8 ms·
Engineered ‘Superplant’ Cleans Indoor Air Like 30 Regular Plants
- c7b 4y agoI suppose the plant could mate and procreate with regular Pothos plants? I'm wondering what the implications would be if that happens in the wild, ie those special genes spreading further.
- alexmorenobaeza 4y ago
- tripletao 4y agoPothos naturally almost never flowers; it's propagated mostly vegetatively both by humans and in the wild. That decreases the risk, though I still consider the concept reckless given the lack of significant benefit. They apparently haven't yet received the USDA approval necessary to sell their GMO, though I'd guess that under current regulations they will.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI used to have a Chinese woman working for me. I'm pretty sure she came from a privileged place, in Beijing. Anyway, she told me that they always had tea plants around her house in China. She said they smelled great, and "cleaned the air."
- socialismisok 4y agoPothos are easy to grow and easy to propagate. One pothos could turn into 30 without a huge amount of effort. I kinda like the idea of living in a space with 30 pothos plants. I guess the engineered one would also be easy to propagate? Which raises an interesting question, after I buy one, can I just give away dozens of clones? Are there IP restrictions? Does the plant die without the special sauce bacteria?
- seydor 4y agoit's also a very invasive species. not eaten by animals it grows everywhere and loves to climb on trees where it can choke then > after I buy one, can I just give away dozens of clones I mean, it s going to be so popular that the company will have no way of stopping the IP thieves.
- ch4s3 4y agoThen you have 30 plants to take care of and find space for. It would be basically impossible to stop you from propagating and giving away cutting if the plant can do that. All of that other stuff seems like extra cost to develop with questionable gains to sales.
- masklinn 4y ago> Then you have 30 plants to take care of and find space for. Pothos are pretty much vines, so seems pretty easy to put the pot on a high surface and let them fall down or creep along, unless they're too structurally solid to do that?
- ch4s3 4y agoI mean, I get it I have some pothos but also limited window space and shelf space. A 30x improvement in efficiency is compelling.
- missosoup 4y agoBased on the OP post and the notion of a wait list for something that should be trivial to propagate as you mentioned, I'm guessing this whole thing is a $$/Month subscription to a proprietary variant of a common plant. "Just one Neo P1, as the company dubbed its initial product, can remove as much pollution from a home’s air as 30 regular plants, the company says. Neo P1 was in development for four years, and is a bioengineered version of a common houseplant called Pothos." What does this even mean? What is 'pollution' in this claim? Just grow and happily propagate regular pothos which are wonderful plants, and if you need to filter your air... get certified filters?
- zeristor 4y agoNASA had studies on plants to clean air, I have a copy of Bill Wolverton’s book. Although no plants… https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_Clean_Air_Study https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_Clean_Air_Study
- kodah 4y agoI'm a bit skeptical of needing a "special pot" and adding some bits to support a microbiome. My partner got me into pothos and we've been growing our collection ever since. They're very easy to maintain and require very little attention as long as you give them some light and keep them away from drafts.
- EvanAnderson 4y agoI’ve heard pathos described as “thriving on neglect”. When WFH hit I imagined empty offices choked and overgrown by pathos allowed to run amock. (Having said that I’m aware they need watered.) Edit: Spelling.
- Patrick-T 4y agoHi Kodah, Patrick from Neoplants here. Pothos are indeed super easy to maintain and very robust. But even then, not everyone has a green thumb and might overwater or underwater the plant. Which is why we designed our pot or “Shell” with a water reservoir. But more importantly, the Shell is designed to maximize the soil/air surface for maximum efficiency of the entire system.
- davidmurdoch 4y agoIf it does actually require regular maintenance of a proprietary microbiom then, eh, it doesn't clean the air like 30 regular plants; it's more like a subscription service for clean air that comes with a plant. Still cool though.
- Nathanael_M 4y agoCAaaS+P is the business model of the future.
- agilob 4y agoPlant as a service :(
- Nathanael_M 4y agoThis is not the solarpunk future of my dreams. I self-host my plants. My plants are on-prem bare-dirt.
- faddypaddy34 4y agoAs they should be.
- dylan604 4y agoWhat happens when you need to go out of town for an extended period? If it was just another ${X}aaS, you could temporarily suspend those plant instances and avoid the charges. Their work would be unused during that period anyway, so why pay for it? On-prem would still continue to accrue those charges. Also, what happens if you have your large extended family over for the holidays? Your on-prem plants would be unable to handle the load and start returning 504 type errors. With ${X}aaS you could just spin up a few more instances or even upgrade to larger instance types. Once the family holiday nightmare is over, you just spin them down again.
- SapporoChris 4y agoThere's no information that I could find about the rate of removing volatile organic compounds. I suspect adequate ventilation along with normal filter system to remove particulate matter is still the best bet. Of course, the first step regarding volatile organic compounds would be to test using an air quality monitor that can detect VOCs to see if you actually have a problem.
- vasco 4y agoI really doubt a passive plant can get even close to an active air purifier machine with HEPA filters. This sounds like it'll do great with the "but it's natural" crowd though.
