10 ms·
Warren Calls Out Wells Fargo and Zelle for “Evasive” Responses about Fraud
- pencilguin 4y agoI don't understand how Wells Fargo executives avoided being personally indicted for thousands of counts of fraud, for their previous activity, ordering underlings to create fake credit card accounts for poor customers and then suck them dry.
- justin66 4y agoSimilarly, I can’t imagine why anyone still banks with them.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoInstant ACH, what could possibly go wrong?
- toomuchtodo 4y agoSome fraud is a cost of instant payment infra. It must be built into the P&L of the system, with robust controls to prevent what can be prevented. Security and convenience must intersect, it’s just a matter of sussing out that point.
- gleenn 4y agoThe fact that ACH takes 3 days is actually because the original protocol was file and FTP based, where one bank would upload the transfer as a file to another's, and the other would return a file with exceptions or something within 3 days. If the first bank didn't see a file with exceptions in 3 days the first would actually wire the money. Money can move way faster and fraud can be detected, obviously some time for human intervention is good too but that wasn't baked into the solution on purpose as much as it was just a terrible protocol to begin with.
- nrmitchi 4y ago> because the original protocol was file and FTP based As if that's not largely how it still works today? :sad-face:
- kylehotchkiss 4y agoNow the 3 days is beneficial to banks since whichever bank is holding the funds can claim the interest due on it.
- nrmitchi 4y agoBy that logic it works the other way too. They miss out on interest on funds that were delayed in being sent to them.
- notch656a 4y agoPrisoner's dilemma. slow-slow is the stable equilibrium point, even though fast-fast is just as good or better. The other 'prisoner' can always beat your fast by going slow, so they pick slow so they can't lose.
- nrmitchi 4y agoBut ACH isn't an ungoverned system where parties get to just behave in their own best interest. It, and the timing/behaviour, are governed by the NACHA Operating Rules. If you are being a bad party and failing to submit transactions on time so that you can collect a bit of extra interest, you are going to get a very large hammer brought down on you.
- xboxnolifes 4y agoNobody said anything about not being on time. Just not fast.
- gt565k 4y agoIt’s the price you pay for instant money in your account. I mean you want quick settlement or 3-4 days to access your money. Pros and cons. The consumer is at risk, well don’t be an idiot consumer. No different than giving someone cash and them running away.
- ceejayoz 4y agoPeople understand giving someone cash, though. Zelle is implemented in a confusing way that's begging for fraud.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhat is confusing about Zelle? This is BoA’s page on Zelle, and it seems very clear to me: https://www.bankofamerica.com/online-banking/mobile-and-online-banking-features/send-receive-money/ https://www.bankofamerica.com/online-banking/mobile-and-onli... Wells Fargo’s is similar. https://www.wellsfargo.com/online-banking/zelle/ https://www.wellsfargo.com/online-banking/zelle/ Wells Fargo FAQ: > What protections do I have when I use Zelle®? >You are protected in the unlikely event an unauthorized user accesses your consumer accounts and initiates payments using Wells Fargo Online or Wells Fargo Mobile. >However, because Zelle® is intended to replace instances where cash and checks are being exchanged, you do not have the same protections associated with a credit card or a debit card transaction, such as the ability to dispute purchase transactions. Once you send money with Zelle®, you cannot cancel the payment if your recipient has already enrolled. Neither Wells Fargo nor Zelle® offers a protection program for any authorized payments made with Zelle® – for example, if you do not receive the item you paid for or the item is not as described or as you expected. >We recommend you only send money to known and trusted recipients when using Zelle®.
- andirk 4y agoA good ole finger wag oughta learn em to not be professional fraudsters. Yeah. Worked real well with all the non-binding suggestions put in to law post-2008 banker scams.
- ceejayoz 4y agoWe're just gonna pretend Warren didn't propose and found the CFPB, are we?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoCFPB is amazing. I had an employer sponsored HSA account from PNC, and PNC reps were giving me the run around about transferring money to another HSA custodian. Sent one message on CFPB website describing my problem, and the next day I got a call from a “VP” at PNC letting me know my issue was resolved. A simple matter that could have been solved if PNC had intended their customer service agents to actually solve my problem, but I assume was left unaddressed because transferring funds out is not of any benefit to PNC.
