11 ms·
Hey Google, thanks for making my daughter cry.
- cschmidt 15y agoI'd suggest a Fastmail.fm account instead. Their TOS says: This Service is provided to individuals who are at least 18 years old or minors who have parental permission to open and maintain an account. I think I read somewhere that they consider a charge on a parent's credit card to be explicit parental consent. Makes sense to me. Also, since you are paying them a little money, they offer actual technical support, unlike Google. They also have family accounts, where you can have one person take care of billing and administration of several accounts. That's what I use for my whole family, including my parents.
- danilocampos 15y agoB-b-but Google made this fancy video advertisement about how I can give my infant daughter a Gmail account and write to her as she grows up! Does it only work if she never uses it? You've gotta wait until you can hold a bat mitzvah to hand it off to her? This kind of chicanery is why I can only chuckle when Google announces new initiatives that require significant customer service, like selling telephones or providing a fulfillment system to compete with Amazon Prime. They treat their users like ants. And given the way their business is structured, that scale is about correct. Google doesn't need for any given user of their service to be pleased. They're a whale, straining krill from the ocean, playing a vast advertising numbers game on a scale individuals can barely grasp, and can barely factor into. Which is not an illegitimate position. But it poses a problem for individuals who are swept into its gaping maw - there is zero incentive machinery to compel Google to ever get things corrected. Depending on where a product is on its growth curve, it might even cost Google more to fix the problem than to replace the users. Your only recourse is to hope for enough public embarrassment to short-circuit the system. It also calls into question the viability of their entry into any business where service is a differentiating characteristic.
- yanw 15y agoThat is not entirely fair, automation is the only way to admin millions of users and when nonsensical factors like COPPA get introduced to the system this happens. And I don't think that they did anything wrong here considering the consequences of not complying with the law.
- danilocampos 15y agoThe fact that it makes Google look bad doesn't impact its fairness. I acknowledged that that's not an illegitimate way to run the business. But that doesn't really matter to a little girl whose correspondence with loved ones has disappeared down a black hole. That despair is as reasonable as Google's indifference. And, it points to a great opportunity to make a reliable mail service that addresses the needs of the ever-growing population of young people who will need email long before it is regulatorily convenient to Google.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- biot 15y agoDisney manages to provide good customer service for the millions of real-life humans that walk its theme parks annually. Google's problem is not that it can't be done, but that it's unprofitable to provide customer service when your business model consists of making a few pennies here and there.
- csmt 15y agoThis is absurd. Instead of not collecting data for children Google is blocking access to children. I am seriously looking for alternatives to Gmail. Any suggestions? I don't want my email account hooked up to a social network and advertising machinery.
- eli 15y agoIt's a bit more complex than that. In order to comply, Google would need to verify that you are a parent/guardian and that you are giving permission for your child to join. Faxing of identity documents would likely be involved. Google's approach is heavy handed, but it's a really bad law.
- danilocampos 15y agoIt seems like a very straightforward solution to me. If an account is created for a person under-age, suspend ad service to that account (end data collection) and require a nominal fee to activate it (which provides abundant evidence of parental consent). Cutting off the next generation from email does not seem like the answer. Would a Montessori-educated, eight-year-old Sergey Brin have appreciated such treatment? Since that won't happen, I mean, when we have kids I guess we just have to pay for hosting and administer their email ourselves?
- unabridged 15y agotheir time as innovative and useful is coming to a halt. they have nearly zero incentive any more to improve, even in their core products. search results everyday become more and more polluted with seo spam. google maps hasn't changed in years, still the same blocky loading and no useful overlays like demographic data built right in.
- eurleif 15y ago>google maps hasn't changed in years, still the same blocky loading MapsGL. http://support.google.com/maps/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=1630790 http://support.google.com/maps/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answe...
- fpgeek 15y agoIndoor maps? Not to mention this whole Google Maps on your phone thing (and navigation on your Android phone)...
- magicalist 15y agoIt may feel like the Googles and the Facebooks are self-sustaining juggernauts, but customer happiness and retention is exactly the incentive machinery you are missing. Everyone plays the balance game. You can have the best customer service in the world, but my daughter is still going to cry if your moving company breaks her stuff, or your store sells us tainted dog food, or your family-run email service writes the wrong data to the backup tapes just before a failure. Amazon might be awesome in terms of rates of well handled customers, but Google is doing pretty well, maw metaphors notwithstanding. edit: it's really the rates of bad experiences/customer I'm talking about. There's another side of things, that of, bad experiences/customer with a problem, which Amazon is better at (in a market that isn't really comparable to the one in which google's services primarily reside, of course). On the other hand, Bezos's often cited goal of every call that has to be made to customer service being a bug to be fixed is exactly google's goal, it just sounds a lot better when there's still a number you could call.
