3 ms·
What a bizarre post. I haven't come to a definitive conclusion on the subject, but "how can I help a trillion-dollar organization?" is very far from my first t
by mixmastamyk 4y ago
What a bizarre post. I haven't come to a definitive conclusion on the subject, but "how can I help a trillion-dollar organization?" is very far from my first thought on it. Is this a service folks have become dependent on?
- bugfix-66 4y agoIt boggles the mind. I was also in disbelief when I saw this post.
- ThrowawayR2 4y agoYou do have to admit that it is Microsoft (and the other vendors of similar CoPilot-like services) that are on the side of "Information wants to be free!" this time. The irony of FOSS advocates reversing course on their own principles to oppose it is deep indeed.
- bugfix-66 4y agoYou can't take a person's name off their work and sell it. People who work hard to produce open source software expect credit and acknowledgement for their work. That's why almost every license has an attribution clause. If you don't want credit for your work, you use the MIT No Attribution License: https://opensource.org/licenses/MIT-0 https://opensource.org/licenses/MIT-0 Not widely used, as you might expect.
- ThrowawayR2 4y agoSuch a short-sighted view. The grand goal of FOSS was the abolition of copyright protection for code and and the end of proprietary software, was it not? Credit and acknowledgment doesn't even figure into it. What is a ML model that has knowledge of huge swaths of humanity's code (eventually all of it) and can serve as an assistant to build any kind of software on demand if not a huge milestone on the road to the total software freedom envisioned by RMS and GNU? People will be able to build whatever software they want, easily and at any time, and whatever the code they finally wind up with will even feed back into making the ML model even better for the future. One could still build closed source software or harp about "credit" but why bother? The ML model would replicate anything with a modest bit of effort. It might not have been the path to end-user freedom that the early FOSS proponents imagined but, if it works, that's victory.
- Eleison23 4y agoNo, that was not the grand goal by any stretch of the imagination. "Copyleft" protections depend on copyright protections. The reason the GNU GPL can be viral is because the license is preserved from one instance of the code to the next. If credit is not being given, then how can the GPL survive and perpetuate its virality? RMS wanted software to "be free, like air". Free software is not gained by putting it into proprietary code without licensing it. Free software is not served by filing off the serial numbers and scattering it to the four winds. The writers of free software should be given credit and they also deserve to earn a living from writing it, if they so desire. CoPilot threatens to rob them of that livelihood by side-stepping IP protections.
- imtringued 4y ago> The ML model would replicate anything with a modest bit of effort. Yeah, by stealing it. Last time someone wrote a comment on HN on this topic he insulted a library author and said something like "you are just bitter that eventually this AI software will be able to write your opensource library based on the GitHub description alone" Well, of course it does, it can just literally search through GitHub and produce a verbatim copy.
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 4y agoNo, one does not, in fact, have to admit that. Your statement represents an opinion.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- imtringued 4y agoYou mean they want to abolish intellectual property by allowing proprietary code fed through the AI to be stripped of copyright? Because that would be the end of copyright.
- warning26 4y agoYou need to think bigger — if the class action wins, it effectively would ban training AI classifiers on internet data. Yes, we all want to stick it to Microsoft, but that’s not what’s at stake here.
- t-3 4y agoAI research companies can't be bothered to ethically source data so everyone else should just shut up and take it? It's not like the lawsuit can stop independent researchers from using whatever data they like, but putting the fear of the judge into big AI corps is a good thing.
- im3w1l 4y agoIf this class action wins then it means we can put license restrictions on AI-training. "You may use this code to train an AI model as long as you release the weights under AIGPL, and any work substantially derived from the AI output is also released under AIGPL" If the class action loses then this will not be possible.
- quickthrower2 4y agoInternet data? Copyright, licenses like GPL MIT etc. mean nothing if it is just all “internet data”.
- warning26 4y agoWhatever happened to “information wants to be free”? There is a post on the front page right now about how it’s totally okay to post copyrighted books online.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoIt's almost like different folks have different opinions right?
- quickthrower2 4y agoI think “information wants to be free” is more of an observation than legal or ethical stance. Even as an ethical stance where it might be interpreted as “DRM bad” I am not sure it also means “pirating good”.