42 ms·
Twitter Now Asks Some Fired Workers to Please Come Back
- pinewurst 4y agohttps://archive.ph/VLCqz https://archive.ph/VLCqz
- cbtacy 4y agoCan we now, at long last, kill the myth that Elon Musk is a business genius?
- aliswe 4y agoNot just yet.
- _oqj3 4y ago[flagged]
- ctvo 4y agoI wouldn’t call it communism to say a business person who made a bad deal by overpaying 3x the price for something is incompetent.
- forgetfulness 4y agoAnd then races to lay off half the workforce days after coming in, based on napkin calculations that suspiciously work out to cut costs to cover the loans he took with the company as collateral ahead of time. After trying to fight off in court the completion of this impulse buy. If Mr. Musk turns this around after so much fumbling around, that would be the display of business acumen that his admirers expect of him, so far trying to say that these moves make sense amounts to saying that these are the tactics of a genius beyond mortal ken, because they simply don't look good.
- wolfram74 4y agoDon't forget TSLA is down ~63% of it's price since april 14th compared with S&P500 drop to ~86% in the same time frame, impossible to say what's causally linked, but musk is not just out ~40+billion from this whole ordeal.
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y agoI realized Elon wasn't a scientist or engineer a long time ago. But a good businessman I thought he was and I think it's too early to say in this case whether that holds true. One issue is that since the company is now private, we most likley will not get to see it's profit. All we will have is what employees or musk says. So I still think it's too soon to make conclusions.
- lottamus 4y agoSure, but I’m really interested to see what he does with http://x.com http://x.com
- tapoxi 4y agoHe wants to make a WeChat, but WeChat can only happen because Apple allows WeChat to bend the rules so it can access the Chinese market.
- rdtwo 4y agoHe’s just a young Donald trump
- qeternity 4y agoI’m don’t fall into one camp or the other: I think the guy is human, like everyone else, and riddled with faults. But one guy has put humans into space, and the other sold steaks on infomercials.
- kevinh 4y agoThat's quite the slanted framing. An alternate framing: one was president of the United States and one got pushed down a flight of stairs for making fun of a kid because his father committed suicide.
- forgetfulness 4y agoBut as a businessman, Musk has done far more for society with SpaceX and Starlink than Trump ever did as a sketchy real estate developer, or media personality. Let's give that to Musk, not withstanding his dubious personal choices, polarizing public persona, or this questionable decision of buying and then gutting an unprofitable social network.
- ajmurmann 4y agoI have very strong, very mixed feelings about Musk and am not sure if he is a great businessmen or not. However, I did appreciate DHH's blog post about Job's returning to Apple. Massive layoffs and Jobs admitted that mistakes will be made, but at least decisions are being made. Short worthwhile read: https://world.hey.com/dhh/apple-fired-4-100-when-steve-jobs-returned-in-1997-57ed6bc6 https://world.hey.com/dhh/apple-fired-4-100-when-steve-jobs-... Edit: auto-correct typo
- pessimizer 4y agoI wish the Elon anti-fans would wait for Elon fans to say something, then respond to them, rather than posting 900 comments picking fights with people who haven't even posted yet. This obsession with adoring or condemning love-hate branded celebrities as quickly and loudly as possible is unbelievably grating.
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 4y agoI thought the hyperloop was that moment but in fairness he managed to get investment for that shit.
- shrubble 4y agoSo maybe 36 out of 3700?
- BrentOzar 4y agoI would love to listen in on those negotiations. If you’re reading this, and Twitter wants you back, I hope you ask for a contract with a year’s pay in advance, due before returning to work, at 10x your prior rate. After all, you must be one of those 10x developers if Elon is willing to eat crow and ask you to come back.
- forgetfulness 4y agoJust having those emails in hand would be almost a voucher for negotiating higher salary when looking for another job, they certify that you were one of the people that were vital for Twitter to run.
- onion2k 4y agoBeing asked to go back just means it's cheaper to get you to return than it is to recruit someone to do your old job.
- BrentOzar 4y ago> Being asked to go back just means it's cheaper to get you to return than it is to recruit someone to do your old job. Only at your old rate.
- seadan83 4y agoFor software, the existing employees will always be cheaper. It has been argued that an engineers value is captured most in their mental model of the system. EG: Want a new feature in a system I built and maintained? Boom, here are the touch points, the gotchyas, and here is the roadmap to get if done in three days. Anyone new to that system will first say, cool, give me about 3 weeks to learn this code, and then maybe another 7 while we implement it and work through all of the trip wires we did not know about.
- kaba0 4y agoAnd firing them was just an insanely dumb thing significantly increasing expenses.
- 4y ago
- zzzeek 4y agoCan't wait to see the HN "just give Elon a chance to put his brilliant plans in motion!" crowd to explain this one to us. Enlighten us please !
- qeternity 4y agoHN seems pretty anti Elon, no?
- d23 4y agoI can’t speak for the rest of HN, but his childish narcissistic megalomania certainly rubs me the wrong way.
- kevinh 4y agoDepending on the thread it can go either way. There are large contingents on both sides as Musk is quite divisive.
