8 ms·
Teachers Don’t Like Creative Students
- danso 15y agoEverytime I read an article like this, I think of how if Steve Woz were growing up today, he would be in a maximum security prison by now: http://books.google.com/books?id=hlA6Xv3-59YC&lpg=PA47&ots=Hq93lh1uyT&dq=he%20rigged%20it%20to%20start%20ticking%20faster%20when%20the%20locker%20opened.&pg=PA47#v=onepage&q=he%20rigged%20it%20to%20start%20ticking%20faster%20when%20the%20locker%20opened.&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=hlA6Xv3-59YC&lpg=PA47&#...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- tallpapab 15y agoSo many job adverts ask for creative people, but on the job creativity is discouraged. Employers want employees to implement the employer's creations. That said, getting along socially is enormously important. Smart, creative people figure this out. The general impression that to be creative one has to be some sort of social misfit is overblown. As Piccaso demonstrated, great creativity is born aloft by great mastery. It's not that hard to Get a bad haircut and some outlandish clothing to pose as a creative naughty person.
- luser001 15y ago> So many job adverts ask for creative people > but on the job creativity is discouraged. The book "disciplined minds" has a great phrase to capture this: assignable curiosity. That's what they're looking for, not creativity. http://www.disciplined-minds.com http://www.disciplined-minds.com
- pnathan 15y agoSpeaking as a former TA who ran college classrooms for a while... Classroom management rides the line between order and chaos. You don't want students constantly interrupting, but you don't want them to be silent. Assignment grading is rife with judgement calls - what qualifies as 'correct' work? Some students feel incredibly entitled and challenge any slighting (ie., getting downgraded for being wrong). In these conditions, it's easy to see how rolling out a pigeon hole system becomes the solution to the challenge. So Teachers Don’t Like Creative Students is a bit of an unsubtle title, full of false dichotomies and ignorant of nuance.
- Maro 15y agoI attended German, Hungarian and US schools in K-12. In my experience, the US system is the weakest form of education and all the touchy-feely liberalism just results in a crappy education. I knew guys who were taking some idiot version of algebra in 11th grade, homework was doing multiplication on a calculator? but you don't want them to be silent Yes you do, most of the time. what qualifies as 'correct' work? Most of the time it's pretty obvious. Btw. I agree with the OP.
- mahyarm 15y agoIn non hard subjects, the 'correct' answer often crosses into opinion.
- absconditus 15y agoOpinions can be well-supported or completely unfounded.
- ahoyhere 15y agoAlso in "hard" subjects, it's a matter of interpretation. Such as, real science. Such as interpreting the results of a finding. There are very few things in life where there is a true, platonic right answer and everything else is wrong. "For large values of 2."
- lazerwalker 15y agoThis is true. However, it's still not that difficult to grade for "well-done" work in subjective areas. Whether the thesis of a literary analysis paper is "correct" may be opinion, for example, but it's definitely possible to grade fairly based on a rubric of "did the student defend their thesis in a clear, organized manner, properly using appropriate citations from the text" (after filtering out theses that are completely inane or insane).
- _delirium 15y agoI guess I tend to have the opposite view, that the European systems tend to focus on drilling facts and highly regimented exam- and track-based advancement structures, while the U.S. system produces more creative students and more flexibility (and more entrepreneurs and inventions). But then neither of us are citing data. =] edit: Though I suppose "European" probably needs to be further qualified, because my understanding is that the Scandinavian systems are in many ways even more liberal than the American one, with a strong emphasis on students' autonomy to co-direct their own education.
- blahedo 15y agoI think this is generally true, but there are counterexamples---I'm sure many of us here remember some of our own teachers that bucked this trend. Speaking for myself, I do try my best to foster the creative ones; they can be kind of a pain in the ass sometimes but they keep me on my toes and exert a net positive influence on the class by hitting ideas from an unexpected angle (i.e. one unexpected by me and therefore one that the other students wouldn't have otherwise been presented with). That benefits everyone. I do have to rein them in sometimes, though, e.g. "when I give you a spec you really have to implement that function, not something else that does something similar, however much more awesome that other thing is". Because sometimes you really do have to just implement the spec.
