail has been a total failure when it comes to s
by crazygringo 4y ago
> Email is the example I give people of how federation could work... You can't get banned from email.
Except e-mail has been a total failure when it comes to spam/abuse, and in practice it isn't this federated, decentralized paradise at all -- virtually everyone I know uses Gmail for their personal account. And if you want to run your own server, good luck getting Gmail to accept your e-mails at all.
And if you can't get Gmail to trust your server, that's pretty much a ban for all practical purposes.
- jmbwell 4y agoPlenty of organizations and individuals run their own servers and have no problem exchanging email with Google, Microsoft, and other large providers. The point is that they can and do because the system is not, in fact, centralized. Also, judged only on the volume of spam and abuse, many systems besides email -- decentralized and centralized alike -- could be called a "total failure." And yet somehow these systems remain stable and functional and useful.
- joecot 4y agoThe only problem with doing this could be mail deliverability. But if you setup SPF/DKIM/DMARC, and use a mail service, it works fine if you're not spamming. Mailgun, Amazon SES, Mxroute, they'll all deliver your mail and for cheap. There's no single point of failure needed to get your mail delivered.
- xiaomai 4y agoYou don't need to use a delivery service. It's true you need to set up SPF/DKIM/DMARC for many peers to accept mail from you, but then you can deliver the mail yourself directly.
- joecot 4y agoYes, this is true, but I still get better delivery through delivery services. For example a lot of email providers send any email coming from a cloud hosting IP directly to spam.
- nijave 4y agoEven with that most big providers (looking at Outlook) still use IP reputation. Some popular email blacklist providers will list entire /24s if they receive enough abuse complaints so you generally need a high quality provider that takes abuse seriously to prevent getting caught up with a bad neighbor or your own IP block. After using the same Digital Ocean IP for 8 years, I got unlucky and their /24 block got listed on spamhaus (or mailcop, or similar) and major providers (Outlook and Gmail) stopped accepting messages from my server. It works great until it doesn't
- secabeen 4y agoFor some definitions of fine, sure. I run my own mail, and relay it through an AWS EC2 instance that I've used on the same IP for over 5 years. It took an exceptional effort over many months to get off the Hotmail blacklist a while back. I still wonder when emailing someone I've never emailed before if that message will go do a Junk folder, or be delivered. The benefits outweigh the costs, but it is not easy, and you can start having problems that are very hard to solve.
- js2 4y agoNo one called it a paradise. That's a strawman argument. I've been using my own domain for my email for over two decades. In that time it's been self-hosted, hosted with Google, and hosted with Fastmail. I control it, so I can take it wherever I want. I've been able to take my full message history with me too. It has not been a "total failure" with spam/abuse either, though I'm glad to have Fastmail handle that for me these days. In any case, I'll take the tradeoffs over a centralized system.
- vidarh 4y agoSame position here, and having the ability to move my domain is by far the most important to me. And also why my medium to long term plan is to move my Mastodon setup to my own domains. > though I'm glad to have Fastmail handle that for me these days. I get less spam in my Fastmail account than on my remaining Gmail accounts, but far more importantly for me: I get far fewer false positives with Fastmail. The amount of real mail that used to end up in my Gmail spam folder made the spam filtering pretty much pointless because I ended up going through the spam folder daily anyway.
- FpUser 4y ago>"I've been using my own domain for my email for over two decades." Same here since the end of the 90s. Completely agree with the rest of your post.
- blowski 4y agoI receive as much social media spam as I do email.
- piccolbo 4y agoBut that's enabled by the DNS MX record. There isn't anything like that for social AFAIK, so if you wanted to do the same with your mastodon account you are hosed. Some people are saying once you have million followers on mastdon.social, you are not going to restart from zero on mastodon.net. You can, but it's hard. So centralized or federated, without handle portability, it's not very different. You are stuck. It seems to me federated mail and federated social are similar for people who don't own their DNS entry (gmail addresses), but for people like you, that's a substantial difference. You'd have to run your own instance to have your own social handle, and that isn't portability, that's DIY. It only works for a small number of techies, you have to have an instance and a domain.
- 98codes 4y agoAnd when I wanted to rid myself of all things Google, nobody needed to know, I didn't need to rebuild my contacts -- I moved my custom domain to a different provider, done and done. Beyond that, Twitter is rife with spam, scams, and tons of other abuse. So is Facebook. So is reddit. The fact that email doesn't work that way doesn't matter.
