5 ms·
Apple now valued at more than Amazon, Alphabet and Meta combined
- johndfsgdgdfg 4y agoApple and Amazon are adding real values to the economy and making positive contribution to society. Google and Meta are parasites that invade our privacy and show us ads. These ad companies should disappear from the earth.
- MBCook 4y agoI’m getting more and more iffy on Amazon. I love the convenience but the fact that they’re hiding the real merchants and so much fraud goes on is pushing me away. Also raising Prime prices to add more services I don’t want but have to pay for. I miss the old days when everything I bought from Amazon came from Amazon and was trustworthy and not a fake. Their terrible worker treatment isn’t endearing in any way either.
- smoldesu 4y ago> the fact that they’re hiding the real merchants > Their terrible worker treatment isn’t endearing in any way either Aren't these also things Apple struggles with?
- MBCook 4y agoI don’t see how #1 applies to Apple at all. #2 is a problem with companies Apple contracts with. And Apple holds those suppliers to high standards, partly because of past attention. The dirty little secret is everyone uses Foxcon and other companies like them. MS does (did?) for Xboxes. Other computer makers. Electronics device makers. Everyone. Very few companies have their own factories they run top-to-bottom. But the headlines are pointed at Apple. That gets clicks. Do those other companies try to keep worker standards up the way Apple does? No one covers that, do they. But Amazon owns the warehouses. Amazon sets their labor standards. Maybe there are subcontractors for the workers or divers. But it’s 100% Amazon’s control. Amazon didn’t contract everything out to a logistics company. Amazon IS the logistics company. That’s a very big difference in my book.
- bloomark 4y ago> Their terrible worker treatment isn’t endearing in any way either Yeah but they're Chinese workers, so people are happy to look the other way /s
- jamesredd 4y agoAmazon has free delivery over 25$. I cancelled prime a few years ago and don’t miss it at all. You just have to wait a couple more days at most.
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoIf you live somewhere everyone else has Prime, you'll usually get free super saver items in two days or less as well. I don't pay for Prime but since the truck is on my street every day, my stuff gets dropped off quickly anyhow.
- jamesredd 4y agoI actually like waiting a few more days though, it decreases my tendency towards impulsive buying.
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoI get that benefit, but I feel it's in the way of having to find $25 worth of items before placing the order. A lot of times I'll change my mind on that $8 item before I get there.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- oliv__ 4y agoRespectfully, a lot of advertisers seem to disagree.
- coldtea 4y agoAdvertisers are parasites
- nordsieck 4y ago> Advertisers are parasites Could you explain your position more fully? Perhaps a bit about how society would function without advertising.
- pmontra 4y agoWord of mouth. Of course spreading the word of new products and services would take a lot of time so some businesses won't be able to spend a lot of money and bootstrap to millions of customers in a few months. Everything would be slower but it will function.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- onepointsixC 4y agoSo a future where only large businesses serving large segments of a market are able to operate with any success while small players have little to no chance in establishing themselves into small niches. And that's of course before getting into how you broke the primary method of monetization of the entire web.
- pmontra 4y agoThat's how it would work if we remove advertising. But is there any chance of removing advertising from the world? I don't think so. What's happening instead is that a big player like Apple is using their existing base (iDevices) to build its own advertising platform and weaken rivals in the advertising business.
- yamazakiwi 4y agoI see a lot of negative from the Amazon side...but I'm open to hearing some positives!
- reaperducer 4y agoI'm not big on Amazon, especially lately. But, one thing it does do is open the world to people living in rural areas who wouldn't otherwise be able to access so many goods and services (of, admittedly, varying quality and provenance). It's the Sears Catalog of the 21st century.
- hasbot 4y agoExactly. I've lived in a rural area for ten years where the nearest hardware or clothing store was an hour away. I get most of my hard goods from Amazon. I can't recall a single issue with the hundreds of products I've ordered. The biggest issue is USPS shipping is no longer reliable and I can't count on items being delivered when Amazon estimates.
- damon_c 4y agoJeez... Google isn't perfect but... I feel like a lot of people really benefit from Google existing. Ever use Tensorflow? Or... use 8.8.8.8 as a DNS server? Or... Gmail? or Learn something from watching YouTube? One has to pay the bills somehow. If Google disappeared from the Earth would the replacement be better?
- ketzo 4y agoor, yknow… searched something on the internet using Google search? that tiny little thing that literally revolutionized the human experience of recorded information?
- serf 4y agoGoogle search was by no means the first search engine, or the best. They succeeded by having good business acumen during one of the most turbulent phases of industry that tech has ever seen, along with a big drive to integrate the non-tech public into their products. google has done great, I don't buy ' literally revolutionized the human experience of recorded information? ' -- it's simply not true; they just did well in that niche. Had they gone insolvent another similar group would have dominated that same field, that should make it dead obvious that their business (search specifically) wasn't revolutionary -- just very successful.
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoGoogle is one of the most harmful entities on the entire planet. Anyone who doesn't realize that just... doesn't know enough about the topic yet. Nobody is as good at extracting profit from unethical and outright harmful behavior while simultaneously shifting the blame onto someone else for it.
- zip1234 4y agoApple and Amazon both show ads and make a lot of money from it. You think Apple's 'privacy' changes are for actual privacy and not to undercut a competitor?
