4 ms·
Miguel de Icaza works for Microsoft, and Microsoft has extended Mono developers a patent license for all relevant C#/.NET patents,... Except, said patent grant
by DiabloD3 15y ago
Miguel de Icaza works for Microsoft, and Microsoft has extended Mono developers a patent license for all relevant C#/.NET patents,...
Except, said patent grant does not extend to people who don't work for de Icaza, people who distribute Mono, or people who use Mono, or people who have compiled C# apps with Mono.
Microsoft refuses to make Mono patent free, and anyone who distributes, uses, or distributes binaries compiled with Mono _can and will be sued_.
Not only is de Icaza not a competitor to Microsoft, he is helping Microsoft attack Linux and the Free Software movement.
Mono refuses to switch to a license, such as GPLv3, to protect users, distributors, and developers from the patents; not only do they refuse, they are getting rid of all GPLv2 code in favor of BSD code. Once Mono is BSDafied, Microsoft can import all code from Mono and close source it within the main C#/.Net implementation on Windows.
- teyc 15y agoYou are reading too much into events. MS likes Miguel because he brings some open source respectability to the NET platform. It is also a potential source of licensing revenue stream in the future. MS has no reason to want someone else's implementation of the CLR and VM.
- DiabloD3 15y agoMono's VM executes C# bytecode faster than Microsoft's, and Mono's C# compiler produces better bytecode than Microsoft's. So, yeah, Microsoft is very interested in trying to make their core product faster so they can catch up to other solutions such as native code (C/C++) or Java (C# is still typically much slower than Java). Oh, and Mono can also compile to AoT binaries, which do not require Mono/.Net installed on the target system, such as being able to target iOS under Apple's anti-VM policy. Microsoft is very interested in all of these.
- jahewson 15y agoComplete nonsense: - Microsoft's CLR is vastly more sophisticated than Mono, involving millions of man-hours work, unless you show me a benchmark I have absolutely no reason to believe it executes bytecode faster, especially given that Microsoft Research publish papers on fast JIT [1]. - Mono still doesn't have a stable generational GC [2], I hope you like memory leaks and long pauses. - .NET can compile AoT binaries, and does this for all built-in libraries using ngen [3] In conclusion: Microsoft have no interest in any of Mono's technologies. [1] http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/projects/spur/ http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/projects/spur/ [2] http://mono-project.com/Generational_GC http://mono-project.com/Generational_GC [3] http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/6t9t5wcf(v=vs.71).aspx http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/6t9t5wcf(v=vs.71).as...
- iam 15y agoNgen still requires the CLR to be present though.
- rodrigokumpera 15y agoFew things to notice here. Mono's new gc is quite solid now. Mono for Android customers use it by default. Yes, performance is not the best nor does it support a concurrent mode. But a garbage collector is one of those projects that is never done and always have an infinite amount of work left. Our gc has been improving a lot and the next release, for example, features a lot of scalability and performance work. Said that, if you compare it to other gcs offered on mobile environment we're doing very well. Mono features a much simpler JIT and runtime and this is a competitive advantage for us or do you think MS ships its desktop/server VM on winphone? We do, and it has teached us a lot about how been slim and simple makes you much more adaptable. Now on the subject of AOT, mono features a much more sofisticated system than .net, it's the only one that supports running without a JIT while retaining generics. BTW, I work for Xamarin but those are my personal opinions on the matter.
