7 ms·
Over the years so many different jurisdictions around the US and the world have stated their desire to be the "next Silicon Valley" and have poured an immense a
by paxys 4y ago
Over the years so many different jurisdictions around the US and the world have stated their desire to be the "next Silicon Valley" and have poured an immense amount of money and effort to make it so, whether in the form of incentives for businesses, tax breaks, education, job training, or even just straight paying smart people to move there. Every such scheme has generally failed because they refused to emulate the one key piece of California law that is necessary for a startup ecosystem to exist – banning noncompetes.
"But I'll spend money to train my employees and they'll just take those skills to go work for a competitor or start their own business!" Yes, that's a feature of the system, not a bug.
- kennend3 4y agoHere (Canada) the courts almost always rule that the non-compete is unenforceable. The core issue is the rights of an individual to earn a living supersedes the rights of a corporation. https://globalnews.ca/content/8363992/can-non-compete-clause-be-enforced/ https://globalnews.ca/content/8363992/can-non-compete-clause... " The majority of non-compete clauses challenged in the judicial system have been rendered unenforceable. Canadian courts, in my experience, look unfavourably on clauses that restrict an individual’s ability to use their knowledge and experience to earn a living." What companies here do falls into two general categories: 1) attempt to get people to sign and hope they don't know it is unenforceable. 2) pay people to stay at home and not-compete - Given this is expensive it doesnt happen often.
- yardie 4y agoI wonder what the cross-section of the population is smart enough to be worth making sign a non-compete yet not smart enough to do a basic Google search on their enforceability.
- ipaddr 4y agoCanadians don't break rules.
- DangitBobby 4y agoA lot of people are good natured and just take others at their word.
- kennend3 4y agoThis is exactly why I posted this. I want to make sure other Canadians are aware... It is really dumb that while unenforceable, companies are able to get you to sign. As per the link the government is working on laws to outright ban the process. The government needs to step up here, and enforce its own laws. If these are unenforceable companies should not be allowed to "trick" people.
- diob 4y agoRight, the idea is to train + pay them well enough that they stay. It helps the local economy because rather than your business putting more into investments around the world (or wherever the rich store / grow their money), that person puts the money in the local economy. Folks understand this, but their pay depends on them not understanding it so. . . here we are perpetually. Funny enough, paying folks well often will pay dividends for your business in the long run. So long term they would make more money. Humans are unfortunately quite short sighted, which I'm fairly sure nothing can be done about. We're just fancy animals after all.
- lazide 4y agoI saw first hand a sales guy at a prior company I worked for start a side business directly competing with the primary business he was working for in his day job, while still working with them. Including redirecting customers while working for them. The owner got suspicious due to some comments made by customers, and started listening in on the phone calls he was making on the company phone system. This was a small business, and it nearly tanked the company, as the customers were confused as hell, and the ‘new’ company wasn’t doing well either. She ended up having to fire him, and sue him, but it took years, and meanwhile he kept operating. He was paid well, but for some people it’s never enough. I don’t care what anyone says, that is shitty criminal behavior.
- moron4hire 4y agoThat's basically the one situation in which non-competes are enforceable in the US. The problem is, most people don't understand that, and fall prey to companies putting non-compete clauses into their employment agreements that say they can't go do CRUD software development at any company in a 50 mile radius.
- diob 4y agoYeah, I'd say that's different, not sure how the anecdote applies whatsoever.
- lazide 4y ago
- vkou 4y ago> Every such scheme has generally failed because they refused to emulate the one key piece of California law that is necessary for a startup ecosystem to exist – banning noncompetes. As I look out the window of my Seattle apartment, observing a literal forest of new construction, sky-rocketing rents and costs of living, I must interpret the tech boom here as 'the next Silicon Valley failing', because Washington state has had a very strong form of non-competes prior to 2020, and a somewhat strong form of non-competes today. Or, maybe I can choose to believe my eyes, and note that the the presence or absence of non-competes isn't a very important factor for driving a tech boom. [1] It is a popular topic to bikeshed over, though. [1] As a sibling poster points out, non-competes are absent in Canada, and yet nobody can accuse any locale in Canada of being the next SV...
- ghaff 4y agoYou can argue the degree to which non-competes have contributed to Silicon Vslley success but there are a ton of companies elsewhere in the country with various degrees of non/compete enforcement that have had and have considerable success in various technology sectors. Another example is MA which historically did allow non-compete enforcement (now somewhat weakened) which spawned the whole Route 128 computer industry and more recently biotech/pharma. Although allowed, I only once had to sign a pretty limited non-compete with an MA company. And people jumped between the various minicomputer companies all the time although tenures tended to be longer for other reasons.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> Or, maybe I can choose to believe my eyes, and note that the the presence or absence of non-competes isn't a very important factor for driving a tech boom. [1] Or that other factors of working in WA somewhat mitigate downsides of non competes. Sad that WA lawmakers accepted the bribes from large businesses and capped non compete bans at $100k per year payrates. Could have leveled the playing field with CA a bit more.
