6 ms·
The economics term for this is Price Discrimination (https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/price_discrimination.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/price_di
by paxys 4y ago
The economics term for this is Price Discrimination (https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/price_discrimination.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/price_discrimination.as...).
I don't want to go into fair or unfair as the author does (that is a very complex discussion), but it is definitely the most optimal way to price your product. The basic idea is – charge every customer the max they are willing to pay. As long as everyone is above the break-even point, you will maximize your profits.
This is definitely not a new idea ("emerged these past few months" as the author states). I remember people would pack their bags with boxes of Microsoft Windows and Office when coming back from foreign trips. Same goes for subscription pricing. That premium $20/mo Netflix plan costs $4 in Turkey.
It's also a bit weird to see a service advertise their price discrimination. You are essentially saying "your country has a shit economy, so here's a discount" on the checkout page. And then are you also going to show the opposite – "you are in the USA so need to pay 50% more than average for this product"?
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoThis same effect is why individuals get charged so much for healthcare. It's really easy to leverage information asymmetry to make a ton of money, rule #1 is to never let the customer know how much things cost to you
- jihadjihad 4y agoAirline tickets and hotels, too. You likely paid a different amount for your ticket than either of the people sitting (or staying) next to you.
- xapata 4y agoHotels aren't as good at this as airlines are. The airlines have more legal support enforcing that tickets are tied to an identity. Hotels can't check the IDs of everyone who goes into the room. And there are fewer airlines, so they have more data and more market power.
- ISL 4y agoI don't know, but I'd guess that the majority of hotel room-reservations (not necessarily guests) are for individual travelers.
- ralph84 4y agoThere are also scenarios with airlines where the only way for a flight to turn a profit is to price discriminate. It's possible to have a demand curve such that if you choose any point on the demand curve as the price for everyone, total revenue is less than total cost. But if you price discriminate you can capture the full area under the curve and have revenue exceed cost.
- ElFitz 4y agoReminds me of some constraint programming example I read yesterday: https://mlabonne.github.io/blog/constraintprogramming/ https://mlabonne.github.io/blog/constraintprogramming/
- ghaff 4y agoHotels in general do check IDs of people when they check in. Most rooms within a given hotel just aren't that different. (ADDED: And to the degree that a room of a given size with a King bed might have a better view/light than another room, large hotels basically make it about the luck of the draw.) The main price discrimination is based on date. Businesses will eat the $400+/night rooms in SF when there's a big event at the Moscone. (Though there are also room blocks and negotiated rates.) Individual tourists will, in many cases, just go a different week and/or scour the listings for an AirBnB that's hopefully a bargain and not a too good to be true. Airlines have a lot of levers related to status and price-sensitivity for products (seats) that don't have markedly different costs to deliver. Airlines could presumably offer business class seating, even internationally, for much less of a markup than they do. But the average family going to see grandma probably isn't willing to pay even a 30% markup much less a 2x one. So you do different classes and even levels of service within classes.
- tjoff 4y agoNot sure how knowing I get overcharged by 50X is gonna help me? It is not like I have a choice in the matter anyway (when it comes to healthcare).
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoOh yeah, we don't have a choice in the matter in terms of healthcare. You'd need a much bigger actor without a financial interest in making you terrified to be involved. It's why insurance and pharma really don't want large state actors in the health space, they have a proportional amount of power to restrict prices to a reasonable amount
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI think that is backwards. State actors want insurance in order to price segment/discriminate. That is why Medicaid pays less than Medicare, or federal government employee coverage. Or Tricare for military or Medicare for old. The insurance company becomes the fall guy even though the payer is directing them to require more extensive prior auths for certain populations, or reduced reimbursement such that fewer providers are available. Government leaders can then give different populations different levels of healthcare, while simultaneously claiming they are giving everyone healthcare. I bet UK’s leaders are jealous now of the US’s leaders, since they have to answer questions about NHS that they cannot deflect onto third parties.
