12 ms·
Twitter Suspends Kathy Griffin After She Changed Her Handle to ‘Elon Musk’
- groutlick 4y agoI look forward to seeing Musk continue to run Twitter into the ground, and have to eventually forfeit Tesla and SpaceX because of this. They'll be better off without him at the helm.
- recuter 4y agoI believe it was Edward R. Murrow who said as goes Kathy Griffin so does the rest of the civilized world.
- techdragon 4y agoTesla might, they seem to have reached critical mass... but I don't know how far SpaceX will get given he made driving down $/kg to orbit a personal mission in order for his entire Mars stuff to be even remotely feasible as an endeavour (to speak nothing of how likely it is to succeed) Without someone to say "Falcon 9 isn't good enough" when its already crushing the launch industry and all the competition is racing to catch up to its capabilities, which could take as much as a decade for slower moving companies like ULA (partial reuse goal is years away) or ArianeSpace, and regardless of the timeline often requiring significant efforts to develop reusability technologies that fit existing designs, whole new rocket design programs to add reusability, or fleeing to niches where such reuse is not viable (rapid schedule (in terms of calendar days between purchase and launch day) in the hope of holding onto some market share... SpaceX without Elon would quite possibly turn into Blue Origin, who's glacial schedule is moving so slowly, the largest customer they have signed is for their engines, and due to widespread rumours those engines wont happen on time, the customer made a very big deal about showing off that they do indeed finally have some engines they can use to build their first test rocket. Regardless of his many faults, personal and professional, he as CEO of a privately held company who gets to make the big decisions about what does and does not get built, has been responsible for pushing forward the space rocket business in a way that hasn't been seen in nearly half a century... The Apollo era saw companies push designs and innovate and resulted in actual test hardware programs with such experiments as Aerojet's 260, a 6.6m diameter solid rocket motor with 16 MN of thrust, equivalent to the entire Saturn 1 first stage. The funding cuts post Apollo shrunk the industry into just relying on the R&D from the Military Industrial Complex side of the aerospace companies and so we got decades of slow incremental progress mainly off the back of maintaining the fleets of ICBMs.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Whatarethese 4y agoOh boy he real mad now. Amazing that simply changing a name and picture is considered impersonation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CleverLime 4y agoIt was annoying, anyone, especially verified could change picture and name to someone else and write some bullshit. Most of people wouldn't notice the handle, only the name and picture, and that's how fake news might spread. Lately there were a lot of verified profiles that changed their profile pic and name to Elon Musk and were trolling.
- thisiswater 4y agoSurely context would show that these are parodies, not impersonations. Are these people trying to impersonate Elon Musk, or are they parodying Elon Musk on their clearly-marked "not elon musk" (due to the handle) accounts? I'm inclined towards the latter.
- insanitybit 4y agoThis has always been the case and it has always been fine.
- silisili 4y agoUm, yeah... because those are prominent. The ID is smaller. Don't be verified and pretend to be someone else. Or just don't pretend to be someone else regardless. Seems pretty straightforward...
- socialismisok 4y agoWait till you learn about parody. Saturday Night Live is going to be a real mind blower for you.
- bilekas 4y agoWasn't this the point of the blue checkmark originally?
- seanhunter 4y agoYes. It’s almost like it wasn’t “bullshit”[1] but served a useful purpose and that the policy of believing that all speech that doesn’t break the law should be protected wasn’t fully thought through. [1] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1587498907336118274 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1587498907336118274
- KerrAvon 4y agoThe problem is that it was always at the whim of some opaque internal Twitter process. There always should have been an actual process for anyone to be verified. It creates resentment when the criteria for verification are not transparent. Is this going to fix it? No, one of two things will happen: (1) Musk will end up with a gigantic tax write-off when he sells what’s left of Twitter to Verizon for 140M two years from now. (2) Musk will turn it into something that is successful by some definition but isn’t Twitter and no longer commands the same attention from the world at large.