- CamperBob 15y agoIt may feel like the Googles and the Facebooks are self-sustaining juggernauts, but customer happiness and retention is exactly the incentive machinery you are missing. Except we're not their customers.
- william42 15y agoYeah, but if we leave, then the advertisers(their "real customers") will too, so it works out the same.
- danilocampos 15y agoIt really doesn't. Advertisers have committed budgets and have switching costs that are often much, much higher than those of end users. It would take a sustained, double-digit-percentage loss of users to impact Google's bottom line. One user fucked over out of 1,000, even if they never return, is pretty easy to paper over. Which is why there's no phone number a user can call if they're in trouble. They don't really matter, so it's not worth the cost to address their issue. AdWords advertisers, on the other hand, they can get a human on the phone whenever they want. Because if they have an issue, it's honest-to-god cash money that stops flowing into Google's coffers. They're the real customers.
- cynwoody 15y agoThis would seem to have more to do with the 535 dumbest people on the planet than with Google.
- funkah 15y agoWhat? Kids cry all the time, come on.
- okoni 15y agoThis is a common case of "If you are not paying for it, you are the product being sold.", this is what happens when you engage in careless computing and put your data on a third party remote server under their control. Don't be careless and it won't come back and bite you.
- ctdonath 15y agoGood life lesson for the kid about government, and why freedom & liberty are so important. And set her up with her own website already. Show her the power she has to not put up with such stupid limitations.
- sp332 15y ago1. This has nothing to do with the government. 2. Google are completely within their rights to do this. It's their servers after all.
- dillona 15y agoThe reason this happened is a rather obnoxious law called Children's Online Privacy Protection Act of 1998 (COPPA)
- sp332 15y agoOn the contrary, plenty of companies handle this just fine. COPPA does not require Google to disable or delete the account. Legally, they only need to get the guardian's permission. This is much more trouble than is required by COPPA.
- einhverfr 15y agoNo. Actually it requires "verifiable parental consent" meaning you have to be able to prove later you had such consent. This means having them fax a form that you retain, or get a digitally signed email, or the like. This is not trivial to comply with.
- okoni 15y agoGoogle's services and google data collection are two sides of the same coin. Make it possible to have google services without the data collection part would expose the actual data collection taking place and worse users could start asking to be disconnected from the data collection since it's now possible.
- 15y ago
- ronaldj 15y agoGood thing Yahoo didn't do this in the 90's otherwise no one in my middle school class wouldn't have had an email account.
- Tangaroa 15y agoIf Google did not collect and sell its users' personal information, they would not have to worry about a law saying they can't do that to kids.
- learc83 15y agoThat's how they make money. Their entire business model is based on it. TANSTAAFL, you're paying for their services by acting as their product.
- MichaelApproved 15y agoI bet the biggest thing holding Google back is that many will say they're under 13 just to take advantage of the ad restrictions and privacy protections placed on those accounts.
- jodrellblank 15y agothey've chosen to act apparently without ever considering how their actions might affect the people who use and rely on their services. Hyperbolic nonsense. Their consideration for multicultural, international, legal, technical, practical, and end user issues under time and effort constraints doesn't come out exactly the way you wanted it to under one edge case that you happen to hit therefore they "haven't ever considered"? Never assign to malice what can be adequately be explained by stupidity needs a corollorary - never assign to malice or stupidity what can adequately be explained by being outside the normal patterns of a huge system.
- danilocampos 15y ago> outside the normal patterns of a huge system Can you expand a bit on how a sentient human being, wishing to communicate with other sentient human beings, is outside the normal patterns of a communications system?
- yew 15y agoGoogle isn't just a communication system, though. They're a very large corporation involved in numerous enterprises that often interfere with one another, and their actions are further modified by an even larger legal system that only imperfectly represents the collective will of its constituents. Decisions are often (indeed, perhaps mostly) made without any consideration of individual people (even the people making the decisions aren't always entirely conscious of what they're doing). I don't believe that's a necessity, but a lot of people are pretty comfortable with it and it mostly approximates working. This sort of thing shouldn't come as a terrible surprise.
