23 ms·
Wells are running dry in Southwest as foreign-owned farms feed cattle overseas
- mtw 4y agoThe US exports $25B worth of soybeans per year, which is one of the most water intensive crop. Should these exports be banned? same for almonds, cotton, rice etc.
- zamfi 4y agoNo but perhaps the negative externalities of water overextraction should start to get priced in.
- rubyfan 4y agoSeems hard to put a price on some of those negative externalities. A tariff or something doesn’t really fix or curb the problem.
- silon42 4y agoHas the tariff been tried? Increase it if the aquifer levels are dropping.
- vkou 4y agoIt's pretty easy, just charge ruinous usage rates for any water use that is beyond replenishment rates. It doesn't matter if these soybeans are going to China, Mars, or Washington state, the only thing that matters is whether the people growing them are exhausting their region's water supply.
- dahart 4y agoHow? When it comes to pricing the environment, we have a long history of missing the mark by orders of magnitude, due in part to the extremely long delays between cause and effect, and also due to markets and financial vested interests preventing accurate information about costs, and even preventing the analysis of costs. https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1326&context=facpub https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?a...
- richk449 4y agoIf the externality currently has no cost, then even pricing it low by orders of magnitude should be better than the status quo. Pricing it high by orders of magnitude would have negative consequences, but that seems unlikely to happen in practice.
- dahart 4y ago> even pricing it low by orders of magnitude should be better than the status quo. No, while this assumption seems econ 101 logical for a second, it’s not really true and the paper I linked above explains why. The pricing has to match the approximate order-of-magnitude cost of externalities for it to actually prevent any of the consequences we’re discussing here (or more likely be regulated so that Saudi Arabia can’t buy all the water regardless of price). There’s enough price flexibility over water and high enough demand that increasing prices 2x or even 10x today will not slow consumption at all. Water in the US west is already over-subscribed, and people with more money have already lined up to buy whatever becomes available. Increasing prices a little will only change who buys water, not whether it gets used. It has to be high enough that people start choosing not to buy it, which with water is an extremely high bar. In the mean time, draining our aquifers has ramifications for the next several thousand years. This is the whole problem with cost-benefit analysis and free market thinking. When it comes to things that all humans need, like air and water, we have never yet managed to calculate either the true costs or the true benefits correctly, and reducing the equation to money loses all sense of proportion, and more or less always frames things in terms that let rich people and corporations win and take whatever they want.
- richk449 4y agoI don’t think it is as black and white as you make it out to be. Yes, there will be large demand for water even at higher prices. But less than at lower prices. Maybe a little less, maybe a lot less, but either way we are better off than now. Also, there are many other effects to consider besides how much the demand will change. As the price increases, alternative water sources become more economic - trucking water in, building pipelines and canals, building water capture systems, desalinization, etc. Rather than solving the problem by using less water it may be possible to solve the problem by using water that has less environmental impact. Generally speaking, I find your framework hard to parse. Free market thinking and cost benefit analysis are orthogonal, not two parts of a whole. Pricing externalities, as we are discussing here is not the same thing as cost benefit analysis. Cost benefit analysis is a bureaucrat sitting in an office and deciding what policies should be enacted. Pricing an externality means assigning a cost to use of some scarce resource, and letting the market decide if and when the resource is worth the cost.
- pixl97 4y agoHow much of the soybean crop is grown in the desert southwest versus the midwest? Almonds is really the only contentious item on this list as they are grown in areas with water insecurity.
