2 ms·
What do you think about the idea of having a "challenge period", i.e. a time where other parties than the applicant can come up with solutions to the problem st
by amelius 4y ago
What do you think about the idea of having a "challenge period", i.e. a time where other parties than the applicant can come up with solutions to the problem stated in the patent (or with prior art)? I bet there is an army of volunteers that would want to help fight illegitimate patents. Also, if $BIGCORP tries to file a patent application, then why can't $SMALL_COMPETITOR contest it during such a challenge period without going through a court of law?
- MikePlacid 4y agoThe original article describes three small (actually - one-person) companies going after some big guys. There is a patent troll behind them, but the article mentions that such a discovery is not an ordinary thing to do. At the patent troll is still a much smaller company than defendants- I guess. Besides, the idea of punishing me for being successful, that is - having more sales of my product, while popular, seems extremely counterproductive to me.
- btrettel 4y agoYou can submit prior art as a third-party while the application is being examined here: https://www.uspto.gov/patents/initiatives/third-party-preissuance-submissions https://www.uspto.gov/patents/initiatives/third-party-preiss... A lot of people propose things similar to what you have, but in practice these sorts of things almost never are used. You also don't need a formal procedure like this. I'm sure if you contact the examiner assigned to the application, they'll listen if you have a valid legal reason to reject the application. (Again, like my other comments here, this is just my opinion, not that of the USPTO or US government.)