4 ms·
Whatever Apple is doing, it should be possible to buy a phone and not have it phone home without permission. And you should be able to use the phone without eve
by amelius 4y ago
Whatever Apple is doing, it should be possible to buy a phone and not have it phone home without permission. And you should be able to use the phone without ever contacting the vendor again. Otherwise you bought a service, not a product.
Also, I recall a case where MacOS was asking Apple permission whenever the user wished to start an executable. This is nuts.
- _Algernon_ 4y agoThat exists. It's called a dumbphone
- coldtea 4y agoThe line is blurry with smartphones, as all kinds of "smart" functionality IS a service, and depends on contacting the vendor. >Also, I recall a case where MacOS was asking Apple permission whenever the user wished to start an executable. This is nuts. Not that nuts. It's intended to be able to blacklist malware and such and retroactively disable it, through notarization (basically, registering apps to Apple and them getting a kind of fingerprint). They could have done it with a local cache (and they probably do in some capacity), but it would still need to ask/sync every now and then.
- amelius 4y ago> The line is blurry with smartphones, as all kinds of "smart" functionality IS a service, and depends on contacting the vendor. No, because you can make your phone work with other service providers. The dependence on the original hardware vendor is artificial. > It's intended to be able to blacklist malware Choice of blacklists, content filters etc. is also orthogonal to the vendor.
- simonh 4y agoAnd if you want a phone that works that way, they do exist. Personally I'm happy to offload most of that to one service provider, so I'm happy to use an iPhone. If that changes, I'll look elsewhere. Your mileage may vary.
- coldtea 4y ago>No, because you can make your phone work with other service providers. The dependence on the original hardware vendor is artificial. Yes. But then it wouldn't be a commercial commodity product, it would be more of a build-your-own DIY kit. Would it be as succesful? >Choice of blacklists, content filters etc. is also orthogonal to the vendor. Everything is orthogonal to the vendor, even choice of screen or disk. But most people don't like choice, want something that mostly works as is. And even for those that do the optionally increases the product complexity, maintainance, and error condition space (integrated vs mix-and-match). Plus, a few modular laptop and mobile phone designs never sold well.
- simondotau 4y agoThe merits of your arguments aside, Apple is not obliged to sell you a device that satisfies your personal requirements. Apple most definitely sells you a service, which is a managed computing platform. Alternatives exist. (And if they don’t, that’s not Apple’s problem.)
- amelius 4y agoIt's a different discussion but I don't buy the "alternatives exists" argument. There are huge network effects. Some governments even make apps only for the duopoly. Banks also. Yes, sometimes you can use websites instead of apps, but it is not the same thing. Alternatives exist only in theory. Companies should not have absolute freedom if this means that the freedom of the consumer is restricted in any way. "Alternatives exists" sounds a lot like this fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergo_decedo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergo_decedo The world isn't as simple as: there are companies and they can sell whatever they like, and there are consumers and they can buy whatever they like, because that would end very badly for the consumers.
- simondotau 4y ago> "Alternatives exists" sounds a lot like this fallacy The fact that an argument is superficially similar to an informal fallacy doesn't make the argument inherently fallacious. You can easily construct a variation of the same conversation which is structurally identical but is obviously not fallacious— Critic: "I want a banana, but I don't like the texture." Respondent: "If you don't like them, don't eat them." What the respondent said is only a fallacy if the purpose was to counter the criticism. But the criticism wasn't rejected. What was rejected was the unstated but implied assertion that the critic was entitled to a banana which satisfies them. Now let's turn that into an "alternatives exist" argument and replay— Critic: "I demand a banana that I do like." Respondent: "I understand your desire for a banana which suits you. However nobody is obligated to supply you with such a banana. Thankfully, alternatives do exist, such as the nectarine." That's not a fallacy. And it's not a fallacy to say that Apple is not obligated to make an iPhone which satisfies you. Especially because it's a statement of fact. If you don't like that you can't buy an Apple branded dumbphone, and you have failed to convince Apple to make it for you, perhaps try lobbying your government? They could pass a law which requires smartphone makers to also sell dumbphones.
- kmlx 4y ago> it should be possible to buy a phone and not have it phone home without permission. And you should be able to use the phone without ever contacting the vendor again. don't connect it to the internet.
- rplnt 4y agoApple doesn't even allow users to turn off Bluetooth or GPS (easily in a straight-forward way, it prevents you to make it easy). And while some of it is to provide a better experience to you, major reason is to provide service to other Apple customers.
- hazz99 4y agoCan’t you just swipe down from the top of the screen and press the Bluetooth icon, or am I missing something?
- StockHuman 4y agoThat does not do what you think it does: that’s the button to disconnect from currently connected devices, not to turn off radios. Similarly, the airplane mode button above it will maintain Bluetooth.
- 4ggr0 4y agoI created a Shortcut for that, essentially a button on my homescreen I can press which actually disables bluetooth and wifi. And when my phone is connected to wifi, mobile data gets disabled. It's not perfect, but at least I don't have to open the settings app each time.
- rafram 4y agoTurning Airplane Mode on and then tapping the Bluetooth icon will fully disable Bluetooth (gray background, not white). You can also just disable it in Settings. Apple’s argument, as I understand it, is that Bluetooth and WiFi don’t actually consume much battery, but non-technical users would habitually disable them to save battery and then complain that Location Services didn’t work well. Hiding the setting but keeping an essentially useless toggle prevented those non-technical users from making their device function worse while still letting them feel like they were saving battery life.