11 ms·
Home truths about macOS
- Danborg 4y agoIt works as long as you’re willing to stay current on Apple hardware. If you’re not… then macOS probably isn’t for you…
- wlll 4y agoTo be fair, I've always upgrade my hardware before the hardware has lost OS support. If I really wanted to I guess I could run linux on these and use them for something, but I never do (I have one server in my house, it's enough). I upgraded the hardware for a reason.
- bombcar 4y agoI’ve yet to have my main laptop fall out of updates before I’ve updated it (just jumped from 2016 to the M1). Secondary devices for particular purposes have fallen out of updates now and then
- hgsgm 4y ago
- kennend3 4y agoThis was my personal favourate statement in the article. "Deciding whether and when to upgrade macOS is one of the more difficult choices we face. If your Mac isn’t capable of running the current release of macOS, or you’re dependent on key hardware or software which is incompatible, then the decision is made for you." If you head over to the hackintosh side of things you will notice that very rarely does a hackintosh not upgrade to the next version. I don't want to get "conspiracy theory" here but I do wonder how often the next release is blocked by Apple, not by hardware? There are hacks to allow the new OS to run on real Apple hardware despite being blocked and people who have done this seem to be running the new OS just fine? Releasing an OS with serious bugs, then limiting someone from upgrading to a newer one which fixes those issues is just bad.
- webmobdev 4y agoWe can indeed run newer macOS on older macs with the Opencore Legacy Patcher - https://dortania.github.io/OpenCore-Legacy-Patcher/ https://dortania.github.io/OpenCore-Legacy-Patcher/ . But the bugs aren't the only concern. There's also the revised terms of services and privacy policies that we have to consider with each new macOS, as Apple plans to become a service company at our expense. It is also clear that Apple has been taking away developer options, and rearchitecting macOS to be more and more like ios / iPadOS to have greater control of over what developers can do on the system. (There's now even talks of Apple working on a hybrid macOS and iPadOS merge so that they have one common OS for both platform).
- ben-schaaf 4y agoThere is no excuse for the most profitable company in the world to drop support for working hardware. It's entirely within their capability to support even PowerPC macs. And that's besides fact that Apple has an incredibly small portfolio of hardware to support; so much so that they could trivially exhaustively test every update on every possible piece of hardware.
- hgsgm 4y ago
- calvinmorrison 4y agoI was just rereading the ppc history for Apple as they're doing it again for ARM and it seems quite reasonable to be honest. They pulled something off I think would be difficult for many others and have shown they're not married to a single architecture. Still RIP my favorite machine the last ppc Mac tower
- kennend3 4y ago> They pulled something off I think would be difficult for many others and have shown they're not married to a single architecture. You mean like how MS Windows ran on the DEC Alpha as well as X86? Or how Linux runs on X86 and ARM CPU's? Running an OS on multiple CPU types goes back a very long time.
- curling_grad 4y ago> One factor that makes recent memory an unreliable indicator is the series of changes to macOS to prepare for Apple silicon Macs. Slightly off topic, but such changes from High Sierra kinda makes sense now. Back then it seemed like Apple engineers were dropping backward compatibility just because of their own convenience...
- lapcat 4y ago> What other actively exploited bugs are Big Sur and Monterey now vulnerable to? Actually, Apple sometimes patches actively exploited vulnerabilities in "unsupported" older versions of both macOS and iOS. The vulnerabilities that don't get quickly patched are the ones that aren't actively exploited. In any case, security researchers talk about known vulnerabilities that have or haven't been patched, but as the author says, "New versions of macOS are full of bugs". This includes security vulnerabilities! Every new major OS version has brand new, unknown (to Apple) vulnerabilities that did not exist in the previous version. So just because the latest version is "fully patched", that doesn't mean it's "safer". I've seen it happen many times in the past where a new security vulnerabilities in a new OS isn't discovered by the public until many months later. As far as stability and safety is concerned, I personally consider macOS N-1 to have the best tradeoffs. Moreover, the most dangerous software on your computer is not the operating system per se, it's the web browser. The browser is where you're mostly likely to encounter "malicious crafted code" (i.e., JavaScript). Apple supports Safari for macOS N-2, and Safari on macOS N-2 is more similar to Safari on macOS N than macOS N-2 itself is to macOS N. In other words, Safari is likely to be fully patched even if macOS isn't. You can also use another browser such as Firefox or Google Chrome, which ironically support older macOS versions than Apple supports, and the latest versions of those apps are identical and fully patched on every macOS version they support.