- danilocampos 15y ago> Google isn't just a communication system, though. Gmail is. It's not positioned with anything like the complexity you describe. So it's not unreasonable, as OP suggested it was, for a user to want to use it, without giving much thought to age.
- tiles 15y agoA similar article from this past July titled (aptly) "Google made my son cry": http://sunpig.com/martin/archives/2011/07/03/google-made-my-son-cry.html http://sunpig.com/martin/archives/2011/07/03/google-made-my-...
- Cl4rity 15y agoI was just about to reference this article. Same shit, different day.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jronkone 15y agoAnd here I almost thought I was going crazy...
- shard 15y agoAh, it was a different person. I was wondering how the guy got away with reposting the same story...
- redwood 15y agoFunny isn't it, how "son cry" and "daughter cry" have very different rhetorical weights.
- cma 15y agochromebook: 13 and up
- RexRollman 15y agoI have to wonder if anyone at Google even thought about the repercussions of that.
- RexRollman 15y agoIt is really sad that Google can't figure out a way for those under 13 to have accounts, provided there is a parent signing off on it. And the first comment by someone about how their child can't log onto their Chromebook anymore is particularly disturbing.
- dexen 15y agoLosing access to Chromebook is an interesting case. Where did we go so wrong that breaching particular point of AuP causes our own hardware to become inaccessible? People rally against zealous lockdown of PC (recently restricted boot in EFI, earlier TrustedComputing in general). Not being able to install any software of choice (with reasonably little effort) sure is bad, but having an already functioning computer swept right from under your fingertips could easily be way more damaging. Government couldn't do that without serious due process. Why a company can, and why aren't there voices of stern protest?
- sigmaxipi 15y agoFYI, you can still log into a Chromebook with a Anonymous/Incognito/Guest account and use it as long as you don't care about persistence. Chromebooks are designed to be orthogonal to a Google account so changing the accounts that are attached to a given Chromebook is trivial.
- artursapek 15y ago"Log onto our website, but only with your parents' permission!" died quickly a decade ago for a reason. There's virtually no way of validating that. Which is why I'm still surprised that movie and video game sites still use the faded "Enter your age to continue" screen.
- ThePawnBreak 15y agoHow is adding a decade or two to your age when registering any less difficult to validate?
- jamesgagan 15y agoi'd be interested to see if this got enough +1's if it would show up in the "What's hot on Google+" section.
- quanticle 15y agoTo be honest, I think a large part of the blame goes to COPPA. I remember listening on those hearings, and those opposed to COPPA warned against this exact thing happening. They said that taking the decision away from parents would lead to disaster, and guess what, it has. Rather than blaming Google here, shouldn't we be writing our legislators to repeal COPPA? We should be telling them that this misguided law is starting to intrude onto the choices that parents make when raising their children, and that it should be repealed immediately. As long as COPPA exists, we'll see more and more stories like this.
- 1010011010 15y agoCOPPA is fucking stupid legislation, but Google should at least provide a "parental consent" mechanism.
- dotBen 15y agoA parent can't 'over-rule' a federal law. "Hey Mr Food-N-Liquor owner, I give you consent for you to sell my 18 year old alcohol" etc
- freiheit 15y agoExcept, of course, that COPPA has a parental consent provision. The problem is the burden of verifiability.
- CamperBob 15y agoWhich other services like Yahoo seem to have no problem with.
- Vivtek 15y agoCOPPA explicitly provides for a parental consent mechanism; Google simply doesn't choose to implement it. Everybody else implements it just fine.
- 15y ago
- thenextcorner 15y agoThis is why you should take control of your own data, and not let your data in the hands of a company. Buy your own email address, set up your own blog self hosted.
- pyre 15y agoWhat would you suggest for comparable calendar and contact management software?
- chrisjsmithuk 15y agoGenuinely speaking the following works for me: Calendar: A moleskine. Based on the amount of times I haven't had access to "the cloud" or my phone is DOA (less of an issue now I've downgraded to a Nokia 6303), this has saved my ass over and over. Contact management: My phone SIM in my Nokia 6303.
- icebraining 15y agoI think Zimbra is a common suggestion, but I'm not sure how comparable it is.
- Tangaroa 15y agoUnfortunately, that's easier said than done for people who can't afford hosting fees or who don't understand how everything works and would not know where to start working on something like that. People go to the free services because they're free of charge and often far easier to set up than rolling your own.
- shinratdr 15y agoNot to mention better. To get a gmail level of features and service, I would have to spend an arm and a leg. It's a completely unrealistic solution.
