6 ms·
Looking at the comment section it seems that people struggle to understand how it works and thinks it is literally copying parts of people's images. Educating
by charcircuit 4y ago
Looking at the comment section it seems that people struggle to understand how it works and thinks it is literally copying parts of people's images.
Educating people about such a technical topic seems very difficult especially since people get emotional of their work being used.
- pyridines 4y agothat is unfortunately a common misconception among artists on Twitter (however representative that group is)
- kadoban 4y agoIt's worse than copying parts of images, it's replacing artists. I know because I'm literally working on setting up Dreambooth to do what I'd otherwise have to pay an artist to do. And not only is it replacing artists, it's using their own work to do so. None of these could exist without being trained on the original artwork. Surely you can imagine why they're largely not happy?
- toomuchtodo 4y agoNo one is happy when technology renders them obsolete or drives the marginal cost of what they produce to zero.
- kadoban 4y agoAnd in my lifetime it'll probably come for coders too. What happens to society when none of the workers are needed anymore, and any pretense of it being anything other than solely "the rich get richer" disappears?
- toomuchtodo 4y agoTransition to a superior compatible economic system? It’s all I’ve got honestly as a suggestion. The technology is coming regardless.
- kadoban 4y agoYeah, that's about the only real choice, but how messy will it be getting there? Certain political parties will absolutely burn everything down before they let anything like that happen.
- Daub 4y agoThis is manifestly true. Artists worried that they would be rendered obselete by photography, and to a degree they were correct. Those that survide had to completely redifine their role and how they served that role.
- frumper 4y agoI am not a portrait artist despite having a camera. Instead of hiring a portrait painter, I hire a photographer. It’s much cheaper now, so I can afford to hire many portraits throughout my life. It still takes an artist to get a good portrait.
- Daub 4y agoPortraiture is a good example of what I mentioned. I am a painter, but I would say that a camera is far more capable of capturing the subtleties of the human face your than a painter. Don't believe me? Search for paintings made before 1800 that feature a smiling face. They exist, but even the lamest insta does a better job of showing us those fleeting facial moments. Landscapes are another matter. Try finding any photo of a landscape that is half as sublime as the landscape paintings made by the Hudson river school. An effective painter can improve upon optical reality in a way that beggers belief. They do this with a clever mix of increasing contrast and affinity in a way that would be almost impossible for a photographer.
- bitwize 4y agoThe Mona Lisa kind of proves your point: the smile is very slight. Were it broad, there would have to be exacting detail given to the configuration of the facial muscles in order to convey the emotion of the smile.
- underwater 4y agoPeople didn't smile in painted portraits because of cultural norms. A smile was perceived as looking foolish (or drunk). Early photography followed this lead. A quote attributed to Mark Twain says “A photograph is a most important document, and there is nothing more damning to go down to posterity than a silly, foolish smile caught and fixed forever.“
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 4y agoTraditionally technology renders people obsolete because the technologists figure out how to do something better than those people. Nobody's happy when it comes for them, but that's life. Someone invents the camera, and art is changed forever. In this case, technologists figured out how to exploit people's work without compensating them. A camera is possible without the artists it replaces. Generative modeling is not. It's fundamentally different. If people figured out how to generate this kind of art without exploiting uncompensated unwilling artists' free labor, it would be a different story.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bugfix-66 4y agoThank you for saying it. We're surrounded by people who don't understand what's happening. They seem to think some kind of art intelligence has been invented. No, it's the aggregation and interpolation of vast amounts of existing art. The same thing is happening with software, through Microsoft's Copilot: https://bugfix-66.com/7a82559a13b39c7fa404320c14f47ce0c304facc51cdacbba3f99654652bf428 https://bugfix-66.com/7a82559a13b39c7fa404320c14f47ce0c304fa... I think people just don't understand what they're seeing. They have no idea what it is. They think it's really "intelligence", dreaming and imagining and simulating and feeling and experimenting and... It's none of these things. It's a sophisticated interpolation, not so different from linear interpolation: a*x + (1-a)*y
- visarga 4y agoMemes (in the sense Dawkins used) have found easier replication into this new medium. Rather than jumping from brain to brain, with the intermediate step of writing, our old memes now replicate by language model. They do meaningful work when deployed without a human in the loop. I think both humans and AI without training are stupid. Take a human alone, raised alone, without culture. He/she will be closer to animals than humans. It's the culture that is the locus of intelligence and we're borrowing intelligence from it just like the AIs.