- JohnTHaller 4y agoIt was. Now it's just an $8 a month symbol. The folks changing their name to Elon Musk were pointing out the stupidity of this change.
- r721 4y agoHer profile on Mastodon: https://mstdn.social/@kathygriffin https://mstdn.social/@kathygriffin (14k followers for now).
- recuter 4y agoWell how do you know on Mastodon? I think the actual account is: https://mstdn.social/@stunning_and_brave https://mstdn.social/@stunning_and_brave
- r721 4y agoI found proper account name in Google cache of her Twitter profile (in bio): https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:IVCAOsk5c-cJ:https://twitter.com/kathygriffin https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:IVCAOs... (archived: https://archive.is/MdSyK https://archive.is/MdSyK)
- recuter 4y agoNo man, I think that's just somebody trolling you. The account in your link clearly states it is Elon. Must be one of those dodge scams. Not sure.
- r721 4y ago>The account in your link clearly states it is Elon The display name states it is Elon, but the unique handle is @kathygriffin (which is linked from her official website www.kathygriffin.com). But you know all that and somehow decided it's funny to pretend you don't.
- recuter 4y agoThat's impossible because actually I am Kathy Griffin.
- Dylan16807 4y agoWow, this is the most "got the joke" version of not getting the joke I've ever seen.
- recuter 4y ago> Going forward, any Twitter handles engaging in impersonation without clearly specifying “parody” will be permanently suspended > My commitment to free speech extends even to not banning the account following my plane, even though that is a direct personal safety risk So Babylon Bee and The Onion is secure as long as they don't pretend to be actual news like the rest of the media. Excellent. :)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- KerrAvon 4y agoYou know, he was not willing to pay the kid running that account more than $5000 to take it down, so he can spare us the personal safety risk whining and just take commercial first class like us single-digit millionaires if he’s so concerned about it.
- recuter 4y agoYou know, that would open him up to blackmail and doesn't solve the problem.
- KerrAvon 4y agoYou know, you might finish reading my post before replying to it, it’s not very long.
- recuter 4y agoHe can also keep flying his jets and ban all such accounts for $0. Not sure you'll stay a single digit millionaire for very long flying first class nilly willy tho, a million dollars ain't what it used to be, amirite old sport?
- seaal 4y agoThink the deal closed somewhere above $0, unfortunately for Muskboy
- KerrAvon 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- adwn 4y ago> Space Karen Please keep HN free from these kinds of low-effort memes [1]. Thank you. [1] https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/karen https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/karen
- Brian_K_White 4y agoSpace Karen was awesome. Please keep HN free from these kinds of low effort hall monitors. Thank you.
- olliej 4y agoI'm recalling a week ago when he said comedy was allowed on twitter again, and also the claims that they would not be censoring people.
- jurassic 4y agoSo his commitment to free speech absolutism has lasted an entire week! That's honestly longer than I expected. He's gonna need thicker skin if he's going to be extremely online all the time during this rebuild of the company.
- davesque 4y agoYeah, who could have seen this coming? Will be interesting to see what other innocuous behavior ends up suddenly qualifying as a violation under this regime.
- imron 4y agoI'm recalling a week ago when he said verified accounts that impersonated others would be suspended. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1587853006699401216#m https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1587853006699401216#m
- Dylan16807 4y agoWhen the phrasing is "spam/scam/impersonation", I'd say it doesn't cover this.
- thisiswater 4y agoI would argue that these accounts are parodying, not impersonating.
- rvz 4y ago> If verified accounts violate terms of service, eg spam/scam/impersonation, they’ll be suspended, but Twitter will keep their money! Yup, they were warned and they done it anyway and now they are crying over that suspension. So this over-reaction isn't newsworthy.
- 4y ago
- mjr00 4y agoThe obvious question is, "Why are verified profiles allowed to change their account display name in the first place?" Which seems to be getting addressed[0]. [0] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1589401231545741312 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1589401231545741312
- socialismisok 4y agoWhy wouldn't they be? Twitter culture is frequently about changing names. Many people just changed their display names to "spooky" Halloween versions. The handle is the id, not the display names. Plus, Twitter could easy make the check mark link out to a profile page explaining who the person is.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- moomin 4y agoConsider this: how is changing your profile name _in the wake of removing verification_ not speech?