- hangonhn 4y agoI had a similar experience with the California PUC. Sprint raised the texting rate so I tried to cancel my plan. Their service rep wanted to charge me for breaking my contract but I pointed out that any material change to my contract is grounds for breaking the contract -- basically Sprint broke the contact first. The rep tried to offer me another plan that gives me a similar rate but would entail me signing onto the new plan. I argued that wasn't acceptable. He refused to budge and kept saying because he offered me another plan it's not material change, which is total BS. I finally called the California PUC. They routed my call to Sprint's Executive service line and 5 minutes later I was free from the contract and got to keep my phone. Without a body like the PUC the power is entirely in the hands of the big corporations. The cost (in time and/or money) for me to fight Sprint legally is going to be more than the contract was worth but it's still something. I'm sure that's all part of their calculus.
- formerkrogemp 4y ago
- LorenPechtel 4y agoWhere are they claiming it's anything but users falling for deceptive messages? The banks won't do anything because the transaction isn't fraudulent.
- usea 4y agoLying to people in order for them to send you money is fraud. Duped users are victims of fraud.
- j-bos 4y agoAgreed. That's why the fraudster's should be tried Using the bank records as evidence. When someone opens an account in one's name, that's fraud on the bank, and the bank needs to pay for it until squeezing it from the scammer. When someone convinces one to send them money under false pretenses, that's on one and one needs to pay for it until squeezing it from the scammer.
- miohtama 4y agoBut are banks responsible for fraud? Should one make a criminal report and get your money back in a court?
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoNo; the bank won't do anything because the transaction isn't unauthorized which is the operative word in the law.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoOk, yeah, same concept. I'm saying the transaction was initiated by the person, thus the transaction is not fraud. They were defrauded into making the transaction, but the fraud happened with the person, not the bank.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoRight but the distinction is important - c.f. the confused people on the other branch on the thread.
- ajaimk 4y agoI watched the hearing a while back and honestly don’t get the fuss Warren in making in this specific scenario. She calls out scenarios where people willingly sent money to someone over Zelle themselves. This wasn’t a compromised account; it was people being conned by other individuals (think Nigerian Prince). Why should Zelle be on the hook for someone being stupid? They did exactly their job. Should the US Mint refund me money if I gave a fraudster cash? Update: Love the comments below folks. I get it now.
- mimikatz 4y agoThe reason is incentives and lack of protections. If banks don't eat the cost of fraud they don't properly protect people from being preyed upon.
- anon291 4y agoWire fraud is a huge problem already.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoSo people expect credit card/debit card level protection without paying the credit card/debit card fees or going through the process of merchant vetting by a payment processor?
- colechristensen 4y agoIn other words, banks shouldn’t be allowed to drop those protections to provide a cheaper service. And the fees are mostly just profit. Banks are responsible for knowing their customers.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y ago>Banks are responsible for knowing their customers. What do you think that means?
- gruez 4y ago
- judge2020 4y agoI wonder how much reversal power will be possible with FedNow, releasing mid 2023. https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/other20220829a.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/othe...
- anonthrownaway 4y agoReal world scenario I witnessed recently: 1. subject had a bank account with the ability to link to Zelle 2. subject turned on Zelle to receive money from a family member 3. several high dollar Zelle transactions were made - subject claims that they were at home with covid and no one had access to her phone 4. she calls bank to cancel transactions, bank refunds money 5. bank investigates and claims face id and her IP address was used and takes refunds back 6. subject takes bank and zelle to court 7. Zelle says: we are just a middleman - not our responsibility 8. bank claims that it can't investigate where the money went because it was instant transferred 9. banks settles for some of the money Conclusion? If you have to use Zelle or Venmo, attach it to a bank account with limited funds in it.
- gruez 4y ago>8. bank claims that it can't investigate where the money went because it was instant transferred They really couldn't, or their policies didn't allow handing out information without a subpoena? Given KYC laws, I'm sure that every financial institution involved probably has the records somewhere. As for the policy itself, I'm not so sure whether zelle refusing to hand over recipient information is a bad thing. If I'm selling something on facebook marketplace, I wouldn't want my counterparty to get my dox just because they cried foul. I'd want a judge to examine the request before zelle hands over my info.
- rasz 4y agoYour story sounds possible with one exception, 8 "subject threatens to take bank and zelle to court". There is no universe where bank tells the judge it wont investigate.