- cinntaile 4y agoThey're not claiming it does either. They're claiming their engineered plant cleans the air like 30 normal plants.
- eachro 4y agowhat's the tradeoff here? what are the downsides of these superplants?
- Nathanael_M 4y agoI would assume functionality. To me this reads as a funding round to kickstart further development. I want some numbers, because my initial assumption is that 30x a regular plant is still essentially zero overall impact. The longterm goal would be to breed a plant that has 300x or 3000x effectiveness. I don't see anything wrong with this, by the way. Prototypes funding future success is an effective business model. I just suspect that this prototype doesn't really do anything other than present exciting possibilities for the future in a really nice package.
- googlryas 4y agoBetter than nothing, but the level that plants "clean the air" is entirely negligible. Every time you open the door, enough air enters your house where you would need to dedicate an entire room of plants for multiple days to clean that air. Just get a filter that can filter VOCs if you have that kind of concern. And then add plants as you wish to make you happy.
- dinvlad 4y agoI wonder how that compares just to some baggies with activated carbon.
- jrockway 4y agoGet a fan and a furnace filter and you have a top-of-the-line air purifier.
- silisili 4y agoThey are generally cheap enough now that it's probably not worth the effort. I think my last 2 cost 35 a piece, and came with extra filters and such. I used to think they were kinda useless until I had tile ripped up. The neverending dust was driving my wife insane. On a whim, bought a couple purifiers and it's cut the dust down by at least 90%.
- thecoppinger 4y agoAny chance you could provide a link to an example product? Air purifiers seem pretty expensive, but I expect that might be due to my location
- silisili 4y agoI bought these for 34.99 last month, but it appears to be gone now. https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B01N4IRIWK https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B01N4IRIWK If you're looking for more features and a more known brand, Costco has these for 99, which is a pretty good deal considering their size and that they come with all extra filters. https://www.costco.com/winix-true-hepa-4-stage-air-purifier-with-wi-fi-and-additional-filter.product.100662892.html https://www.costco.com/winix-true-hepa-4-stage-air-purifier-...
- driverdan 4y agoVOCs shouldn't be found in significant amounts in any home. If you do have VOCs you need to do something about it, not get an overpriced plant.
- jonahbenton 4y agoWill mention another product of this ilk- that I own and am very happy with, full disclosure- called AlgenAir Aerium https://algenair.com/products/the-aerium-3-0?variant=42491936374938 https://algenair.com/products/the-aerium-3-0?variant=4249193... Their algae is also claimed to be as effective as 25 regular plants. In reality, to have a noticeable/measurable impact on indoor air quality (specifically CO2), these products would still need to improve in absorbtion rates well beyond the 30x- probably to about 3000x. However, I like the Aerium for its visual and auditory qualities, irrespective of inefficient CO2 consumption. And real plants of course are also pleasing to many people. I have hopes that through genetic and other engineering products like the Pothos and the Aerium can get that 100-fold improvement over the next 10 years.
- fbdab103 4y agoThat does look attractive, but getting some sticker shock at $225 initial + monthly installments. I could just as easily buy and kill several $5-$10 plants from Home Depot on a monthly basis. At least then I would get some variety.
- jonahbenton 4y agoYup, it's definitely a luxury good. But it's like a living lava lamp, but with water bubble sound. Really enjoy it.
- Nathanael_M 4y agoI would love to see some numbers and comparisons. As I said in a reply below, I suspect this is functionally ineffectual and that 30x the air cleaning of a regular plant is like saying 30x the intelligence of a regular plant. I suspect this is functioning as a shiny, attractive prototype to fund further research to develop a 300x or 3000x plant or something in that neighbourhood. No judgment from me for that, prototype funding a bigger plan is a cool business model. I'd just love to get some absolute data. EDIT: Reading a little bit about the NASA plant study[0] that I saw in the comments below. It says that it determined that you'd need 10-1000 plants per square meter (I don't understand this measurement? Wouldn't it be cubic meter?) to get the equivalent of outdoor-indoor air exchange. That's a really wide range, but does this mean you'd need 0.33...-33.33... of these neoplants to have the same impact? That's a lot of plants, but another 10x or 100x and you're actually getting somewhere in the range of reasonable. Counterpoint, I don't know what I'm talking about. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_Clean_Air_Study https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_Clean_Air_Study
- bilsbie 4y agoI thought I saw snake plants could do way better than that.
- agilob 4y agoIn real life snake plant wins, because it's the easier in maintenance. A common saying about it is "it thrives on neglect". I propagate them (have about 120 at my home right now, I even produced my own hybrid that's almost completely yellow) and give as gifts to many people, those who never had plants before and those who go for 2 months long holidays, so far no reports of any dead one. It's resistant to drought and overwatering, nothing bad happens when it has too much sunlight or not enough. Having 10 of them at home is work free, stress free compared to having 1 peace lily or other dracaenas.
- Nathanael_M 4y agoYou produced your own snake plant hybrid... That's got to be one of the most fascinating conversation starters I've ever heard. Do you think there's any merit in this concept of air cleaning super plants?
