6 ms·
Not in the article: a common sense explanation why rising interest rates, which haven’t been combating inflation, are supposed to reduce the price of food and g
by interesting111 4y ago
Not in the article: a common sense explanation why rising interest rates, which haven’t been combating inflation, are supposed to reduce the price of food and gas (CPI) and clothes, furniture, cars, toys, electronics, and other junk (core CPI).
- arcticbull 4y agoDemand destruction mostly. The thesis is that there is more demand than supply of basically everything (not least oil) causing a positive feedback loop on prices. Crush asset prices, reduce labor bargaining power, induce layoffs - this all reduces demand for everything back to what we can supply today, which will cause lower prices in time. Prices have already stopped going up month over month in aggregate. They don’t say it because it sucks. Focusing on the supply side would have been far more palatable but there fed was backed into a corner where it needed to be seen to be acting, and they only have one tool to use. The fed can’t build oil wells.
- lamontcg 4y agoThe really pedestrian explanation is that the Fed just crashes the economy into a wall. It doesn't really have a magic wand, it just creates a recession (and I've definitely argued with people on here who think the Fed has the magical ability to steer us around inflation and recessions without causing any kind of crisis--but I'm old enough to have heard all that about Alan Greenspan back in 1999). But then to completely switch gears and get even more technical about how raising interest rates results in a slowdown--the higher interest rates immediately raises borrowing costs for stuff like cars and houses and makes them more expensive. But at the same time there's a lot of bad business investment on the margins that rolls over their loans on a 1-2 year period (similar to an ARM on a house). Those loans are going to start refinancing at higher rates. When you look at stuff like the vacancy rate of commercial real estate in SF and Portland, those are going to have loans like this behind them which are only being propped up by low rates. As rates rise, the firms behind those properties risk going bankrupt and the ones at the margins will, which turns into losses for the creditor banks, tightening all kinds of appetite for risk and availability of credit. Those effects wash over the system creating layoffs and reducing demand for goods in a positive feedback loop--things like advertising spends also decline, hitting companies like Google and Meta. That's the actual cause-and-effect that creates the slowdown going from raising the cost of borrowing to financial problems at FAANGs. Of course the current round of layoffs is mostly anticipatory. They aren't really hurting yet, although they're certainly seeing their growth numbers start to turn down.
- cplusplusfellow 4y agoAnd we have zero support on any of those topics from the current administration, which is solely focused on NOT supplying BTUs to the market. Some see this as a good thing, so welcome to the outcomes they’ve been wanting. Time will tell if Americans actually prefer this.
- arcticbull 4y agoPersonally I am in favor of high gas prices in order to incentivize switching away from fossil fuels. However, it does require the government meaningfully invest in a replacement (nuclear, other renewables, etc) - and that the government shouldn't allow a transient spike to derail the longer trend. More supply of oil is needed now in order to support the long-term transition away. IMO ofc.
- cplusplusfellow 4y agoYou can be in favor of this, but don’t act like it’s not a cause of inflation.
- mindslight 4y ago> current administration, which is solely focused on NOT supplying BTUs to the market What? Did you somehow miss that huge climate bill, which drastically increased the subsidies for solar and other forms of energy independence? It seems like the bickering is over the form of "BTUs". I myself would have been happier if the climate bill didn't prematurely end the consumer biomass subsidies (eg for wood stoves, etc). But your blanket characterization is a bit ridiculous.
- cplusplusfellow 4y agoLike it or not, better for the climate or not, but solar and "other forms of energy independence" subsidies will not power a Caterpillar D9. The world still needs diesel right now, and we're discussing inflation that is happening right now. When we've successfully build construction & transportation equipment that can use electrons, then we can discuss their utility. What we're bickering about is the timeline.
- avalys 4y agoExactly. This is not a mystery, this is how this system is intended to work.
- WalterBright 4y ago> The thesis is that there is more demand than supply of basically everything (not least oil) causing a positive feedback loop on prices. That's a myth. Inflation is caused by a river of money poured into the economy. Supply&Demand forces then devalue the money, i.e. inflation. There is no feedback loop. Stop pouring the money in, and inflation will stop.