- antifa 4y agoWhat they like even less is being left behind via top-down enforced austerity in an economy of rapidly increasing inequality _after_ their mostly modest and ethical profession suddenly stops existing.
- asutekku 4y agoThe big problem here is that it trains the artists style and allows third parties to create art in their style without effort. This is especially bad for artists with really distinct style as now hundreds of copycats can come and steal the previously unique style.
- random_cynic 4y agoHate to inform you that the "cat is literally out of the bag" now. There's no putting it back. If it isn't DA it would be someone else. Right now, anyone who does anything creative like painters, authors, composers, designers have to live with the fact that AI can generate something similar to what they can and (this is the most tragic part) generate material that would be indistinguishable (or perhaps even superior) to the general public who're not connoisseurs of their art.
- iszomer 4y agoI wonder what would Beeple say.. "Welp, I made my worth, so long suckers!"?
- PinkMilkshake 4y agoI have to agree, this is a pointless battle. It doesn't matter what DA does or doesn't do. If your art is on the internet, it will be used to train AI. It's not even that it's an inevitable future, it's already the past. I do feel sorry for digital artists, but Pandora's box is open; A black ball has been drawn from the urn (in the world of digital art) and it's too late to do anything meaningful about it.
- visarga 4y agoA black ball for artists who don't use AI, for sure. The artists who jump on this trend will be benefiting the most as they know how to guide the AI better and can fix errors manually.
- gedy 4y ago> This is especially bad for artists with really distinct style as now hundreds of copycats can come and steal the previously unique style. Are you talking about human copycats? Same thing applied before AI models, to be honest.
- bakugo 4y ago> thinks it is literally copying parts of people's images It is. Changing the colors a bit doesn't make it not a copy, just like Copilot changing variable names doesn't make it not an unlicensed copy of someone else's code.
- odessacubbage 4y agothis is such a weird sentiment to see in tech communities like hn that are generally so focused on data privacy.
- bakugo 4y agoI agree. At this point I just assume that anyone defending any kind of AI generation has never created anything of their own and is probably stands to earn money from this in some way, because I can't think of a single reason why anyone who actually creates the data that is being used for AI training without permission would be okay with it.
- kmeisthax 4y agoTech communities are actually really inconsistent about basically all of our strongly-held values. We want data privacy, but we also like playing with any sort of leaked information. We like it when we can get music for free but clutch our pearls when Microsoft sells our code back to us. We talk a good game about free speech, but fail to understand that being shouted over, DDoSed, or harassed is a form of censorship. And whenever words are used that reference any of these concepts in ways we haven't considered - i.e. "marginalized voices", or "consent" - we circle the wagons. The only consistent thing I can infer is that we don't like it when we get a taste of our own medicine.
- jjcon 4y agoI don’t post my private data in public places and expect everyone to stay away from it. Maybe I’m missing the contradiction somewhere else?
- dorkwood 4y agoIs it really an education problem? Should the artist care that their images are not actually being stored in a database? Would they say "oh, well now that I know how it works, I'm actually fine with it"? I suspect their indignation is more to do with their work being consumed without their permission, and then turned into a tool that undermines their value. These tools wouldn't exist without the work of artists. I don't think it's fair to act like no injustice has been done.
- friend_and_foe 4y agoI suspect their indignation has more to do with the fact that the marginal cost of what they do to feed themselves (so that they can live another day to express themselves, of course) is now close to zero. If we had arrived at these art producing machines by some other means, I doubt that the artists would be pulling any punches, seeing as they suffer all the same.