8 ms·
NYC jail complex to be restored into citywide green energy hub
- nonethewiser 4y agoIt's hard to understand why you would want to close one jail and open 4 smaller jails further away. That is going to be a lot more difficult to manage. Not to mention crime has been increasing and the total jail capacity will be a bit over 50% of Rykers. It seems like they are waisting time and resources with dreams while neglecting basic needs.
- _eht 4y agoIt’s called keeping payroll busy. Also known as taxation without representation.
- ceejayoz 4y agoWhat part of NYC lacks elected representation?
- swores 4y agoPresumably the part that is in prisons?
- ceejayoz 4y agoHow many of the prisoners are subject to taxation? Some of them get to vote, too. https://www.nyclu.org/en/know-your-rights/voting-criminal-record https://www.nyclu.org/en/know-your-rights/voting-criminal-re... "Misdemeanors do not impact your right to vote. You may still register and vote if you are in jail for a misdemeanor or are awaiting trial..."
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThey've been planning this for years. Rikers is down about 50%-75% in occupancy since 1991 and there's a similar big dip in crime. Distributed jails just make financial sense, though there's lots of other "progressive" reasons to make the change too.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Not to mention crime has been increasing... Rikers was opened in 1932. It's seen far higher crime rates than this year's. Murders, for example, are 1/4 what they were in the '90s: https://twitter.com/brianpmangan/status/1588275665350012928 https://twitter.com/brianpmangan/status/1588275665350012928 Coverage of crime, though, disproportionately spiked, which is likely why folks think crime is high: https://twitter.com/brianpmangan/status/1588277958556274688 https://twitter.com/brianpmangan/status/1588277958556274688 > It's hard to understand why you would want to close one jail and open 4 smaller jails further away. Further away from what? The intent (https://rikers.cityofnewyork.us/ https://rikers.cityofnewyork.us/) is to bring prisoners into newer facilities closer to their families.
- james-bonds 4y agoIt's not just media coverage, although that is a narrative being pushed. For instance, this Bloomberg article tries to paint that narrative: https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2022-is-nyc-safe-crime-stat-reality/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2022-is-nyc-safe-crime-st... However, if we look at the NYPD data [0], you can see that rape, robbery, felony assault, burglary, grand larceny, and car theft are all up by 14.4%, 34.4%, 25%, 2.2%, 45.3%, and 52.7% respectively over the last 2 years. Over the last 12 years, rape is up 22%, felony assault is over 50%, grand larceny up 37% and car theft up 30%. How can you look at this data and say this is just a media narrative? [0] https://www.nyc.gov/assets/nypd/downloads/pdf/crime_statistics/cs-en-us-city.pdf https://www.nyc.gov/assets/nypd/downloads/pdf/crime_statisti...
- zuminator 4y agoCrime has spiked up quite a bit in the past few years in New York City and if you follow the narrative being pushed in the New York Post and other conservative organs, you'd think that crime level has nearly returned to the "bad old days" of the 90s. But your own stats show that even with the current boomlet, crime's still down 80% from the peak in 1990. Of particular note, your data shows that all of the city's current crime numbers are still lower than 2001's, which was Giuliani's final and best year in office.
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago>That is going to be a lot more difficult to manage Hard to manage also means hard to scrutinize.
