10 ms·
Reading these threads on twitter is like listening to a friend having a bad mdma trip replaying his whole emotional life to you in a semi incoherent diarrhea li
by lm28469 4y ago
Reading these threads on twitter is like listening to a friend having a bad mdma trip replaying his whole emotional life to you in a semi incoherent diarrhea like stream of thoughts
Please write a book, or at the very least an article... posting on twitter is like writing something on a piece of paper, showing it to your best friend and worst enemy before throwing it in the trash
- sorum 4y agoHe inadvertently invented the Twitter mid-roll ad and we're all doomed now because of it
- pc86 4y agoThese things seem to be fine when it's 5-6 tweets in a coherent thread. There's even that guy who regularly multi-thousand-word threads that are almost always a good read. This thread in particular is really bad.
- bongobingo1 4y agonitter.net has a vaguely more readable view, not good but better. https://nitter.net/yishan/status/1586955288061452289 https://nitter.net/yishan/status/1586955288061452289
- dynm 4y agoJust realized there are extensions that will auto-redirect all twitter links to nitter. Why didn't I do this year ago!?
- foobarbecue 4y agohttps://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1586955288061452289.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1586955288061452289.html Agreed, though, Twitter threads are a really poor communications medium.
- madsmith 4y agoThis thread was a delightful read. Just NOT in twitter. I gave up on twitter and signed out of it years ago and refuse to sign back in. I spent a good hour of my life looking for ways to read this thread. I personally know Yishan and value the opinions he cares to share so I new this would be interesting if I could just manage to read it. Replacing the url to nitter.net helped but honestly it was most cohesive in threadreaderapp although it missed some of the referenced sidebar discussions (like the appeal to Elon to not waste his mental energy on things that aren’t real atom problems).
- throw7 4y agoagreed, but you can go here as a workaround: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1586955288061452289.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1586955288061452289.html
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoIt is painful. I got about 11 posts in before giving up. You described it perfectly.
- danwee 4y agoI gave up after the 3rd tweet in the thread. I can't understand why Twitter threads are a thing.
- nfin 4y agomy guess is that people can like () individual posts. The positive of that is: a) possibility to like () just one post, or 2, 3… depending of who good the thread is b) the fine granular way to like () gives the algorithm way better possibilities to whom to show a thread and even better, to first show just one intereting post out of that thread (also people can mores easily quote or retweet individual parts of a thread)
- fknorangesite 4y agoOr retweet individual posts. It makes each one a possible pull-quote.
- jjulius 4y agoYep; everything's a soundbite.
- Akronymus 4y agoWhy are you adding () after "like"? Havent seen that convention before, so I am unaware of the meaning.
- peruvian 4y agoThing is no one's going to read a blog post that he would've linked to. As bad as they are, Twitter threads guarantee a way larger audience.
- heed 4y agoWhat got me was him weaving in (2-3 times) self promotion tweets of some tree planting company he funds/founded(?). He basically personally embedded ads into his thread, which is actually kind of smart I suppose, but very confusing as a reader.
- mikeryan 4y agoI didn’t even know he circled around back to the topic. I split when I got to “TREES!” and wondering “that’s it?” After this comment I went back to read the rest.
- pjc50 4y agoKind of genius to put it in the middle. Most normal people write a tweet that blows up and then have to append "Check out my soundcloud!" on the end. Or an advert for the nightsky lamp.
- toss1 4y agoAt the same time (as much as I strongly support climate efforts, and am impressed by his approach, so give him a pass in this instance), that 'genius move' sort of needs to be flagged as his [Category #1 - Spam], which should be moderated. It really is inserting off-topic info into another thread. The saving grace may be that both small enough volume and sufficiently interesting to his audience to be just below the threshold.
- 4y ago
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > Please don't complain about tangential annoyances—e.g. article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting.
- miiiiiike 4y agoIt was a massive stream of tweets, with two long digressions, and several embeds. The only thing that would have made it worse is if every tweet faded in on scroll. If we're going to pedantically point out rules, why don't we add one that says "No unrolled Twitter threads."?
- Karunamon 4y agoIt is not pedantic, it is people derailing possibly interesting discussion of the content with completely off-topic noise discussion of the presentation. If you do not like the presentation there are ways to change it.
- miiiiiike 4y agoIf people are constantly complaining about the same thing, the thing should be fixed. Then you'll have no more complaints about the thing or people complaining about complaints about the thing. I'm tackling world peace next.