- KerrAvon 4y agoGoogle and Facebook are not really in the same businesses as Amazon and Apple. That Amazon isn't worth more is puzzling. I know I've stopped buying from them unless I absolutely have to because I can't trust that the product I get is non-counterfeit and previously unused -- seriously, who sells used shavers as new, totally f'in gross -- but has everyone else stopped buying too? update: grammar
- reaperducer 4y agoGoogle and Facebook are not really in the same businesses as Amazon and Apple. I think it's interesting, and still kinda sorta valid since when tech companies surpass the value of companies like Ford and Exxon, they make similar hoopla, even though those are in entirely different sectors.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y ago> That Amazon isn't worth more is puzzling. The simple answer is that Amazon is the least profitable company in the list (even less than Meta in its current state). There are factors that excuse this, hence Amazon is actually valued very high compared to how little money it makes.
- jjeaff 4y agoThat's because Amazon is the most aggressive at attempting to push all of there value into stock appreciation rather than profits / dividends.
- ancientworldnow 4y agoThen shouldn't their stock be worth even more which is what this discussion is about? The simple answer is their fixed margins are far worse than these other competitors (aws aside).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AzzieElbab 4y agoNot for long I am afraid. They are announcing hiring freezes, China locks some of their larger factories, and they have nothing new to sell.
- dudus 4y agoNothing new to sell? As long as time keeps ticking Apple will keep announcing the new Apple N+1 and N+1 Pro. And people will keep buying them. Every adult in the modern world has a smartphone and buys a new one every 2.5 years. Apple sells what is seen as the most premium device, with high margins.
- undoware 4y agoI believe you may have misread the parent -- I believe the author is implying that it's MSFT that has nothing new to sell (IIPC[1]) Storytime! As it happens, I was working at MSFT when the first M1-based MacBooks rolled out. I actually ran around trying to get people to look at the specs and talk about this serious emergent threat. Rank & file SWEs just shrugged, and the vibe was that I wasn't senior enough to be allowed to worry about it. I don't know what management was thinking. But, looking back over the years since, I'd reckon that whatever they were thinking was too quiet. (There is a sidebar I am omitting about Permission to Worry, which is the name of an upcoming newsletter article I intend to write about this phenomenon -- I've come to regard it as the singular most important privilege that an organization can assign an employee -- but it is well beyond scope for this thread.) [1] If I Parse Correctly
- smoldesu 4y agoWhat changed? Microsoft doesn't really care about Apple in the same way that Apple doesn't really care about Microsoft. Both companies operate in their own lanes, serving their core userbases. Microsoft sells OSes, subscription services and as a footnote, hardware - how did M1 threaten that? Apple has increased Mac sales by ~20% over the past 5 years, but it's still ~1/4th of the money they're making off selling iPhones. Even if the M3 impresses everyone again with a 40 hour battery life and increases sales by 30% (a generous stretch), Macs still wouldn't be Apple's moneymaker or priority. You want to get an idea of how small the Mac is to Apple? The App Store makes almost 3x more money annually than Mac sales. Their de-facto iPhone monopoly is more valuable than the entirety of the Mac platform. I think "Permission to Worry" is a pretty pretentious title considering how Microsoft butters their bread, but take my opinion and numbers with a grain of salt.
- singlewind 4y agoI wonder say investors now smart enough to tell the reliability between real and virtual economy.
- HollowMan 4y agoWhy is the article not talking about MSFT? Seems like it is holding up rather better than others non AAPL GAFAM values. What would be the explanation ?
- layer8 4y agoLarge installed Windows base (and Office, AD, SQL server, Sharepoint, …) in enterprises.
- batiudrami 4y agoHaving good products that it’s proven people and companies will actually pay for is useful like that.
- ThrowawayR2 4y agoOne can find convenient charts that compare both revenue sources and profits for the big tech companies. Revenue sources: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/how-big-tech-makes-their-billions-2022/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/how-big-tech-makes-their-bi... Profit breakdown: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/cp/big-tech-revenue-profit-by-company/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/cp/big-tech-revenue-profit-... MSFT has more diverse sources of revenue than the FAANG members dependent primarily on consumer directed ads and so won't be as badly affected by a downturn in consumer directed ad spending.
- lupire 4y agoMSFT value is even huger when you factor in dividend payments.
- SSJPython 4y agoI feel like Apple, Amazon, and Google are the most robust and antifragile businesses. They offer goods and services that are quite inelastic and difficult to replace. Facebook, on the other hand, is something that can be replaced. I doubt its long-term viability as a business.
- trollski 4y ago
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- jeffhwang 4y agoAmazon has benefited from high price/earning ratios for decades; even the growth-adjusted PEG version has been aggressive. Interesting comparison made by Horace Dediu: “Netflix, Apple and Microsoft all have similar P/E ratios. (25-26). Meta and Google have collapsed (9 and 18.5 respectively.) Amazon is holding 100.” https://twitter.com/asymco/status/1587430613405110272?s=46&t=UDOsrAlu0pcFI6a9l4Iy4Q https://twitter.com/asymco/status/1587430613405110272?s=46&t...
- chris_armstrong 4y agoWhat's extremely funny about this is that Amazon, Alphabet and Meta are all very much oriented around advertising and data collection (with a bit of product on the side, as a treat to users), and Apple is now ready join the same party after neutering the potential competition in the platforms it controls. (in fairness, Amazon is really all about AWS, which almost seems like its there to prop up the e-commerce business)
- browningstreet 4y agoIt’s not like Apple is at some crazy high. The others dropped. Apple has been priced a bit higher than where they’ve settled. I know. I’m still in the red on a block of my AAPL holdings.
- 5350-uiop-1130 4y agoit's like the titanic, and apple is the last life raft. rats fleeing a sinking ship.
- miles 4y ago10 years ago: "Apple is bigger by market cap than Microsoft, Google, Amazon & Facebook combined" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4447454 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4447454 https://thenextweb.com/news/apple-now-bigger-market-cap-microsoft-google-amazon-facebook-combined https://thenextweb.com/news/apple-now-bigger-market-cap-micr...