- matkoniecz 4y agoWith ability to compare prices going to hospital 200km away with 100 000 $ lower price may become a good idea for non-emergency medical services.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- s1artibartfast 4y agoYes, people can and do shop around all the time for many medical procedures. For example. if you are going to have laser eye surgery, call 10 doctors and you might see a 3-5x difference in price.
- antaviana 4y agoI am a bit contrarian on this. While I do agree that market segmentation maximizes revenue, I think that with regards of fairness, long term it is best that prices are the same worldwide. The reason is because if someone in a poorer country gets a good at a lower price than someone on a richer country, that person will have less pressure to raise their prices to eventually reach real equality. So the only real driver for segmentation for prices is to maximize revenue, not to be more fair. I remember that before the EUR, the items in Zara stores had the prices in all European currencies (ESP, ITL, DEM, etc). It was simpler for production to just have one single ticket will all possible prices. If you made some algebra to compare actual pricing, you could see that prices were very different, but not because of fairness. For example, at the time, the absolute value of a Zara product for Greece was above the absolute value of the same product in Spain. The GDP per capita of Greece was lower than the GDP per capita of Spain, but at the time in Greece Zara products were perceived as luxury items and in Spain were perceived as low cost, so Zara capitalized on that perception.
- mym1990 4y agoMaybe I am missing it, but I don't quite understand what 'fairness' has to do with cross market pricing. Different markets will constitute many variations in variables that will affect pricing. The cost of doing business in France is different than the cost of doing business in South Africa. The brand reputation of a McDonalds is different in China than it is in the US. I can go to almost any European country and buy groceries for cheaper than in the US, I have never thought "this is not fair".
- ISL 4y agoThe primary thought I have regarding pricing at grocery stores is, "Man, Safeway has these apples on sale for half the price they're selling for at QFC. I sure wish I could buy apples at Safeway and sell them to QFC." Unfortunately, that's not how the world works. There's a bid and an ask. The bid for outside groceries is usually zero. But I still think about it. Someday, Amazon will let us buy and sell items in their warehouses without taking delivery -- that'll be a good day.
- HWR_14 4y ago> As long as everyone is above the break-even point, you will maximize your profits. Given network effects, and depending on your horizon, I'm not even sure everyone needing to be above your breakeven is required.
- mr_toad 4y ago> definitely the most optimal way to price your product. Only if you have no competition. If you do, you can expect them to undercut your most profitable markets.
- iso1631 4y agoThe presence of competitors selling the same or alternative goods lowers the "max they are willing to pay"
- jasonpeacock 4y agoHeh, Amazon tried this back in 2000 and it was very bad for customer trust: https://www.computerworld.com/article/2588337/amazon-apologizes-for-price-testing-program-that-angered-customers.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/2588337/amazon-apologi...
- maccard 4y agoThe world and internet have changed significantly in 22 years. Microsoft were too early to the party in 2013 for a "digital only console" and 7 years later both MS and Sony shipped a digital only console.
- fomine3 4y agoYeah PSP go...
- mhuffman 4y agoThe problem that Amazon has is that it is very, very easy for people to compare pricing. So they will have to be very clever to come up with some pricing segmentation that people will accept. They already do this to some extent with a "club member fee" segmentation with Amazon Prime. The problem they had there is that so many people signed up for Prime that it doesn't work as an effective price discrimination segment any more. Also, they have to deal with sellers. If you remember it was once upon a time that if you had Amazon Prime, you could buy items cheaper (including shipping) than non-prime members, because that hefty $75 fee made a "special members group" that could be directly marketed to. But now if you calculate shipping and price it is the same for Prime and non-Prime (if non-Prime selects two-day delivery).
- ilyt 4y ago> and 7 years later both MS and Sony shipped a digital only console. Not exactly. They gave you option to purchase cheaper digital only one. Not blocked physical games altogether like MS tried before. Big difference.
