8 ms·
The End of the Road to Serfdom
- mark_l_watson 4y agoIf you have ever read Thomas Piketty’s 1000 page tome “Capital in the 21st Century” (I have ), this short article can be thought of as an extremely short summary, with some very nice nuances added. Great read!
- machina_ex_deus 4y agoIt takes a really distorted world view to on one hand describe so accurately the problems and lack of freedom in America, the disrespect for workers and how they seek freedom and will eventually overthrow the existing order. And then on the other hand to say China which the author himself described as even more oppressive work environment will somehow be better off in this new enlightened world. Socialism solves nothing. There's no free healthcare, doctors need to work for that. No free phones either. One way or the other you always pay the price. Authoritarian governments are always worse off because they suppress the criticism that would progress them further. In some funny way this author is quite similar to the elite in that he is views the working class of china the same way the elite view the working class of rich countries.
- midislack 4y agoChina has a coherent vision and elevates Chinese, west is the opposite.
- commandlinefan 4y ago> they can turn their wealth into pro-wealth policies He's arguing (of course) for cradle-to-grave socialism while overlooking the obvious: the ultra-wealthy are using their wealth to promote the exact same thing.
- fallingfrog 4y agoCategorically untrue. The one percent have had their taxes cut enormously, and their share of the national income has doubled since the 80's, meanwhile all sorts of welfare programs and boons like almost-free college education have been slashed. Unions were attacked and are now almost non-existent. The minimum wage has been allowed to stagnate for so long that it's now meaningless. Jobs were shipped overseas where labor was cheaper leaving a vast rust belt. And it's the political donations and patronage, usually made discreetly, of the ultra wealthy that has allowed this to happen.
- pessimizer 4y agoThe ultra-wealthy have controlled the country for longer than you have been alive, so if they'd wanted socialism, you'd be living in it. The ultra-wealthy also paid Glenn Beck to convince Americans that there was a conspiracy amongst the ultra-wealthy to oppress the ultra-wealthy, so the best way to stick it to the ultra-wealthy was to remove all limits on the activities of the ultra-wealthy.
- MichaelZuo 4y ago[flagged]
- adamrezich 4y agofirst time reading Doctorow?
- MichaelZuo 4y agoNot the very first time but I haven’t read enough, nor met him in real life to understand what kind of character he is. Some of the claims seem so bombastic that it’s difficult to believe anyone sane fully believes in them unironically.
- Apocryphon 4y agoI see little has changed in a month https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33288047 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33288047
- MichaelZuo 4y agoRight, like I said. Thanks for finding that comment, it definitely shows a trend of bombastic writing. Maybe he only uses this style for some portion, and I just happened to read only them.
- Apocryphon 4y agoThat was my comment. I’m criticizing you for harping on a feature that’s not a bug, from a target you clearly don’t know enough about to skewer.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoHow does reinforcing my point count as criticism?
- ricky_lake 4y ago
- legitster 4y ago> According to Piketty, capitalism always leads to rich people running the show, and that always leads to the follies of the wealthy few taking precedence over the material needs of the majority, which eventually leads to some kind of collapse, wherein wealth is destroyed and a space opens for a new society. This is NOT what Piketty's work says. And I wish people would stop regurgitating it. The entire onus of his book (much contested) was that, in a natural order, private wealth grows faster than an economy overall. Everything past that is pure conjecture. And depending on what your view of what "capitalism" is, this probably supersedes it. The presence of market economies is irrelevant - his dataset included non-market based economies.
- fallingfrog 4y agoI think the truth is somewhere in between- Doctorow does seem to have overstated what Piketty said, but not by a huge margin. I don't think this error dilutes Doctorow's argument very much. From wikipedia (the article on Capital in the 21 Century): "The book's central thesis is that when the rate of return on capital (r) is greater than the rate of economic growth (g) over the long term, the result is concentration of wealth, and this unequal distribution of wealth causes social and economic instability." Doctorow got a little hyperbolic and replaced "instability" with "some kind of collapse", and "capital" with "capitalism" which is, as you point out, misrepresenting what Piketty said. But not tremendously.
- imtringued 4y agoHonestly, in retrospect he is saying something very similar to Keynes who says unemployment is caused by an interest rate (r) above the marginal productivity of capital (g). The difference between Piketty and Keynes however is that Keynes has the concept of a liquidity premium which explains how it is even possible for r to exceed g assuming the central bank doesn't set interest rates.