- qeternity 4y agoYeah fair enough, two sides to everything. Anecdotally I feel like I see a lot of Elon hate, but that could just be my decency bias due to Twitter drama and layoffs.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- theonething 4y agoI'm seeing the same thing here on HN. People are frothing at the mouth to hate on him. Wild speculation all over. Case in point, the HN trope that he is an idiot and doesn't know anything about technology and just takes credit for brilliant engineers' work. I laid out solid evidence that is not true, quoting top of the field scientist and engineers' assessment of his technical knowledge and skills. The only response I get is from RavingGoat (username kind of checks out) claiming Elon must have paid these people to say these things with no evidence whatsoever. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33504228 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33504228 I know this is cliche here, but in this case, it really seems like Redditors have invaded this space.
- nodesocket 4y agoI don't know how we can all believe a lot of the saga and news that is coming out of Twitter. After all the misinformation and trolls (pretending to be laid off employees) and culture of misinformation and manipulation we can trust much of the media coming out on Twitter.
- magwa101 4y ago
- atum47 4y agoIt seems that this website asked me to accept cookies with a Pop up that covers the whole screen (mobile) after accepting (only apparently option) it was still behind a subscription. Could HN parse links and put how many cookies each website is trying to force you to accept?
- brigandish 4y agoTurn off Javascript, and possibly CSS and you can read it. (I browse the web now with both off by default)
- awinter-py 4y agotweeps understandably upset but if he is really offering to buy them a horse I think that is more than fair?
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoIt's not about fairness, it's about Musk making terrible decisions.
- fm2606 4y agoIf I were asked back I'd take it (hopefully with an increase in salary) then I'd actively search for another job. Once I landed it I'd give zero day notice. Fuck them. I understand I could be potentially hurting coworkers by adding additional work to their plate but Twitter didn't give 2 shits about the people left behind and the work that they would have to take on. Why is it corporations can "layoff" without notice but as an employee you are expected to give 2 weeks notice? I guess one could argue that if the corp gives a severance pay then that makes up for sudden layoff. But it doesn't. Even if I have a savings for emergencies employee sponsored health insurance will eventually end. Then COBRA kicks in and there goes your emergency savings if you have a family. Of course the whole U.S. health insurance shit-show is for another discussion but when you have a family AND a serious health issues, health insurance is front and center on one's mind. If I never had to worry about health insurance and have the ability to go get the care I need/want would take a huge burden off of my shoulders and I'm sure I'm not alone. Sorry for the rant.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ianai 4y agoThe at will is both ways, legally. It’s the massive unequal market power that forces two weeks notice.
- s1k3 4y agoThey were given 90 days severance… which is like 6 standard notice periods.
- seadan83 4y agoNot the original plan to do that, so there was a forcing function. Check further down for the comments noting that severance is there to cover the WARN period.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- MangoCoffee 4y ago"Some of those who are being asked to return were laid off by mistake, according to two people familiar with the moves" https://archive.ph/VLCqz https://archive.ph/VLCqz
- jmclnx 4y agoSounds familiar. Where I worked years ago, the company asked for volunteers to be laid off, many people, took the package (1 years salary). IT was not allowed to volunteer. Mang. did not keep count, some Departments were emptied out. So after a couple of weeks, many people were re-hired and was able to keep their '1 year salary bonus'. Many people in IT left once the re-hirings happened. The company went chapter 11 about 5 years later.
- akmarinov 4y agoAccept to leave for 1 year salary? I’d do that any time. It’s a free year off, you can even start working somewhere else if you get bored and just be 1 year ahead finance wise. That’s a great deal.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoPlus generally speaking, changing jobs will get you a raise as well.
- jrochkind1 4y agoYeah, sounds like a company desperate to reduce the metric of ongoing operating cost, no matter what it did to anything else. I would guess private equity shenanigans.
- aaron695 4y ago
- dirkg 4y agoWhatever happened to the WARN lawsuits against Musk? How is he allowed to layoff 40-50% of staff with zero notice?
- bluedino 4y agoDo they apply since they are still being paid?
- chowells 4y agoLawsuits take more than 1 week. They are coming, in time. Unfortunately, their only penalty is monetary. So the answer to your latter question is "he can pay the fine."
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoHe's paying 3 months severance.
- int_19h 4y agoSo when he's bragging that severance is larger than it had to be, it's basically a lie?
- lurker616 4y agoYes
- theonething 4y agoIf it's 3 months severance, doesn't seem like he's lying. > WARN protects employees, their families, and communities by requiring employers to give a 60-day notice https://edd.ca.gov/en/Jobs_and_Training/Layoff_Services_WARN https://edd.ca.gov/en/Jobs_and_Training/Layoff_Services_WARN
- throwawayhaxor 4y agobecause severance covers the WARN period
- reset2023 4y agoTwitter has lost its prestige. Is there any company in the world that could fill this void?
- vinyl7 4y agoFrom what I've been told, this is common at large companies. Lay off staff then hire them back as contractors.
- awb 4y agoCalifornia is one of the strictest states around the contractor / employee designation. I’m not sure of all the rules but I think working more than 20hrs or getting the majority of your contractor income from a single source raises a lot of flags.
