3 ms·
If the Brian is using some physics we don’t understand that’s something new not Quantum Mechanics. QM a specific theory of how the world operates, if something
by Retric 4y ago
If the Brian is using some physics we don’t understand that’s something new not Quantum Mechanics. QM a specific theory of how the world operates, if something else is involved it doesn’t fall under that theory it’s [insert new theory’s name here].
I really don’t get why everyone wants the Brian to operate on some new QM effect other than peoples perception that a 100 year old theory is somehow cutting edge, spooky, or something. Perhaps it’s that the overwhelming majority of people who talk about QM don’t actually understand it even a little bit. Odd bits of QM are already why lasers, LED’s, and transistors work. You use incites from the theory everyday in most electronic devices, but it’s just as relevant for explaining old incandescent bulbs we just had other theories that seemed to explain them.
- RosanaAnaDana 4y agoMy understanding of the hypothesis being represented here is QM as a kind of random number generator operating at the neuron/microtubule level. I didn't think there was anything other than a modest injection of randomness being invoked, but I could be misstating the premise.
- crowbahr 4y agoIt's an absurd premise to begin with: The scale at which quantum effects propagate and are observed is radically different than the scale at which the neurons in your brain operate. The functional channels for neurons are well understood, even if we're still diagramming out all the types of neurons. Voltage gated calcium channels are pretty damn simple in the grand scheme of things, and they don't leave space for quantum interactions beyond that of standard molecular interactions. The only part of the brain we don't understand is how all the intricacies work together, because that's a lot more opaque.
- dekhn 4y agoI think you're probably missing a number of the important details. In the Penrose/Hammerof model, they're explicitly saying that humans are observed to generate problem solutions that could not have been generated by a purely classical computing process, therefore, the brain must exploit some specific quantum phenomenon. When you talk about QM a a theory of how the world operates, there are wide ranges of QM. Everything from predicting the structure and energy states of a molecule, to how P/N junctions work, to quantum computers. Now, for the first one (molecules), the vast majority of QM is just giving ways to compute the electron density and internuclear distances using some fairly straightforward and noncontroversial approaches. For the other ones (P/N junctions, QC computers, etc), those involve exploiting very specific and surprising aspects of quantum theory: one of quantum tunnelling, quantum coherence, or quantum entanglement (ordered from least counterintuitive to most). We have some evidence already that there are some biological processes that exploit tunnelling and coherence, but none that demonstrate entanglement. Personally, I think most people think the alternative to Penrose- the brain does not compute non-computable functions, and does not exploit or need to exploit any quantum phenomena (expect perhaps tunnelling) to achieve its goals. Now, if we were to have hard evidence supporting the idea that brains use entanglement to solve problems: well, that would be pretty amazing and would upend large parts of modern biology adn technology research.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- russdill 4y agoThe set of problems that are computable by a classical computer are the same set of problems computable by a quantum computer. I think you might be misstating the Penrose argument/position.
- dekhn 4y agoI'm fairly certain I'm giving a passable description of what Penrose claims in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emperor%27s_New_Mind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emperor%27s_New_Mind and and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadows_of_the_Mind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadows_of_the_Mind I should have said "problems which do not have computable solutions" rather than "set of problems computable by a quantum computer", which seems fairly pedestrian compared to what Penrose is saying.
- Retric 4y agoThose mean very different things, which is why quantum mechanics wouldn’t work for him and he was arguing for new physics. As to the specifics, let’s just say there’s a reason he was publishing books rather than peer reviewed papers.
- Retric 4y agoThe Brian using entanglement would completely destroy modern physics as we know it, the effect on biology would be tiny by comparison. Your other points are based on such fundamental misunderstanding that it’s hard to respond. Saying something isn’t the output of classical computing processes while undemonstrated, is then used to justify saying they must therefore use Quantum Phenomenon. But logically not everything that is either classical or Quantum so even that logical inference is unjustified. Logically it’s like saying well it’s not a soda so it must be a rock. PS: If people where observed to solve problems that can’t be solved by classical computer processing that would be a really big deal. As in show up on Nightly News, and win people Nobel prizes big. Needless to say it hasn’t happened.