- seanhunter 4y agoYou know that Elon Musk (who has of course had a verified profile for some time) has changed his displayname in the past right? To "Elona" https://www.newsweek.com/why-elon-musk-changed-his-name-elona-twitter-1688470 https://www.newsweek.com/why-elon-musk-changed-his-name-elon... To "Lord Edge" https://www.forbes.com/sites/petersuciu/2021/11/08/elon-musk-changed-his-twitter-handle-to-lorde-edge--he-remains-an-edge-lord/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/petersuciu/2021/11/08/elon-musk... ...and probably some others.
- mjr00 4y agoAlright. That doesn't answer my question though -- why should anyone with a verified profile be allowed to change their name, which could mislead people of their identity, while maintaining their verification status?
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoIts sad that censorship decisions are treated differently in the US media based on political affiliation. Throughout the pandemic, I witnessed people questioning the science behind lockdowns and government overreach being banned, censored, de-patformed from social media sites and the common response in the media being "start your own platform" "The shoe on the other foot" is such a bad place to find ourselves as a society, it speaks to us being incapable of reconciling our differences for a common good. Since the 2016 election, the US has gone batshit insane it feels like. It was crazy before, but its incredibly hard to have any sort of a conversation about touchy issues these days without an overwhelming negative, non-critical response in the form of downvotes, aggressive bucketing into political buckets, pariah treatment etc. I hope, at least on HN, we're able to hold discussions on political topics without such tribalism.
- socialismisok 4y agoI've had a mixed experience. I've had people call me a mass murderer and a fascist because I identify myself as a communist. (Not a Tankie, fuck tankies.) But I've also had some great discussions here with people who listen, trade book recommendations, and at least try to learn before writing me off. A lot more of the former these days, unfortunately.
- HourglassFR 4y agoTo be fair, being considered a threat to national security and held as a pariah for having communist ideas is hardly a recent development in the US.
- socialismisok 4y agoYeah, turns out of one thinks, "maybe the relentless pursuit of growth above anything else is bad" is pretty scary to some folks?
- dane-pgp 4y agoIf that's the defining characteristic of being a communist, then the defining characteristic of being a capitalist must be thinking "maybe the relentless pursuit of financial equality above anything else is bad". If both of those things are true, then I would guess that at least 90% of people in the world are simultaneously capitalists and communists.
- socialismisok 4y ago[flagged]
- Blackthorn 4y agoIncredible. The "free speech absolutism" lasted even less long than Anthony "The Mooch" Scaramucci did (eleven days).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- laputan_machine 4y agoNow wait for all the apologists to come in and tell you how this is actually protecting free speech.
- k1t 4y agoWell actually... the best way to protect free speech is to make sure nobody says anything objectionable... /sigh
- socialismisok 4y agoAnd now this post gets flagged, lol. I suppose the Elon defenders have logged on.
- WalterSear 4y agoI might need to rethink my opinion of Elon: this more than a week longer than I expected.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- exodust 4y ago> "speech" How is changing your name to that which belongs to someone else "speech"? Sounds like trolling and impersonating to me. What exactly is being spoken when you change your name to a false one? I thought "speech" was when someone with name X, says something about subject Y. I'm not surprised the attention seeker got suspended.
- Slaminerag 4y agoJeph Jacques of Questionable Content fame had his account suspended for the same thing. https://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4911 https://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4911
- yanderekko 4y agoMy understanding is that this behavior already violated the rules, it's not like Elon made this up on the spot (although perhaps he changed the punishment.) I believe when this happens to less-sympathetic parties we chalk this up to "freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences", right? I mean, few people are actually going to defend a right to misrepresentation. Depending of the circumstances it could actually be libel/defamation, right?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- atoav 4y ago> freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences This is the point I am not sure Elon Musk would have agreed with you about before aquiring the platform.
