10 ms·
The Sad Saga of the 500 MHz Power Mac G4
- exabrial 4y agoMy powerpc widescreen powerbook what is the finest product Apple has ever put out. It was repairable, it had MagSafe, it was beautiful, and it had actual fricken ports. Usbc pretty much negates the need for ports, except ethernet, but still…
- JeremyHerrman 4y agoApple laptops had an amazing run from 2000-2015, starting with the Titanium PowerBook G4 and ending with the retina MacBook Pro (pre-touchbar). FYI MagSafe was introduced with the first intel MacBook Pros in 2006 (although they had a nearly identical case as the PowerBook G4), so unfortunately no PowerPC notebooks had it.
- exabrial 4y agoMaybe it was an intel then, not a g4… definitely had magsafe!
- WoodenChair 4y agoWe ordered the 500 MHz model when it was first announced. When it didn't come out as originally scheduled, we were offered to continue waiting or take a 450 MHz model. We opted to wait. We did eventually get our 500 MHz model and I used that computer for at least 5 years. It was an awesome machine for the time, even late. It was a great machine for the early versions of Mac OS X and the transition from Mac OS 9 to Mac OS X.
- pencilguin 4y agoTl;dr: Announced .5GHz G4, shipped slower ones that were, nonetheless, faster than contemporaneous PIIIs, for a long time before delivering the announced faster one.
- theandrewbailey 4y ago> The Power Mac G4, which features the PowerPC G4 processor with its remarkable Velocity Engine, runs professional applications like Adobe Photoshop over 50 percent faster than 800 MHz Pentium III-based PCs. Is that any faster than modern versions of Photoshop today?
- purpleflame1257 4y agoThat Photoshop was probably CS2 IIRC. I'm fairly sure that software bloat has eaten all the speed gains from faster processors. I have an old 1.33 GHz Powerbook which runs 2004 Word as fast as my M1 macbook runs Office today. If I put in an SSD it might even be faster.
- leeter 4y ago> If I put in an SSD it might even be faster. I think most of the retro youtubers I've seen have done this mod along with PRam battery replacements that don't leak. They seem to use the m.2 SATA mode drives to 44pin like thus (not recommending, just showing an example) https://www.amazon.com/44pin-Converter-Adapter-Computer-Accessries/dp/B06XC36V63 https://www.amazon.com/44pin-Converter-Adapter-Computer-Acce...
- anthk 4y agoOpenBSD for macppc would run perfectly fine and fast enough on that. Not for JS heavy sites, but Seamonkey with UBlock Origin Legacy would do a great job. For youtube, Mplayer and yt-dlp would do the job. SMPlayer + "open url" dialog for graphical folks.
- xxpor 4y agoDo you think the g4 would have enough juice to do software decoding of h264 in real time? (slash is ffmpeg optimized enough for a relatively obscure platform like macppc? e.g. does it actually use altivec?)
- 4y ago
- yongmuller 4y agoI had a 400MHz model that I hand overclocked to 800MHz by re-soldering the multiplier on the processor. That thing ran perfectly for over 10 years as my main PCI Pro Tools system. 2001-2010. RIP you beautiful grey beast.
- geerlingguy 4y agoThat was the era where I remember every radio and audio production studio would start moving systems over to Windows—except for it seemed there was always one Mac left running ProTools, since it could sit quietly in the studio and the licensing was pretty crazy expensive. Plus the audio processing chain the Mac was a lot better (better latency and easier introspection) than anything on Windows at the time.