- rnk 4y agoSeattle succeeds because it's the same time zone and Cali, Microsoft pulled tens of thousands of programmers here, then Amazon, now we have critical mass. What we don't have is nearly as many companies starting up here. I think noncompetes do actually reduce the number of new companies started in Seattle, and also reduce people switching jobs.
- vxNsr 4y agoYup kinda interesting to see this play out. With the federal trade secrets law tho it no longer matters.
- rileymat2 4y agoDoes banning non competes help if you don't already have businesses attracted to an area in some critical mass? I can see how it could make for a vibrant scene if you already have incumbents, but if you are an area trying to attract them, I am not sure that works.
- NegativeK 4y agoWithout talent, your employer pool isn't going to grow much. Non-competes are one of many things to make the chicken and egg problem worse.
- harry8 4y agoBeyond banning them de-jure you've also got to ban them de-facto. "We all know non-competes are unenforceable and illegal." <- Absolutely useless if you can end up in court. Using unenforceable rights as a deterrant is common and potential future employers get spooked by it even if it is illegal. "Don't hire Jill, Mary is almost as good and has no non-compete. Don't want to go to court even if its unenforceable." There are no consequences for forcing someone to have the stress, expense, time and to secure the financing so that if everything works as it should (which it often doesn't in all the various legal systems) you get only some of that back. If it doesn't work as it should you're toast. Not a nice thing to be hit with when the law is clearly designed that you should not be hit with anything at all. For an individual or a startup it matters. For a large revenue incumbant they have people employed to abuse the system like that and the business expense of doing it is trivial, more than worth it. The law may exist so that the strongest do not always get their way - but this is an ideal with many exceptions including this one. Ban away, but with no consequences for abuse and all measurements for the abused being the magnitude of the downside alone, no upside possible you don't get the result you're looking for. Summary dismissal with costs, compensation and the potential to be branded a vexatious litigant so it is more difficult to bring any court action against anyone would be a real consequence for abusing the rules. Is the best one? Is it fair? Dunno. What we have now in most countries sure isn't.
- ghaff 4y agoI worked for a very small company. We wouldn’t hire anyone with a non-compete end of story end of discussion. Just wasn’t a risk or cost management was willing to even entertain.
- Eleison23 4y agoHow would you know they had one? What is the process for disclosing or discovering non-competes? Ostensibly part of a private citizen's employment contract, that's a confidential document. So what basis would a prospective employer have to request a copy, and how would said third party verify its authenticity?
- 4y ago
- bdw5204 4y agoI'm fine with allowing non-competes as long as the company pays the ex-employee their full salary for the length of the non-compete and can't rescind the non-compete without mutual consent. For example, an 18 month non-compete would mean 18 months of paid vacation after you leave a job. I imagine this would be functionally equivalent to a ban on non-competes because it seems like it'd be an insane waste of money but if a company wants to provide a paid vacation on the way out I see no reason to stop them. Unpaid non-competes should be illegal as somebody's right to earn a living trumps a corporation's right to impose an unconscionable contract on its employees.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoThis is a smart way to go about it. Only a tiny portion of truly critical positions would have compensated non-competes under this system and the rest would have no such blocks.
- LadyCailin 4y agoThis is how it works in Norway.
- divbzero 4y agoPaying to delay competitors could be a good use of money for companies in many circumstances. That would work fine for an individual from a financial perspective, but keeping talent away from work is suboptimal for society as a whole.
- ska 4y ago> but keeping talent away from work is suboptimal for society I think this is basically a non-issue in practice. People with such iron-clad non-competes typically either a) take a non competing job, or b) work on something anyway. The latter effectively means the original company funds some research. If you do this with say, sales people, or traders, or whatever, it shuts down their work. If you do it with engineers they'll just make something at home.
- chrisdhoover 4y agoSome say the valley dominated over route 128 for this very reason.
- ghaff 4y agoExcept things didn’t really switch West for many years and a lot of other factors were in play.
- ryandrake 4y ago> "But I'll spend money to train my employees and they'll just take those skills to go work for a competitor or start their own business!" Yes, that's a feature of the system, not a bug. This mentality has never made sense to me. Why would a business invest so much money into training someone, then fail to spend the money needed to retain the (more valuable) trained employee?? "They'll leave after we train them" is a ridiculously easily preventable problem.