- Maursault 4y ago> "New versions of macOS are full of bugs" This is why I never liked Apple's annual upgrade schedule. Ostensibly to stay ahead of security issues, annual upgrade isn't working and is causing more issues than it is worth. Leopard to Mountain Lion were the glory days of OS X stability, with Snow Leopard, Mountain Lion, and High Sierra standing out as focusing on bug fixes rather than introducing new features (and new bugs). I wish Apple had development and stable branches for macOS, such that stable was plain and had very limited features, stayed compatible with decade-old hw, and continued to receive security updates, and upgrading to development was effectively a large patch for stable that included all the new features. > Moreover, the most dangerous software on your computer is not the operating system per se, it's the web browser. Agreed. > You can also use another browser such as Firefox or Google Chrome, which ironically support older macOS versions than Apple supports, and the latest versions of those apps are identical and fully patched on every macOS version they support. If one must have browser connectivity on a mac, then do this, even when still supported and fully patched. I wouldn't mail or surf on any unsupported OS.
- sys_64738 4y agoThis article talks about regular bugs not being updated in anything but the current version of the OS. It talks about security bugs only being fixed in up to N-2 OS releases and then on a sliding scale of importance. It then talks about security bugs not being fixed in those older, unsupported N-3 and older which may get a rare security update. My conclusion is that Apple wants to sell you a new Mac instead of fixing bugs for you.
- jrochkind1 4y agoI am increasingly annoyed by it -- especially when Apple hardware, commendably, kind of can last forever these days. But at some point while the hardware may still be completely usable, it will stop running the latest OS. Which, with OS's only really supported for (depending on how you look at it) 1 to 3 years, isn't great. There haven't for years really been any features I wanted in new OS versions, just have to upgrade to stay on the maintainence treadmill.
- kennend3 4y agoSee my other post here.. opecore legacy patcher (https://dortania.github.io/OpenCore-Legacy-Patcher/ https://dortania.github.io/OpenCore-Legacy-Patcher/) allows you to bypass Apple's artificial "lock" and install newer releases on perfectly working hardware. This is why I own an iPad and iPhone but will not buy an apple Laptop. I dont need to have an expensive laptop suddenly ruled "end of life" and not able to upgrade unless i "patch" it first.
- xtiansimon 4y ago…But I really like my 11” Airbook from 2012
- lizardactivist 4y agoSort of agrees with my own opinion, that your use of Macs and iPhones and your stay in the ecosystem is only secure as long as you keep paying up. More specifically, you're good for a year after you do a major upgrade. After that you may or may not see critical issues addressed, and after two years all bets are off. I'm not sure how long Apple supports their overly expensive things these days, but I will not be surprised if they at some point declare only 3 years of support from introduction. It would mean more money, and they know people will payup.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- scarface74 4y agoThe iPhone 5s from 2013 just got a security update in July of this year. But if you care about how long the vendor supports your phone, you really should get an Android phone. I’m sure you will be delighted about how long they support their phones.
- somebehemoth 4y agoThat’s nice. The article and most comments are about mac os. Snarky android comment is misplaced.
- scarface74 4y agoFrom the parent comment > Sort of agrees with my own opinion, that your use of Macs and iPhones
- somebehemoth 4y agoI read that too. Parent went off topic for 1 word. Your entire comment is off topic. Do you have any thoughts on mac os you would like to share since that is the topic of the post?
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoMy low-end test Mac is an old (2012) 11" Air, running Catalina (it can't run anything newer). It's been getting updates, until recently. I don't know for sure, if they are done.
- black_puppydog 4y agoMy dad switched to Ubuntu Mate when his updates stopped coming in. He's happier than ever with the "look inside, see all the details" approach of Linux, compared to the "details are behind extra hoops because we don't trust our users^W^W^Wwant you to have to think about these scary, scary things."
- zikduruqe 4y agoOh it can run newer... https://dortania.github.io/OpenCore-Legacy-Patcher/ https://dortania.github.io/OpenCore-Legacy-Patcher/
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoThanks! I'll check it out.
- zikduruqe 4y agoLooks like you can go to Monterey at the moment and Ventura is in development. You shouldn't have any issues.
- kennend3 4y agoSee my post below. Often this is an artificial limit and as the other guy posted, opencore legacy can bypass this "lock" and allow you to upgrade beyond Catalina.
- bombcar 4y agoSometimes you can install but things are disabled (Metal was one).
- gw98 4y agoGot to be honest I rarely get any issues with macOS for a couple of years now. The only notable one I remember was the date selection in reminders on 12.6 stopped working and that was fixed in 12.6.1. Workaround was to manually key it in. You do have to keep within the 2-3 year update cycle though. Quite frankly it pays for itself though in less eye poking than windows.