- Maursault 4y ago> That was the era where I remember every radio and audio production studio would start moving systems over to Windows This is a myth. I seriously doubt any nationally marketed record was ever tracked and mixed using Pro Tools on Windows, at least, I am unaware of any. When big artists showed interest in Microsoft products, it was not for Windows with Pro Tools, it was for Internet technologies. Throughout the 90's up to 2000 (500Mhz G4 "era") nearly all pro audio was still Mac, but Windows was an alternative in audio by 2001 and it got talked about. Certainly some had built Windows rigs, but they were independent and home-based operations. Few, if any, professional studio enterprises used Windows for tracking and mixing. By 2004, Windows and PCs still did offer a slightly cheaper alternative (Digi equipment cost what it cost on either platform), but only new operations and some higher education communication programs had invested in audio on Windows platforms. No one was replacing and tossing Mac DAWs, ever, because Pro Tools and other audio hw was expensive and still sounded good, no matter how old it was it sounded the same as it did when new. By 2004, Windows still barely had its foot in the door in pro audio, and most pro audio operations were still Mac central.[1] By 2011, any competition Windows ever gave Mac in the studio was over, but for some reason the myth that Windows took over audio production from Mac at some point still existed.[2] But it was always false. Certainly, there were Windows PC fanatics that have ever insisted Mac was overpriced and better rigs could be built on PC, and some of them were engineers and opened their own studios, but in general these were much smaller operations compared to full size, full service recording studios. You'd have some little studio that had a tracking room and a control room built into their basement or their garage or shed. Any large studio with a full-sized control room and multiple tracking rooms, a couple smaller control rooms ("Studio B, Studio C") and, you know, a lobby, an artists' lounge, a business office, storage rooms, what you'd consider a "real" professional studio, was always Mac, even if they were still running OS9 and older Digi equipment as late as 2009 and beyond, these systems stayed in place because they kept working and new ADCs and Pro Tools software licensing was and still is expensive. It is 2022, and I guarantee you there are full sized pro studios still using OS9 on G4 with Pro Tools and Digi racks that will only upgrade to 10yo hw when those things stop working or they can't find replacement ATA hard drives, because Mac Pros are crazy expensive and it is hard for them to get their head around USB3 and Thunderbolt2 and not needing PCI anymore, but mostly reluctance comes from having to reinvest maybe tens of thousands of dollars into Intel-based plugins they already have on PPC and new multi-channel digital rack ADC systems. If it was only the Pro Tools licensing, they might have stayed current, but even with bundled plugins and lower cost hardware, it's hard to abandon things that are already paid for 20ya and still working, unless, of course, you're Skywalker Sound. [1] https://duc.avid.com/showthread.php?t=99826 https://duc.avid.com/showthread.php?t=99826 [2] https://gearspace.com/board/music-computers/609183-most-professional-studios-use-windows-using-windows-7-now.html https://gearspace.com/board/music-computers/609183-most-prof...
- Cockbrand 4y agoI ordered a G4 450MHz pretty much the day they were announced. After some back and forth with the dealer, I was sent two machines - one with 450MHz as originally announced, and one with the same specs, but only 400MHz as initially shipped. Somehow, my dealer was able to get a few of the initially very rare machines with the original specs, and I was lucky enough to get one. I don't really recall why I had been sent two machines, but I know that I was instructed that this would happen, and I had to look at the specs printed on the box and send back the slower one.
- erickhill 4y ago"G4 lineup clown" I assume this was a PDF copy/paste snafu where it should have said "down" not "clown". But it definitely made me do a double-take. (or triple)
- rsynnott 4y ago> you won’t be able to play with cool new capabilities like using an AirPort card, internal FireWire devices, two separate USB ports _Internal FireWire devices_? Did anyone ever actually produce one of these?
- addaon 4y agoI recall them coming up in the context of capture cards occasionally. Wasn't on the video production side of the world so not sure how common they were.
- esprehn 4y agoIt doesn't seem like it: https://lowendmac.com/tech/internalfw.shtml https://lowendmac.com/tech/internalfw.shtml I think you could put a storage drive inside the case maybe, or a rail mount bay. I never heard of anyone using that port.
- compiler-guy 4y agoThe derisive term “speed dump” evolved out of the term “speed bump” which is what people called it when a vendor shipped a new machine with a higher clocked cpu, but no other changes.
- Kon-Peki 4y agoI ordered the 400MHz PCI version (Yikes!) with student pricing on the first day. The first computer I owned myself. I remember getting it with no delay, as well as a t-shirt and two large posters. I upgraded the memory as soon as I could afford it. I remember using the OS9 RAM disk feature for many programming assignments and getting amazing performance with a nearly silent machine, as it spun down the HD and turned off most fans. It was a great computer, and upgraded to OS X perfectly.
- snapetom 4y agoI remember this fiasco. And then shortly after that, rumors started popping up that Apple was working on porting OSX to x86.
- Maursault 4y ago> I remember this fiasco. And then shortly after that, rumors started popping up that Apple was working on porting OSX to x86. Article concerns the last half of 1999. It turns out Mac OS X development on PPC was shadowed on Intel (after all, since 1995 NeXTSTEP ran on Intel), but the rumor didn't appear until nearly 3 years later in Spring 2002, and it didn't really have any traction and quickly subsided long before Jobs' announcement confirming the rumor another 3 years after that in Summer 2005.[1] No one still expected it by then, but at the same time, no one was all that surprised. Business as usual that Apple kept a secret for 3 years, but it's pretty crazy how they somehow suppressed a true rumor for 3 years after it was published. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacOS#PowerPC–Intel_transition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacOS#PowerPC–Intel_transition
- diskzero 4y agoWe actually had an Intel build of most of OSX from the beginning. Various parts would go stale and then a motivated engineer would dive in and get it running again on some specific set of audio and video hardware. At some point the existence of the "Marklar" project leaked out, but several of us at Apple had various builds running on commodity PC hardware.
- shrubble 4y agoAny truth to the 'NRW' based on the Motorola 88k CPU, rumors?
