4 ms·
> Make a new account that isn't traceable to the reputation you lit on fire They tried... And doing that leaves a blade dangling above your head even if your
by Dylan16807 4y ago
> Make a new account that isn't traceable to the reputation you lit on fire
They tried...
And doing that leaves a blade dangling above your head even if your behavior is perfect on the new account.
Why can't there be anything you can do to wipe the slate mostly clean? Maybe even donating $100 to charity and giving github a few dollars for wasting their time.
- tptacek 4y agoIf you really feel like GitHub bans are a "blade dangling over your head", use GitLab, or Source Hut. GitHub is not going to develop a charity-linked rehabilitation program for people who shit on their carpet. They're just going to ban you. They're a business, not a public utility. There's some unpleasant subtext to being blocked from GitHub that has nothing to do with someone's ability to write code: it's that your employer is certainly going to ask "uh, why are you not able to make a GitHub account?", and when you tell them "because I shat on GitHub's carpet", they may very well fire you. But that's on you, not GitHub.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> They're a business, not a public utility. That's the standard line. And it has problems when applied to companies with tens of millions of users.
- tptacek 4y agoPeople say it has problems, because that makes for fun message board debates, but the arguments are deeply unserious. Go use Source Hut.
- Dylan16807 4y agoSaying that there's a sliding scale toward being effectively a utility is "deeply unserious"? Is it also "deeply unserious" when I say it's bad that shopping malls are privately owned areas masquerading as public spaces, which lets them ban people in ways that actual public spaces can't? Because there's a lot of literature on that topic, and I see it as pretty similar.
- tptacek 4y agoYes, yes it is unserious. Shopping malls aren't public squares, as several decades of US jurisprudence has ably established, and the collapse of shopping malls in the face of ecommerce amply demonstrates that the argument was silly to begin with. You couldn't have picked a better bit of evidence for my argument; thank you.
- Dylan16807 4y agoI don't think you understand what I'm saying. Yes, legally they are very much not public squares, and that is a bad thing. I'm talking about what should be, what is good for society. Not how the legal system currently works. Talking about that is not "deeply unserious". And nothing about the collapse of malls changes that either.
- tptacek 4y agoThey were never legally determined to be public squares, and that's a good thing, because that would be an eminently stupid decision to make about an institution that will be about as relevant to American life as drug store soda fountains in 10 years. And so it goes for the awesome societal importance of GitHub. Inconstancy is my very essence, says the Wheel.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> because that would be an eminently stupid decision to make about an institution that will be about as relevant to American life as drug store soda fountains in 10 years Malls lasted a long time. But why is that a stupid decision? Let's not even say "decision" though, let's just say every mall offered to rent the hallways out to the local government at a nominal fee, nothing else changed, no lock in. Wouldn't that be a significant improvement? And when I said earlier, tens of millions of users, if github wants to be small again then it will go back to the bottom of the sliding scale.
- 4y ago
- gw98 4y agoIf your employment is limited because you are banned arbitrarily from a tool for any reason then the situation is wrong. Regardless of that, my entire org relies on github globally. If we could not onboard or retain someone due to this I would raise this with our risk and compliance board and the product would be written off from the accepted vendors list almost immediately and cause a fuck load of evaluation and migration work and a $100k/year enterprise customer to disappear for them. That's how bad this is. We already did this to two other vendors and we don't get a choice. It's a business risk.
- tptacek 4y agoIt's not getting banned, it's why you got banned. You could get banned from a tool nobody even gives a shit about for reasons that will absolutely get you shitcanned from a variety of jobs. You could get locked out permanently from Google Mail and Github simultaneously and still keep your job if the reason it happened truly was that you made a fair-minded and impassioned case against closed-source development tools that was so persuasive freaked evil vendors out. It's all about the circumstances.
- gw98 4y agoThat is correct. Which is why I don't give a fuck about the circumstances. I care about the risk to the organisation. And that is a tangible one. And it must be mitigated.
- tptacek 4y agoIf you’re worried GitHub might ice one of your team members, use something else. GitHub is extremely up-front about their willingness to ice users.
- hotpotamus 4y agoWell, you won't be able to onboard the original poster.