- pjscott 15y agoI propose the term "RMS solution" for this sort of thing: it's a lot of bother, but I'm glad that somebody is keeping it a viable option, just in case.
- DuncanIdaho 15y agoWhat about the Google commercial, where parents open a childs google account upon birth, fill it with images and commentary... Only to have it all deleted when Google get around to it?
- Kylekramer 15y agoPretty well covered here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3010687 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3010687 TL;DR: The account in the commercial is the parent's, not the kid's.
- danilocampos 15y agoHard to believe the ad wasn't titled "Dear Sophie's Account Held by Myself, Her Father, Not to be Handed Over to Sophie until such time as she meets Google's User Age Threshold for Regulatory Compliance." "Dear Sophie" does have a much nicer ring to it, I guess.
- Kylekramer 15y ago"Dear Sophie" pretty clearly implies it isn't Sophie's account to me. When you write an letter (especially one that hasn't been sent yet as the commercial implies), you are the owner of the letter, right? To cite the Bible, it is Paul's letters to the Corinthians, not the Corinthians' letters from Paul.
- danilocampos 15y agoLeaving aside my glee that we must reach into mythology (edited, thanks rubidium) to help Google's case, any letter that begins "Dear Sophie" sounds like it's a letter... to Sophie. And while she might not be able to read it right now, my initial guess as to why would be that infants don't have great reading comprehension, not that Google can't find an algorithm to get around COPPA.
- rubidium 15y ago
- cmoscoso 15y agoYou're the Product.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- tonfa 15y ago"Focus on the user and all else will follow" is still number one at http://www.google.com/about/corporate/company/tenthings.html http://www.google.com/about/corporate/company/tenthings.html
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- okoni 15y agoThis is PR, you know devised by Freud's nephew Edward Bernays in the early 20th century, popularized by its infamous book "Propaganda".
- joelhaasnoot 15y agoWhatever happend to "If you are under 18 (or 13?), ask your parents or gaurdian for permission"? Believe that's the current Dutch regulations, not an expert though. It's quite unfair to assume that companies will keep track of this. Kids under 13 should probably have parental/monitored internet usage anyway. (Though I have to admit to having had a Fb account back when it was 18+ when I was 17. School wasn't on Fb and everyone did it...)
- dangrossman 15y agoIt's a US company so they have to obey COPPA, which requires verifiable consent from a parent before collecting any private information from the child and restricts marketing to that child. So, in practical terms, for Google to offer mail accounts to children under 13, they need to be able to collect faxed or mailed proof of consent from parents, have some system to process that information and tie it to the accounts, then they need special rules for the ads shown on the gmail site to that user.
- CamperBob 15y agoWhy do no other COPPA-compliant account providers require anyone to fax or mail anything?
- adgar 15y agoI assume you mean "COPPA-compliant account providers that allow children under 13". If so, scroll up in the thread - they all require either faxing, mailing, or credit card payments.
- PPGualtieri 15y agoThat's why no one should ever trust $GenericCompany$ blindly with their data without having a backup.
- jimktrains2 15y agoEveryone asks why I still run a mail client when I could just use webmail. This is why. They just don't get it.
- ck2 15y agoSo - when was the last time everyone reading this backed up their gmail? Take the next 5 minutes to install thunderbird (you'll be impressed if you have not seen it in years) and enter the IMAP settings for google and download everything in the background while you work. When your account gets hacked and you lose everything, you'll appreciate the backup.
- gonzo 15y agoor install something like https://github.com/imapsync/imapsync https://github.com/imapsync/imapsync and be able to backup your imap mailboxes without a GUI
- icebraining 15y agoI use http://offlineimap.org/ http://offlineimap.org/
- TillE 15y agoThat should be SOP in any case. Just takes a few clicks to make Thunderbird sync everything from IMAP (Account Settings -> Synchronization & Storage).
- sliverstorm 15y agoI prefer POP3. Then just mix in Dropbox and local backups, and my email is pretty darn safe.
- pak 15y agoThis is a great idea, I just set it up on a spare box using Matt Cutts' instructions for getmail and POP3. http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/backup-gmail-in-linux-with-getmail/ http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/backup-gmail-in-linux-with-get... If anybody else tries this, I'd recommend sticking with POP3 as getmail's IMAP client seems to mark all your messages as read (not cool).
- nirvdrum 15y agoIf you have additional services (e.g., Google Docs or Flickr) and are willing to trust someone else with your data, I highly recommend backupify. I set it up for my gapps account and my personal stuff. Pretty easy to set up. And then you can just export all your data at once. In the interest of full disclosure, I do know the backupify team, but I pay for the product because I find it useful.
