6 ms·
Curious from someone with more knowledge. Given some of the results from the war in Ukraine, what's the latest viewpoint on tanks in modern warfare? All I can
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Curious from someone with more knowledge. Given some of the results from the war in Ukraine, what's the latest viewpoint on tanks in modern warfare?
All I can say is I would rather be an infantryman than a tank operator. Seems way too easy to be a sitting duck given the effectiveness of anti-tank missiles. Honestly I don't really understand the need for manned tanks in any case. Why couldn't they just be operated remotely, and then put your actual soldiers in more nimble forms of transport?
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agomachine guns are very effective against infantry. tanks are vulnerable but they can fight back effectively, and being able to go 40mph and be protected from small and medium calibers makes taking ground a lot easier.
- Fomite 4y agoFrom a former tanker I know: This has proved that poorly driven and commanded tanks are vulnerable. The Russians are really bad at doing the things necessary to protect themselves. They're all buttoned up. There are a ton of pictures where they're essentially ambushed while in parade formation, rather than how you'd be on a road in a hostile area.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lawn 4y agoAs an aside, it's been interesting to see the impact drones has had in the war. Reconnaissance, blowing up non-tank vehicles, bombing trenches and suicide bombers. Maybe tanks will still have a place in warfare, but I doubt they'll be as ubiquitous as before?
- scottLobster 4y agoAgainst an enemy with signal jamming capability remote operation is not a given. Plus tanks communicate in real time with infantry/other elements. The lag introduced by remote operation/communication would be a serious hindrance even if everything was working, which it often isn't. Tanks have to respond in real time, they don't have the luxury of seconds of delay like say an orbiting drone. There's also the case of not wanting disabled tanks to fall into the hands of the enemy. Short of rigging the tanks with a self-destruct system (which would likely just make them explode more easily when hit), you need soldiers to do that. Keep in mind that anything operating in battlefield conditions must be resilient. The entire situation is a constant stream of edge cases. Also, don't look to Russia in Ukraine for an example of how tanks are used. Tanks are generally not meant to act alone. Either they're operating with a lot of other tanks, substantial supporting infantry, or both. There are tons of other reasons as well, The Chieften, a former Tanker, has a good video on the subject: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lI7T650RTT8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lI7T650RTT8
- int_19h 4y agoRussia does, indeed, have many issues wrt tank/infantry comms. Not even because they get jammed, but rather because they often don't have working comms at all, or because tank and infantry radios use incompatible frequencies or digital encoding. Much of the army's communication gear is from 1970-80s, poorly maintained, and often without spare parts to repair it if it's not working. In theory, there were new gadgets adopted into service that should have fixed it... but, as with many other things, there are too few of them, and the ones that are there have teething problems. There's a guy who has been fighting on the Russian separatist side since 2014, who is responsible for comms and drones in his unit. He regularly makes long-winded posts about the specific issues that they face, and he had posted about tank/infantry comms several times, even before the all-out war: https://kenigtiger.livejournal.com/2069492.html https://kenigtiger.livejournal.com/2069492.html https://kenigtiger.livejournal.com/2188404.html https://kenigtiger.livejournal.com/2188404.html
- dsfyu404ed 4y agothe separatists are not likely getting handed “standard kit”. They’re likely getting what reserve units don’t want.
- int_19h 4y agoThe guy discusses both the LDNR militia and the Russian military, since he has seen both in the field, and not just this year - to remind, Russia already invaded Ukraine directly back in 2014 to stop the Ukrainian offensive when separatists failed to hold on their own; it just didn't advertise that fact back then. The title of the second blog post that I've linked to is literally, "The story of how comms (and UAVs) were stolen from the Russian army".
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> Against an enemy with signal jamming capability remote operation is not a given How is this not an issue for airborne drones?
- jjk166 4y agoIt should be noted that we're not seeing large russian infantry formations walking around safely while the tanks and other armored vehicles are sitting ducks. Yes, tanks aren't invulnerable, but anti tank missiles are expensive, bulky, and require some advanced training. With advances in technology and western support, Ukraine is fielding more anti-tank weapons than the russians anticipated, but it still is nothing compared to the number of more traditional weapons like machine guns or mortars it could have pulled out of cold war stockpiles. The russians decided to send in mechanized units with minimal to no infantry support because 1) they needed to advance quickly since their logistics could not support a prolonged war, and 2) any russian walking through Ukraine's flat and open terrain without a few inches of armor around them is a dead man. It's Zap Brannigan logic - a Ukrainian squad can only carry a limited number of anti-tank munitions so you just need to keep sending tanks until they reach their kill count and shut down. This turned out to be a bad strategy which mostly has just resulted in lots of destroyed tanks with few strategic gains, but had they done things differently odds are there would just be a lot of dead infantrymen around those destroyed tanks. As for unmanned tanks, these have been explored time and again but they don't really work well. Truly autonomous tanks are extremely difficult to implement compared to say UAVs because it's very difficult to navigate. Remote control relies on reliable communication which is pretty difficult to achieve, especially if your adversary is being supported by a more technologically advanced superpower. You basically need a tank crew in another armored vehicle very nearby. This armored vehicle is still vulnerable so you're risking soldiers lives and those soldiers are basically doing twice the work operating and maintaining two vehicles instead of one, plus consuming twice the fuel, without doubling the firepower.