- RobotToaster 4y ago>That premium $20/mo Netflix plan costs $4 in Turkey. Hence the popularity of Turkish and Pakistani VPN tunnels.
- Ozzie_osman 4y ago> it is definitely the most optimal way to price your product. Yes, but it ignores some second-order effects. When you leave some money on the table by charging some users less than the max they are willing to pay (often referred to as consumer surplus), you get some benefits like more word of mouth, higher likelihood to get repeat purchases from a customer, and so on. Think of the feeling you had the last time you bought something and thought "oh, this is so expensive i can barely justify paying for it" vs "oh my God, this is so worth the money I'm going to feel good for the next week and tell all my friends it's a no-brainer". Most people underestimate these effects when they price discriminate.
- edmundsauto 4y agoI can see how people would forget to include them (2nd order thinking is hard!). But how would they underestimate the effects when there is t really a clear way to accurately quantify them? It makes a big difference if word of mouth was 1% increased versus 20%. (And then there are 3rd order psychological effects - people tend to increase their perception of how valuable something is when they pay more. that’s kind of the BMW strategy!) What we’re left with is a world where we make decisions on easy measurements. That does not necessarily mean including 2nd order effects would change the calculus. And if you’re doing 2nd order, how can you make smart business decisions that aren’t just your gut? Human psychology is really complex, situationally dependent, and cannot be generalized from our own experience. That’s why companies rely on data, even if it’s incomplete.
- jonas21 4y agoJoel Splosky wrote a great article on software pricing and price discrimination a while back (gosh, was it really 18 years ago? I feel so old now): https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/12/15/camels-and-rubber-duckies/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/12/15/camels-and-rubber-...
- bjelkeman-again 4y agoThe kicker at the end is great. > Take my advice, offered about 20 pages back: charge $0.05 for your software. Unless it does bug tracking, in which case the correct price is $30,000,000. Thank you for your time, and I apologize for leaving you even less able to price software than you were when you started reading this
- kubanczyk 4y ago> charge $0.05 for your software. Unless it does bug tracking, in which case the correct price is $30,000,000. At the time the author was creating a bug tracker (if you want a shallow interpretation).
- inopinatus 4y agoCar rentals often show wide variation based on visitor origin. This was observed decades ago (I recall an economics professor mentioning it way back), and on a cursory check just now I was quoted up to 40% lower prices at an international airport, for an otherwise identical rental, by presenting as European* rather than American or Australian. Such a difference cannot be explained by PPP or insurance factors. We might conjecture that consumer expectations account for the price discrimination, e.g. visitors from Europe may be accustomed to high quality integrated mass transit (including to/from the airport) and thus resent a high car rental price, whilst Australians and Americans assume they'll need a rental to get around, with consequently higher willingness to pay. * tested with UK, France, Germany, Italy, and the Netherlands.
- NavinF 4y ago> by presenting as European* Based on what, IP?
- judge2020 4y agoCould also be based on billing address, if required.
- connicpu 4y agoOr even the currency being used
- TheGeminon 4y agoSome car rentals at airports will ask for flight information as well, so they may take into account the inbound flight.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- crazygringo 4y agoThat's so crazy, I just need some verification in order to believe it. I've never in my life seen price discrimination by citizenship like that before, with the exception of discounts for locals vs. tourists for museums etc. What are the links you're using to check the prices? And are you using a VPN to change your IP location, or something to do with the passport associated with an Expedia account or something, or is it a billing address? And what airport and car rental company are you looking at specifically? I want to make sure it's reproducible. I know Americans in Europe often wind up paying more to rent, but only because many of them require the less common and more expensive automatic transmissions. But you say you're selecting an identical rental so that can't be it.
- dragonwriter 4y agoPrice discrimination is optimal for sellers if you can wall off markets, but is PPP really the optimal basis for geographic price discrimination?
