7 ms·
Beginning of the end. It's nice that the developers are giving users a choice, even if it's opt-out not opt-in. But AdBlock Plus is a tool to remove ads- that's
by hammock 15y ago
Beginning of the end. It's nice that the developers are giving users a choice, even if it's opt-out not opt-in. But AdBlock Plus is a tool to remove ads- that's it. And they're extremely good at it. The moment they become politicized and try to be "a tool to support small websites" or whatever nonsense, marks the beginning of the end.
- monochromatic 15y agoStick a fork() in it. It's done.
- rishi 15y agoI totally agree. It doesn't make any sense from a marketing/branding standpoint. The company is called "AdBlock" not "SomeAdsBlock". Lots of people still have no clue about this company. How will new users perceive it moving forward?
- gujk 15y agoThink of it as "block of ads"
- jarin 15y agoI don't think there's anything wrong with being a little socially considerate. Only a Sith thinks in absolutes.
- Jach 15y agoBut I guess Jedi are still allowed to speak absolutes, if not think them. Anyway, I'd rather see an option for an in-page popup asking to donate to the arbitrary website you're on, with AdBlock as an escrow where site owners can collect their donations. Edit: just saw https://flattr.com/ https://flattr.com/ linked below. The problem with their execution (unless they do this already and I missed it) is that they don't stick a flattr button on every site. They should do this, and if a site isn't registered with them alert the donating user of the fact. If the donating user cares enough to contact the site owner in question they can sign up and get their money, otherwise at the end of some period it goes back to the user. Edit2: Ah, looks like they do have an unclaimed feature. Yay! Everyone who uses the excuse of allowing ads to support the site should use flattr and make a direct known contribution instead of an unknown one. https://flattr.com/unclaimed https://flattr.com/unclaimed
- bad_user 15y agoThe problem is that AdBlock Plus is becoming popular. Advertisers are noticing it too. And it will become a whac-a-mole game, in which advertisers will come up with creative ways to get around ADP or publishers will just block users with ADP enabled, or just setup a paywall. We are indeed tired of intrusive advertising. But some websites are good citizens and shouldn't be punished for the mistakes of others. It wouldn't be in our long-term interest. For example - Reddit is a good citizen. It only has an image in their right toolbar. Many times they just advertise for other reddits you might be interested in, which is also cool. I even clicked it a number of times. So why punish websites like Reddit for the mistakes of others? We shouldn't. Reddit provides a valuable service too and the developers working on it need salaries too. And there are other websites like Reddit, also good citizens. It is in our interest to reward these websites - this way advertisers will start getting a clue.
- maximusprime 15y ago* It's not becoming popular. It's about 1% of users. * It's trivial to get around. Other options would be for webmasters to give Adblocking users a watered down version or just serve them up crapply encoded videos/images etc If adblock ever became popular, webmasters would quickly work around it, and you'd have an arms race, with the webmasters winning. * Adblock probably blocks 50% of adverts. The other 50% people don't realize are adverts.
- waitwhat 15y agoIt's not becoming popular. It's about 1% of users. The problem is that this 1% aren't evenly distributed -- some websites are inevitably going to have more Adblock users than others, and I wouldn't be surprised to find that some large sites (reddit?) are hitting 20%. It's trivial to get around. Being hostile to their users/customers doesn't seem to be working all that well for the music industry, and just adds to a general feeling of resentment. It is not clear that the result would be any different in another content industry.
- maximusprime 15y ago
- comex 15y agoThis is basically what happened to Readability.
- stonemetal 15y agoIt is a tool for blocking ads but is there a reason why it should be the nuclear option of block all ads everywhere, instead of a block the ads users want blocked, leave the ads the user wants left. If anything this just makes the tool more usable and configurable.
- georgemcbay 15y agoThis is the beginning of the beginning for me. I've never used AdBlock despite being aware of it from the start because I've always felt it breaks the economics of the web. If it becomes a tool to weed out the bad apples while not punishing the rest, I'll actually start using it.
- aw3c2 15y agoYou could always a) white-list pages where you do not want ads to be blocked and b) decide on the ads to block yourself.
- georgemcbay 15y agoYeah, that's true, but the less I have to think about the issue the better.