- mschuster91 4y ago> It's hard to understand why you would want to close one jail and open 4 smaller jails further away. That is going to be a lot more difficult to manage. Multiple issues come to my mind: - the larger the facility, the greater the chance of riots or unrest escalating - it is more difficult to maintain different standards of imprisoning (low, middle and high security) in one complex - it may be infeasible to renovate an existing building to current code and requirements while it's still being occupied, if it is at all possible (e.g. floor plan layout changes tend to be difficult to modify in prisons as the walls are very thick) - smaller prisons spread across the country can make it easier for prisoners' relatives across the state to visit them, which usually leads to lower recidivism as prisoners can still keep contact with family
- aerostable_slug 4y ago> it is more difficult to maintain different standards of imprisoning (low, middle and high security) in one complex This is a solved problem. It's really not hard to segregate the various populations. We do this every day. > it may be infeasible to renovate an existing building Likely true. > smaller prisons spread across the country can make it easier for prisoners' relatives across the state to visit them Arguably true. Tablet-based video visits have changed the workload on family members. That said, the reduced burden on friends & family that don't want to engage in video visits is significant.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- galimaufry 4y agoRiker's island is very poorly designed. A big part of the problem is that it is quite inaccessible from the rest of the city. This has a ton of knock-on effects: 1. There's a severe shortage of guards. Anything that could make working in the jails more attractive will help, and a 2-hour commute is not attractive. 2. Getting medical service, prisoners with court dates, lawyers, etc. on and off the island is really really slow. 3. The jail has insourced a lot of services (for example they run a large bakery). These get staffed by corrections officers. This both makes staffing harder, and the existence of these plum positions has weird effects on the politics of the corrections union (people with power in the union are not actually working as guards and are out of touch with the reality of the jail) Moving to a model like the Tombs, with the jail directly above the courthouse, makes way more sense. In addition, the buildings on the island need a serious revamp (e.g. there is no automatic access control, so every major door needs a guard physically standing there to let people through and climate control is broken). As long as you need to seriously renovate anyway, might as well just build a new jail where it should have been put in the first place. Source: I read a lot of blogposts.
- FateOfNations 4y ago> Riker's island is very poorly designed "designed" is a bit generous... It's a hodge-podge of facilities built over time as need arose with little consideration of long-term planning or a comprehensive strategy for the complex.
- ceejayoz 4y ago4. #2 means family visits are often impractical and time consuming, which leads to fewer visits, which leads to more crime. https://www.prisonpolicy.org/blog/2021/12/21/family_contact/ https://www.prisonpolicy.org/blog/2021/12/21/family_contact/ > A 1972 study on visitation that followed 843 people on parole from California prisons found that those who had no visitors during their incarceration were six times more likely to be reincarcerated than people with three or more visitors.
- willcipriano 4y agoThat's almost certainly correlation and not causation. Most families will probably visit you the first time you end up in prison, by the 5th time they will have written you off.
- Spooky23 4y agoIt’s completely ungovernable because the labor runs the asylum. Opening new facilities makes it easier to deal with the union and fix the administrative processes. The management can transfer people and be slightly more selective to encourage and punish. Also, they can hire actual administrative staff instead of having COs working as clerks, etc.
- bobthepanda 4y agoThere are a couple of factors aside from the fact that Rikers is a well-documented human rights abuse well beyond most jails: * the court systems are at the county level, not city, and so everyone being at Rikers means that you have to transport people to court, lawyers and families have to travel far from their homes, etc. The county courthouses for each borough are much more centrally located than Rikers * Rikers is simultaneously not near anything and also on prime land. LGA has really bad capacity constraints, Rikers is the next closest piece of land available and the East River between it is very shallow
- pasttense01 4y agoNew York City is a very small place: only 302 square miles. Nobody has to travel very far to get from one place to another in the City. Conversely the rural Midwest county with less than 19,000 people where I live has an area twice as big--and most of the counties in my state are roughly that size. As to transporting people to court they should switch to Zoom instead.
- aerostable_slug 4y ago> As to transporting people to court they should switch to Zoom instead. This is happening. Same with video visits. The reform movement for Riker's started well before these were realities for the majority of inmates.
- panzagl 4y agoWater makes travel take longer than the small area would indicate- there's a reason why anyone who drives through NYC is obsessed with bridges and tunnels.
- bobthepanda 4y agoAlso, heavy congestion. It can easily take an hour to drive from Rikers to Downtown Brooklyn or Jamaica, where two of the five courthouses are.
- alecb 4y agofor those unaware, even in deep blue New York, Riker's has been run as a Guantanamo-style prison camp where there is no civilian oversight over conditions or corrections officers. to me, the most appalling aspect has been the amount of people locked up indefinitely over misdemeanors and thrown into gen pop to basically die
- spywaregorilla 4y agoWhat does civilian oversight over conditions and corrections officers mean in practice?
- jakelazaroff 4y agoAs a bare minimum, professional consequences and/or criminal charges when inmates die?