- miles_matthias 15y agoIsn't this an old story? I feel like I read this exact story a few months ago.
- joelmichael 15y agoI felt the same way. Turns out there was a story in July with an almost identical title, but they seem to be different occurrences. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2725983 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2725983
- miles_matthias 15y agoAh good catch. Thanks.
- funthree 15y agoSeems eerily the same.
- portentint 15y agoNot sure I'd blame Google as much as COPPA, and the politicians who think parents can't make this choice on their own. Of course, our kids can still find p0rn, violence and who-knows-what-else online with no filtering whatsoever. But at least they can't blog about it.
- pjscott 15y agoThe primary purpose of online child-protection laws is to make their supporters look and feel like concerned citizens who protect children. Their efficacy at actually protecting children from anything is laughable.
- tristanperry 15y agoA pretty bad story - not that I'm surprised though. Google have never been good at customer service (obviously with the web so large and most of Google being free, you can't expect much, but what is 'offered' is usually sub-par, even for paid products). On the plus side, this is #1 on Hacker News meaning Matt Cutts should reply any second and internally flag this up inside Google. One of the comments on the Google+ entry also stuck out: "The same happened to me. It also means my daughter can't log into her Chromebook!" If that's true that's pretty awful. It does bring up a good point though - if Google close your account (rightly or wrongly), it does make owning a Chromebook somewhat useless.
- Matt_Cutts 15y agoCOPPA is pretty far afield from my area of expertise. I'm more than happy to encourage people back at the plex to talk about the situation with COPPA and our services though.
- tristanperry 15y agoThanks Matt. It's something I hadn't really thought about although this story has raised an interesting point/concern.
- ajays 15y agoI'm a bit disheartened to see that everyone is buying the COPPA bullshit. Yes, COPPA is the law that applies, and has some restrictions. But that doesn't force Google to act like a total dick about it! Lets assume there's an automated process for detecting underage accounts. Why can't they just prevent the account from being used to send email? Or why can't they say "Sorry, we have to disable your account; but you can download all of your emails at (insert some secure link to a ZIP file)"?? Or, as the post says, migrate these accounts to their COPPA-compliant set of accounts? You know what the real problem is? The real problem is that Google collects a shit-load of data about its users. And they don't want to put in filters which will not log the data of underage children, because that opens them up to scrutiny. So they would rather keep this blackbox closed, and in the process if a few kids get screwed, then, well, screw 'em!
- adgar 15y ago> Lets assume there's an automated process for detecting underage accounts. Why can't they just prevent the account from being used to send email? Any data collection is forbidden by COPPA without parental verification. You seem to think that's just logging ad targeting data or something. No, it includes any information entered by the child into the service. So not only can they not send any email, they can't receive e-mail. They can't even have an email address! They can't thumbs up a video on youtube, let alone save one as a favorite video for later. You could only view google docs that are globally-viewable, since you can't share a private document with a child without storing some data about them. They certainly can't edit a document! It goes on and on.
- okoni 15y agoeverything you mentioned seems to me to be ad targeting data, email, email address, thumbs up, save as fav even viewing a global google docs all this is part of data collected as part of the profiling process in order to do ad targeting. Actually I don't think there is a single you do once logged on (or registered) that is not collected to profile you. facebook even collects what you do when logged off.
- sliverstorm 15y agoI never can quite buy in to fuss like this. They are just a company, and I am not surprised nor do I get upset when I get caught in a cog. Knowing that it can happen, I prepare. As they say, "Luck favors the prepared".
- sigmaxipi 15y agoThere is an interesting rule in COPPA that is the cause of this bad experience: http://www.ftc.gov/privacy/coppafaqs.shtm#teen http://www.ftc.gov/privacy/coppafaqs.shtm#teen For sites that choose to age-screen, age information should be asked in a way that does not invite falsification. See Question 39, below. In addition, we recommend that sites that choose to age-screen employ temporary or permanent cookies to prevent children from back-buttoning to change their age in order to circumvent the parental consent requirement or obtain access to the site ... However, as described in Question 38, above, should you choose to block children under 13, it is important that you design your age collection input screens in a manner that does not encourage children to provide a false age in order to gain access to your site. If you take reasonable measures to screen for age, then you are not responsible if a child misstates his or her age. For example: ... Not encouraging children to falsify their age information, for example, by stating that visitors under 13 cannot participate on your website or should ask their parents before participating. In addition, a site that does not ask for neutral date of birth information but rather simply includes a check box stating “I am over 12 years old” would not be considered a neutral age-screening mechanism.