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoGuardian Columnist Jack Schofield suggests China is making a Totalitarian Bet - that with enough software, enough sensors and enough State Security the people of china can be forever controlled and directed. I think software is too complex, society and opportunity too complex for directed development to work - it must evolve, and like science needs openness and spread of ideas - a Democratic Bet. One kind of society will be utopia and one ... not. Everyone will want to live in utopia - and it's on us to code it, vote for it, nurture it.
- hilyen 4y agoCode isn't going to solve anything unless the people deciding on what to code are the people who are directly affected by it. Code today written by America's engineers is dictated top down by their CEO's or board who are only looking to enrich themselves, so the result will be the same.
- nimbius 4y agoIm a bit of a Doctorow fanboy, but I think hes hit the nail right on the head. The reason most American trade sanctions seem so poorly defined or defended as of late is because we're not actually fighting to keep china from gleaning yet another ICBM Secret or gobbling up all of our data (American tech companies already do that.) What we're fighting so vehemently against is Huawei's introduction of 5G technology to the global market nearly a full year before any US players myopic market vision decided the US needed it. We're fighting chinese chipmakers --not because they are theives-- but because they are arriving to market with challenging, responsive, disruptive, and in some ways more advanced offerings than traditional western players. The Tiangong space station should have basically settled the oft rattled question from the octogenarians in congress: how close to the US is chinese technology. its there in most cases, beyond it in some. the sad part of Corys article is the conclusion that for every $chinese_company that now makes it to market with faster tech or better tech, the US will be forced to escalate using counterproductive and increasingly meaningless non-competitive responses like sanctions and tariffs. its a slow death unless the US gets more competitive, and by competitive i mean it cant just be axing domestic labor and posting higher revenue. US companies are going to have to eat their crow and actually offer something customers want, not something theyre told to want.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoCould you give some specifics on where the Chinese chipmakers are more advanced than western players? (Note that Taiwan does not count as "Chinese" for this.) Also, note that the US didn't try to sanction Taiwanese chipmakers at all, so Doctorow's explanation of "why" seem to not hold water.
- yogthos 4y agoa few examples https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/28/us/politics/us-china-semiconductors.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/28/us/politics/us-china-semi... https://techwireasia.com/2021/12/the-newest-chip-by-alibaba-is-the-worlds-first-heres-why/ https://techwireasia.com/2021/12/the-newest-chip-by-alibaba-... http://en.people.cn/n3/2016/0323/c98649-9034426-2.html http://en.people.cn/n3/2016/0323/c98649-9034426-2.html https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202210/1277405.shtml https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202210/1277405.shtml
- skywal_l 4y agoIt is to be noted that this road was chosen through democratic means. Reagan was elected. Clinton was elected. Thatcher and Blair too. Only fairly recently people have realized their mistake and started to resist [0] but that's probably too late now. Corporations are people and money talks and have spoken. Back to the mines people and soon the trenches ? [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_establishing_a_Constitution_for_Europe#National_processes_at_a_glance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_establishing_a_Constitu... (look at the bottom of the table)
- WalterBright 4y agoThe article has a glaring omission - the US from 1800 to WW2. Never before have such a vast quantity of people been raised from owning nothing to the middle class. You can see it in the stats - dramatically rising height, lowered infant mortality, and longevity. You can also see it in old pictures - lots and lots and lots of middle class housing.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoI think he's anchored his idea of "middle class" to a specific set of possessions, rather than to an economically reasonable definition. Specifically, he seems to be using a 1970s definition of "middle class". He gives a description that's all about having specific things like dishwashers and television. People in 1920 didn't have dishwashers, because dishwashers weren't really a commercially-available thing yet. But they were still middle class in terms of their economic relationships.