- socialismisok 4y agoIf I print the words Elon musk on a sheet of paper and tape it to my chest and start making stupid comments, I'm generally considered ok. These "impersonations" are flimsy paper masks of Elon's face with the eyes cut out so you can see through. This whole enforcement change is nothing more than Elmer Fudd throwing a tantrum because he bought a website full to the brim of bugs bunnies.
- yanderekko 4y ago>These "impersonations" are flimsy paper masks of Elon's face with the eyes cut out so you can see through. Debatable. If I go on a major Mastadon instance and impersonate an admin or a top celebrity there will I get banned? If I do, should I expect much sympathy if I accuse the relevant admins of throwing a tantrum? Can I go on a major Mastadon instance and pretend to be a politician up for re-election and start making claims in hopes of damaging their electoral prospects? It just strikes me as implausible that the people who are accusing Musk of being thin-skinned here actually believe that this sort of impersonation is defensible behavior. I guess it's reminiscent of the people who pearl-clutch about political violence but also were okay with Griffith doing a photoshoot posing with Trump's bloody decapitated head.
- nullstyle 4y agoIt's good to know free speech is secure :rolleyes:
- maxbond 4y agoI'm curious to hear if anyone has recently changed their opinion on Elon Musk, in any direction, and why?
- socialismisok 4y agoI suspected he was pretty shitty and petty. I no longer suspect, I'd say he's absolutely confirmed that now.
- Whatarethese 4y agoI really like Tesla and SpaceX but I have really started to hate Elon over the past year. Just STFU and build quick cars and rockets. It can't be that hard but he thinks he's some kind of edge lord that thinks everyone loves him.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoI never had a particular opinion on him. I hate the glorification of people we quite frequently see in the US. In the same way vilifying him is the other side of the medal and just as stupid. I think he is funny from time to time, but I believe he is an asshole as boss. Sometimes you have to be, but there are ways to go about that. There was a weird instance where he fired an allegedly incompetent engineer on the fly, but I don't know the details anymore. It seemed impulsive and random. Still, my opinion somehow improved lately. Maybe it is just his marketing team, but I prefer an asshole who is direct, instead of one that tries to hide it. Musk has enough self-reflection to know that he is an asshole. At least some points here...
- nickthegreek 4y agoAt the beginning of covid, I wanted a tesla so bad. Now, I will never buy a tesla. Mind blowing to me that a company that sells something so pricey could alienate me so thoroughly, so quickly.
- pixxel 4y ago
- 4y ago
- emptyparadise 4y agoi thought comedy was legal now on twitter
- akmarinov 4y agoThe bird was supposed to be freed
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- socialismisok 4y agoA few things: Elon has no idea what he bought. Elon cannot post, despite desperately wishing he could. Elon has done the worst thing you can do if you are being trolled online ("mooom the Internet is being mean to me!"), which harkens back to #1. He's rapidly pissing off the reason why many people are on Twitter in the first place. All while laying people off and then sending them messages with, "wait, no, please come back". ... It's like watching an any% Speedrun of "destroying one's own company".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- akomtu 4y agoWhat would the original Twitter management do differently? Wouldn't fire 50% of the staff over the next several months despite the recession? Kept the comedian's account active even if she impersonated Parag?
- socialismisok 4y agoProbably both of those, yeah. Ad revenue was growing until Musk got involved.
- theonething 4y agoPre-Musk Twitter board planned layoffs. > Before Musk took over the site, Twitter had already planned broad layoffs, which would have affected up to a quarter of the staff, according to people familiar with the plans. The Post reported previously the company’s board was planning to cut thousands of jobs as part of an effort to save $700 million in labor costs. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/11/03/elon-musk-twitter-layoffs/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/11/03/elon-mu... And I don't understand why you think Parag would have allowed impersonations (himself or others). It's just bad for the platform overall.
