8 ms·
‘Whisper list’ contains 40 politicians never to accept a drink from, MP claims
- webmobdev 4y agoYou expect politicians to be brave, fearless and know how to use power. But here's a politician admitting to being powerless. That is such a screwed up situation. (To be clear, I am not blaming them but the existing political environment).
- randomdata 4y ago> You expect politicians to be brave, fearless and know how to use power. You do? There is some nobility in stepping up to be a public servant, but you're still a servant at the end of the day; one that works for a bunch of petulant, out of touch bosses who can't get along to save their lives. Not where I would expect to find the brave and fearless. There may be something to be said about the marketing opportunities that a head of state-type position opens up for such a person, but a general representative without a fancy position in government seems like a strange fit for someone who isn't afraid to take on the world.
- webmobdev 4y agoYes, I know I am in the minority but I do admire politicians. When you work with them, you realise the skill-sets you need to become an elected representative. Imagine CEOs who have to manage not thousands or tens of thousands, but millions of people (in populous countries like India and China). You need to command respect from the people, know how to deal with people of varying personalities, you need to know when to follow and when to lead, you need to have the ability to identify potential leaders and teach them to lead, you have to watch out for backstabbers and political opponents, you need to be clear about your self-interests and other people's interest, you have need to know how to negotiate between various power brokers etc. Most of us cynically mock them and even despise some of them, but it really is not easy to be one.
- randomdata 4y ago> Imagine CEOs who have to manage not thousands or tens of thousands, but millions of people Except it is an inverse relationship. You have possibly millions of people, all with conflicting ideas, trying to manage you. If you want to use that analogy, it is more like being a CEO with millions of shareholders who have no distinct profit motive and can't come together and decide, in a unified fashion, what they want out of their company. Although the board of directors is a much closer analog. > it really is not easy to be one. Nor is there much upside, except in the most prominent positions providing a branding advantage, which is why it is a strange choice for those who aren't limited by their own hangups. Academically interesting, for those into that kind of thing, but being brave and fearless is often at odds with having a proclivity towards those academic interests, so while it indeed takes a lot of talent, you don't expect bravery and fearlessness to necessarily come along for the ride.
- ekianjo 4y ago> You expect politicians to be brave, fearless and know how to use power No, I expect them to be complete incompetent fools. Most of the time I find out this is not wrong.
- gadders 4y ago"Politics is showbiz for ugly people."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jonathanstrange 4y agoWhere is the list?
- boomboomsubban 4y ago>The list, which is not written down...
- pjc50 4y ago"The list, which is not written down" This is not unusual. A lot of large organizations have a ladies' whisper network where they tell each other where the "missing stairs" are; those men it is unsafe to be left alone with. Edit: it may be possible to reassemble the list from existing allegations; https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10726693/More-50-MPs-reported-sexual-misconduct-parliamentary-watchdog-reveals.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10726693/More-50-MP... / https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/may/18/list-of-sexual-misconduct-allegations-made-against-mps https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/may/18/list-of-sexu...
- jonathanstrange 4y agoWell, I expected the journalists to write it down. It's an integral part their profession.
- pjc50 4y agoCan't write down something you're not given.
- jll29 4y agoI would quite like to see this list; I hope someone - e.g. a strong female like the interviewee - leaks it anonymously. It's disgraceful that there's such a cover-up about it. To clean up the systems and make it a safe environment, one needs to know the perpetrators. Also, who says all on the list are actually perpetrators? Theoretically, there could be a harmless person on the list that was put by an opponent to destroy them.
- andrewclunn 4y agoMake an accusation. Hushed "whisper lists" protect no one and allow merely suspicion to serve as indictment. Again, if something happens, make an open public accusation.
- yathaid 4y ago> Again, if something happens, make an open public accusation. What do you think will change if they do?
- randomdata 4y agoThe Guardian will be able to publish an article with a little more substance.
- akdor1154 4y agoHaving a private "possibly a sex pest" list sounds very useful, even if it has a couple of false positives, and even if most of its contents are based on anecdote. Having false positives in a public accusation would be a disaster for everyone involved. Additionally, a list that is private creates far less incentive for any malicious/spurious additions. A private list seems far more practical, sadly.
- Neil44 4y agoIt does. But sadly this alleged list will now just become a football for politicians to play with, whispered allegations of who might be on it to damage your opponents, no recourse for those accused. And I really don't agree with the sentiment that a few false positives are OK in situations like this where lets face it accusation = guilt. We don't operate like that in any other areas of criminality and for good reason.
- pjc50 4y ago> accusation = guilt We've been through months of "evidence=impunity". Partygate. Braverman getting sacked over a "but her emails" incident of deliberately leaking classified material and then getting reinstated six days later. Gavin Williamson. And much of the misconduct isn't actually illegal! It's just misconduct and intra-party bullying. The problem is there's no "adults outside the room" you can call on to make a determination. It's only a political system, a set of interlocking popularity contests.