- batman-farts 4y agoI always figured this had to be the case. OPENSTEP 4.2 ran just fine on x86, why give that up?
- mschaef 4y agoApple really did have to push the (Motorola) G4 way more than they'd have liked. A 1999 G4 was a 400MHz G4 on a 100MHz FSB. By the 2003, when they were done with Motorola and and onto the IBM G5, they were running a pair of 1.25GHz G4's on a 167MHz FSB... I'm sure it was possible to get a lot of speed out of workloads that ran out of the on-chip cache, but I'm equally sure that it was easy to wind up constrained by memory bus bandwidth. I tried to convince myself to buy one and switch to OS X, but couldn't get past the architectural limitations. (Which were worse because I'd also have wanted to run Windows under emulation.)
- LAC-Tech 4y ago500mhz was really slow in '99 wasn't it? I had my first computer either then or in 2000: 10GB hard drive, 64mb of ram, and 600mhz. It was the cheapest one they had. EDIT: Maybe my memory is hazy and it was more like 300mhz.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Zak 4y agoClock speeds are not directly comparable as measures of CPU performance between different architectures. Intel in particular focused on increasing clock speed with little regard to performance during that time period. The G4 had a powerful (for the time) vector processor, which is relevant to media production. It was not slow when used for that purpose with software that took advantage of the vector unit. Apple's marketing cherry-picked benchmarks to claim that the G4 was much faster than Intel chips with higher clock speeds, but the reality was somewhere in the middle.
- _chu1 4y agoExactly like the M1 now
- santoshalper 4y agoIt's good to see some things never change. The generous interpretation is that Apple knows that their users tend to skew towards "creative" professions like digital audio, video, graphic design etc. and so they pick the benchmarks that those people care about. You can write the ungenerous interpretation yourself.
- Maursault 4y agoPPCs ran hot and sucked power. Apple's machines at release are ordinarily the most performant machines available for consumers, but that lead never lasts long. The G4 at each new release was indeed more performant than the current Intel machines, but only for a few months. Remember, the G4 was considered a "supercomputer," and the US government banned its export, which hurt Apple, though they tried to make hay with it by marketing this, by the end of 1999, they were desperately trying to get that ban lifted. There still seems to be some confusion about Apple Silicon and the M1. When M1 was released, it wasn't the fastest processor. You could actually build a faster Intel machine in 2020, but it would cost a lot more money and use a lot more power. What was and is special about the M1 is how little power it uses for its performance, which is decent but, like all new Apple products, an incremental increase in performance, and how cheap the low end offering still is. And I'm pretty sure that today you still can't beat the 2020 M1 Mac mini performance and features on Intel for 700 bucks. What is amazing about the M1 is that it is a lateral move, a platform shift, without sacrificing performance, and it is incrementally faster than the 2018 Intel Mac mini at less than half the price.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoSad saga ==> High-end CPU delayed six months. :-/
- justinator 4y agoI had one of these machines - I wanna say the 450 Mhz one, I bought in early 2000, c/o the Apple Loan for Students program. The total was $4,000 for everything including a whopping 17" CRT monitor! Had I paid it on their schedule, the rig would have cost me $8,000. Way too much computer for a kid that worked part time as a Perl dev at a web design company making $10/hour while also going to school for art. Now of course my iPhone SE 2020 is far more powerful in every single way. I do remember being rather annoyed with the speed reduction/price raising. Being a total Apple fanboy, I was deeply entrenched in their fight against uh: the Man, or Intel, or whatever the marketing told me to be mad at.
- Finnucane 4y agoI had a b&w G3 and i remember actually being a little miffed that Apple introduced the G4 version only a few months later. At some point I upgraded the CPU to a G4 anyway (when you could still do that sort of thing on a Mac), so I guess it didn't make a lot of difference.
- mk_stjames 4y agoSomething I'd like to reminisce on for a second is the absolute amazing combination of both form and function the G3 and G4 standard tower case was, in my opinion. It was a machine that looked sleek and futuristic while also being 'made for work'. They were heavy beasts, but had the integrated handles. And the hardware layout inside... with the side panel that mounted the motherboard on the side that folded out with no tools, just a pull on the latch.. and the PSU cable and hard drive cables all made to route to where they ran at the hinge, allowing the fold out to be so clean and presenting the whole board so perfectly. The closest modern equivalent is something like a HP Z8 series (I now own an 840 as a workstation), but with GPUs and CPU coolers being so massive, it just cannot be as elegantly packaged as those simpler PPC machines.
- autotune 4y agoiMac G4 non-tower form is probably the best looking Mac out of any imho. Peak design.
- dec0dedab0de 4y agoI used to do tech support for a small ISP and we had a power mac G5 in our test lab. I would open it up and show everyone how beautiful it was.