- shagie 4y agoFrom https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/rssiws/al/us_cropprod.aspx https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/rssiws/al/us_cropprod.aspx https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/rssiws/al/crop_production_maps/US/USA_Soybean.png https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/rssiws/al/crop_production_maps/US/... The midwest (not counting Arkansaw in that set, and just going from the labeled state numbers) makes up at least 80% of the total soybean production (Wisconsin and Michigan aren't labeled). You will note not even a pail yellow on anything west of the Dakotas. If we want to talk about water... check out rice production. https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/rssiws/al/crop_production_maps/US/USA_Rice.png https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/rssiws/al/crop_production_maps/US/... Though there's some other interesting parts on that - https://www.npr.org/transcripts/1019488080 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/1019488080
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoWe grow a butt-ton of soybeans in iowa, and I have yet to see anybody irrigating them anywhere. See, we water crops here like god intended - by water falling from the sky for free.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rsj_hn 4y agoWe really shouldn't be growing soybeans or corn in Great American Desert (the vast plains west of the Mississippi and east of the Rockies). That is arid land intended for grass, and then you should raise cattle and livestock on the grass, with at most occasional rotations for crops, say once every 30 years or so. That is why herds of buffalo roamed this area and only small regions were cultivated for corn, and only for a few growing cycles, before it again returned to grassland for cattle. This is how all civilizations traditionally cultivated grasslands -- as lands on which ruminants were raised, and then you drink the milk and eat the meat of the ruminants as your main source of calories. Trying to raise crops on arid cattle country requires you to deplete aquifers and then import large amounts of fertilizers because the land itself can't sustain that type of production. It can, however, sustain growing grass, with no fertilizer or water additions required. Then as the ruminants eat the grass, they fertilize the soil and the roots decompose, adding more nutrients. Do that over many generations, and you create a rich soil, and on the rich soil, a few crops can be grown, and then they need to be replaced again with grass and cattle. The decision to grow millions of acres of soybeans and corn in this desert is a short sighted policy. Milk and meat need to be food products from that region, given the climate. East of the Mississippi, there is a wetter climate, and that's where we should be growing most of our crops.
- shagie 4y agoSoybean production: https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/rssiws/al/crop_production_maps/US/USA_Soybean.png https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/rssiws/al/crop_production_maps/US/... Corn production: https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/rssiws/al/crop_production_maps/US/USA_Corn.png https://ipad.fas.usda.gov/rssiws/al/crop_production_maps/US/...
- x86_64Ubuntu 4y agoNone of the top states that grow soybeans are as water starved as the desert. https://www.cropprophet.com/soybean-production-by-state-top-11/ https://www.cropprophet.com/soybean-production-by-state-top-...
- ianai 4y agoHave to wonder why the tie-in to overseas trade in an article about wells running dry. Feels more like stoking outrage over foreigners than drought.
- LatteLazy 4y agoAgreed. We can do shitty shortsighted things for money, but foreign money is "dirty"!?
- im-a-baby 4y agoWhy do countries exist? To protect the interests of the citizens. Water is an important issue
- simonsarris 4y agoDepleting an underground reservoir is a matter of national security. Doing it to sell alfalfa to another country is off the charts a matter of national security.
- sbarre 4y agoWould it be different if the farm was American-owned, but still growing alfalfa and selling it to another country? Are you suggesting export controls on vegetables?
- ianai 4y agoAlso the US long ago decided to make international trade a point of ensuring and reinforcing national security. Marshall plan and all that.
- red_trumpet 4y agoHow about restricting the amount of water one is allowed to extract from the aquifer?
- btown 4y ago
- bamboozled 4y agoFree markets
- baggy_trough 4y agoLack of proper free markets in water.
- kevingadd 4y agoIs there an appropriate price for a child's drinking water? 500/yr? 5000/yr? What if a company wants to use all our water to make really expensive luxury food and earn back everything it spends? Should we sell them all our water since they're the highest bidder?
- vitiral 4y agoConsidering wars have been fought and blood spilled over it I'd say the answer is yes, but it's a price many would prefer not paying.
- malyk 4y agoUnder 100 gallons a day (totally random choice), free-ish. Over 1 acre-foot per day, $100,000 (totally random choice).
- MichaelCollins 4y agoHow do you accomplish that sort of pricing scheme with free markets? You need government regulated markets to accomplish this.