- Hyena 15y agoThat finding relies heavily on reports by teachers, not actual tests of creative ability. As such, the methodology tends to filter out any non-disruptive creatives, leaving people who have both creativity and anti-social behavior sets.
- imroot 15y agoIt's not that teachers don't like Creative Students -- my wife is a K-12 Special Ed teacher working on her Ph.D -- but that the educational system doesn't know what to do with students who do not fit into their state-provided lesson plan. In Kentucky, the state dept of Education provides: - The lesson plans - The Powerpoint slides - The quizes - The lecture outline The lazy teachers use the state provided materials and don't change it. The good teachers modify the plans to suit their students learning behavior and work accordingly. The great teachers identify a different instructional design model and make it work for all of the students in their class.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThere are two more groups of teachers you missed: The bad teachers modify the plans in a manner they think suits their students, but works worse than the provided materials. The terrible teachers completely make up their own system, which simply fails.
- imroot 15y agoThe kids are tested every year at a state level that ensures that the student who lives in BFE, Kentucky (where I live) receives the same level of education as a student in a medium sized town and both students learn the same things that a student who lives in a 'major' area like Lexington or Louisville will learn. If a teacher isn't making the grades at a statewide level, they will get rid of her or cut funding to the school. Sadly, this means that many lazy teachers are just teaching to the test, and nothing else.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIf the system works as you describe, then it's fantastic - state provided standards ensure a minimum level of education, while still allowing some students to receive a superior level of education. Perhaps the rest of the country can learn something from Kentucky.
- 15y ago
- thetrendycyborg 15y agoHomeschool. Then you don't have to deal with group dynamics like that. If you care about your children's education and don't trust teachers then do it yourself.
- king_jester 15y agoHomeschooling can be a great option but it's not feasible for everyone, esp. those without the time and/or resources to be able to do homeschooling. It's still important to look at public education critically to look for ways of improvement since there are many that rely on public education as one of the, if not the only, available source of group education in their communities.
- thetrendycyborg 15y agoDefinitely agreed. The public education system needs a cold hard look and it needs to be overhauled. We haven't really changed it since its inception, and it's just assumed that it works. But its core assumptions are being proven false. A one-size-fits-all education is failing most of our students, the students who are slower and can't catch up, and the students who are faster and are held down.
- thetrendycyborg 15y agoOr you could give it more money and call it a day.
- ahoyhere 15y agoThe vast majority of people who homeschool bring in less than a typical salary for a good developer. It's not about feasibility for the HN crowd, it's about willingness to prioritize.
- thetrendycyborg 15y agoMost families today choose a dual income over the reduced childcare and educational costs and greater control over the education of their children. It's a trade-off few people consider. Income is not the only aspect of this.
- rkon 15y agoThis was made painfully clear to me when I took an English literature class in college. The class focused on short stories and involved a lot of "deep analysis". My method of analysis was to approach stories from a rational standpoint, which doesn't sound creative at first, but the problem with fiction is that the stories exist in a realm without rules (or incomplete rules, in the best case scenario). Approaching this type of work from a rational standpoint usually leads to a nearly endless number of possibilities, each of which cannot be proven more likely than the next. Analyzing fiction is a guessing game at best, and a completely naive, amateur attempt to perform psychoanalysis on dead authors at worst. Anyone who points this out will not fare well in such a class... take it from someone who learned firsthand. Professors who have taught the same interpretations for twenty years don't like it when someone has a new idea of what their favorite stories might mean.