- benj111 4y agoSurely we've all learnt from the Jimmy saville affair that you don't keep things hushed up. I don't want to get into victim blaming but these are our representatives. If they can't / won't come forward. How can they expect others to. How can they expect to change the culture in the rest of the country? But then trying to make this all add up just calls into question the very existence of this list. Are you really saying there's no one in parliament willing to name names? It just smells of one mp making things up for her own agenda.
- pjc50 4y agoAccusing someone of sexual harassment will quite often tank your own career, and is not guaranteed to have any effect at all on the accused. Besides, Westminster runs on bullying; MPs aren't quite party employees, so they have to use extremely underhand coercive control to keep people in line. See Gavin Williamson. For example, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Pincher_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Pincher_scandal : as chief whip, he would be the person you'd have to report misconduct to! And it was apparently "widely known" that he was prone to sexually harassing other men before he got that job.
- benj111 4y ago>Accusing someone of sexual harassment will quite often tank your own career. Any examples? Plus any politician you ask would say they're willing to take the hard decisions. So we should hold them to that. And if it's at the point where there's a circulated list of 40 names that no one is willing to do anything about. Don't mention the list at all! Mentioning the list is corrosive without doing anything about the problem. If a judge announced 10% of judges were bent, but wouldn't name names, what do you think that would do to the justice system? Ultimately the list can be announced on the floor, there's vulnerable people outside of Westminster that might want to talk to their, and trust their MP. They have the right to know the contents of the list. If there truly is a list, and it's accurate, it needs more than a report to the chief whip to fix it, as the Chris pincher thing shows.
- asoneth 4y ago
- orwin 4y agoIn a different way, if you're a service worker (especially female) and found a job at a hostel/restaurant, you should contact the nearest trade school and ask them if they discourage female internship/apprenticeship at the restaurant. Sadly, in those place it is easy to be put in a "she said/he said" situation, and since you're not in the public eye, nobody will really care, especially not the policeman who took the second rape complaint, and your lawyer will only tell you to log the complaint to the police and that she will follow up and call you once she found a third or fourth occurence (that's crazy to me that two complaints is not enough btw).
- MandieD 4y agoAt least sharia law is open in its contempt for women with its stated valuation of a woman’s testimony at half that of a man’s.
- iinnPP 4y agoI obviously don't think anyone should be the subject of violence, let alone rape. I can understand however, that in a society where the truth is seen as a negative, why more than a person and their potential bestie is needed to testify against anyone for anything major. More so when the laws against perjury are more often used in a dishonest way to take the truth and silence it. We have a serious problem with honesty.
- michaelt 4y agoEh, loads of crime can only be prosecuted because of the victim's testimony. Let's say Bob thinks Charles is an asshole, so he goes to Charles's house and beats him up. Charles has no CCTV in his home. The police can see he's been beaten up, but the only thing identifying Bob is Charles's testimony. Bob says it wasn't him, he was at home watching TV. Is it just for Bob to be convicted?
- thfuran 4y ago>Let's say Bob thinks Charles is an asshole, so he goes to Charles's house and beats him up.[...]Is it just for Bob to be convicted? Of course.
- sandworm101 4y agoSuch lists exist everywhere, and not just amongst women. In the military, everyone knows not to be around certain officers when they are drinking. Some are angry drunks, some hold grudges and some while drunk attempt to enforce rigid military codes. Warnings about such officers are shared with everyone, not just women. Any power rigid structure results in such situations if left unchecked.
- H8crilA 4y agoGetting them all into a single room with free alcohol would be my secret life project.
- sandworm101 4y agoEvery unit mess dinner. Every at-work retirement party. Every roll call. Manditory fun days are where such reputations are made.
- rrwo 4y agoThere are different kinds of lists for different behaviour and different victims. When I was in university, there was a women's bathroom in one of the buildings that was noted to have a list of alleged rapists (students and professors) written on the walls. The cleaners intentionally never removed it.
- poszlem 4y agoThat sounds like something that is not slanderous at all and would never be used to harm innocent people.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoTotally no way, someone would add someones name, just to fuck their lives...
- notadev 4y agohttps://www.thecut.com/article/cancel-culture-high-school-teens.html https://www.thecut.com/article/cancel-culture-high-school-te...
- constantcrying 4y agoHow can you have a working government which has these problems? These people have significant power over millions of other people, yet they are unable to resolve issues like these amongst themselves. I am not saying that these women are wrong, certainly my oppinnion on politicians is low enough, but the gravity of the situation is astonishing. A government where one group sees another group as potential rapists clearly can not function well.
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago>How can you have a working government which has these problems? I know after a decade+ of mainstream culture shitting on people for what they do outside of their professional capacity this is going to seem like an odd opinion but doing bad things and/or having moral failings outside of the specifics of work does not preclude being good at one's job. How do you think all those wife beating cops everyone talks about manage to stay employed? They do their jobs. All those commies that McCarthy said infiltrated industry, how did they get there? They did their jobs. Alan Turning's "moral failings" were so bad he was criminally convicted for them yet he did some of the highest quality work in his field. Etc. etc.
- leobabauta 4y agoI would discourage the idea that wife beating and believing in communism are in any way similar.