- unethical_ban 4y agoI for one support this. Too many people in the thread are just saying a phrase like "Free markets" while making no point foolishly, followed by rhetorical questions. Allow me to be unambigious. If we agree that overconsumption of groundwater combined with under-replenishment of all frewshwater resources due to climate change implies a coming strategic shortage of water, then yes, absolutely, state and federal government should be severely scrutinizing where water is going and prohibit excess water consumption for luxuries and for exports. Another way to go about it would be what the person above you said: Create tiered pricing for water such that the reasonable monthly use of water is as close to free (minus upkeep of water infrastructure) as possible, while quickly ramping up marginal cost.
- mastax 4y agoYou could try to come up with a scheme that targets people you don't like, but that leaves you with an inconvenient truth: people you do like are just as capable of sucking the wells dry.
- pwarner 4y agoYeah the foreign owned part seems like the least important part.
- steve76 4y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoIt's not really so much that the farm is foreign owned, it's that the very water intensive crop is grown so it can be shipped overseas to feed livestock for foreign populations. This is essentially "exporting water". Which, in and of itself, is not necessarily a bad thing, but it is when water is essentially so mispriced that it's a really bad deal for the place that is supplying the water, especially during a mega-drought.
- Maursault 4y ago> it's that the very water intensive crop is grown The article is very much pot, kettle black. Agriculture is using the majority of the water and mostly for growing alfalfa to feed cows. Everything there is wrong. We don't need that many cows. If the town wants to save itself, it must start water-rationing for agriculture, and ban a lot of alfalfa growing.
- supportlocal4h 4y agoInstead we need to be growing more chicken feed?
- jacobolus 4y ago> If the town wants to save itself, it must start water-rationing for agriculture, and ban a lot of alfalfa growing. Or more effectively (because it is much simpler and can’t be gamed nearly as easily), price the water appropriately based on the sustainable supply. Then it will not be profitable to use at huge scale for low-value water-intensive crops. If fairly pricing the water ends up hurting local residents, that would best be dealt with by directly paying cash to every resident to make up the typical difference. (We should do the same with other resources that are scarce or have negative externalities; e.g. gasoline should have the environmental costs of carbon emissions priced into it with a very steep tax, and then every resident should be directly paid cash enough to make up the difference for a typical person’s transportation. Otherwise, people are incentivized to over-use resources that are effectively being subsidized, and the free market economy cannot perform its function.)
- Danieru 4y agoWhat I find most interesting is how this plays into Warren Buffet's complaints about the American trade deficit: America has been selling long term assets to buy short term toys. In Warren Buffet's explanation he uses selling farm land as this exact example. Of course under free trade we would expect foreign buyers to own bits of land. The challenge for America: these are not land swaps. America is not buying up bits of land elsewhere. Instead America is selling these bits of land for trinkets. The US Dollar is a global reserve currency. Which in the abstract sounds nice to have other countries sell US things in exchange for more US debt: but in practice that means selling assets. US Government Bonds or US Farm Land. Both are assets openly traded. The issue is not foreigners. The issue is America is running up a debt and is selling the farm.
- toss1 4y agoAnd not only the farm assets, but the other natural assets, not to mention the know-how of manufacturing (the stupidest thing we ever did was follow the MBA's recommendations that "labor is just fungible, ship it off to the lowest-cost markets"). >>"You can't take water and export it out of the state, there's laws about that," said Arizona geohydrologist Marvin Glotfelty, a well-drilling expert. "But you can take 'virtual' water and export it; alfalfa, cotton, electricity or anything created in part from the use of water." Seems it is time to put a stop to a LOT of that. Fortunately we already are returning semiconductor & other mfg. Must keep this up...
- jjtheblunt 4y agoWhat about labor that is fungible insofar as it is easily done by robots?
- MichaelCollins 4y agoHigh tech manufacturing is even more important to keep domestic.