- avereveard 4y ago> The russians decided to send in mechanized units because... Because that is their doctrine, the rest is inconsequential. It's how they train to fight, how they are supposed to fight, what they produced to fight. There is no infantry push in Russia doctrine, it is developed around crossing Europe in debilitating strikes. You push gaps with mechanized units, filtrate deep and leave town behind you, keeping the front moving and causing the enemy line to fragment, while infantryman behind deliver the siege to the cities as needed. It's built around being the aggressor, stocks deep and then consolidate. What people see happening here it's just their doctrine playing out exactly as written. It is quite outdated and it's receiving lot of attrition, but still.
- shadowpho 4y ago>All I can say is I would rather be an infantryman than a tank operator. You still should be tank operator rather than infantryman. If you are in a tank people who have AT missiles can shoot at you. If you are outside the tank ANYONE can shoot and kill you. Yes there's a lot of videos of tanks blown up. But that's because of their high propaganda value and relative ease of capturing videos (new AT have command center further away = safer)
- int_19h 4y agoIf you're outside the tank, you at least have a chance to see people before they shoot at you.
- greedo 4y agoTanks (I'm mostly speaking of Western tanks) generally have excellent optics with thermal imaging that is so good you can use it in the day time. The ability to see a couple miles away is better than an infantryman would be able to do.
- int_19h 4y agoThermal etc is great, but it is not a good substitute for "head on a swivel" when it comes to rapidly detecting threats - with optics, you need to know where to aim them first. Tank commanders today still prefer to stay unbuttoned if at all possible.
- greedo 4y agoYeah, I was more comparing an 11B with binoculars versus a TC using all his sensors. When you add in the difference in communication suites, networking (is Blue Force Tracker still a thing?) the infantryman is at a serious disadvantage.
- themadturk 4y agoAlso tank design is a factor. Is your spare ammo arranged in a ring around the turret (as in Russian tanks) or an armored container behind the turret (US M1)?
- giantrobot 4y ago> Given some of the results from the war in Ukraine, what's the latest viewpoint on tanks in modern warfare? You're only asking part of a question. It's not whether the tank as a piece of equipment is universally useful, but does an army have a battlefield doctrine that uses tanks well. A tank in general is a useful piece of equipment. It's a bunch of firepower, sensors, and radios all under armor while being highly mobile. A tank can see enemy forces a long ways away, shoot at them, then coordinate with friendly forces to also shoot at the enemy. Tanks however aren't invulnerable. They also end up with poor situational awareness when the crew is all buttoned up under armor. So tanks just sent out by themselves with no infantry support find themselves big obvious targets for enemy infantry with effective anti-tank weapons. If an army's doctrine keeps tanks in good repair, well supplied, and uses them in concert with supporting forces they can be amazingly effective. If instead an army's doctrine doesn't value logistics and presumes tanks are invulnerable they can be laughably ineffective. Russia has been demonstrating laughably terrible battlefield doctrine. They're losing as many tanks to their own ineptitude as they are to enemy action. Their performance isn't an indictment against tanks as a weapon but Russia's particular doctrine and military practices.
- Oxidation 4y agoIf against an opponent with a functional military-industrial base, I'd want to be neither. I feel like the next major war will be swarms of Slaughterbots[1] but with thousands of anti-materiel drones, as well as the hundreds of thousands of anti-personnel ones. If you can't achieve a near-hermetic control of the airspace, anything outside, and much inside is minutes from bring speared by jets of molten metal. And even then, the cost of intercepting them is far higher then the cost of sending multiples until the anti-drone ammunition runs out (and meanwhile any electronic warfare emitter is being hammered by radiation-seeking weapons). [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slaughterbots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slaughterbots
- AlbertCory 4y agoThere's a whole space on Quora about that. Some people with actual combat experience, too. It almost makes it worth wading through all the auto-generated idiotic questions. Fun interview with a Vietnam-era vet here: https://operationcode.org/podcast#dick-sonderegger-link https://operationcode.org/podcast#dick-sonderegger-link He said he wanted to fly close air support in 'Nam. The Marines said, "No, you're going to be a computer programmer."
- lmm 4y agoAs always, there's a spread of views and we can't really know who's right. There are credible military theorists who believe the tank is or will shortly become obsolete, although I wouldn't say that's the mainstream consensus yet. The premise of a tank is: it can move rapidly through almost any terrain, it carries heavy firepower, and it's armoured enough to be more-or-less invulnerable to a typical opposing infantryman. The first point remains as valid as ever. The second is more or less valid - there are more missiles flying around today's battlefields than ever before, but missiles are expensive; a tank gun doesn't make for cool videos but it can put fire on the target all day long. Artillery is also stronger than ever, particularly with drone spotting etc., but it's not really a replacement for direct fire. So the big question, and the one that may ultimately spell the demise of the tank (at least in its current form), is how common weapons that can take out tanks are. Right now IMO the tank is still valid - anti-tank missiles are more common than ever, but it's not like they're standard-issue equipment. And defensive technology is improving too - modern ERA is very impressive, and can only really be fitted to armoured vehicles. If we reach a point where every infantryman carries a missile launcher then the tank will probably stop making sense, but we're not there yet.
- gherkinnn 4y agoBy all reasonable accounts, tanks are here to stay. The Russians are failing at operating shovels, let alone tanks. The main point seems to be that it is not about vulnerabilities. It is about capabilities. No current system can do what a tank can. A pickup full of Javelins can’t roll over, take, and hold ground. An infantryman is about as vulnerable it gets. And yet, humans continue to run about and will do so for a long, long time.