- oneeyedpigeon 4y agoYeah, I can't recall any real bugs at all — the main problems for me are various accessibility flaws and ui issue that Apple will probably never choose to fix anyway. I take issue with your "2-3 year update cycle", though — my 8-year old MacBook Pro is still fine as the daily driver and I know plenty of others with Macs around the same age.
- rocketbop 4y ago> I take issue with your "2-3 year update cycle" I think the OP meant the software update cycle not hardware.
- gw98 4y agoBoth actually. I replace hardware the moment the AppleCare runs out. I also tend to track near or at the latest versions of macOS. I factor in the cost on a monthly cost basis.
- LoganDark 4y agoI also had to replace my Mac when its AppleCare ran out, but only because it started having random issues with its keyboard and USB ports. Stinks of logic board issue, not worth paying to replace when it'll just break again. Still unhappy about that because nothing will ever live up to my mid-2015 MBP.
- gw98 4y ago
- RadiozRadioz 4y ago> It’s safer to delay upgrading This is my policy for most of my software unless there's some kind of critical exploit. Software updates have been the cause of many breakages for me, but I have not (yet) been affected by running out-of-date software (to my knowledge).
- donio 4y agoThe only software I look forward to upgrading is Emacs. Everything else fills me with dread about what will break or what functionality will be lost this time.
- LoganDark 4y agoI avoid updating my software like the plague. Actually, the reason I switched to Firefox is because Chrome's updater snuck past my firewall. That is literally the only reason why. I am considering switching back after seeing how terrible Firefox is. For example, it has a memory leak that causes a crash after 3-4 days of uptime.
- melvyn2 4y agoI wonder if just maybe an update might… fix a bug?
- LoganDark 4y agoI've been looking for evidence that the bug's been fixed, but even upon bringing up the issue with Mozilla engineers, all they have to say is "turn overcommit back on, we don't support your configuration". Excuse me, Mozilla? Firefox should not be collecting 20-30 gigabytes of committed memory in the first place. They must be high or something.
- allarm 4y agoA recent Firefox update had completely cleaned up all configuration and plugins that I had installed. I wouldn’t go back to Chrome over this, but it wasn’t a minor issue for me and it definitely made me more reluctant to the future updates.
- BoardsOfCanada 4y agoEven as a full time mac user, both at work and privately I have a hard time remembering which release, say Sierra was and which one Mojave was and which one came first and if any release was in between.
- bombcar 4y agoI only really remember Snow Leopard heh.
- shmde 4y agoIsn't that... Umm good ? Windows completely rehauls everything in every major releases and makes it difficult to navigate through.
- InCityDreams 4y agoBut at least we all know 3 came before 7, 11 followed 10 etc. Vista was 8. Dunno what happened to 9 but I'll never remember the order of 'name'. Same with android....kit kat was version what now?
- TillE 4y agoAndroid has always gone in alphabetical order, so you can work it out in a few seconds. Strangely I think it was easier to keep track of the order of OS X codenames when they were all big cats. It was more memorable.
- fomine3 4y agoApple naming is too Californian centric.
- nvrspyx 4y agoVista came before 7, so I guess it was 6? Then there was XP before that, which I suppose was 5?
- tambourine_man 4y agoSystemwide OCR is the last feature I remember being excited about in a decade, of the top of my head. But it’s something I could use a third party software for and comes with a few annoyances, like, sometimes I just want to drag an image, not select text. Recently, I fell macOS releases take away more than they give. Either by quality of life (allow terminal.app to access your hard drive), poor UX and aesthetic decisions or downright feature removal. Ventura, for instance, removes Preview’s ability to render PostScript files, and suddenly the man2pdf bash alias I’ve been using for 20 years is broken.
- brainzap 4y agoI miss being able to change application icons. I can't stand these square white icons with 4px padding.
- kmfpl 4y agoThis is simply how Apple does things. They provide software support for ~10 years and then they drop it. Is it wrong? I’m not entirely sure. You can call that greedy, but take a few things into consideration. Firstly, Apple provides highly specialized software that runs extremely well and efficiently on their own hardware. Continuously providing support for old hardware while simultaneously maintaining the same level of performance is simply not feasible. I challenge any software developer to achieve a similar goal. We are not talking about Linux here, where if you’re lucky, things work. Anyone’s that ever used macOS even once knows that things really work. Now, I assume this window of time between a new hardware’s release and the software drop for that given piece of hardware will increase over time, given that new hardware released by Apple nowadays is incredibly performant, this would allow longer software support. Frankly, my opinion is that 10 years of support is more than enough for anyone to consider renovating their hardware. Recently, in the last XNU kernel release (corresponding to macOS 13/iOS 16) the 32-bit part of the kernel has been entirely removed, meaning that XNU won’t support any 32-bit device anymore. This is really exciting to me, as I see the technology moving forward, without getting stuck on prehistoric hardware support.