- athenot 4y agoMy email addresses do get more spam than, say my Twitter DMs. But my email provider (not Gmail) is good at identifying most and my own Mail client can pick up the rest. So the net number of spam emails in my email inbox is less than 1 per week. On Twitter, for me it's at least 1 per day and there's nothing I can do to tweak the filtering.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- firecall 4y agoSadly, this is very true! It's a total nightmare out there! I have clients on big Hosts like SiteGround, and sending email is a problem! I'm 100% in support of the idea that services should be protocols though! :-)
- UncleEntity 4y ago> virtually everyone I know uses Gmail for their personal account. Which, ironically enough, is the answer to everyone’s problems with mastodon. Does everyone you know use gmail for their business accounts? Does absolutely, 100% of the people you know use gmail for personal accounts? I’m going to go out on a limb and say no to both the above. There’s no reason mastodon has to be everyone runs their own server just like everyone doesn’t have to run their email server today. People use the company server for work stuff and fluffycat233575@yahoo.com for personal stuff. I don’t know if it’s just the HN bubble but all people post is why it can’t (or shouldn’t, because, get off my lawn) work. It’s like people have a vested interest in making sure non-adtech doesn’t succeed, almost like their very livelihoods depended on it. —edit— And, back in the day, spam filtering was something you had to do on your own or just dealt with all the spam. The big email providers became big in part because they solved that problem for most everyone. In ‘97 nobody (OK, nobody but the US postal service) was saying there needed to be this gigantic corporation monitoring everyone’s emails for wrongthink or only a central entity could solve the spam problem. People just bucked down and solved the problem enough to get a sizable portion of the population using email…I’m genuinely curious if there’s ever been a technology with higher uptake than email now.
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> The big email providers became big in part because they solved that problem for most everyone. Yes, and the major way in which they did it also made it hard to self-host an e-mail server. > I don’t know if it’s just the HN bubble but all people post is why it can’t (or shouldn’t, because, get off my lawn) work. It’s like people have a vested interest in making sure non-adtech doesn’t succeed, almost like their very livelihoods depended on it. Perhaps it's true in some cases, but I think it's more likely that people here recognize the new federated communication services are structurally equivalent to e-mail, so there's little reason to expect they'll end up in a better state than e-mail did. On the contrary, there are reasons to expect they'll end up worse, because e-mail had the benefit of predating the commercialized web and mass adoption of the Internet by not tech-savvy people.
- spion 4y ago
- tombert 4y agoFWIW, I have been using ProtonMail for about four years for my personal email, and I haven't had any issues with communicating with folks from Gmail or Outlook. Regardless, I don't think it's contradictory that people flock towards a somewhat-centralized system like Gmail; the point is that it still supports an open protocol. The fact that Protonmail "just works" when emailing Gmail is a testament to the fact that federation can work in practice, even if it does start becoming more centralized.
- dredmorbius 4y agoAlso on Protonmail. I haven't been able to send mail to Pocket support for about a year based on Gmail blocking. YMMV.
- bodangly 4y agoI’ve had a different experience. I have been mysteriously appearing in surbl periodically ever since I switched to ProtonMail. Never had that problem in like 10 years of owning my domain, but within a month of ProtonMail sure enough, I started having deliverability issues. I usually get removed fairly quickly but it was still extremely disruptive when important emails would randomly not get delivered. It hasn’t recurred in a year or so, but the situation with no calendar integration is driving me crazy. That’s another topic… I think I am done w Proton though and am going to give in and sell my soul back to the devil.
- yreg 4y agorelated: After self-hosting my email for twenty-three years I have thrown in the towel. The oligopoly has won. https://cfenollosa.com/blog/after-self-hosting-my-email-for-twenty-three-years-i-have-thrown-in-the-towel-the-oligopoly-has-won.html https://cfenollosa.com/blog/after-self-hosting-my-email-for-... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32715437 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32715437
- rodgerd 4y ago> And if you want to run your own server, good luck getting Gmail to accept your e-mails at all. I still can, but only because I hate myself enough to run my own email for more than 20 years, so there must be some magic field of trust somewhere in the background. I wouldn't start from scratch though.
- wink 4y agoYou live in a weird bubble if that's the case, or maybe in the USA. Or both. Less flippant, very few companies except startups and one person shops use GMail in Germany. I'm no fan of Outlook and Exchange, but that doesn't mean I can just ignore it away.