- guhidalg 4y agoBut they are similar in that some people believed it precluded others from doing their jobs (indeed maybe even being a part of society) if they engaged in the behavior. You may not like the analogy, but it works.
- poszlem 4y agoYou should talk to an older person from eastern europe, where believing in communism is (rightly) seen at the same level as believing in nazism (and in absolute numbers it actually harmed more people). Then you can reassess your comparison.
- roenxi 4y agoI assume this happens in all governments, we know the sort of people who get voted in. There is strong selection pressure for people who are totally in love with power to the point where they put up with the abuse of competing for a political office and the risk of failure. There is nearly no evidence that politics selects for conventionally honourable people, and a substantial body of evidence to suggest that the halls of power are staffed with serial liars and sneaks. What really interests me is that this illustrates how completely staged the public face of a political party is. not really news, but interesting nonetheless.
- dmurray 4y agoBut are "the sort of people who get voted in" more likely to be 1. Serial rapists or 2. Backstabbers adept at using rumours and lies to undermine political rivals? I suppose how much you trust a list like this depends on whether you incline towards 1 or 2.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoQuality 2 enables one to get away with all sorts of stuff including but not limited to 1.
- t-3 4y agoIs there a dichotomy between 1 and 2? The tendency of assumptions in these regards is that someone willing to act contrary to the norm in one way is willing to also be so in other ways. Neither convicted shoplifters or convicted drug dealers will get hired for positions that require trust, even though only the shoplifter can be shown to be a thief.
- roenxi 4y agoThey're both springing from the same source - people who want power over others and no consequences go into politics. Why would someone be a serial backstabber if that wasn't motivating them? Serial backstabbing isn't much fun in and of itself. They do it because loyalty doesn't secure them power. Take a man who lusts after power, has power, is used to getting their own way, escaping consequences, trained by experience to be unscrupulous and in an environment where nobody tells the truth so what people say gets ignored. Put them alone in a room alone with a women. There is a very obvious risk. Now I'd hope most men would turn out to be ok, but you don't need to know the people involved to be able to predict that there are serial rapists being created in politics.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vmilner 4y agoHow on earth does a list of 40 people that’s never written down maintain any sort of resistance to “Telephone”/“Chinese Whispers” errors?
- SkyMarshal 4y agoGood question. Maybe: 1) People who have been around a while already know most or all of it, while people new to the scene know none or little of it. 2) It's never whispered all at the same time, but rather one or a few at a time when the circumstance calls for it, kind of like a distributed consensus algorithm gradually coming to consensus. Also, easier to recall parts of the list when in the physical vicinity of people on it. 3) The newbies learn the whole thing gradually, not all at once.
- asoneth 4y agoIn addition to the other answers given: If a name is erroneously omitted from the list then a subsequent incident would presumably re-add the offender. If a name is incorrectly included on the list (accidentally or maliciously) then there could be a decay function if reports include a timeframe and/or confidence level. For example, if the last report of bad behavior was third-hand and years ago and no one has heard corroborating reports since then then individuals may choose to de-prioritize or drop that name from the lists they transmit. It may also be the case that the list is not particularly resistant to transmission errors and yet may still be accurate enough to provide value to the people using it.
- upsidesinclude 4y agoOr not at all. The list serves to alienate certain people and prevent them from becoming competitive or developing networks. The negatives of this kind of behavior are equal to the supposed benefits
- asoneth 4y ago> Or not at all If the list is not at all accurate I doubt it would propagate as well or as long because an entirely inaccurate list provides negative value to its recipients by giving them a false sense of security that will be eventually dispelled when they realize their personal experience does not correlate with the list. I would be more concerned about a list that is sufficiently accurate to ensure continued propagation while still containing harmful inaccuracies. > The negatives of this kind of behavior are equal to the supposed benefits Whether the harm caused by inaccurate warnings exceeds the harm avoided by the accurate warnings seems subjective because these harms are different and impact different people. It would also be hard to assess without knowing the actual ratio of accurate to inaccurate warnings. But regardless of whether these kinds of lists cause net harm overall, individuals will continue to share warnings as long as doing so provides net value to them. Outlawing rumors is something not even totalitarian regimes have managed to do, so the only solution I can think of would be to ensure that the alternate methods of addressing problematic behavior are more attractive to people than resorting to rumors.
- LatteLazy 4y agoThe way the UK system works (and I imagine the same is true in the US and other FPTP, 2 Party systems) means officials who behave badly are retained and promoted while the clean, honourable ones are rapidly expelled. Parties want officials that will do as they are told. The way that is assured is to know and cover up for their sins. 3rd time drunk driving? Can't keep your hands to yourself? Money keeps being sent to your personal account? Don't worry, the Whip will sort it out, no one needs to know, and don't forget to vote as you're told tomorrow! Squeaky clean, honest, principles representative of your constituents who won't vote against what is write for them and the nation when told to? You'll be removed quickly.
- lolc 4y agoI know technical solutions cannot solve all society's ills. But these fucks desperatly need some footage published to neuter them. If nothing else stops them, they must fear to get exposed that way.