- yogthos 4y agoWait till you find out what USSR managed to do when it comes to lifting people from owning nothing. Russia went from a backwards agrarian society where people travelled by horse and carriage to being the first in space in the span of 40 years. Russia showed incredible growth after the revolution that surpassed the rest of the world: https://wid.world/document/soviets-oligarchs-inequality-property-russia-1905-2016/ https://wid.world/document/soviets-oligarchs-inequality-prop... https://wid.world/document/appendix-soviets-oligarchs-inequality-property-russia-1905-2016-wid-world-working-paper-201710/ https://wid.world/document/appendix-soviets-oligarchs-inequa... USSR provided free education to all citizens resulting in literacy rising from 33% to 99.9%: http://www.revolutionarydemocracy.org/archive/PubEdUSSR.htm http://www.revolutionarydemocracy.org/archive/PubEdUSSR.htm http://www.revolutionarydemocracy.org/archive/anglosov.htm http://www.revolutionarydemocracy.org/archive/anglosov.htm http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0000/000013/001300eo.pdf http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0000/000013/001300eo.pdf https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Likbez https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Likbez USSR doubled life expectancy in just 20 years. A newborn child in 1926-27 had a life expectancy of 44.4 years, up from 32.3 years thirty years before. In 1958-59 the life expectancy for newborns went up to 68.6 years. the Semashko system of the USSR increased lifespan by 50% in 20 years. By the 1960's, lifespans in the USSR were comparable to those in the USA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_Soviet_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_Soviet_Uni... https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_briefs/RB5054/index1.html https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_briefs/RB5054/index1.html Quality of nutrition improved after the Soviet revolution, and the last time USSR had a famine was in 1940s. CIA data suggests they ate just as much as Americans after WW2 peroid while having better nutrition: https://www.scribd.com/document/430076844/CIA-RDP84B00274R000300150009-5-pdf https://www.scribd.com/document/430076844/CIA-RDP84B00274R00... USSR moved from 58.5-hour work weeks to 41.6 hour work weeks (-0.36 h/yr) between 1913 and 1960: https://books.google.com/books?id=x8JYjwEACAAJ https://books.google.com/books?id=x8JYjwEACAAJ https://b-ok.cc/book/2669908/77497f https://b-ok.cc/book/2669908/77497f USSR averaged 22 days of paid leave in 1986 while USA averaged 7.6 in 1996: https://www.ilo.org/public/libdoc/ilo/1994/94B09_66_englp2.pdf https://www.ilo.org/public/libdoc/ilo/1994/94B09_66_englp2.p... https://www.bls.gov/news.release/ebs.t05.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/ebs.t05.htm In 1987, people in the USSR could retire with pension at 55 (female) and 60 (male) while receiving 50% of their wages at a at minimum. Meanwhile, in USA the average retirement age was 62-67 and the average (not median) retiree household in the USA could expect $48k/yr which comes out to 65% of the 74k average (not median) household income in 2016: https://www.ilo.org/public/libdoc/ilo/1994/94B09_66_englp2.pdf https://www.ilo.org/public/libdoc/ilo/1994/94B09_66_englp2.p... https://www.cbsnews.com/news/could-you-get-by-on-the-average-americans-retirement-income/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/could-you-get-by-on-the-average... GDP took off after socialism was established and then collapsed with the reintroduction of capitalism: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Soviet_Union_GDP_per_capita.gif https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Soviet_Union_GDP_per... The Soviet Union had the highest physician/patient ratio in the world. USSR had 42 doctors per 10,000 population compared to 24 in Denmark and Sweden, and 19 in US: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0735675784900482 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/07356757849... (sci-hub for access) USSR defeated a smallpox epidemic in a matter of 19 days https://www.rbth.com/history/331857-how-ussr-defeated-black-smallpox https://www.rbth.com/history/331857-how-ussr-defeated-black-... The Social Consequences of Soviet Immunization Policies https://www.ucis.pitt.edu/nceeer/1997-812-03g-Hoch.pdf https://www.ucis.pitt.edu/nceeer/1997-812-03g-Hoch.pdf Professor of Economic History, Robert C. Allen, concludes in his study without the 1917 revolution is directly responsible for rapid growth that made the achievements listed above possilbe: https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.507.8966&rep=rep1&type=pdf https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.50... Study demonstrating the steady increase in quality of life during the Soviet period (including under Stalin). Includes the fact that Soviet life expectancy grew faster than any other nation recorded at the time: https://www.jstor.org/stable/2672986?seq=1 https://www.jstor.org/stable/2672986?seq=1 A large study using world bank data analyzing the quality of life in Capitalist vs Socialist countries and finds overwhelmingly at similar levels of development with socialism bringing better quality of life: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1646771/pdf/amjph00269-0055.pdf https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1646771/pdf/amj... This study compared western and eastern blocs in measures of the physical quality of life (PQL), taking into account the level of economic development https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2430906/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2430906/
- imtringued 4y ago>But by the Reagan era, the party was over. People had all the stuff they needed. They’d replace it from time to time. Capitalism doesn't work if everyone has everything they need. Perfect markets reduce profit margins as close to zero as possible. People will then stop investing because they can just sit on cash instead and do nothing. If you base your economy on constant profits and endless growth then you will have to reset it with a war every now and then.