- FpUser 4y ago>"Anyone’s that ever used macOS even once knows that things really work." I am not a regular Mac user but I was once asked by client to port my CI/CD related script so it can work for developers who use Macs. Script involved dealing with docker among other things. After dicking around for a while I've discovered deeply nested folder created by docker that was not supposed to exist after successful script completion. Do not remember all the details but this folder was a thorn. Short of sacrificing a virgin no matter what I tried I was not able remove it. Invoking search power of Google did not help either - plenty of recipes and suggestions and none worked. Finally after giving this Mac to system gurus and them dicking with it for a day I was told that they have failed so far it is no longer worth their time and they will reinstall the OS.
- lkois 4y agoMacs have a bunch of weird quirks where simple things simply do not work. I got a new mbp for work recently, second to my main windows gaming machine with 34" ultra wide 1440p monitor. And I've basically installed chrome, vscode, and a whole bunch of little packages to make basic hardware operate normally. There's an app to allow the track pad and mouse wheel scroll directions to be set differently. There's another to allow the mouse side buttons to work. It's a basic mouse. These are settings and compatibility issues that do not need to exist. But the most annoying is that the monitor is a bit blurry on the M1. I use vscode for a few mins before I realise there's a fuzziness to it. And apparently this is a known issue, because macs only scale properly for 4k resolutions. So there's another app to make it think its 4k or something. Helps a bit but not that well, and it's a trial. It's maddening. How the hell is anyone supposed to know that Apple has just decided that they won't be compatible with an entire category of bloody monitors, of all things.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anta40 4y ago"If your Mac isn’t capable of running the current release of macOS, or you’re dependent on key hardware or software which is incompatible, then the decision is made for you." Since I need Mac for building iOS apps, unfortunately I couldn't rely on old Mac systems (say > 8 years old). Apple regularely increase the minimum OS version for running Xcode. Since v13.3, you need to have Monterey installed. https://developer.apple.com/support/xcode/ https://developer.apple.com/support/xcode/
- leeches 4y agoApple needs to stop pushing annual upgrades. Please spend 2 years polishing the core system. No features. We need to rebase onto a more stable and reliable platform.
- esskay 4y agoBasically we need a Snow Leopard. That was by far the most rock solid release they've done in years. It included a few new features but was at it's core a massive performance and bug fix release. The fact that it was also released on some very old macs at the time helped too. This being said, day to day I cant remember the last time I experienced a bug on any mac I've used. It's generally very stable, but does need a maintenance release to refine a few areas.
- leeches 4y agoHm I guess it depends on use cases, and machine configurations. I encounter many, many bugs. Off the top of my head: - On reboot, sometimes the Menu Bar fails to load entirely, and I have to keep rebooting until it appears. - WindowServer process memory leaks that require a reboot to fix. - Finder steals focus from other apps. For instance, when I cmd-tab to quick switch between Mail and Notes, Finder will insert itself into the quick switch stack and replace the last focused app. - Finder drag and drop randomly stops working. - Spotlight fails to find files in normal directories, so I have to drop into Terminal to find them. - Terminal sometimes loses input focus for no discernible reason. - Calendar notifications either don’t show up at all, or dismiss themselves automatically, or the snooze action dismisses them and they never return. - Safari page content crashes when the I resize the browser window. No discernible pattern for what causes this. Death by one thousand paper cuts. The list just keeps going.
- lowbloodsugar 4y agoOh, so the unreadable Time Machine backup on my APFS Encrypted drive is not just me then.
- hesk 4y agoI ran into the same problem. What I found most irritating was that even reformatting the drive (in any file system and on different machines), would not make the drive work again. After plugging it into my Mac the FS would corrupt again.