- tracerbulletx 4y agoIt's just taught as an assumption that you will do this in a business school's bachelors curriculum. For different countries they'd just treat it as a different market with different pricing but a lot of times it's done by acting like something is a different product through packaging and branding. Like the 150 dollar lip cream is probably chemically not that different than the 10 dollar one but they just make it feel more premium and sell it under a premium brand name. Or even just the way consumer electronics include or don't include features at various product levels is also price discrimination. (Which is why sometimes the low tier product includes a physical ability to do something but it's turned off with software or something. To nudge people willing to pay more to the one aimed at them.)
- greycol 4y agoBack in the early 2000s so long as you were buying two or more copies of Adobe Photoshop it cost as much to hop on a 28 hour round trip plane ride from NZ to the US to buy those copies rather than purchase and download the software off Adobe's website (which was geolocked and priced to match the only local physical distributor). With physical goods price discrimination is limited by arbitrage opportunity in moving the good from one country to another. With intellectual property licensing can tie a good to a location which means that the price discrimination can effectively be any amount. My personal opinion is regulation should proscribe the price discrimination past some multiple of purchasing parity to curtail the worst possible abuses. Having said that it's not a major real world problem while piracy remains as an outlet for abused markets.
- achow 4y ago"Shit economy"? Some places a dollar goes far, that cannot be construed as 'shit economy'. The place where a $10 USA haircut costs $0.5 need not be due to local (bad) economic situation. Similarly for food and other living essentials.
- sfe22 4y agoAgreed, the cheaper the service the more efficient economy they got.
- dahfizz 4y ago> Some places a dollar goes far, that cannot be construed as 'shit economy' You're implying a strange causality. The places with the highest PPP conversion factor are places like Colombia, Iran, Cambodia, Indonesia. The reason a dollar goes so far is because these places have no money. When controlling for PPP, 10% of the population of Cambodia lives on less than $2 per day. So yeah, a dollar will go pretty far. And its because their economies are shit.
- achow 4y ago> ..Indonesia.. It is doing very fine. Thank you. https://www.marketwatch.com/story/indonesia-s-third-quarter-gdp-growth-accelerated-further-271667796494 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/indonesia-s-third-quarter-... Since you are cherry picking examples, here are some more cherries. Countries where the amount of $ one needs to spend to get equivalent of $100 goods in USA: Country $ ------------ Turkey 36 Poland 52 Hungary 56 Mexico 56 Spain 84 Korea 88 Italy 89 Germany 95 Source: Wikipedia
- dahfizz 4y agoHmm, There is a certain trend here.... First world countries: Spain 84 Korea 88 Italy 89 Germany 95 All close to 100. Developing nations: Turkey 36 Poland 52 Hungary 56 Mexico 56 Are all much lower. Seems like enough cherries to me to conclude that developing nations with weaker economies have a higher PPP adjustment.
- coffeeblack 4y agoSo why does a millionaire in Turkey get it for $4 while a homeless American single mother has to pay $20? How is that “fair”? It’s just racism.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoMost countries, including Turkey, don't actually define race or care about it really. The U.S. and a few other countries are the exception. In fact even the UN doesn't really put much stock in it, since the concept is too muddled for it to be useful across 190+ countries. Ethnicity, the kind provable by family ancestry or genetics, is the usual replacement.
- evrydayhustling 4y ago> It's also a bit weird to see a service advertise their price discrimination. I think there are two angles here that are can be rational depending on what you are selling, and to whom. One is "stakeholder consumerism" similar to e.g. fair trade coffee. Some consumers want their payment to be part of a system that shares benefits with other parts of the economy. The provider is saying to the rich world, who will provide most revenue: you pay more so that I can provide my service everywhere while maintaining some margin. The other is reassuring people that your price discrimination "isn't personal". All prices must thread the needle of making the product more valuable than the buyer's next best alternative, but the alternatives vary from buyer to buyer. PPP isn't perfect but it's a non crazy proxy for what the buyer is giving up to have your product (eg one dinner in Switzerland vs a month's food in Cambodia). And yes, it's a weak proxy when one region has a really wide range of incomes.