3 ms·
> The problem with suspending withdrawals for crypto firms is the market interprets it as your exchange is insolvent As it should. Inability to withdraw obviou
by matheusmoreira 4y ago
> The problem with suspending withdrawals for crypto firms is the market interprets it as your exchange is insolvent
As it should. Inability to withdraw obviously means they don't have the money. Any limits on withdrawals are and should be major red flags. Exchanges should be punished by the market every single time they pull stunts like that until they learn the lesson.
- notahacker 4y agoAnd to underline the difference: suspending withdrawals can allow a bank's customers to [eventually] get their money back when the bank's creditors get repaid. And the bank never pretended it wasn't making loans in the first place. If a crypto exchange suspend withdrawals, on the other hand, there's no reason to suspect they're just waiting on a bunch of loans to ordinary people and businesses to come in, especially since it usually means they lied about custody of assets.
- kasey_junk 4y agoClarification: depositors are considered a banks senior creditors. They get paid before the other creditors. The reason a bank would suspend withdrawals is so it can be either taken over in an orderly fashion (in the US supervised by the FDIC) or so they can get a liquidity infusion (in the US, depending on their charter, from the fed). Those regulatory agencies and bankruptcy rules don’t exist for a crypto exchange so there is very little an exchange can be doing when suspending withdrawals that doesn’t end with the exchange going bust.
- lupire 4y agoYou can't "punish a market" after everyone stopped putting money in and started taking money out.