- toss1 4y agoNot to be rude, but you don't work much with manufacturing or robots, do you? Even if, and especially if, a mfg process is highly automated, it takes myriad layers of expertise to get it right. That is the LAST thing you want to ship overseas to your adversaries, which both increases their expertise in the field and your dependence on them. Economically, it is long-term-stupid. Strategically, it is suicide.
- tzs 4y agoHere was an interesting recent longer story about megafarms vs residents conflicts over water in one particular Arizona county and what residents are trying to do about it: "The Cochise County Groundwater Wars--A thirsty megafarm is driving a libertarian enclave in Arizona to embrace a radical solution: government regulation" [1]. I submitted it to HN a few days ago but it went nowhere [2]. It's one in a series of several articles on climate change and megadroughts [3]. [1] https://grist.org/regulation/arizona-groundwater-cochise-county-riverview/ https://grist.org/regulation/arizona-groundwater-cochise-cou... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33407914 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33407914 [3] https://grist.org/series/drought-parched/ https://grist.org/series/drought-parched/
- criddell 4y agoIs the water free for anybody to take, or is there a system of water rights that have to purchased first?
- nkurz 4y agoWater rights in the Southwest are complex, but in general, "surface water" (rivers and streams) is alloted according to historical water rights, but "ground water" (drilled wells) is available to whoever owns the land on the surface. From the article: Groundwater is the lifeblood of the rural Southwest, but just as the Colorado River Basin is in crisis, aquifers are rapidly depleting from decades of overuse, worsening drought and rampant agricultural growth. Residents and farms pull water from the same underground pools, and as the water table declines, the thing determining how long a well lasts is how deeply it was drilled. Now frustration is growing in Arizona's La Paz County, as shallower wells run dry amid the Southwest's worst drought in 1,200 years. Much of the frustration is pointed at the area's huge, foreign-owned farms growing thirsty crops like alfalfa, which ultimately get shipped to feed cattle and other livestock overseas. "You can't take water and export it out of the state, there's laws about that," said Arizona geohydrologist Marvin Glotfelty, a well-drilling expert. "But you can take 'virtual' water and export it; alfalfa, cotton, electricity or anything created in part from the use of water." Residents and local officials say lax groundwater laws give agriculture the upper hand, allowing farms to pump unlimited water as long as they own or lease the property to drill wells into. In around 80% of the state, Arizona has no laws overseeing how much water corporate megafarms are using, nor is there any way for the state to track it. Essentially, this means that in most of Arizona, the water in the ground is free and unmetered for agricultural use by anyone who owns enough land to drill a well. As one would guess, this creates a crisis when some users are drawing enough water to lower the water table on surrounding land.
- supportlocal4h 4y agoIt is not true that ground water from wells is freely available to whomever owns the land. See recent judgements regarding multi-billion dollar disputes in Nevada, Idaho, and Utah. It is not a new thing for some wells to run dry because of neighbors' water use. And it isn't catching anybody by surprise. There's a whole lot of gunfighters flowing into these here parts. Uh hem, sorry. I mean lawyers.
- naycombinator 4y agoI've been following reporter Nathan Halverson on this topic (and other related ones) for years now. Some of his older work on this is still worth a read or a listen: https://revealnews.org/podcast/high-and-dry-a-deep-dive-into-the-water-crisis/ https://revealnews.org/podcast/high-and-dry-a-deep-dive-into... https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/11/02/453885642/saudi-hay-farm-in-arizona-tests-states-supply-of-groundwater https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/11/02/453885642/sa... He's also a producer/face on a new documentary making the rounds at film festivals this year: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt21820452/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt21820452/ There's a trailer on https://www.docnyc.net/film/the-grab/ https://www.docnyc.net/film/the-grab/ as well as online viewing in mid-November. I haven't seen it yet, but it's been well-received thus far.