- Brian_K_White 4y ago
- at_a_remove 4y agoI guess that last episode of "Fuck around and find out" didn't really take with Griffin. Finding out that, apparently, there were under the table "You get a blue check for $15,000" schemes going on will make things ... super-interesting, if any forensics can find out a goodly percentage of the culprits. And I wonder exactly what overlap will be with this crop of sudden whiners.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DarthNebo 4y agoWonder if this is the 'rationale' with which they start demanding national IDs to ensure people with same names avoid getting flagged for impersonation. Also begs the question of since when was legal name ever a requirement for social media.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qull 4y agoWow, all these Hateful elon comments might be warranted, but are not what I though HN was about. Maybe this isnt the right forum to have actual discussions anymore.
- socialismisok 4y agoThere's plenty of room for discussions. Most people see Elon as a petulant villain right now. So when he's particularly petulant to the detriment of his platform and hypocritical, it's reasonable to call him out as such.
- ihatepython 4y agoWhat exactly did you think HN was about? HN leans heavily to the left. I think it's best to just observe these types of topics, and only participate in the technical topics.
- Apocryphon 4y agoFree speech is a civic liberties issue often embraced by libertarians such as Elon Musk.
- socialismisok 4y agoAs a leftist who regularly gets flagged, downvoted, or mixed votes for even suggesting a vaguely leftist idea I'd say: Hacker news does not skew left. Not right. It's simply not a monoculture and it tends to emphasize data first and foremost. Anything even remotely politically charged will draw out all sorts of arguments.
- ihatepython 4y agoSorry I should have said left-brain
- bonchile 4y agoHN leans heavily towards a pro-capitalist perspective, not left-wing viewpoints. Which makes sense as it was founded by venture capitalists and is essentially used as a vehicle to promote their ideology.
- pavlov 4y agoThis link points to yahoo.com which gives me a weird nostalgic twinge: “Remember when people used to care about what happens to this Yahoo! company and now it’s basically a random domain?” Twitter seems to be on the same path to oblivion. Microsoft offered $44 billion for Yahoo in 2008, which in a strange coincidence is the same amount that Musk actually paid for his Yahoo/Waterloo.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- drumhead 4y agoI gather it was a leveraged buyout so he wont be losing much if it does go under. The only problem is most leveraged buyouts are for mature low or no growth companies that are profitable have strong cashflow and low capex requirements. Cant really say that about Twitter in any way. It feels like its going the way of Digg.
- tomcam 4y agoAnd now that sterling example of a human being, Ethan Klein of h3 productions: https://twitter.com/mattwallace888/status/1589508886469697536?s=61&t=j3eEgYDFtYUo0yipk-sKAQ https://twitter.com/mattwallace888/status/158950888646969753...
- exodust 4y agoThey should change their youtube channel next, to impersonate official google staff and services and see what happens. You know, for lolz and likes.
- nullstyle 4y ago
- maxbond 4y agoI don't think it's okay to call someone a bootlicker, or to reference their views from one thread in another (especially without reference to something specific they've said, as that essentializes their views). Both of these apply scrutiny to a person rather than to an idea. That results in toxic conversation where no one learns anything and everyone walks away unhappy.
- nullstyle 4y agoNah, I'd rather say my piece. There isn't anything but toxicity to be had in conversation with someone who unironically takes the position that people changing their screen names to Elon Musk are impersonating him. Those banned are trolling him, plain and simple, and if you comment as though you can't see that, you deserve some judgement and scorn.
- maxbond 4y agoPeople with infuriating views still deserve respect. That's something Musk doesn't seem to understand. If you express yourself the way you just did, lurkers and people on the fence will read your comment. If you employ thought terminating cliches ("bootlicker") then they'll filter you out as noise.
