7 ms·
A local "green" grocery store replaced its plastic hot bar containers with compostable cardboard containers. But when I looked at the maker of those containers
by pfdietz 4y ago
A local "green" grocery store replaced its plastic hot bar containers with compostable cardboard containers.
But when I looked at the maker of those containers, and dug a bit, I discovered they used polyfluorinated alkanoates (PFAs) to keep the hot greasy liquids from soaking into the cardboard.
Compost these things and you'll get fluorinated forever chemicals in your garden.
- RetpolineDrama 4y agoI give it another 20 years before people rediscover the milkman model
- pfdietz 4y agoI'd be fine with plastics, separated from the trash stream and sent to a big petrochemical plant to be thermally decomposed into a petrochemical feedstock. It would make a lot more sense than pretending plastic bottles can be directly turned into more bottles. When oil stops being a thing and carbon becomes scarce for making stuff I think this will make sense to do. Until then, let's just make piles of the old plastic so they can conveniently mine it then.
- braveyellowtoad 4y agoLove your thinking. Rather than comingle the plastics with waste, let's keep them separate at the landfill for use when future humans figure out what to do with it. By mixing it all together we just make it much more difficult for ourselves later.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> when future humans figure out what to do with it I'm not keen on models that include: "Let our grandchildren solve the problem". I have grandchildren.
- pfdietz 4y agoBut sometimes just waiting and letting someone else deal with it is the right solution. For example: spent nuclear fuel.
- denton-scratch 4y agoI don't agree with you. Or rather, I agree with "just waiting" - we don't have any choice about that. I don't agree with "letting someone else deal with it". The spent waste we've already produced needs to be stored in a way that puts it beyond the possibility of access within 200,000 years. And we need to stop producing new nuclear waste. Note that modern humans have been walking the Earth for just 200,000 years; we can't hope to be able to label it with readable danger warnings. The oldest languages we can read are only a few thousand years old. And we can't just pop it into orbit - there are many thousands of tons of it, sitting around in cooling ponds.
- pfdietz 4y agoWell, unless we become immortal, waiting long enough means letting someone else deal with problems. Right now, the obviously (and I do mean that) best way to deal with spent nuclear fuel is (after some cooling) to stick it in dry casks and just let it sit there. It's much cheaper than the alternatives, it's quite safe, and it doesn't preclude any other solution. But (you might say) we're leaving the cost of dealing with it to our descendants. I respond: we leave the consequences of all our actions to our descendants. For example, if we spend resources of doing something to nuclear waste, we do not do something else with those resources that might have been better for our descendants. Economics is all about tradeoffs; you can't just look at anything in isolation. Delaying dealing with a problem also means that those who ultimately solve it can choose the solution they prefer, rather than one we impose on them. Maybe they'll want to extract plutonium. Maybe they'll want to bury the fuel unchanged. Maybe they'll want to shoot it into space. They will know better which solution is best for them. This question is mostly orthogonal to the question of whether more waste should be made (except if you're trying to use the waste issue as a bludgeon to force the other issue.) I get the distinct impression the waste problem is being greatly overstated for rhetorical reasons.
- cycomanic 4y agoThat model has made a comeback several years back. I have friends who get vegetables delivered in wooden crates every week and return the crate at the next pickup. At a supermarket where my parents live, you can't get meat and cheese wrapped in plastic but have to get a container (admittedly a plastic one) that you then can bring every time.
- happymellon 4y agoA plastic container that you use more than once already halves your plastic consumption.
- namdnay 4y agoDepends on how thick the plastic is and how many times you reuse it. I’m guessing you have to reuse a Tupperware a good 100 times before you’ve saved vs Saran Wrap (Of course the Tupperware has other advantages)
- pixl97 4y agoInteresting you're getting downvoted for something that is absolutely true. Thin film plastics are exceedingly efficient. When you add in secondary energy effects like adding soap and water for cleaning the reused packaging, and 3rd order effects like food borne illness when you fail to do so properly, the plastic wins the energy game every time. The discussion goes in to debates over energy use versus litter at that point.
- happymellon 4y agoI normally use my Tupperware about 100 times or so. And while I completely agree, I not sure if lots of thin is better or worse than one thick even if it ended up being used relatively the same compared to thickness.
- xdfgh1112 4y agoOr the pfand model which Germany still uses today.
- shapefrog 4y agoStill have a milkman. Takes the empty glass bottles off the front steps and replaces them with full ones. Even had an electric "milk float" up until a few years ago. Its like he reimagined and modernised Hello Fresh or Just Eat.
- pmontra 4y agoSupermarkets were buying back empty glass bottles in Italy in the 70s so people didn't send them to a landfill anymore. My parents handed bottles to a clerk at a desk, got some coins, then we started shopping. Then plastic bottles took over the world.
- badpun 4y agoStill works for beer (at least in Poland), as people don't want to drink beer out of plastic or even metal containers.
- OJFord 4y agoIn the UK I sometimes see mention of this scheme on the backs of bottles, but it's denominated in cence (which we don't have) and is for Australia & New Zealand only. We can recycle them at home of course (though I was surprised to learn not everywhere! It's up to the council! Wandsworth borough of London has no recycling for many flats, unless the landlord cares to provide something) - but not in a supermarket or anywhere for cash incentive.