- jonnathanson 15y ago"Analyzing fiction is a guessing game at best, and a completely naive, amateur attempt to perform psychoanalysis on dead authors at worst." Actually, one of the cardinal rules of literary criticism is that you should not attempt to psychoanalyze the author of a work; rather, you should treat the work as a self-contained unit. If you're going to analyze the author, then it's an entirely different task. Blending the two bastardizes both efforts. So yes, I would agree that bad criticism tends to employ such efforts. But I would also argue that no literature professor worth his tenure should even be proposing such methods in a classroom. I do agree that trying to discern intent is a "guessing game." But some ways of guessing are much more effective than others. And some guesses are more sound than others. While I sympathize with much of what you're saying, I think you give short shrift to the field of literary criticism and analysis. There's some genuinely insightful, analytical, occasionally profound stuff out there. "My method of analysis was to approach stories from a rational standpoint..." What do you mean by this? "Rational" in what sense? Are you studying the rationality of the text? Are you proposing a set of logical guidelines to be used in evaluating a text? Are you focusing on the internal coherence and consistencies of the world within the story? Are you focused on the story's structural soundness? "Rational" is a pretty big and broad word that begs clarification. As you can see, I just generated a handful of different ways of interpreting your statement. This would seem to indicate that the statement needs further clarification. Now, the real problem with this is that you're suggesting that your approach was "rational," and implying that other approaches are irrational. Such a claim demands explication. "...the problem with fiction is that the stories exist in a realm without rules (or incomplete rules, in the best case scenario)." Again, this is pretty vague. What do you mean by "rules?" And are the "rules" you're proposing in any way tainted by your own subjectivity? It's very, very, very tricky to define sets of rules for fiction. By and large, we're still pretty much working with the set that the Greeks came up with a couple thousand years ago. I don't mean to knock you or your post, because I think I understand what you're saying. But if you're going to attack a system, you need to be very clear about a) what's wrong with the system, and b) what your alternatives entail.
- feralchimp 15y agoThe article title sensationalizes the sum of two separate findings, without arguing (except by anecdote) that the findings can be summed that way (or at all). That is, "teachers don't like creative students" is not at all the same thing as "teachers report not liking disruptive behavior" + "creativity is positively correlated with disruptive behavior." I strongly suspect many readers on HN: - are creative - were at times disruptive in school - were nevertheless well-liked by the vast majority of their teachers
- smoyer 15y agoI was that disruptive kid ... And I'll bet many others here were too. Now's our chance to have the last laugh!
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- commieneko 15y agoI spent a couple of years teaching at a career college in MA. The problem was not so much dealing with disruptive creative students, and I certainly had several of those, as it was dealing with students that didn't have the prerequisites and mental tools to learn the skills they needed to express themselves usefully. An example: I had one student who spoke very well, he was from Cameroon and in fact spoke _several_ languages, was something of a class leader, he had very good visual ideas and his presentation style was remarkable. But. He did not know how to read a ruler and fractions were a complete mystery to him. Algebra was completely beyond him at his current state. He was in a graphic design class and was going into a web programming class, and following that a 3D modeling class. He often became actively resentful that I was forcing him to focus on things that he considered trivial and not apparently related to the results he wanted. He very much felt I was stifling his creativity. Convincing him that he would simply fail at his goals without studying some basics was very difficult. We got the fractions and ruler issues licked with some outside class work, but he simply was not able to handle the coding in the web design class and failed. I didn't teach the 3D class, so I don't know how well he did there, but I can only imagine. (One of the reasons I left the school was that with such a wide variety of students with incredibly varied levels of education, I wasn't allowed to adapt the classes to meet their needs. I did finally get the school to offer remedial math and reading lessons, but they were not prerequisites and they did no kind of testing to determine need.) My point is that creativity is important, but basic skills often are more important, at least at the beginning. And no matter how gifted one is, developing the discipline to work on non-interesting and non-creative tasks is essential in the real world. There are problems that have aspects that are simply beyond hacking and shooting from the hip. And they are often, ultimately, the most interesting and rewarding to solve.
- mathattack 15y agoI think it's only fair. After all, how many creatives like typical square teachers? Exceptional students and exceptional teachers eventually find each other.