3 ms·
The problem with this argument is that it's founded in how the AI is used, not how it is made. It's not a compelling reason to ban the tool, it's a compelling r
by lolinder 4y ago
The problem with this argument is that it's founded in how the AI is used, not how it is made. It's not a compelling reason to ban the tool, it's a compelling reason to regulate its use.
Copilot can produce code verbatim, but it doesn't unless you specifically set up a situation to test it. It requires things like "include the exact text of a comment that exists in training data" or "prefix your C functions the same way as the training data does".
In everyday use, my experience has been that Copilot draws extensively from files that I've opened in my codebase. If I give Copilot a function body to fill in in a class I've already written, it will use my internal APIs (which aren't even hosted on GitHub) correctly as long as there are 1-2 examples in the file and I'm using a consistent naming convention. This isn't copypasta, it really does have a clear understanding of the semantics of my code.
This is why I'm not in favor of penalizing Microsoft and GitHub for creating Copilot. I think there needs to be some regulation on how it is used to make sure that people aren't treating it as a repository of copypasta, but the AI itself is pretty clearly capable of producing non-infringing work, and indeed that seems to be the norm.
- ceres 4y agoPlease let’s not start dictating how people should use a piece of software. It would be like ”regulating” Microsoft Word just because people might use it to duplicate copyrighted works.
- lolinder 4y agoI'm not saying we should regulate the software, I'm saying we need some rigorous method of ensuring that using the AI tools doesn't put you in jeopardy of accidental copyright infringement. We most likely don't need new laws, because infringement is infringement and how you made the infringing work is irrelevant. Accidental infringement is already illegal in the US.
- chii 4y agoi would argue that we _do_ need new laws. AI generated code is so quite different from any other literary works - after all, it was not created by a human. My own personal opinion is that the AI generated code (or pictures in the case of the article) should be under a new category of literary works, such that it does not receive copyright protection, but also does not violate existing copyright.
- XorNot 4y agoThis is meaningless though. The majority of AI generated art you see out there is either hand tweaked or post-processed or both. There's human input involved and drawing a line is going to absolutely backfire.
- chii 4y agoif you presented both the generated image and the "original" to a jury of peers (or even a panel of experts in the field), they would be able to make a determination as to whether the generated image violated the copyright of the presented "original". Humans tweaking the image is immaterial to this determination - if the human tweaked it so that it no longer seem to violate copyright, then that said panel would also make the same determination.
- XorNot 4y agoYou are arguing that AI generated means no copyright protection. So you can't tweak it to "not violate copyright" because their literally isn't any. Of course you have no way to prove whether any image was or was not generated by AI so welcome to a new scam for law firms to aggressively sue artists claiming they suspect AI was used in their works.
- pulvinar 4y agoThe vast majority of paintings weren't created by a human either, but by a paintbrush. We should really ban those too. Just think of all the poor finger-painters who've been put out of a job!
- joenot443 4y agoI think it's worth pointing out that Adobe has been doing this for a long time. You can't open or paste images into Photoshop which resemble any major currency.
- irrational 4y agoHow would you regulate this?
- lairv 4y agoThere is a part of Deep Learning research (Differential Privacy) which focuses on making sure an algorithm cannot leak information about the training set, and this is a rigorous concept, you can quantify how much privacy-preserving a model is, and there are methods to make a model "private" (at the cost of performance I think for now)
- f_devd 4y agoDifferential Privacy only proves that it cannot leak a certain amount of information about individual samples of the training set. This only guarantees the input is not leaked exactly back, any composition of the training set is valid, although in image generation this usually means a very distorted image. An example of DP in image generation (using GANs): https://par.nsf.gov/servlets/purl/10283631 https://par.nsf.gov/servlets/purl/10283631
- andrewxdiamond 4y ago> Copilot can produce code verbatim, but it doesn't unless you specifically set up a situation to test it. It does not matter what a service can or cannot do. We do not regulate based on ability, but on action. The service has an obligation to the license holders of the training data to not violate the license. The mechanism for which the license is violated is irrelevant. The only thing that matters is the code ended up somewhere it shouldn’t, and the service is the actor in the chain of responsibility that dropped the ball. The prompting of the service is irrelevant. If I ask you to reproduce a block of GPL code in my codebase and you do it, you violated the license. It does not matter that I primed you or lead you to that outcome. What matters is the legally protected code is somewhere it shouldn’t be.
- lolinder 4y ago> If I ask you to reproduce a block of GPL code in my codebase and you do it, you violated the license. It does not matter that I primed you or lead you to that outcome. What matters is the legally protected code is somewhere it shouldn’t be. This isn't accurate. If I reproduce GPL code in your codebase, that's perfectly acceptable as long as you obey the terms of the GPL when you go to distribute your code. In this hypothetical, my act of copying isn't restricted under the GPL license, it's your subsequent act of distribution that triggers the viral terms of the GPL. The big question that is still untested in court is whether Copilot itself constitutes a derivative work of its training data. If Copilot is derivative then Microsoft is infringing already. If Copilot is transformative then it is the responsibility of downstream consumers to ensure that they comply with the license of any code that may get reproduced verbatim. This question has not been ruled on, and it's not clear which direction a court will go.
- leereeves 4y ago> The big question that is still untested in court is whether Copilot itself constitutes a derivative work of its training data. Microsoft has a license to distribute the code used to train Copilot, and isn't distributing the Copilot model anyway, so it doesn't matter whether the model itself infringes copyright. Whereas that same question probably does matter for Stable Diffusion.