- scruple 4y agoA grocer near me (California) still operates this way for certain items. My wife and I go there for cream and milk from a nearby dairy and there's a $1 (I don't remember the exact value, it may be $2 or even $3) deposit on the bottle. Bring the (clean) bottle back and you can swap it for a new bottle or get your deposit back.
- OJFord 4y agoI'm sure there's a local milkman you could sign up to, but you'd probably find it's 'just' delivery of 'normal' plastic bottles. (Perhaps with a more expensive glass option, or a premium option that happens to be in glass.)
- youngtaff 4y agoOur local milkman (UK) still uses glass bottles
- debesyla 4y agoOr just plastic, metal and glass bottles/cans deposit like in Lithuania. You pay 10 euro cents extra when buying, and get it back after depositing the bottles/cans at local taromat. If someone is trashy and throws bottle to dumpsters, at least they already paid for their damage.
- Spooky23 4y agoI’m lucky - we have a milkman. It’s great and our milk comes from a local farm. The cost is about 40% more, but it magically shows up in the milk box every Monday and Thursday.
- interestica 4y agoOntario's beer bottle model is basically this. And it works really well.
- empyrrhicist 4y agoGood god, that has to be some kind of crime.
- pvarangot 4y agoI think it's the difference between compostable and "compostable in an industrial facility".
- Arbortheus 4y agoFluoridated forever chemicals can’t be composted in any scenario.
- pfdietz 4y agoThere must (?) be some microorganisms that can break down C-F bonds, because there are organisms that naturally create C-F bonds. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dichapetalum_cymosum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dichapetalum_cymosum https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/B9780123942913000034 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/B97801...
- Gigachad 4y agoIt’s not because that’s how all paper products are waterproofed.
- hgomersall 4y agoNo, often a PLA lining is used e.g. https://www.vegware.com/uk-en/catalogue/single_wall_cups/ https://www.vegware.com/uk-en/catalogue/single_wall_cups/
- lettergram 4y agoI’ve just installed a reverse osmosis system and full-house filter after discovering fairly high levels PFAs, Bromodichloromethane, and chloroform in my water after a test. I didn’t realize moving here how bad it was, but the testing company said it probably wasn’t safe to bathe in lol. All these chemicals leech into the water from various factories and farms. I imagine dumps have a similar issue. In terms of the environment I’m far FAR more concerned about this than climate change. It’s an imminent risk. I personally switched to glass containers for storage of food and water. I also use cast iron for my food, non-stick has a lot of chemicals. It’s slightly less convenient, but easy enough. I also get satisfaction from the cast iron and regularly bake steak and what not.
- zamfi 4y ago> discovering fairly high levels PFAs, Bromodichloromethane, and chloroform in my water after a test Out of curiosity, how did you have these tested?
- lettergram 4y agoThere are lots of companies that’ll test water for you. I picked two, one test was on Amazon (was like $300 for all the trace chemicals). Then I selected another test I found online. Both came to the same basic conclusion so I trusted the results.
- pixl97 4y agoHmm, some group needs to come together to crowdfund a series of tests by these companies versus a laboratory test to ensure we don't have a 'Everybody hosts on AWS' problem where all these tests actually go back to one or two labs across the entire nation.
- lettergram 4y agoThe way it works is that the NSF (and other groups) certifies labs then you can go to them. Mine had the results of two different labs. I’m sure they could be cheating in some way, but seemed legit enough
- jazzyjackson 4y agoSimilarly I was very dissapointed to find paper coffee cups are almost always lined with plastic. In hindsight it's obvious that paper is not going to hold boiling water, but I dunno, I'm not a paper cup engineer, I guess I thought someone figured it out. Of course I've been tossing the paper cup in the recycling this whole time, which is fine, since it all ends up in the landfill anyway.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoWhat about wax linings?
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoThat is the issue, all of this always comes down to cost and volume... and convenience. Beeswax is perfectly acceptable but it costs more and I don't have the numbers but there is probably not enough bees in the world for all those starbucks cups. The unpleasant truth that nobody wants to hear is that the only way to solve this is to ban all these disposables and use ceramic cups in the cafe or bring your own flask. Everybody is an environmentalist until the environmental policy bothers their sense of convenience.
- taberiand 4y agoThere was a brief push for "keep cups" that seemed to have growing momentum ~2019, but that came to a halt with COVID and it seems isn't coming back any time soon. I think the fundamental problem is plastic is cheap and companies have zero need to factor in the environmental costs. It's pointless to blame the consumer for buying something that they can afford, these products that do terrible damage to the environment need to be made unaffordable through taxes on the companies producing them.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoIndeed perhaps my wording wasn't explicit but by "ban these disposables" I meant ban/regulate them out of the market through governmental policy. Consumer sentiment alone will never make a significant impact.
- autoexec 4y ago> Compost these things and you'll get fluorinated forever chemicals in your garden. It's already there (https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-62391069 https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-62391069). It's still not a good idea to compost that stuff and spread it around near you or on your veggies.
- titzer 4y agoYeah, most stuff that is marked as compostable should be treated with suspicion. I only compost organic food waste, no wrappers or containers, no matter how they are marked. We have decent recycling where I live, so all cardboard, paper, metal, and plastic just goes in the bin. TBH the biggest benefit from composting food waste (vs throwing away) is that my garbage bin doesn't smell.