- kweingar 4y agoIt was previously a Twitter norm that you could temporarily change your display name to “impersonate” (satirize) someone, with your handle being the giveaway that it’s not real. This norm seems to have been summarily overturned. I thought that Twitter was going to keep the status quo with moderation and make changes through a moderation council with diverse viewpoints.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- benmmurphy 4y agoI thought this was verboten for blue checks because it kind of defeats the purpose of verification. It says on the blue check page that parody accounts are not eligible for verification. Though, it does not say explicitly that parodying using an existing verified account will lead to suspension. https://help.twitter.com/en/managing-your-account/about-twitter-verified-accounts https://help.twitter.com/en/managing-your-account/about-twit...
- theonething 4y ago> It was previously a Twitter norm that you could temporarily change your display name to “impersonate” (satirize) someone, with your handle being the giveaway that it’s not real. Here is the policy archived from January of this year. https://web.archive.org/web/20220108193314/https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/parody-account-policy https://web.archive.org/web/20220108193314/https://help.twit... > The account name (note: this is separate from the username, or @handle) should clearly indicate that the user is not affiliated with the subject of the account. Non-affiliation can be indicated by incorporating, for example, words such as (but not limited to) "parody," "fake," "fan," or "commentary.” Non-affiliation should be stated in a way that can be understood by the intended audience. So the requirement goes beyond your handle, it must be clearly indicated in your display name that it is a parody. Kathy did not do that. She changed it to just "Elon Musk". So Musk is enforcing a policy that existed way before this takeover.
- kweingar 4y ago
- snvzz 4y agoThere's nothing nice or funny about a "parody" of someone by impersonating them. It's an asshole thing to do, and very unpleasant to be a victim of. Rules should just be changed to be completely clear about that. Impersonating equals ban.
- sackbut 4y agoIt being an asshole thing to do to people in positions of power has been the reason for parody for literally thousands of years.
- lamontcg 4y agoFree Speech Absolutists should firmly support people saying asshole things. Unless only certain people are allowed to be assholes with their speech.
- snvzz 4y ago>Free Speech Absolutists should firmly support people saying asshole things. Understandable, but without impersonation. i.e. Don't put words into other's mouths.
- panarky 4y agoTwitter's new owner promised to allow all speech that is legal under the first amendment to the U.S. Constitution. He demonstrated his high-minded principles by reinstating the account of his friend who had been banned for anti-Semitic speech. But parody accounts that criticize the new owner are somehow a step too far. The unifying principle appears to have nothing to do with what is legal under the U.S. Constitution, but instead whether the new owner personally wants to amplify or suppress the speech. Hard to believe that all that talk about the wisdom of the founders and the value of unrestricted free speech was just bullshit.
- dmix 4y ago> But parody accounts that criticize the new owner are somehow a step too far. Elon claims she was suspended for impersonating a comedian not Elon. She later changed it to Elons name but the original report she was banned for was someone else. Saying this is only about protecting the boss doesn't really hold up. Having rules again Impersonation isn't wrongthink. Thats a big stretch and sounds a bit desperate. I also highly doubt the new rules are "everything goes except what is illegal". They haven't even announced what the new policy is but there's no way it's going to be a free for all for prominent accounts (random accounts were always given more leeway because there are simply too many of them). Twitter went hardcore in one (highly inconsistent) direction. You could significanty pull back from aggressive moderation and still not be an "illegal or all" scenario. Which is far more likely to be the case given pressure from advertising and because it makes sense as a product descision. People didn't care about Twitters moderation until they went hardcore. The solution doesn't need to be hardcore in the other direction to be a big improvement.
- bitshiftfaced 4y agoIt appears to be part of their premuskian TOS: https://web.archive.org/web/20221003235153/https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/parody-account-policy https://web.archive.org/web/20221003235153/https://help.twit...
- incomingpain 4y agoWhile under her normal name she made a number of comments supporting the democrats. Saying to vote democrat, etc. No problem. When she switched her name and picture to Elon, she broke an existing rule about no impersonation. In effect, when both of these combined she was publicly spreading election misinformation by making it look like Elon Musk was recommending to vote democrat. Also against the rules. This is not the first time she has broken the twitter rules; she must be surprised they got enforced this time.