3 ms·
> Once AA is overturned, that's it—hands off the scale Or change it so it is not race based. Instead make it geographical. Say you want to admit 1000 students
by tzs 4y ago
> Once AA is overturned, that's it—hands off the scale
Or change it so it is not race based. Instead make it geographical.
Say you want to admit 1000 students from the US. Partition the US into 1000 districts, with 1 student admitted per district.
Gerrymander the district boundaries to make sure that you get the racial demographics you want.
Have fun watching the Supreme Court try to explain why that is not OK but it is OK to gerrymander congressional districts to ensure Black people are underrepresented.
- jimmygrapes 4y agosounds like the solution is to mandate that black (and asian and so on) people are required to be evenly distributed rather than congregate in enclaves susceptible to gerrymandering. or, wait. that's not good, is it. or is it?
- mancerayder 4y agoMake it geographical or conscious of class, parental income and geography. That would go so much further in the goal of reducing inequality and increasing fairness than classifying people forcibly on something which we used to say wasn't a scientific classification, race.
- scarby2 4y ago> conscious of class, parental income and geography. This is going to be a pain in the ass and you'll just lead to people gaming the system. How about we just aim to make a high quality collage available to all who want it and extremely cheap and easy to finance so it's available to all?
- nradov 4y agoHigh quality college should be available to all who want it and who are actually college material. There are a large fraction of college students who don't belong there and only matriculated to meet parental expectations or because they didn't know what else to do. As a taxpayer I am unwilling to finance this waste.
- Telemakhos 4y agoWhy not make the goal "providing the best education possible to the brightest?" Why is reducing inequality the goal of an educational system, while taking as an unstated premise that inequality is somehow unnatural or bad?