- jstedfast 15y agoHey, Xamarin dev here... Not that I want to defend Diablo-D3 (he's a troll), I do want to make a few slight corrections to your comment. 1. You are correct in that Microsoft's .NET VM performs better than Mono overall (at least in the general case), but Mono does perform better than .NET in some cases. Unfortunately I don't have a list of the areas where Mono outperforms .NET handy, so I can't list them here. Perhaps one of the other Mono devs can follow up and provide details. Most likely SIMD would be on the list. Whether Microsoft would be interested in taking Mono's implementation for these areas or not for their own VM is questionable. Likely not, as it would likely not be easily adaptable to their implementation anyway. 2. SGen is actually stable these days. It is used in Mono4Android and we are working on moving MonoTouch over to SGen as well. Moonlight was also being moved to SGen (it started out using Boehm because that was the default GC when the project was started) when the Novell layoffs came along. As responsible developers, we have been taking our time moving to SGen as the default GC because we don't want the move to break any existing apps if we can avoid it. As with all new things, there are still likely to be bugs here and there, but overall we feel that it is ready for use and we've been eating our own dog food. 3. As was mentioned in another comment already, Microsoft's AOT isn't quite the same as Mono's AOT which allows generation of binaries that do not require an external CLR to run.
- MichaelGG 15y agoMicrosoft is very interested in AoT binaries that don't require a runtime installed? Microsoft has specifically said they have no plans to pursue this path, even though they could obviously do so. The reasons was that they didn't want to deal with patching all these programs that had the runtime embedded in them. I found that sort of a weak argument; they probably just wanted to get higher penetration numbers.
- teyc 15y agoHave you even tried to submit a patch to Microsoft for one of their Microsoft Shared-Source projects (there is a list here: http://www.microsoft.com/resources/sharedsource/default.mspx http://www.microsoft.com/resources/sharedsource/default.mspx ), ? It is near impossible to get MS to accept them. They will give away code, but paranoid about taking contributions.
- xradionut 15y agoIf you don't want to be mistaken for a rabid OSS zealot, you should be more knowledgable about Mono's license(s) and not fling RMS-poo around. http://www.mono-project.com/License http://www.mono-project.com/License The fact that C# programmers can code for multiple platforms thru easier porting makes them more likely to explore OSS options instead of staying solely in Redmonds garden.
- DiabloD3 15y agoI see no patent grant that protects users, distributors, or non-Mono/Microsoft developers. So, again, how does that license protect open source? It is neither GPLv3 or ASLv2, nor will Microsoft stop using patents to attack people. I'm not sure how I can interpret it any other way. Being sued by Microsoft is something no one wants.
- JonoW 15y agoHow is that different from any other OSS project? If MS wants, they could look at a projects source code and decide that they've violated a patent and sue them. To my knowledge they're yet to do this.
- makomk 15y agoThe difference is that Microsoft created .Net and the patents covering it together, so they're fairly narrow patents and it'd be a hell of a lot harder to find relevant prior art to use against them. (The same's true of OOXML, incidentally; Microsoft even tried to get a patent covering both it and ODF but the examiner narrowed it to just OOXML based on a huge amount of prior art dating back to SGML in the 80s.)
- jstedfast 15y agoWe don't own any patents on Mono, so licensing it under GPLv3 would not provide any additional patent protection to anyone. That said, the code donated by Microsoft has been under Apache2 which does provide patent protection, just like GPLv3.
- j23tom 15y ago"Miguel de Icaza works for Microsoft" FALSE " Microsoft has extended Mono developers a patent license for all relevant C#/.NET patents" FALSE "anyone who distributes, uses, or distributes binaries compiled with Mono _can and will be sued_." evidence ? IMHO Java is not so safe either -> Oracle already sued Google for java With mono you can: 1. move apps made with best tooling on the market (VS + resharper) to a cheaper servers (linux) 2. Make multiplatform mobile apps easy (ios, android) 3. Create linux gui apps easy (gtk-sharp)
- regala 15y agocould you pliz stop the bull*$#t ? thank you
- jstedfast 15y ago> not only do they refuse, they are getting rid of all GPLv2 code in favor of BSD code. This claim is completely fictitious. We started an effort a few years ago to migrate MonoDevelop code to LGPL and MIT/X11 (not BSD) from GPL. Our reason for doing so was to make it possible for third parties to write extensions (addins) to MonoDevelop and license it under whatever license they wanted, i.e. we did not want to force them to have to develop their addins and license them under GPL if they didn't want to. It was not some big conspiracy to prepare for some Microsoft takeover or anything.