- davesque 4y agoIf part of the fitness criteria involved printing out code written in the last 6 months on paper, it was predictable that they would have accidentally let go of many important contributors in a 50% layoff. Color me not surprised. Turns out running a large technology platform takes more than just wishful thinking and personal brand stunts.
- byyll 4y agoI'd be happy if I stop hearing about Twitter and it's alternatives.
- simondotau 4y agoI don’t mean to be snarky, but the solution is exercising self restraint. The world will continue on just fine if you stop engaging with the topic.
- gw98 4y agoHow it looked in his head: Swoop in to the sounds of Jan Hammer’s Crocketts Theme with his Tesla staff entourage, you’re fired you’re fired, sit down, hack the planet, job done, planet bows before him, free speech restored. How it turned out: “Um, boss, we’ve spent the last three days trying to get a build running in Jenkins. Might want to get the dudes you fired back.”. While all the advertisers distance themselves from the unravelling incel, racist, sexist shit show. The guy’s a fucking idiot. Nothing else to it.
- dissent 4y agoThe world's full of them though. I don't really get the passion behind the anti-Elon camp. It sounds personal. Isn't it just some billionaire doing what they do?
- Watchwatcher 4y agoIt does feel unnaturally influenced, I agree. Follow the money, I suppose. Who stands to gain from twitter and/or elons failure? We can speculate for fun. Certainly Bill Gates, with his half billion short on Tesla. He'd have the money to influence social media. We already know Microsoft games HN from when the CEO was bragging about it to shareholders. So it can be done. Who else? Oil and Gas probably hate him for Teslas battery tech. The entire automotive industry would be interested in piling on. ... NASA? That doesn't seem like them but who knows. Everyone on twitter who already hated him would be doubling down. I figure most are just secretly jealous. I am.
- gw98 4y agoNot even slightly jealous. The guy purports to be solving the greatest problems humanity has in some kind of altruistic way. But really he’s built a company selling luxury electric cars to the top 5% which allow us to carry on our bad behaviour for a few more years in a new way. At the same time trying to crush worker rights and sell out to China.
- Watchwatcher 4y ago
- pella 4y agorelated: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33488224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33488224 see the top comments. "Allegedly Oracle did this years ago when they had layoffs-- employees were let go, then asked if they wanted to return. Apparently, if they said no, the company considered the exit a resignation instead of a layoff, and would refuse severance. If oracle was then taken to court over the lack of severance by former employees, those employees' refusal to rejoin the company could be used to avoid an unfavorable ruling for Oracle." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33488447 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33488447
- notacoward 4y agoAre you suggesting that Elon Musk is the new Larry Ellison?
- simondotau 4y agoSurely it would have been more remarkable if a company lays off 3,700 employees and exactly zero mistakes are made. A company like Twitter is impossibly complex, and it's very likely that some number of people are legitimately important, but their importance cannot be seen from a top-down view. I see it as a healthy sign that Twitter management are rapidly identifying and rectifying any missteps.
- rdtwo 4y agoCome back to twitter work to rule while everyone else runs around freaking out? What are they going to do? Fire you again?
- n4bz0r 4y agoApparently, I seem to be grossly out of touch with all this twitter-related drama. Can someone please explain why the events surrounding twitter acquisition are such a newsmaker? What does it matter who owns the company and who the company fires? You can still (re)post the messages, you can still read the messages. All the favorite 'content-generators' are still there. Not much has changed from the users' perspective, everything works just fine. I mean. A few memes - why not? A casual discussion - maybe. Rage and daily news titles about some internal decisions - what is this, '16 and pregnant'? And what about this 'looking for twitter alternatives' crap? What for? I feel like these low-effort topics pull the worst out of the community.
- palata 4y ago> And what about this 'looking for twitter alternatives' crap? Well every opportunity is good to try to promote your network, isn't it?
- hagbarth 4y agoIt was pretty obvious from the speed of the layoffs that this would happen. No way they would be able to accurately suss out everyone that would be needed in a few days. They prioritised speed over accuracy, which I can actually respect. Question is how hard it's going to bite them.
- buzzdenver 4y agoSo they hastily, after one week, laid off 50% of their staff, but it took just one weekend to realize that some of those people are needed? I guess they were really missed at Twitter, but this is not exactly the sign of a well run company.
- luxcem 4y agoHopefully all the shit show will lead to the fast decline of Twitter, maybe a new interest in decentralized social media.
- jrochkind1 4y agoDoes this seem a surprising mis-step for a guy who has run multiple companies before, even succesful ones? Or I guess maybe this is actually pretty typical, you can't lay off that much of your company without making some big mistakes you try to reverse? (But still... this isn't Musk's first rodeo, right? Why does it seem like he doens't know what he's doing?)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thrillgore 4y agoWhat I like about this is that Elon apparently made this call by counting SLOCs printed on paper, and then stack ranked them. Clearly the man is a genius, and he will save Twitter. You cannot audit performance at a software company by SLOC. In fact, its a great way to drive up hardware costs and salaries. I stand by my previous statement about stack ranking: It does not fucking work. EVER. Fire low performers if you must but don't turn them on each other.