3 ms·
I don't understand. The problem is that they did want to moderate/adjudicate this across the entire site.
by Dylan16807 4y ago
I don't understand. The problem is that they did want to moderate/adjudicate this across the entire site.
- tptacek 4y agoNo: a user caused problems for them, and they kicked them off the site, the same way you'd get kicked out of a McDonalds for walking in without pants. If you do the Internet equivalent of walking into GitHub without pants and they kick you off, and you gave them money, we can have a conversation about whether they should give you your money back (I guess I probably would). But other than that, what's there to talk about? Make a new account that isn't traceable to the reputation you lit on fire, or go to any of the other perfectly viable Git hosting sites. You can even run your own. I get not wanting to tell your boss why your old GitHub account doesn't work anymore, but: you're going to have to have that conversation, probably.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> Make a new account that isn't traceable to the reputation you lit on fire They tried... And doing that leaves a blade dangling above your head even if your behavior is perfect on the new account. Why can't there be anything you can do to wipe the slate mostly clean? Maybe even donating $100 to charity and giving github a few dollars for wasting their time.
- tptacek 4y agoIf you really feel like GitHub bans are a "blade dangling over your head", use GitLab, or Source Hut. GitHub is not going to develop a charity-linked rehabilitation program for people who shit on their carpet. They're just going to ban you. They're a business, not a public utility. There's some unpleasant subtext to being blocked from GitHub that has nothing to do with someone's ability to write code: it's that your employer is certainly going to ask "uh, why are you not able to make a GitHub account?", and when you tell them "because I shat on GitHub's carpet", they may very well fire you. But that's on you, not GitHub.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> They're a business, not a public utility. That's the standard line. And it has problems when applied to companies with tens of millions of users.
- tptacek 4y agoPeople say it has problems, because that makes for fun message board debates, but the arguments are deeply unserious. Go use Source Hut.
- Dylan16807 4y agoSaying that there's a sliding scale toward being effectively a utility is "deeply unserious"? Is it also "deeply unserious" when I say it's bad that shopping malls are privately owned areas masquerading as public spaces, which lets them ban people in ways that actual public spaces can't? Because there's a lot of literature on that topic, and I see it as pretty similar.
- tptacek 4y agoYes, yes it is unserious. Shopping malls aren't public squares, as several decades of US jurisprudence has ably established, and the collapse of shopping malls in the face of ecommerce amply demonstrates that the argument was silly to begin with. You couldn't have picked a better bit of evidence for my argument; thank you.
- Dylan16807 4y agoI don't think you understand what I'm saying. Yes, legally they are very much not public squares, and that is a bad thing. I'm talking about what should be, what is good for society. Not how the legal system currently works. Talking about that is not "deeply unserious". And nothing about the collapse of malls changes that either.
- 4y ago
- ch4s3 4y agoBeing banned from GitHub can prevent you from doing your job or gaining future employment. Being banned from a single McDonalds doing prevent you from buying fries at 90% of places that sell fries.
- slikrick 4y agoSo the government (of which it would be specifically the US government) should force GitHub to not be allowed to ban anyone? I see complaints with zero solutions for a private company.