9 ms·
I probably don't have much to contribute, but I wanted to share some thoughts on the concept of free will Paul seems to brush against. I found the concept of f
by sph 4y ago
I probably don't have much to contribute, but I wanted to share some thoughts on the concept of free will Paul seems to brush against.
I found the concept of free will at odds with my opinion that the brain and physics are very deterministic. But one thing the "free will doesn't exist" people tend to forget, is that the brain rewires and changes itself.
You are destined to do what your brain is wired to do, but doing anything rewires your brain. Some say even thought is able to rewire your brain. The number of possible brain states at T+n increases exponentially. So our constant reconfiguration of the brain is our way out of determinism. That is, free will does exist in a completely deterministic universe [1]
I shared because maybe someone can suggest some reading material along these lines from someone much smarter than me. But for now, I enjoy the idea that I have complete freedom in a very ordered universe.
1: there are some interesting corollaries to this idea. One among them is that the interaction between other entities with similar free will (other people) increases the complexity even further. We are agents of chaos.
- oezi 4y agoAs far as we know the universe isn't deterministic.
- sph 4y agoDo we know it is non-deterministic, or do we not have any proof it's one way or the other?
- api 4y agoAFAIK hidden variable models have been ruled out in many quantum scenarios. It really does appear that the universe is not deterministic.
- jagrsw 4y agoIt opens itself up to interesting interpretations ;). god(s) aka the simulation developer(s) playing with outcomes of quantum events in order to manipulate your/my behavior, punish the bad, reward the good, make the bushes burn etc. Since quantum events can have macroscopic outcomes, this should be possible? :)
- sph 4y agoIt's probably due to artefacts and signal noise coming from the outer-system that contains our universe and/or the machine running our simulation, rather than God.
- SkyPuncher 4y agoCombining this with an infinite universe theory, it could also just be random noise intentionally introduced to a specific "instance" of a universe.
- oezi 4y agoTo the best of our ability we haven't been able to detect any signs of any strings which might point to a puppet master or any mechanism by which anything as potentially informationally massive as randomness could be transferred to 'our' universe.
- mistermann 4y agoNot quite: there are millions of people who claim the existence of a God(s), or claim to have had "experiences" with the same. However, to those raised in secular environments, these claims "have" "no" validity, but this is actually just the model of reality built by the mind (what "is", in "reality"), which is heavily influenced by the metaphysical framework one was raised/trained on, or exists within. Philosophy (logic, epistemology, etc) has more appropriate tools and techniques for dealing with such questions, but if one (one's mind) has been trained that only the scientific method can provide knowledge, they are kind of stuck at a local maxima (inside a "simulated reality dome") that they are unable to see out of, or typically even want to see out of.
- oezi 4y agoI think people do not deny those religious experiences because there are experiments to trigger them and the experiences can be observed for instance using brain scans. But what scientists deny is that we see any prove that these experiences have any supernatural cause.
- dinosaurdynasty 4y agoYou don't need hidden variables to have deterministic quantum mechanics (many-worlds is deterministic without hidden variables, and we haven't ruled out global hidden variables or superdeterminism afaik)
- oezi 4y agoThe things we can observe about the universe tell us that it is non-deterministic. You have to assume things we haven't been able to observe to construct our universe as deterministic. And it is pretty simple things such as radioactive decay of a single atom in a vacuum which are pretty easy to grasp.
- jagrsw 4y ago> brain and physics are very deterministic Not to get too much into the 'quantum woo' territory, but my naive understanding is that the physics is only somewhat deterministic, b/c non-deterministic quantum events can have macroscopic effects? Say you decide for whether you'll eat a dinner, if a particle with half-time of 1 second will split within the next second. This you wouldn't be able to predict, even if you knew momenta of all particles within your local light-cone (of 1 light-second), no? (a variation of the Schroedinger's cat)
- AlexandrB 4y agoThe problem is quantum effects are random. Even if they impact our behavior, RNG is not what most people think of when they say "free will". In my opinion, any coherent definition of "free will" implies a supernatural force - since it must be non-random yet not bound by deterministic chemical and physical processes. At this point it becomes a matter of faith/religion whether we have free will or not.