- sofixa 4y ago> Inflation is caused by a river of money poured into the economy. Supply&Demand forces then devalue the money, i.e. inflation. Inflation isn't a purely monetary phenomenon. You can have price increases resulting in inflation due to supply and demand issues in various products, and especially more so when the issues in question are a pandemic that disrupted supply lines and a war impacting energy and food exporters and thus prices. Combine that with the increased monetary supply and you have problems.
- WalterBright 4y agoInflation is a general price increase. That doesn't happen with disrupted supply lines. The proof of this is prices under inflation ratchet upwards - they don't come back down after the crisis is over.
- sofixa 4y ago> Inflation is a general price increase. That doesn't happen with disrupted supply lines Yes it does. If the supply lines impacted are critical (e.g. food or energy) every other product and service's prices will also increase because they're based on it. > The proof of this is prices under inflation ratchet upwards - they don't come back down after the crisis is over. That is usually true, but usually there is a general price readjustment - inflation ends at a certain place, but deflation isn't welcome so it never gets to that, monetary value and prices just stay at the new, stabilised normal.
- stephen_g 4y agoYeah, and it's crazy because there isn't much evidence of demand induced inflation in any of the advanced economies... Here in Australia we have massive inflation in the cost of energy (for obvious reasons given world events), but at the same time, the mining, oil & gas companies all have spiraling profits too, making massive windfall profits on the increases (they still manage to structure their businesses to pay almost no tax though...) Meanwhile, real wages, which have been fairly stagnant compared to profits over the last decades, are now down.
- 300bps 4y agoit's crazy because there isn't much evidence of demand induced inflation There are two fundamental components to inflation. Supply and demand. The mere fact that we have inflation means that either supply is too low or demand is too high. Your statement seems to be saying, "there is evidence that 100% of the inflation we are experiencing is from supply side". That obviously isn't true. Meanwhile, real wages, which have been fairly stagnant compared to profits over the last decades, are now down. In the U.S., this is meaningless because at the low-salary end we had direct stimulus and tax rebates. In the mid salary end we had direct stimulus, tax rebates and modest asset (home/stock) appreciation. In the high salary end we had PPP loans (direct stimulus on steroids) and huge asset appreciation. All of this leads to more money available which increases demand. Near me, beach rentals have gotten up to $25,000 per week for a house. A ridiculous sum of money to stay at a house for a week! But if you're "making" $25,000 per month in the stock market? Doesn't seem so crazy anymore and it's why rentals have gotten up that high.
- jbay808 4y agoShelter inflation appears to be largely demand-induced, is the largest component of the CPI, and is highly elevated. I believe this is even more true in Australia and Canada than it is in the USA.
- arcticbull 4y agoThis is a major cause of inflation but it's mostly a local zoning issue, not a monetary policy issue. These countries straight up refuse to build supply enough to meet demand. (1) many folks have convinced themselves housing can be both a good investment and affordable when these are antithetical goals and... (2) they've also convinced themselves that this is the one market in the history of time where supply and demand magically don't exist, and that increasing supply simply won't reduce prices for some reason.
- cptnapalm 4y agoRising interest rates won't reduce the price of anything. Best it can do is slow the inflation down.
- arcticbull 4y agoOh it absolutely can, it has in the past and if interest rates get too high you will see deflation. Higher interest rates and quantitative tightening reduce the supply of money. However that is not the goal. That would be a policy failure.
- lokar 4y agoThe only thing worse then uncontrolled inflation is uncontrolled deflation
- WalterBright 4y agoThe notion that inflation is good for the economy is pushed by the people who benefit from running the government printing press.
