7 ms·
I think the idea this person has is pretty novel. That physical excercise is great for the mind, not only because it has some nebulous general benefits but beca
by scotty79 4y ago
I think the idea this person has is pretty novel. That physical excercise is great for the mind, not only because it has some nebulous general benefits but because it computationally is a very hard task for the brain. Harder than anything you could throw at it consciously.
It might be wrong but it's interesting and somewhat novel.
- tartoran 4y ago> because it computationally is a very hard task for the brain Can you explain what part of physical exercise is computationally hard for the brain?
- jstanley 4y agoInverse kinematics calculations for a large number of joints, and high-precision control of same.
- ben_w 4y agoDon't most mammals have about the same number of joints? This implies a very small part of our mind is responsible for that. Even pumpkin toadlets, who famously can't coordinate their landings, the problem isn't the size of their brain, it's their vestibular system. I'm of the opinion that most animals are probably a lot higher up the sentience scale than is the current social consensus, but I don't think exercise is itself a major cognitive effort. Arbitrary games sure (not just the rules, anything social involves modelling multiple entities like yourself), but not the physical exercise itself.
- jamesmontalvo3 4y agoI don’t think the point is that physical work makes humans intelligent in comparison to animals. I think the point is that physically active humans exercise aspects of their intelligence that modern sedentary humans do not.
- MereInterest 4y agoProcessing of visual information, especially on short time scales. Feedback mechanisms for balance. Adapting to changing environmental conditions (e.g. how much should a stride be adjusted on gravel, in mud, on damp pavement). These are all detailed tasks that are done during physical exercise, just not typically tasks that are done at a conscious level.
- ambicapter 4y agoWhy are people so impressed at Boston Dynamics robots completing obstacle courses that human children could easily complete?
- rendaw 4y agoWhile it's true that Boston Dynamics robots can barely walk, they can't write coherent and innovative stories, solve abstract problems, or other related tasks at all yet.
- ben_w 4y agoHardware is hard. Making an AI that learns to control a purely virtual body appears to be a fairly standard project. 1) https://youtu.be/XrOTgZ14fJg https://youtu.be/XrOTgZ14fJg 2) https://youtu.be/882O_7hsAms https://youtu.be/882O_7hsAms 3) https://youtu.be/1kV-rZZw50Q https://youtu.be/1kV-rZZw50Q 4) https://youtu.be/gn4nRCC9TwQ https://youtu.be/gn4nRCC9TwQ
- ambicapter 4y agoA virtual body in a virtual world. I would say "real world is hard" is the more likely conclusion than "hardware is hard".
- dahart 4y agoYou should try building one! I wonder why isn’t everyone impressed what Boston Dynamics has done? As soon as we make a robot that’s as good as a human child in every way, then I’m going to start worrying seriously about Skynet.
- wly_cdgr 4y agoHave you ever played QWOP? Play QWOP.
- scotty79 4y agoNot falling over while moving and interacting with physical objects successfully. You can throw at it few gpus worth of computing power and still end up short.
- faeriechangling 4y agoI haven't heard people mention it before but I've often wondered why physical exercise wasn't considered "intelligent" when so much of the brain was dedicated to tasks like moving around and coordination.
- ben_w 4y agoThe stereotypical jock who isn't particularly smart, and the stereotypical nerd who isn't particularly fit. Stereotypes are powerful things.
- wjholden 4y agoNot disagreeing, but let me point out that animals can move their bodies quite well and we consider most of them significantly less intelligent. I don't know what proportion of the brain is used for movement and what proportion is used for cognition.
- someweirdperson 4y agoDolphins and bears can balance a ball on their nose. Human artists can balance multiple plates on sticks. Is it a difference in computing power, or just because we can't force animals to practice enough?
- ambivalents 4y agoCouldn't this prove the point that we don't equate movement with intelligence, though? Who's to say animals also don't possess this intelligence? Maybe we'd have to go down the chain then, to more inert species like plants and fungi, though they also possess intelligence I can't begin to comprehend.
- Pelam 4y agoIANAB, but large animal bodies correlate with large brain size. Huge animals like elephants and whales have much bigger brains than humans, but are not considered cognitively equivalent to humans. Maybe moving and maintaining a body requires body size proportional "raw" computational power and maybe human brains have mostly just qualitative differences not related to mass when compared to animals (ok, and a bit of extra proportional brain mass too). If this is the case the connection between excercise and cognitive capacity could seem natural. Excercise requires massive neural resources and thus physical excercises also excercise the brain to a large degree and the whatever qualitative bit that humans have "on top" simply rides the wave to some improvement.
- klipt 4y ago> because it computationally is a very hard task for the brain No they didn't say harder, they said it uses "more computation", there's a difference. Your brain has many parallel systems specialized for exercise, because our ancestors have used similar systems to move their bodies for eons. Exercise fires all these systems in parallel, so your brain is getting great "throughput". On the other hand stuff like Sudoku is using a much smaller fraction of our brain that developed recently, probably for language, and then trying to use the language part to do math, which feels "difficult" precisely because we're trying to do it with just a small, unspecialized part of our brain, instead of a bunch of specialized parallel systems. So exercise is both "easier", but also more efficiently gets your brain working because of parallelism.