- sn0w_crash 4y ago
- jrockway 4y agoI didn't know that Zelle was a thing until one of my credit card issuers recently sent me an email along the lines of "don't use it, it's only for fraud". I immediately assumed that it was because they were sad that they weren't included in the alliance or something like that. They maybe have their competing service that they want to "win" instead, and the marketing department is now making it my problem. Turns out: nope. Not their angle. Their customers are losing money right and left and are unhappy about it, so at least they're trying to warn everyone. A few days after this email, I got a frantic call from my Mom saying that someone stole $5000 out of her bank account, and the bank won't reverse the transaction. It turned out that someone called her claiming to be some antivirus software provider, convinced her to share her screen, and transferred out a chunk of money with Zelle. The email I got, and her bank, both warned that it was irreversible. And thus far, it seems unable to be reversed. To me, this violates a fundamental assumption of banking. If someone takes your money without your consent, you typically have recourse through customer service (often works) and the legal system (almost always works, but costly). This fundamental assumption was thrown away overnight without informing anyone about it. One day, you log into your bank and maybe you can pay a bill to a known physical address. The next day, people in other countries can drain your entire bank account. It's kind of a shock; no 2FA rollout, no way to opt out, just a ticking time bomb that came out of nowhere. My bank has it; nobody ever told me about it. My takeaway is that people aren't really ready for irreversible bank transactions. They have literally no way to understand what that even means. Sure, there's crypto, but most cryptocurrency users are pretty technical, and knew they were entering untested waters, and did so with extensive education. It has simply never been a thing in the "traditional" financial world. The problem here, then, is that people don't associate things like "screen sharing" with taking money. They have had weird charges on their credit card before, and in those cases, called their bank and the charges were instantly forgiven. So they protect their computer with that level of security; "if I allow this screenshare, I might get a virus or worst case, something bad might happen and I'll have to make a call to my bank within 6 months after reviewing my statement". Zelle moved the goalposts; if someone uses your unlocked workstation or guesses your 4 character password, all your money is gone with no legal repercussions. I think this is maybe fine if you opt in to be an early adopter, or your bank rolls out crypto-like payments with the requirement that you enable 2FA and have a 239847 character password every time you transfer money, but it doesn't seem like they did any of that. They just turned a safe system into an unsafe system while nobody was watching. Congress should look into that; the implementation was botched and innocent people were hurt. (I shouldn't have to say this, but people being scammed aren't idiots. My Mom has a PhD and has written multiple scientific papers. She is a little too trusting of people claiming to help with computers and honestly doesn't understand the computery world. But I blame us, the people that make those systems and that software, not her. Ordinary people just want to send email and pay some bills in between their lives real demands. We have fucked it up severely, and the banks did a particularly bad job here. Windows Hello asking "Enter your PIN" before sending money would have stopped the screenshare attack. There's more security required to look at my Grafana dashboard that shows the humidity level of my 3D printing filament than there is around stealing $5000. That's egregiously irresponsible, and victim blaming isn't going to do anything other than ensure that the field of software dies.)
- midislack 4y agoGet outta here the same bank caught laundering for cartels? No way.
- CyberDildonics 4y agoWrong bank
- gruez 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wells_Fargo#Failure_to_monitor_suspected_money_laundering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wells_Fargo#Failure_to_monitor...
- CyberDildonics 4y agoThat's "Failure to monitor suspected money laundering". HSBC offered money laundering directly to mexican drug cartels and was fined 1.9 billion dollars. https://www.investopedia.com/stock-analysis/2013/investing-news-for-jan-29-hsbcs-money-laundering-scandal-hbc-scbff-ing-cs-rbs0129.aspx https://www.investopedia.com/stock-analysis/2013/investing-n...
- chatterhead 4y agoWells Fargo has systemic corruption and needs to lose it's Charter.
- greyface- 4y agoI have a firstnamelastname@gmail.com address. I get a lot of misdirected emails for others with the same name; usually I ignore them. It's linked to a Zelle account and one day I received an unexpected $500 deposit. I asked my bank if it could be reversed. They said no, but I could return it to the sender by initiating a new Zelle transfer. The transaction only showed the sender's name; I asked my bank if they could provide me with a Zelle address, and they said no, I needed to ask the sender for that information. This was obviously impossible and the whole situation smelled fishy. I let it sit for a few days, and got an email from someone with the same name, asking for their $500 back. It was a lot of money to them, they made a mistake, and their bank wasn't helping them recover it at all. I couldn't decide if it was a scam or not. I ended up sending $500 to the address I received the email from. They thanked me profusely, and I never heard about it again.
- wildrhythms 4y agoHow did the sender find your email address to contact you?
- greyface- 4y agoZelle recipients are specified by email address or phone number. They sent the email to the same address that they sent the Zelle transfer to.
- pasttense01 4y agoThis is unacceptable and should be corrected to allow a transaction to be reversed, otherwise a recipient is at risk for a scam.
- lvl102 4y agoWells Fargo and Bank of America are horrible banks. They deserve to go bankrupt and disappear. And anyone working at these places are despicable.