- arcticbull 4y agoNah, not that. New supply is necessary to maintain price stability in a growing economy. If you stop adding supply you get a deflationary spiral. Similarly the ability to contract supply is necessary to maintain stability in a contracting economy. Honestly even Austrians generally agree with that statement. Their theory is inflation is a result of increasing supply in excess of productivity and that it shouldn't under any circumstances be measured. Which is stilly and rejected in favor of actually measuring price change, but I digress. The theory you're espousing there, the 'cantillon effect' has to my knowledge never once been quantified. Nobody seems to have any idea to what extent it actually exists, and if it exists, what the magnitude of its impact is. If you have a peer-reviewed study I'd love to see it but I sure haven't found one.
- 4y ago
- balderdash 4y agoPrices go up if demand exceeds supply. Raising rates cools the economy, reducing demand, thereby reducing prices. That’s the idea anyway…
- beebmam 4y agoPrice elasticity has a lot to do with whether your statement holds in a given circumstance.
- stephen_g 4y agoYes, that's the theory. And it's honestly ridiculous to believe that such a simple, static model could work in the actual, real-world economy, which is a complex dynamic system... (The simplistic theories also assume everything is priced in the way fungible commodities are, which is not how much of the world works)
- skybrian 4y agoFor one thing, it directly makes cars less affordable if you’re borrowing to do it, making it less likely people will want to buy or lease a new car. If demand falls, auto manufacturers will eventually need to do something to keep selling.
- Grimburger 4y ago> are supposed to reduce the price of food and gas (CPI) and clothes, furniture, cars, toys, electronics, and other junk (core CPI). Rising interest rates strongly support the currency, as you might see now with the USD and have far it has outperformed every other because bond rates are great in the US so all the cash starts flooding in. The prices of all those things you mentioned (sans food for the US) are mostly valued in other currencies.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dv_dt 4y agoAnd recent data should make one question why, when remaining inflation is mostly from rent, would this inflation be reduced by increased interest rates. https://twitter.com/jwmason1/status/1587617471422423040 https://twitter.com/jwmason1/status/1587617471422423040
- jbay808 4y agoRising rates means rents will likely be increased and then reduce in the medium term. Conversely, rate cuts would likely induce rents to reduce temporarily and then increase in the long term. There doesn't seem to be any easy solution other than raising rates and then getting over the hill.
- readthenotes1 4y agoAddressing inflation when it shows up instead of claiming baselessly that it's transitory would have been much easier than what they're trying to do now. There is an argument that what the Fed does is mostly irrelevant anyway until the supply chain problems are fixed. Volcker may have done the right thing back in 1981, and he may have been aided greatly by The oil shock being completely absorbed by higher efficiency and more production
- jbay808 4y agoAbsolutely they should have moved sooner, and it would have been much less painful. But I don't think there's any irrelevance to what they are doing now. Especially where shelter is concerned.
- readthenotes1 4y agoBecause the rent addition to inflation lags by nearly a year, the Fed is, in part, fighting last year's war for that. (If I recall correctly, there is still plenty of inflation outside of rent in the current mix. The Fed is fighting last year's war on the other inflations now because for some reason inflation wasn't a trouble until Powell's reconfirmation hearing this year. The old saying of a stitch in time saves nine comes to mind... )
- stephen_g 4y agoBecause obviously increasing borrowing costs will raise the cost of doing business, which will mean businesses will pass that on by raising prices. Oh, wait, that's pro-inflationary... Well, I guess there is the bit that businesses striving to be efficient will try and trim the fat and lay off a bunch of employees, and those now unemployed will therefore be poorer and won't be able to afford to buy much. That, and making people give much more of their incomes to banks to service home loans will mean they don't have as much to spend. Funny how that works really, really well for bank shareholders...
- IAmGraydon 4y agoAh, a conspiracy theorist who fancies themselves an economist, but doesn’t have a firm grasp on simple concepts like how increasing the cost of money quells demand. The world definitely needs more people like you.
- stephen_g 4y agoNot a conspiracy - the economists at central banks are just incompetent and beholden to junk theory, not intentionally malicious or controlling. There aren't "simple concepts like how increasing the cost of money quells demand" - that's linear, static thinking when the economy is a complex dynamic system.