- drewbeck 4y agoIf we’re going to pedantically point out rules why don’t we cook hamburgers on the roof of parliament? Or something else that isn’t pedantically point out rules?
- IshKebab 4y agoIt's not really a tangential annoyance. I literally couldn't read the post because of the insane format.
- polytely 4y agoI've never understood this, it's just reading: you start at the beginning of tweet, you read it, then go to the next tweet and read it. How is that different from reading paragraphs?
- lm28469 4y agoidk man Maybe we could put more Words in a single Please visit my new website and subscribe to my podcast Line so it would be More readable random user comment: yes you're right mark that would be better and much more user friendly _ insert latest Musk schizophrenic rant_ Ah and I forgot the "sign up to read the rest" pop up that seemingly appears at random interval
- polytely 4y agoare you reading on the computer? maybe thats the disconnect. for me each tweet has around 4 lines of text. so it reads more like the post you are reading now. where each tweet is a decent chunk of text. making the reading experience only marginally worse than reading something on hacker news.
- aniforprez 4y agoThe amount of UI noise around each tweet and how much you have to scroll, coupled with the need to trigger new loads once Twitter has truncated the number of replies and also HOW MUCH YOU HAVE TO SCROLL makes this a terrible experience I understand why people tweet rather than write blogs. Twitter gives more visibility and is a far lower barrier of entry than sitting down and writing an article or a blog. That Twitter hasn't solved this problem after years of people making long threads and this being a big way that people consume content on the platform is a failure on their part. Things like ThreadReader should be in-built and much easier to use. I think they acquired one of these thread reader apps too
- j33zusjuice 4y ago
- rideontime 4y agoBut the twitter thread makes it much easier to pivot into talking about his latest startup that's totally unrelated!
- fknorangesite 4y agoAt this point, posting this sentiment on HN is more boring and irritating than the tweet-thread format could ever be.
- bee_rider 4y agoIt is also specifically called out in the guidelines as not helpful.
- Karawebnetwork 4y agoImagine it is a text and you can mark any paragraph. You can save that paragraph, like it, or even reply to it. So the interaction can grow like tentacles (edit: or rather like a tree). Right now, I could make a comment on either your first or second paragraph, or on your entire comment. However, there is no way to determine which category my reply falls into until you have read it entirely. On a platform like Twitter, where there can be up to 100,000 comments on a given piece of content, this is very useful. Better yet, it allows the author himself to dig down into tangent. In theory, someone could create an account and then have all of their interactions stay on the same tree without ever cutting off. Essentially turning their account into an interconnected "wiki" where everyone can add information. With enough time your brain no longer registers the metadata around the tweet. If you ignore it and read it as an entire text it is not very different from a regular article or long form comment: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1586955288061452289.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1586955288061452289.html
- dingaling 4y agoI am imaging a normal long-form blog format but with comments collapsed after each paragraph as a compromise between the two current options.
- lm28469 4y agoWhat you're saying is that we should optimise the way we debate things to please the algorithm and maximise user engagement instead of maximising quality content and encouraging deep reflexions The truth is people can't focus for more than 15 seconds so instead of reading a well researched and deep article or book that might offer sources, nuances, &c. they'll click "like" and "retweet" whoever vomited something that remotely goes their way while ignoring the rest > If you ignore it and read it as an entire text it is not very different from a regular article or long form comment It is extremely different as each piece is written as a independent 10s thought ready to be consumed and retweeted. Reading it on threadreaderapp makes it even more obvious, your brain need to work 300% harder to process the semi incoherent flow, some blogs written by 15 years old are more coherent and pleasant to read than this btw this is what I see on your link, more ads: https://i.imgur.com/rhaXStj.png https://i.imgur.com/rhaXStj.png
- dariusj18 4y agoIt seems apt that the most engaged comment in the thread is a meta comment which derails any conversation about the content of the post itself.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoThe medium is the message.
- dariusj18 4y agoBut also an example of how moderation or lack therein would help to serve a particular end goal. ex. HackerNews is a pretty well moderated forum, however sometimes the content (PC being related to technology) is within the rules, but the behavior it elicited in the other users is detrimental to the overall experience.
- rakoo 4y agoThe post says that moderation is first and foremost a signal-to-noise curation. Writing long form content in a Twitter thread greatly reduces the signal-to-noise ratio.
