5 ms·
Software patents, "better paperclips", and a lot of other "lawyers get rich, bureaucracies get bigger, little people get screwed patents? - YES. (Some sort of
by bell-cot 4y ago
Software patents, "better paperclips", and a lot of other "lawyers get rich, bureaucracies get bigger, little people get screwed patents? - YES.
(Some sort of IP protection or reward system is still needed for real inventions - where it takes serious money, expertise, time, etc. to achieve something major.)
But maybe a better moral would be that shell corporations (& lawyers playing shell games with them) should be outlawed.
- commitpizza 4y agoBut real inventions can occur in software too? Inventions that takes serious money, expertise and so on. Some examples: - Rust memory management - New models in machine learning that enables amazing results - Protocols
- anonymous_sorry 4y agoBut is there broader benefit to a legal system that enables the inventor to enforce time-limited monopolies on them? Rust's memory management was invented without any such incentive, and the world is richer for it.
- bombolo 4y agoSure they can happen, but in general they require a much lower investment to be done, and are easy to reinvent. Once I had an idea while sitting on the toilet, about how to use past log data to pre-emptively scale up, when the peak hour is about to come. I had the idea just randomly sitting on the toilet for a few minutes… it was already patented.
- asah 4y agoThis cuts both ways: it's also easy to "surround" software patents with new innovations that are required to be competitive in the marketplace. Then both parties cross-license and you're good. Yes the lawyers get paid but the cost is pretty low compared with software engineers, and the societal benefit is that these innovative move into the public domain.
- commitpizza 4y agoI don't understand your point, do you mean that this cannot happen in other fields? I imagine that this is the case for most stuff in the world. Ideas are not usually unique but it's the great execution of the idea that present the real challange.
- bombolo 4y agoWell do you think a new pill is done thinking 10 minutes? Just the testing procedures involve massive investment. I'm not in favour of patents at large by the way, but they make even less sense for software.
- oneoff786 4y agoSounds to me like all of that would be better off public or as a trade secret.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoTradition has held that these are ideas, not inventions, and thus obtain value precisely because they can and should be freely shared (which is the ultimate aim of patents anyway). Ideas may also require intellectual labour. But one may not receive the protection of the government for them to give temporary advantage over competitors. Ideas are a collaborative venture, protocols being the very epitome of this - since a "protocol of one" is a bit like a birthday party for one... a bit sad and pointless. If one wants to make money, by all means invest time in pursuing patentable inventions, but do not presume that mere ideas (most of which are "nothing new under the sun") should be afforded the same protection. The problem we have today is that the patent system is derelict. The goalposts have shifted to allow almost all and any silly idea to obtain a patent and the system itself is weaponised for extraction. It has not shown any will to reform, so abolition may be its ultimate fate.
- abduhl 4y agoI’m interested in what “traditions” you’re talking about here? Honestly, it is not even clear to me what you’re talking about when you say “these” in your sentence. Certainly tradition hasn’t held that Rust memory management is an idea and therefore not patentable. Same with new models in ML? Maybe there is some tradition for protocols, but even those are generally patentable but required to be licensed via FRAND. Your post seems to entirely misunderstand the patent system. “But one may not receive the protection of the government for [ideas] to give temporary advantage over competitors.” This is just flat out wrong. The purpose of a patent is literally to receive the protection of the government for your ideas in order to give you a temporary advantage over your competitors via a government granted monopoly on an idea. The bargain that’s struck is that the patent owner gives the details of their patented idea to the world so that anyone can eventually practice it or build off of it in exchange for a limited exclusionary protection in commerce.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoI'm sorry I can do nothing more to help with your misunderstanding of my good faith post. Please do the necessary research with regard to the history and purpose of designs and patents law.
- dbfx 4y agoI'm skeptical rust memory management is such a big invention by them and would bet some money the ownership model already existed before in papers at the very least. And even if not just imagine having to pay Dahl or Alan Kay to implement OO in your language, which was by every possible metric more innovative than rust's memory management. Even if it would have stopped java from being a thing it's just not worth it.