- alecb 4y agoit means that essentially the corrections officer union has gummed up any and all reforms passed through legislation (think video cameras in public areas, anti-violence training, etc.). this has led to a situation where there is a preventable suicide about once every 2 weeks in the prison and state officials are calling for federal intervention since they can't effectively change conditions; https://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/nyc-crime/ny-man-dies-rikers-island-20221022-3c3u4e25snep5am4vafydajhea-story.html https://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/nyc-crime/ny-man-dies-r...
- spywaregorilla 4y agoThat makes sense, thanks.
- ch4s3 4y agoRepercussions when someone dies of exposure in solitary confinement while awaiting trial.
- muaytimbo 4y agoOversight could easily mean installing surveillance infrastructure to monitor guards as well as inmates. Making that public would offer even more accountability.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- returningfory2 4y agoI feel this plan is really poor use of Rikers Island. Green energy installations can be done anywhere. Being in the middle of New York City (sort of) Rikers has amazing potential as a public park - something like Governors Island 2.
- pastor_bob 4y agoRikers: 1. Sits on top of a former landfill 2. Is adjacent to LaGuardia Airport Thus, there aren't many good options for redevelopment. Green energy/industry is definitely one of the best possible moves
- jelling 4y agoNew Yorker here. If this happens, great, but ysk that building those replacements jails is a knock-down drag out fight on the local level. Even renovating/replacing an existing jail in my neighborhood is being opposed by people that literally want to get rid of jails altogether. Literally, we can't close the terrible, poorly run jail (Rikers) because some people don't want jails at all. So take this article with an enormous grain of salt. And ymmv, but articles that simultaneously play to green energy projects (good thing) and carceral reform (good thing, more complicated in reality) are likely high-minded click-bait.
- codyb 4y agoYea, this rings really true, and it's pretty frustrating that we can't do anything about Rikers cause of it. The abolish prisons before neighborhoods are actually safe thing is... ridiculous. You have to uplift the communities before you can have a jail free system. You can't just jump straight to jail free. Most of the "abolish prison" types appear to be the super left wing which is like.... not a lot of NYC and mostly concentrated in Manhattan (hence Adam's win in all the other boroughs). I'm hoping, if done well, and with out treating minorities like shit, that the NYPD being all over the subway will be effective in making NYers feel safe on the subway again (I think the crime wave was a bit overblown but it did get a bit seedier for sure), and maybe get the NYPD and the communities to a decent place. That'd be a nice win for the city.
- asdff 4y agoI don't get why people aren't arguing to just convert jails instead of shutting them down. If there is a lot of demand for people with mental health issues and not a lot of people who truly need to be behind bars, then just convert the jail property into an asylum. Whether you operate with mainly jails or mainly asylums you still need public land and facilities and jails are frankly a good site to store sensitive people. If you shut down jails before you build these asylums then you now have to go to the market and try and get land together for these things, and we have seen what an enormous hurdle that has been for governments undertaking those efforts At least with the subway in LA the way the cops currently patrol it is pretty useless. I've seen four cops talking amongst themselves about 100 feet just on the other side of a stairwell from where someone was using a creme brule torch to light up a glass pipe for their buddy in the middle of the train platform. I see hard drugs smoked probably once or twice a week and I'm going during the 9-5, I can't imagine how much more is smoked during off peak hours when the stations are much more dead. It seems like subway security is better solved by just having someone sit in a room looking at all the camera feeds in the station (there are already cameras everywhere on every corner but evidently they aren't used for much), seeing when someone is clearly hitting a crack rock or prying into a maintenance power outlet, and sending someone down to respond to what was seen on the video feed just now. Otherwise, people aren't dumb, they will just quiet down when they see a cop and start acting out again as soon as the cop is out of sight or earshot. Cops will also not care to do anything unless they literally saw it occur in front of their eyes, so having them be directed by a video operator at least serves as a record.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoWhy would you build energy infrastructure in a flood prone environment? We don't need green washing on every piece of abandoned land to hide the expense of cleanup costs. This sort of crap is why I voted against the vague environmental bond act.
- muaytimbo 4y agoAnd this will only cost . . . billions more than whatever already enormous projection we get from the city and be completed 10 years after the promised date.
- blooalien 4y agoToo little, too late… The "climate crisis" is already well into "climate disaster" at this point, and not enough folks care for it to improve before it's far beyond too late…
- thinkiewinkie 4y ago