- awb 4y agoWhat’s funny is he’s arguing that moderation should be based on behavior, not content. And that you could identify spam if it was written in Loren Ipsum. If this thread and self-referential Tweeting was written in Loren Ipsum, it would definitely look like spam to me. So I guess I disagree with one of the main points. For me, the content matters much more than the behavior. Pretty sure that’s how the Supreme Court interprets 1A rights as well. The frequency and intensity of the speech hasn’t played a part in any 1A cases that I can remember, it’s exclusively if the content of the speech violates someone’s rights and then deciding which outcome leads to bigger problems, allowing the speech or not.
- mbesto 4y agoAnd hilariously he starts with "How do you solve the content moderation problems on Twitter?" and never actually answer it. Just rambles on about a dissection of the problem. Guess we know now why content moderation was never "solved" at Reddit, nor will it ever be.
- ilyt 4y agoHe kinda did in roundabout way; the "perfect" moderation, even if possible, will turn it into nice and cultured place to have discussion and that doesn't bring controversy and sell ads. You would have way less media "journalists" making a fuss about what someone said on that social network and would have problems just getting it to be popular, let alone displace any of the big ones. It would maybe be possible with existing one but that's a ton of work and someone needs to pay for that work. And it's entirely possible for smaller community to have that, but the advantage with this is small community about X will also have moderators that care about X so * any on-topic bollocks can be spotted by mods and it is no longer "unknown language" * any off-topic bollocks can be just dismissed with "this is a forum about X, if you don't like it go somewhere else
- mbesto 4y ago> the "perfect" moderation, even if possible, will turn it into nice and cultured place to have discussion and that doesn't bring controversy and sell ads. That's not a solution though since every for profit business is generally seeking to maximize profit, and furthermore we already knew this to be the case - nothing he is saying is novel. I guess that's where I'm confused.
- ilyt 4y agoSure, to you might be not but you're not the audience he's talking to.
- Canada 4y agoIf only there was some site that was good for posting longer text, with a really good comment system to discuss it...
- drewbeck 4y agoThere’s a study to be done on the polarization around twitter threads. I have zero problem with them and find overall that lots of great ideas are posted in threads, and the best folks doing it end up with super cogent and well written pieces. I find it baffling how many folks are triggered by them and really hate them!
- rchaud 4y agoThis is likely because threads are a "high engagement" signal for Twitter and therefore prone to being gamed. There are courses teaching people how to game the Twitter algo. One of those took off significantly in the past 18 months. You can tell by the number of amateurs creating threads on topics far beyond their reach. The purpose of these threads is for it to show up on people's feeds under the "Topic" section. For example, I often see see random posts from "topics" Twitter thinks I like (webdev, UI/UX, cats, old newspaper headlines). I had to unsubscribe from 'webdev' and "UI/UX" because the recommended posts were all growth hackers. It wasn't always that way. I'm not the only one, others have commented on it as well, including a well known JS developer: https://twitter.com/wesbos/status/1587071684539973633 https://twitter.com/wesbos/status/1587071684539973633
- drewbeck 4y ago> This is likely because threads are a "high engagement" signal for Twitter and therefore prone to being gamed. You mean this is the reason folks respond differently to the form of twitter thread? This is one that is definitely not from a growth hacker but folks here still seem to hate it.
- rchaud 4y agoIf you want to talk diarrhea, look no further than those "save to Readwise / Notion / Pocket" comments that pollute most of these long threads.
- pjc50 4y agoThe core is really: > https://twitter.com/yishan/status/1586956650455265281 https://twitter.com/yishan/status/1586956650455265281 "Hereʻs the answer everyone knows: there IS no principled reason for banning spam. We ban spam for purely outcome-based reasons: It affects the quality of experience for users we care about, and users having a good time on the platform makes it successful." And also this Chinese Room argument: "once again, I challenge you to think about it this way: could you make your content moderation decisions even if you didnʻt understand the language they were being spoken in?"" In other words, there are certain kinds of post which trigger escalating pathological behavior - more posts - which destroy the usability platform for bystanders by flooding it. He argues that it doesn't matter what these posts mean or whose responsibility is it for the escalation, just the simple physics of "if you don't remove these posts and stop more arriving, your forum will die".
- bitshiftfaced 4y agoI would argue that the signal-to-noise ratio outcome-based reason is the principle: it's off-topic. You could also argue another principle: you're censoring a bot, not a human.
- dubeye 4y agoYou do sound a bit like my dad complaining about youngsters reading kindle. I read long twitter threads often, you get used to it