- dangus 4y agoHard truths about software: they have bugs. There's no such thing as an OS that has zero bugs. All major versions of software become abandoned eventually. Then you either upgrade to a newer version of the software or you live with whatever bugs you have. > Those residual bugs are often severe: El Capitan continued to cause many Macs to grind to a halt through its entire cycle, the cause not being addressed until Sierra. Sierra in turn was abandoned with a serious bug in its backup scheduling system that caused automatic backups to fail completely after a few days, and that was only fixed in High Sierra. More recently, Monterey initially suffered from three serious memory leaks, of which two were fixed early, but the third has only just been addressed in Ventura. Citation needed. Citation needed. Citation needed. I had multiple Macs with all these versions of macOS and never noticed any issues like this. My system never "ground to a halt," nor did I have failed backups, nor did I suffer from a "serious memory leak." > APFS is but one example of a critical sub-system that loses all support once Apple releases a new version of macOS. Is this an unknown or unexpected phenomenon? Does Microsoft make updates to NTFS on Windows 2000? What's wrong with APFS that needs to be fixed? "Bugs," I guess. > Many of us had suspected that, during those two security-only maintenance years, older macOS didn’t get all the fixes it could have. Right, because it's an old version that's out of support. What's the problem? > It’s safer to delay upgrading Stop. No. Don't. Stop telling people not to update their systems. This reminds me of everyone who recommended that people disable patches for Windows XP due to the mild inconvenience of the whole thing and then wondered why they got infected with every virus under the sun. > It’s a similar argument to that concerning vaccination of younger people against Covid or other generally non-fatal conditions. Most people under the age of 70 who are in reasonably good health should be safe from serious or prolonged illness or death. Oh, the author is anti-vax. Great.
- simondotau 4y ago(Apologies in advance for embracing the off-topic tangent.) What you quoted from the article: "Most people under the age of 70 who are in reasonably good health should be safe" For someone anti-vax, his own choice of words is odd. Most? Reasonably? Should? Is this supposed to be a compelling formulation of their argument? It's astounding to me that anti-vax arguments are so often laced in ambiguity and "principles", i.e. emotions which cosplay as rationality. Whereas a properly rational and evidence-driven argument is just so straightforward. Your chances of avoiding infection are slim and ever-diminishing. The disease has a non-zero risk of complications/hospital resource dependency/death for people of all ages. The vaccines have a statistically significant impact on outcomes and an utterly spectacular safety track record. End of argument.
- jmbwell 4y agoI was very confused by this article until I realized it was written in a myth/fact structure. The headings are not claims the author is making or that the article supports. The headings are common misperceptions, which each subsequent section refutes. If the point of the article is, as it seems, that people should go ahead and update, then yes; Apple expects people to run only the latest version, and people should go ahead and update. If that’s not possible, they risk suffering issues not addressed until later releases, which is true of course of virtually all software.
- deeblering4 4y agoThere is a complicating factor of 3rd party software bugs and compatibility when run under the latest macos release. It usually takes 6-12 months before those have been fully ironed out
- rcarr 4y agoI recently upgraded from a Late 2013 MacBook Pro to the base model 14 inch MacBook Pro M1. It cost me £1,729.00. I'll probably update more frequently now (I'm thinking every three years) but even if I didn't here is the cost breakdown. 1729 / 7 years / 365 days = £0.68 / day Personally, for what you get, I think this is an incredibly reasonable subscription. I would love to know the percentage of people on this thread that are moaning about official support being dropped after seven years who happily spend £2.72 (4 times as much) on a coffee every day.
- javchz 4y agoPlus, MacBooks hold an amazing re sell value vs HP, Lenovo, etc. I'm not a fanboy (I hate Apple push for anti repair), but in honor of the truth, after the switch from Intel to ARM M1, Apple has one of the best balance of value/performance laptops in the market.
- codepoet80 4y agoLong-time Mac user here -- by that I mean, I use my Macs for a long time. Long, long after Apple supports them. My Mac Pro 4,1 is a daily driver. I replaced my 2011 MacBook Pro with a ThinkPad only this year. I have strong feelings on this, but I'll say only two things: 1) Apple breaks more with each OS update than they offer in terms of features. I own Photoshop CS4 for personal use. It works great. At work, they pay for a subscription for the latest Adobe software and its crashy, screen-flickery, garbage. CS4 just works -- but that means I have to stay on Mojave, and that means I'm sticking with my Mac Pro. Same for the version of Final Cut I have. Same for my back catalog of fun games... and I dual boot Snow Leopard for some of the really old ones. 2) All complaints about Windows here are valid, but I have apps from the 3.1 era that run on modern hardware on Windows 11. Compared to Microsoft track-record, Apple shouldn't even be considered a stable OS platform provider. They make nice hardware; they're increasingly making a dumbed-down OS that's only redeeming characteristic is that it can run all the common browsers and has a nice shell built in.
- godDLL 4y agoTLDR: Apple is not handling the bugs and security issues well for it's OS releases. It does not mean that you should stop updating your software.