- supportlocal4h 4y agoSurely the irony is not lost that USians fret over alfalfa and oranges getting shipped overseas after so many decades of shipping oil, autos, bananas, etc. into the US from around the world.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mym1990 4y agoUSians?
- nkurz 4y agoUSian is used to mean people who live in the US. Some people choose it because it's shorter, some because they think it's too US-centric to call people American when there are many other countries on two continents that could match that definition. If you are a non-native English speaker, you probably want to avoid this term unless you are conscious that many readers will code you as "progressive left". It's not as strong as "Amerikan" (sometimes used to imply Americans are Nazis), but it has a similar register. Here's an HN thread from a few years ago about it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9994159 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9994159.
- mym1990 4y agoWow, some people will really jump some extreme hoops to seem "progressive". Gave me a chuckle, thanks.
- supportlocal4h 4y agoI would color myself conservative, though most of my conservative circle might smile at that. I have no interest in seeming progressive. I've come to accept that I am pedantic. I use phrases like "Native American" to avoid ambiguity, not for any political correctness. I don't refer to anything east of Colorado as the Midwest. I sometimes call cornets trumpets but mostly because I am ignorant. Mostly I find that it's less work to use accurate language instead of long clarifying explanations. But you got me this time.
- avidphantasm 4y agoSeize all foreign-owned land, put capital controls in place to keep this from happening again.
- latchkey 4y ago> Seize all foreign-owned land According to Native Americans, we already did that.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoPrecedent.
- pjc50 4y ago.. very Cuban. This kills foreign investment, and possibly results in retaliatory seizure of land overseas owned by US nationals.
- labrador 4y agoA civilization in the desert and that wastes the limited water supply for the profit of the owners at the top should fail. When the last drop runs out maybe people will wake up. That's my view from a distance.
- birdyrooster 4y agoExcept then its an expensive emergency for the state to deal with, it would be far less expensive for the average stake holder to create a political solution that either resolves the shortage or creates a way for the towns to depopulate in a dignified way over time.
- labrador 4y agoGood luck with that. Arizona is filled with rabid religious nuts so I don't expect much to change until the last minute.
- oefrha 4y agoReminds me of American corps draining water elsewhere, like Coca Cola in some South American towns: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/14/world/americas/mexico-coca-cola-diabetes.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/14/world/americas/mexico-coc... The irony!
- yrgulation 4y ago
- Justin_K 4y agoThe coke example differs, as the product is created and consumed in that region.
- renewiltord 4y agoForeign ownership doesn't matter since domestic owned farms will do the same. Drive down California's Central Valley to LA and you'll find farmers' signs decrying Newsom for "wasting our water" (letting the rivers flow into the sea).
- lacker 4y agoAmerican-owned farms do the same thing. They get water for far cheaper than a residential household gets water, and so they are incentivized to waste it. Alfalfa is a uniquely bad crop to grow in dry areas. It uses up a lot of water, and there's nothing special about alfalfa from the Western US - it goes to feed cows and there's plenty of other ways to feed cows. There's no real reason to create laws specific to foreign-owned farmers, or alfalfa. Just make farmers pay the same amount for water as anyone else pays.
- refurb 4y agoThat sounds simple, but water rights, especially in the West can back further than it’s incorporation into the US. In the treaty that ended the Mexican American war, the US agreed to respect all Mexican land grants. Those grants are still enforced by US law. Of course with eminent domain the government might be able to seize water rights (i don’t know) but owners would need to be paid a fair cost for the loss of those rights.
- jdkee 4y agoThe laws and treaties and compacts governing water rights can be changed. They are not set for eternity in a stone tablet from the Creator, they are human constructions.
- supertrope 4y agoIrrigation water is not potable, it's not plumbed to the point of use, and no sewage treatment is needed afterward. There's definitely some perverse pricing of agriculture use due to the water rights legal framework (e.g. use it or lose it discourages water saving) but tap water and irrigation water are different commodities.