- ryan93 4y agoHis claim that republicans will get rid of social security makes me take the rest of the piece less seriously.
- wnoise 4y agoThere are many that have literally admitted to wanting do so. https://www.barrons.com/articles/social-security-cuts-republicans-congress-51667590595 https://www.barrons.com/articles/social-security-cuts-republ...
- ryan93 4y agoIt’s evil. But also right wing “virtue signaling”. Won’t happen
- Tao3300 4y agoThat's the attitude that allowed Prohibition to happen. Weird virtue signaling over something very few people actually wanted allowed people to gain political clout, but then it all backfired and we accidentally got the thing.
- ryan93 4y agoIt was ratified by 46 states. Eliminating social security has zero support with democrats. And not much more with millions of republicans. Won’t happen. Historical comparisons aren’t necessarily Illuminative.
- rufus_foreman 4y agoNot one Republican in the article you cited literally admits to wanting to get rid of Social Security. Most of them mentioned in the article are apparently 8 Senate Republicans who are co-sponsors of the TRUST Act which would create Congressional committees to come up with plans to deal with federal programs that are heading towards insolvency, including Social Security. The act was also co-sponsored by 3 Senate Democrats, one Senate Independent, 2 House Republicans and 3 House Democrats. If that is "wanting to get rid of Social Security" (it isn't) then getting rid of Social Security is a bi-partisan effort. Then you also have one Republican who thinks we need benefit cuts at some point to deal with insolvency, one who thinks Social Security should be moved to discretionary funding rather than non-discretionary, one who thinks all federal programs should need to be voted on every 5 years, and one who made comments about getting rid of Social Security in 2010 but who now says we need to raise the retirement age to deal with insolvency.
- georgeoliver 4y agoThere is a big disconnect between Doctorow going on about his middle class Phd parents and the plight of 'the workers'. Phds are around 1% of the population and their earnings typically put them in the top 20%. IMO it seems more likely that the interests of this class, and others similar -- the lawyers, doctors, engineers -- will align more with the elite than the serfs, and until that changes the possibility of true structural change in the US feels remote.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoThat depends on the elites (presuming Doctorow's perspective is accurate). Truly smart elites would keep the top 10% in the game. But if Doctorow is right, the elites almost always eventually get greedy and blow this, and the system then collapses, because the elites are not competent to actually run it well (and, my own addition, because the 10% quit propping up the elites' incompetence).
- legitster 4y agoAlso, a lot of this analysis only makes sense to children of the elite (ie, the child of a successful author). There's a natural regression to the mean. Kids of poor parents will be better off than their parents. Kids of rich parents will be worse off than their parents. So when he looks around at his peer group, he sees the same thing - people who were worse off than their parents. But it's really only a view shared by middle class white people.
- advisedwang 4y ago> IMO it seems more likely that the interests of this class, and others similar -- the lawyers, doctors, engineers -- will align more with the elite than the serfs. It often feels like this in the US. We (educated, well paid, middle class people) do have a closer cultural experience with the true elite. But despite the similar cultural experience the economic underpinnings are very different. Paying your bills from the wages of your job is categorically different from getting yield on an investment. This economic difference becomes apparent in how the system evolves - when jobs shift offshore, you might see the well paid jobs disappear while owners* continue to make profit from the offshored business. In other words, it turns out that well paid wage earners like me are actually in the same fundemental economic situation as "the serfs" even if our day to day lives look like the elite, for now. * Many working people do have stock, especially when you count retirement (thanks to the 401k). This does them owners in one sense - the do literally own part of corps and get some of their profit. But while that's still just a supplement to wages as the main income, it doesn't really matter. If you lose your job or it becomes low-paying, your ownership will dry up rapidly. It hasn't changed your position in the system.