- pydry 4y agoAre there any coherent definitions of free will? I dont think I've ever seen a disprovable definition. It's like "god" or "love".
- drdeca 4y agoI think I can give some sufficient conditions for a case in which I would consider someone to have “ceased to have free will”. If someone X with some manner of advanced brain altering technology was able to temporarily force someone Z’s actions to be whatever X specified into the machine, with afterwards Z remembered the experience as their taking these actions for whatever reasons X specified in the input (where this is achieved by influencing whatever is going on in Z’s head at the time, not via altering memories), then, during that duration, I think it would make sense to say that Z “did not have free will” for that duration. As for sufficient conditions for someone to have “free will”, I suppose I don’t have a great description. However, “what/who we are is the primary explanation for what we do (and so in particular, no external influence/manipulation is a primary explanation)” seems, like it has at least something right towards the goal of a good definition.
- solarist 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compatibilism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compatibilism (But personally I don’t think that your argument holds) Also http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2020/10/you-dont-have-free-will-but-dont-worry.html http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2020/10/you-dont-have-free-...
- wodenokoto 4y ago> I found the concept of free will at odds with my opinion that the brain and physics are very deterministic. Physics don't have to be deterministic in order to be at odds with free will. Whether neurons fire due to a predefined pattern, or they fire with some probabilities do not change the equation for "how can a biological machine have free will?" Choice is at odds with both predefined rules and drawing from a random variable. > You are destined to do what your brain is wired to do, but doing anything rewires your brain. Some say even thought is able to rewire your brain. The number of possible brain states at T+n increases exponentially. So our constant reconfiguration of the brain is our way out of determinism. That is, free will does exist in a completely deterministic universe. I completely fail to see how you ended up at that conclusion from that argument. A recursive function, that mutates itself is still bound by it's rules for mutation and recursiveness. Choice doesn't grow out of an exponentially growing number of possible states.
- sph 4y agoI have tried to answer to your last paragraph in 2 or 3 different ways but it's such a complex argument I don't think I'm smart enough to express simply and eloquently in a forum comment. But I very much appreciate the food for thought and input you've given me.
- csdvrx 4y ago> I completely fail to see how you ended up at that conclusion from that argument. A recursive function, that mutates itself is still bound by it's rules for mutation and recursiveness. Choice doesn't grow out of an exponentially growing number of possible states. Not if you add a few random variables. Radioactive elements disintegration seems random. May other things could be as well.
- snowwrestler 4y agoYou’re starting from a definition of free will that is a modern outlier compared to the historical use of the term in Western culture. That our will is not completely free is obvious to a child: they can’t always get they want. They can’t will an ice cream cone into existence. “Free will” never meant freedom from physics, so it’s a tautology to say it’s not free because of physics. > A recursive function, that mutates itself is still bound by it's rules for mutation and recursiveness. It doesn’t matter. If the recursive function results in all possible outcomes within a boundary (as many do), then anything operating entirely within that boundary is not constrained by the function. There are a lot of things denied to human will by physics. I can’t will myself up into the air or will myself to live forever without food. Inside those boundaries, my behavior cannot be said to be constrained by physics. I don’t violate the standard model of quantum physics by declining dessert because I’m trying to lose weight. Which is the sort of banal decision that “free will” has historically referred to. > Choice doesn't grow out of an exponentially growing number of possible states. This is backward. The right way to say this is that many human choices are not constrained by the number of available states.
- wnkrshm 4y agoEven without quantum effects, determinism doesn't enable us to do much with it, except statistical ensemble predictions. We can never know the initial state of a system to infinite precision, as is needed to predict its trajectory. [0] [0] Light-ish reading on nonlinear dynamics: James Gleick - Chaos: Making a New Science
- bjarneh 4y ago> but I wanted to share Are you sure?
- slothtrop 4y agoThe weakness of the perfect determinism model is nothing would ever happen if it were true. The leap to bacteria to mitochondrion to humans was not pre-determined, randomness is part of the equation. I could buy that will isn't free in an absolute sense, but neither is it entirely deterministic. The question is whether the confounding factor for the latter has anything to do with the individual, but you can't divorce it from nature. There's no meaningful difference between "you chose x" and "your brain chose x". There's also a socio-cultural reason I dislike pure determinism which is that it's used as bludgeon to absolve one of responsibility, justify inaction, bad behavior, or Socialism.