- jbay808 4y agoJust because "brakes slow a car down" is a prediction of a simple theory of an idealized car, doesn't mean that a more complete and nuanced theory will give a different prediction. Furthermore, interest rate policy is basically a single lever with "up" or "down" positions. There's not a lot of room for nuance in the policy, regardless of whether the theory that recommends that policy is simple or nuanced.
- nyokodo 4y ago> businesses will pass that on by raising prices Businesses can only successfully pass on the higher cost of inputs if there are more dollars available to bid after the higher prices. Each economic good is different in this regard but if capital is made more expensive then fewer dollars are chasing after those goods which is deflationary.
- matrix_overload 4y agoOne common explanation is that inflation is a self-fulfilling prophecy. Let's say, you have $1000 today that can buy you a certain gadget. You know that you won't need it until the next year, but in a year that same gadget will cost $1200 due to inflation. So you buy it right now for $1000, even though you could get by for another year. This increases the amount of money bidding for a limited supply of gadgets, so the seller can easily rise the price to $1100 right away, speeding up inflation even further. To combat this, the interest rate is raised to the point where you could put your $1000 to the bank, get $1200 in a year, and still buy that gadget. Fewer people are competing for it right now, so if the seller raises the asking price for $1100, many people would rather overpay right away. In reality, we have been printing money like crazy ever since 2008 [0], but rather than immediately raising the price of bread and beef, it went into speculative investments (VC bubble, crypto), assets (housing), bullshit jobs (exponentially growing number of bureaucrat jobs), etc. Now the Ukrainian war and Chinese COVID policies have disrupted some supply chain mechanisms that worked out of inertia, and it turns out we might have killed the mechanisms that would otherwise kick in and redistribute the weight. Nobody wants to step up and produce more stuff - we got too used that we can just print more money and have someone else accept is for payment. Except now we are running out of eager participants, so more and more money is being pulled out of that hip dog spa startup and is bidding up the prices of bread and rice. I don't think the rates will fix the inflation overnight, but they may start a long and painful process of incentivizing more productive work, rather than asking for a bailout in the loudest way. And we desperately need to do this because just printing more money without "printing" more oil, chips, foods and everything else will inevitably result in Venezuela-style hyperinflation, destroying the rest of the economy. You do not want to live through it, really. [0] https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/money-supply-m0 https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/money-supply-m0
- nyokodo 4y ago> Nobody wants to step up and produce more stuff Except they are, at least in North America. The onshoring, reshoring, and nearshoring of production is absolutely massive in size and scope. [1] 1. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/26/business/factory-jobs-workers-rebound.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/26/business/factory-jobs-wor...
- theropost 4y agoI think part of the problem, is in order to truly combat inflation (not just the CPI) the cost of borrowing needs to be higher than the actual inflation rate itself. So, if inflation is 10% right now, interest rates need to be above 10% to create a real negative pressure on the inflation rate itself. Otherwise, it is simply warning shots, and a hope that people will change their behaviour voluntarily. To remove money supply from circulation; saving that money must be more beneficial than borrowing it. At this point in the cycle, it is still cheaper to borrow money vs save it. Inflation is... 8.2% let say, so... I can save that money at get 4-5% return for instance, so I'm still losing 3-4% per year in that simple scenario. Or, I can continue to spend, and borrow at a rate less than the 8.2% inflation rate. It's a bit dishonest that many economists, and experts suggest that interest rates will peak soon. Truth is, they will not until they are higher than the real inflation rate.
- bjornsing 4y ago> in order to truly combat inflation (not just the CPI) the cost of borrowing needs to be higher than the actual inflation rate itself. So, if inflation is 10% right now, interest rates need to be above 10% to create a real negative pressure on the inflation rate itself. Yes, but it’s not the interest rate today that needs to be higher than today’s inflation rate, it’s the expected interest that needs be higher than the expected inflation over the typical loan period. As interest rates increase the inflation rate will come down and the two will cross somewhere in the middle.