- esilverman 4y agofeeeeeeed me seymour
- Maursault 4y ago$179?! What's the performance compared to $25 worth of furnace filter taped to box fan?
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoI wonder if anyone remembers an old experiment they did with houseplants and removing VOCs. They did the experiment right and had one plant have all leaves removed and it removed as much or more as the plant. The source of VOC removal? The potting soil and the life within. That's my memory of it.
- tripletao 4y agoThis is why regulation of GMOs needs to be structured in terms of risk/benefit instead of safety alone. I absolutely support genetic modification of major calorie crops, and I think there's a strong case that the environmental risk from such modifications is smaller than the risk of alternative paths (spray more chemical pesticides, clear more land, etc.) to achieve the same total yields. The benefit here is very close to zero, though; one wild-type pothos won't affect indoor air quality in any way known to be significant to human health, and neither will thirty. We've already got escaped transgenic GloFish in Brazilian streams; those haven't caused any significant harm yet, but I'd rather we stopped rolling the dice before something does.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoNow do it with trees.
- jordemort 4y agoPothos is very easy to propagate in water. I bought one from Home Depot several years ago and now my office features 12 of them, all cut from the same plant (some are even second-generation clones)
- deegles 4y agoIn 2019 I emailed a professor at UW working on a similar project asking for a cutting of their genetically engineered pothos but they said they couldn't send me one because they were still looking for partners for regulatory approval and commercialization. Glad to see someone did it!
- lob_it 4y agoWhere is the talk about adding small-scale hydrogen electrolysis with 21st century new construction to increase oxygen rates in inhabital areas inside a residence? https://www.epa.gov/indoor-air-quality-iaq/introduction-indoor-air-quality https://www.epa.gov/indoor-air-quality-iaq/introduction-indo... The pollutant sources section identifies many everyday components in a residence. It is something similar to 98% of the population in the states having PFOA in thier blood in a 1998 study. https://www.webmd.com/food-recipes/is-teflon-coating-safe https://www.webmd.com/food-recipes/is-teflon-coating-safe I agree with many of the comments about the limited performance of passive plants to effectively remove contaminants with indoor air pollution. It looks like an estimate of 3.2 million people succumb to indoor air pollution annually on a global scale with lifestyle choices (or the lack of choice). https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/household-air-pollution-and-health https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/household-a... Environmental factors may actually make superplants a resonable addition for wellbeing (placebo effect), but lifestyle choices make inventorying 20th century convenience items and amenities part of a healthy spring cleaning routine (with updated information).
- syspec 4y ago…in mice! Oh wait nevermind.
- WillAdams 4y agoThere is a book on this: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/308235.How_to_Grow_Fresh_Air https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/308235.How_to_Grow_Fresh...
- thesausageking 4y agoI watched an interesting TED talk years ago on cleaning indoor air with plants[0]. After digging into the study and understanding the numbers, it was humbling how little each plant on its own does. You basically needed to fill every square inch of floor space with plants in a normal office for it to have a noticeable impact. Bringing in outside air via the HVAC system was many times more cost efficient and effective. [0] https://www.ted.com/talks/kamal_meattle_how_to_grow_fresh_air https://www.ted.com/talks/kamal_meattle_how_to_grow_fresh_ai...
- bamboozled 4y agoWhich is why we need to be preserving the biosphere like our life depends on it. Because if we don't have that, if we don't have a lot of plants and trees, we're in a lot of strife.
- okonomiyaki3000 4y agoDon't you see what these plants are capable of? You put one in your house and it cleans your air... but then, the plant makes the air cleaner and keeps on making it more clean... Can you imagine it? What would it be like for your air to be way, way too clean? I'll tell you something: you don't want to know and I don't know.
- theptip 4y agoAnyone got a recommendation for a VOC meter that is reputable/known-good and not super expensive? Would be interesting to calibrate need for this, and the effect of normal plants, as a comparison.
- platz 4y agohttps://www.amazon.com/dp/B09T643TQ8 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09T643TQ8
- daleswanson 4y agoIf you're ok with a bit of DIY, I recently got some Qwiic I2C sensors combined with an ESP32 running ESPHome. The Qwiic connectors made the hardware part really plug and play. I have SGP40 for VOC - https://www.adafruit.com/product/4829 https://www.adafruit.com/product/4829 For True CO2 I have a SCD40 - https://www.adafruit.com/product/5187 https://www.adafruit.com/product/5187 For dust I have a PMSA003I - https://www.adafruit.com/product/4632 https://www.adafruit.com/product/4632 You can buy 1 of these, and add the other if/when you want to measure something else. This is an ESP32, although I don't have this exact one - https://www.adafruit.com/product/5337 https://www.adafruit.com/product/5337 And then ESPHome - https://esphome.io/ https://esphome.io/ ESPHome publishes the data on MQTT, which I then read in Home Assistant.
- kjkjadksj 4y agoIts probably even more efficient to utilize a regular plant where you get some secondary use from that biomass you’ve been cultivating