- scott_w 4y agoWhile I don't think the universe is deterministic, the existence of evolution isn't proof of this. It's possible that what we perceive as "randomness" is actually just the result of variables and things happening that we're not able to perceive. Take rolling a dice: which number comes up is determined by the starting conditions, the force you throw it with, what it lands on and any external forces acting during the throw. It's not random at all, just hard to predict.
- slothtrop 4y agoWell you can't conflate the banality of rolling dice with evolution. Based on what I've read, randomness has been a necessity for it's fruition, but of course this isn't my field.
- scott_w 4y agoMy point was we call both “random” but, when you think deeply about it, you know that rolling a dice isn’t really random, we just can’t reliably predict the outcome. There’s no reason the “random chance” in evolution is any different. It can just contain a million times more complexity in its determinism. To prove determinism one way or another, we need to prove the fundamental building blocks of the universe are deterministic (or not).
- SkyPuncher 4y ago> I found the concept of free will at odds with my opinion that the brain and physics are very deterministic. IMO, this is the prime example of theory vs practice. In my opinion, our universe is deterministic at a theoretical level, but will never be practically deterministic. * Everything is likely made of a fundamental building block that can be predicted and modeled. In isolation, there is a small enough system that can be represented deterministically. * The universe is far, far too complex to apply determinism in any meaningful way. * Any device able to model the determinism of the universe at a fundamental would itself be non-deterministic. That devices would either (1) need to model itself - which would be infinitely recursive since the model of itself would also need to model itself (2) isolated from the universe - which is currently impossible and also implies that our universe is a simulation within another system (3) operate on abstractions/simplifications - which leaves room for error. * Finally, determinism is only practically useful if it can be used to (1) repeatedly generate the same results for the same inputs (2) or, predict the results based on knowing the inputs. * 1. This will never be possible because we operate within the system being modeled. That system progresses forward and the same inputs can never be utilized more than once (some variable somewhere would be different). * 2. We are so incredibly far from modeling determinism that it's still impossible to predict results for known inputs. There will always be unknown in a model that leads to error.
- sph 4y agoPrecisely, and very well said. My understanding is that our will is still deterministic, but cannot be determined within the bounds of our universe. So effectively, in this universe and within this universe, our free will cannot be simulated nor predicted over even a pretty short amount of time.
- SuoDuanDao 4y agoRegarding reading suggestions, you'd probably like Wolfram's cellular Automata theory. accessible intro: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ez773teNFYA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ez773teNFYA
- roberttod 4y agoYour description of rewiring the brain is an extra feedback loop, makes the system more complex but doesn't break determinism. Regardless, even if the world isn't deterministic through e.g. quantum mechanics, throwing dice to decide your next turn isn't "free will" and doesn't make the case for free will any stronger.
- shrthnd 4y agoSuppose there are n number of hidden, indeterminate variables in your environment... "You," the individual observer, are free to choose the important variables to navigate life. Your "mind" is the thing which assigns value to hidden variables in your environment but "the mind" is not you... the "mind," from my perspective, is the mirror upon which we witness/experience every day reality/waking life, etc. If you think rolling dice is important, it is. If you think randomness will effect and experiment, it will. If you don't think randomness is important, it probably is... (a thing is defined by what it is not.) When you assign an indeterminate (X) value to randomness, this is chaos. If/when you think or realize chaos is an important part of free will... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Are you personally unable to select new variables or assign different "weights"? If so, I contend, you don't exist.
- dinosaurdynasty 4y agoI'm pretty sure the answer to "do we have free will" is "no", and the much more interesting question is "why do we feel that we have free will?" which I don't know the answer to.
- maroonblazer 4y agoAndy Clark, in his book "Surfing Uncertainty", has a pretty convincing explanation, at least to my armchair estimation. You can read a review of his book at SlateStarCodex to get the gist of the argument. https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/09/05/book-review-surfing-uncertainty/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/09/05/book-review-surfing-un...
- tshaddox 4y agoOf course, we don’t all feel that we have free will.