- m463 4y agowonder how that is solved in practice? (also wondering about the armed services and paying for medical school)
- origin_path 4y agoThe investment into training isn't merely money and can't usually be neatly calculated. It's usually paid in the form of time, motivation, distraction and lost opportunities by more senior staff. If you, personally, sink a year into training someone intensively, and then they leave, would you perceive it as merely lost opportunity costs? Probably not. Mentors and mentees are supposed to have a more than purely transactional relationship in most understandings. As to why not just pay more, probably the reason you were trying to train someone to begin with is because you can't afford to pay the higher wages to just poach the most experienced people? Otherwise why not just pay the higher wages to start with and skip the risky and slow training? Also, the software world has the unique problem that everyone is competing against VC backed startups that are willing to spend more up front to minimize time to market, so these firms generally don't train but can afford to poach anyone who is trained at a perhaps unsustainably high salary.
- m463 4y agoI thought austin was like silicon valley, but with own-the-employee-mind-invasiveness. Maybe companies get bigger and move to austin?
- bluGill 4y agoThe real danger is if you don't train your people and they stay. That risk is why you train everyone even those who leave. For cases of expensive training it is fair to demand they pay you back if you don't stay for a couple years. We are talking about a full masters at a major university though, not just some random 3 day design patterns class or whatever the hotness of the day is.
- sokoloff 4y agoThe clawback also needs to be contingent on the employee somehow requesting the training and initiating the end of the job. If you spend $20K on an MBA that I initiated and I quit, totally fair to have an arrangement where I have to pay some of that back. If you fire me? No obligation. If you send me to some series of certifications because you want me to have them? Also no obligation.
- bluGill 4y ago> If you fire me? No obligation. Lets change fire to lay off. There is a subtle but important difference. If you fire someone it is generally for cause - that is they did something bad. You still want someone doing their job, but because of their bad behavior it can't be them. That is if someone gets a MBA, moves to a management position and starts demanding sex of their underlings, you fire them and demand they pay for the education you got. By contrast when you lay someone off, you are saying "you were good at your job, but we don't need someone doing your job anymore" (or maybe we can't afford to pay someone to do the job). You lost your job, but there wasn't anything you could have done different if you wanted to stay.
- sokoloff 4y agoPeople mostly get fired for not doing or for sucking at their job rather than for sexual harassment. For a termination "for cause", I don't care much either way whether the training is reimbursable to the company. For termination for poor performance (still a "firing"), I think training should not be reimbursable.
- 4y ago
- whyenot 4y agoObviously there is a little more to it than that. Oklahoma and North Dakota have both banned noncompetes for 130 years or more. no nexus of tech in either place. ...and then there is Michigan where they were banned beginning in 1905, but then the ban was repealed 80 years later in 1985.
- coding123 4y ago(it's actually just the weather)
- fonix232 4y ago> "But I'll spend money to train my employees and they'll just take those skills to go work for a competitor or start their own business!" Yes, that's a feature of the system, not a bug. Pay your employees well, listen to their problems and fix them, and they won't leave the company for a competitor. People leave for a handful of main reasons to competitors: 1. Money - this is the most obvious. Most employers simply don't want to give pay rises, to the point where they would rather hire a new person at 50-100% higher than your current salary, to do the same job, than to give you a 25-30% raise. 2. Bad management - second most common reason I see people leave, even for lesser paying jobs, just to be rid of bad managers. And for some reason most companies would rather hire _yet another_ manager to "fix things" rather than listen to the actual workers' problems. So the worker leaves when all they see is manager upon manager upon manager getting paid 2-3-5x as much as they are, who either don't do jackshit, or are overbearing micro-managers. Oh and of course these managers often claim any success of their managed people, while pushing any blame on them simultaneously. 3. No way to progress, either professionally, or within the company hierarchy. A lot of professionals end up doing the exact same job for years upon years, without going anywhere. They don't get promoted to a new position (but get new responsibilities continuously, without any financial renumeration of course), they can't go to another project, they're stuck in one place. And nobody likes feeling stuck. Overall, a company can easily ensure that people they invest in, stay with the company to use those skills - just freaking listen to them. Not the managers, not some external "corporate coach", the people you invested in. Make sure they're happy, and they'll stay with you. Oh, also, let's debunk that whole "I invested money in you therefore you can't work for my competitors" bullshit - all that investment, that's actually net zero for the company, since they can do tax writeoffs on those, as an expense. So at the end, that argument is pure BS, and restricting (ex) employees from working for the competition is pure pettiness.
- nicbou 4y agoAfter visiting SV, I wonder why anyone would want to replicate it. I was so disappointed to see so much poverty, such high rents and such poor public transit in the tech capital of the world. It seriously realigned my perspective.