- anonymous_sorry 4y agoThose things got invented anyway though, without being patented. The right question, in my opinion, is whether there are important software innovations that would have been significantly delayed, or kept secret, or never discovered at all, if software patents weren't a thing. And if so, do they outweigh legal costs and chilling effects of patent trolling, and the inefficiencies of people having to engineer around patented ideas. Intellectual property is a fairly artificial concept. It's quite "big government" when you think about it - government grants a monopoly on the application of an idea. It is only worth preserving if it makes the country richer.
- Akronymus 4y agoWhich would you count the olds elevator as? https://youtu.be/-fu03F-Iah8 https://youtu.be/-fu03F-Iah8
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> But maybe a better moral would be that shell corporations (& lawyers playing shell games with them) should be outlawed. Shell companies have done more damage to the world than most tyrants ever could - enabling tax evasion, escaping responsibility for substandard construction (you close the company after completing contruction of a house) or for decommissioning toxic assets like exhausted mines or oil rigs. They are uaed to obscure land ownership.
- kasey_junk 4y agoMost of those aren’t shell companies by the common definition of a shell company. Usually people talking about shell companies are referring to companies with no business interests at all or if they are bring expansive only contracts/ip agreements. A construction company is doing actual business. Land owned in a corporation has an actual asset etc. Most startups start as shell companies, you sort of can’t create a corporation without being one for some amount of time. So I’m ok with the idea of corporate ownership reform but I think you’d need to get more specific than “shell companies == bad”
- newaccount74 4y agoAnonymous companies are bad. I think you could fix a lot of the issues by requiring that all companies must be recorded in a public registry that includes contact information, owner and executive names, as well as a list of actual physical locations where the company operates (if any -- online businesses don't need to have a physical location).
- kasey_junk 4y agoYou’d need a federal level legislation to achieve that (and perhaps a constitutional amendment). The states decide the information requirements in their jurisdictions and many have vested interests in not changing them (particularly Delaware where this case is).
- mikeyouse 4y ago
- bdw5204 4y agoGenerally speaking, most "real inventions" are independently invented by multiple people and aren't successful until somebody figures out how to market them. For example, video games were invented in the 1950s and Tennis for Two[0] was basically Pong in 1958 (a bunch of people had already written tic tak toe, checkers and/or chess). The Magnavox Odyssey (likely the first console) was released around 2 months before Pong (according to Wikipedia) but it was Pong that popularized gaming and made it mainstream. Calculus was independently invented by both Newton and Liebnitz but there was also a Japanese calculus called wasan from the same period invented by Seki Takakazu based on a different foundation. The telephone was also independently invented by several people around the same time but Alexander Graham Bell got the credit because he was the first person to get it to the patent office. There are endless examples of this because ideas are not scarce and there are typically multiple intelligent people who have the same idea. All patents do is allow somebody who fails to successfully execute an idea to weaponize the legal system to extort money out of people who do successfully execute "their" idea. That's not even getting into how the US Supreme Court allows GMO seed companies to patent plants and sue farmers for patent infringement because the neighboring farm's GMO seeds cross-pollinated with their seeds. In Bowman v. Monsanto, the US Supreme Court actually ruled that farmers can't plant their own seeds (when this cross pollination happens) without paying the patent trolls at Monsanto! Patents are simply corrupt, innovation stifling monopolies the entire way down and should be completely abolished and banned from ever coming back via constitutional amendment. (Current copyright terms are excessive but copyright itself along the lines of the US Copyright Act of 1790 is reasonable as a tool to encourage creative works and copyright abolition would likely be even worse than the status quo's century long copyright terms. Likewise, trademarks are also legitimate as a fraud prevention tool. They shouldn't be conflated with patents as they are in the concept of IP.) [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tennis_for_Two https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tennis_for_Two
- pixelfarmer 4y agoCopyright was not introduced by authors, it was introduced by the people who print books, or at least some of them. In Germany books and booklets were dirt cheap, which allowed broad access to all kinds of works and consequently knowledge to spread. Then came copyright, and guess what happened: It wasn't exactly the authors who got richer, and neither the biggest bunch of the guys who printed all these things saw any of the benefits, either. It was a net loss for the society, because some greedy idiots couldn't get enough. Trademark also has a good few issues, aside of being abused to the point where it becomes obviously stupid (like trademarking colors, common words and similar idiocies). It also cannot prevent counterfeits, which is more a game of whack-a-mole than anything else.
- 8note 4y agoEven for the big things like mRNA, intellectual property protection still doesn't make the right results for society