- 0x445442 4y agoThat and the Sun Ultra 45 were very nice designs.
- space_ghost 4y agoI also have fond memories of the G4 case for this reason - it was a breath of fresh air after so many years of dealing with cumbersome Whiteboxen.
- jtbayly 4y agoBeige...
- ben7799 4y agoAll I remember of this early period was just how much OS9 would crash when using "Professional" applications, making any performance increase in the Mac almost pointless. I took a "fun" elective course in electronic media my senior year of school. It was Photoshop, video editing on VHS + digital video editing, and electronic music production. All my CS work was on IBM RS6000s or SGI Indy & O2s at that point. I had a homebuilt Pentium desktop machine dual booting Linux & Windows NT that I used for my work and a 486 laptop running Linux that was getting long in the tooth by 1999. I was very much used to computers not crashing by that point, NT was pretty good, Linux and the Sun/IBM/SGI workstations would stay up for a year no problem as security updates requiring reboots weren't coming very quickly yet. I vividly remember greatly preferring doing all the video editing on the analog VHS editing stations because OS9 was so unbelievably unstable. Maybe the ultra expensive Avid workstations were less unstable, but I was in a 100 level course and not allowed to use them. We were saving our work after every operation the Macs were crashing so much. Of course pretty soon after this OSX started making things right in the world. It's easy to take Mac OS for granted these days! Heck even an iPhone with iMovie today would run rings around the Avid workstations from 1999!
- pcurve 4y agoI used Mac throughout the 90s. System 7, 8, as they called it. The worst part of Mac crash was they were violet, unpredictable and would result in app crash or more often complete system lockup.
- Cerium 4y agoBack then people would joke that Macintosh was an acronym: Most Applications Crash, If Not The Operating System Hangs
- runlevel1 4y agoClassic Mac OS was cursed by its memory management. Decisions that made sense pre-multitasking would later haunt them up through Mac OS 9.[^1] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classic_Mac_OS_memory_management https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classic_Mac_OS_memory_manageme...
- jedberg 4y agoMy first Mac was a used 400MHz G4 that I picked up in 2002. At the time it was a spare machine next to my Intel PC running Linux. I put (brand new at the time) Mac OS X 10.1 Puma on it, mainly so I could compare the experience of using the two OSs side by side. The Mac experience was just so smooth compared to the desktop Linux experience. I've been using Mac exclusively since 2003, and it was all due to that free used G4 tower.
- jamespo 4y agoWell... you get what you pay for.
- Lammy 4y ago> In order to get one model in the G4 lineup down under $2,000-and to get it out to customers as soon as possible Apple placed a 400MHz G4 processor onto a slightly modified version of the blue-and-white G3’s logic board and put the board in the new Power Mac G4 case. One really shitty thing Apple did alongside this was release a firmware update for the actual Blue&White G3 which prevented it from booting with a G4 CPU swapped in, something that worked fine with the original 1.0 firmware: https://web.archive.org/web/20021002071131/http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=58374 https://web.archive.org/web/20021002071131/http://docs.info.... Luckily the block was easily and quickly undone by the various upgrade manufacturers, but it shouldn't have been there to begin with: https://macintoshgarden.org/apps/powerlogix-g4-firmware-updater-11 https://macintoshgarden.org/apps/powerlogix-g4-firmware-upda...
- Tepix 4y agoIt's happening all the time, for example AMD B450 boards received PCIe 4.0 compatability via a firmware update before AMD asked the mainboard manufacturers to pull the feature again. Or now nVidia is offering DLSS 3.0 with their new Geforce 4000 cards, however it appears very likely that they could also do it with the older cards. Statements to the contrary seem far fetched. nVidia has done this in the past, too (RTX IO comes to mind).
- AceJohnny2 4y ago> "The move is in response to Motorola’s delays in reaching volume production of its 500 MHz G4 processor chip, which is now scheduled for availability early next year." > "A full six months after its original introduction, Apple was finally shipping a 500 MHz Power Mac G4. [...] a lesson in controlling your own technology stack that Apple wouldn’t forget." I guess this was the start of the PowerPC production (and later, performance) woes that would eventually lead to Apple transitioning to Intel, announced at WWDC 2005.
- classichasclass 4y agoStill got a 450MHz Sawtooth G4 as a server (with a FireWire RAID). It also broadcasts radio audio from a RADIOshark or a USB flash drive of music, and controls the air conditioner.
- wazoox 4y agoBack in 2000 in my job I had a 400 Mhz G4, and a dual PIII 500Mhz server (running RedHat 5.2) to work with. Once set up to dual-boot Yellowdog Linux, the G4 literally ran circles around the dual PIII machine particularly for anything network-related (the onboard 1 GigE certainly helped).