- pjscott 15y agoDoes COPPA think that children were born yesterday? Who would keep falling for the old "what year were you born?" age-verification trick?
- modeless 15y agoThis is the important bit that people miss. Google isn't allowed to warn you that changing your age will apply restrictions to your account, and they aren't allowed to let you easily undo it after it's done. This is what happens when Congress dictates user interfaces.
- cynwoody 15y agoSo, in effect, this means a kid is 13 as soon as he figures out he needs to be 13. OK. Not all kids are created equal, and some kids will be 13 sooner than others. Some might argue that's not fair. But, back in the day, I would not have been among them.
- vasco 15y agoI remember being on the internet since I was about 10 and I always said I was over 18 for whatever I did on the internet because I knew otherwise there would be restrictions. Is this a hard concept to grasp?
- cynwoody 15y agoNope. And it should set your attitude towards the government for the rest of your life.
- tokenadult 15y agoAn example of a United States-based website that has a user-friendly COPPA procedure for opening parent-approved accounts for users under age thirteen is the Art of Problem Solving, https://www.artofproblemsolving.com/ https://www.artofproblemsolving.com/ a site that many HN users may like, especially if they have children, because of its many resources for learning mathematics. It's regrettable that Google doesn't follow this example. How is Google's behavior in this reported instance consistent with Google's claimed support for data liberation? http://www.dataliberation.org/ http://www.dataliberation.org/ And how is the lack of notice and lack of help for parents who approve of their children having email accounts (not to mention Google's apparently contrary advertising campaigns) consistent with a policy of "Don't be evil"? http://investor.google.com/corporate/code-of-conduct.html http://investor.google.com/corporate/code-of-conduct.html
- holograham 15y agonot sure I get how people can assume Google (or any company, person, or government) owes them something. Google provides a free service (which they figured out how to support via ads). They can refuse service to anyone. In this case, google is enforcing a rule that is not even their own. Obviously there is a huge pre-teen advertising market that they cannot capitalize on because of this rule. You have knowingly broken this rule, used the account and got caught. They make is clear when you sign up that you must be over 13. Tough luck.
- tobtoh 15y agoThis old chestnut of an argument gets rolled out every time a situation like this occurs - "Well they are the rules, you should have read them, it's your fault. Suck it up". In most situations I've read, the people don't so much object the rules, they object to the unfairness of them. Two factors often come into play - were the rules clearly stated and is the penalty in proportion to the 'crime'. 'Rules clearly stated' doesn't mean 'here is a 10 page 8pt font terms and conditions document we assume you read' because you clicked through a EULA apge. If your rule is going to have an impact where they will likely lose their service, that had better be upfront and unmistakable. The dad claims he didn't see such a warning and in all the Google accounts I've signed up for, I don't recall reading such a condition either (I'm sure it's there, I just don't recall ever having seen it). Punishment fitting the crime - it's a bit like those banks which charge you a $5 fee for falling below the $4 minimum amount you have to keep in your account, and then charging you an overdraft fee, then charging you for accessing an overdraft you hadn't previously arranged, then charging you for ... etc. Or perhaps laws where 'if you aren't doing anything criminal, you should have nothing to fear about constant unwarranted surveillance, searches or whatever'. Just because a rule is broken doesn't mean it's fair game for any penalty to be applied. In the case of this kid, losing access to all that data seems to be unfair. I get the sense that if the dad could at least retrieve the data, most of his unhappiness would be gone and he would move on. Arguing with a 'the rules have been broken, lynch them' position, really doesn't take into account basic human behaviours - people make mistakes, you have to help them not make them (clear rules) and guiding them to the correct behaviour when they deviate (appropriate in proportion punishments). Of course, a business doesn't have to take into account basic human behaviour - that's their right - but they rightly deserve the scorn at their lack of respect for their customers when they get called out.
- garbowza 15y agoThis was the reason I co-founded Moment Garden http://momentgarden.com http://momentgarden.com, to help parents securely save the memories of their child. I know it's a leap to trust a small startup with such important data, but with stories of Google arbitrarily shutting down accounts, it helps make our case. Sure, we've had some growing pains, but when a parent emails us with problems, they get in touch with a founder who will make the situation right. Good luck getting that with Google.
- svdr 15y agoWhen my son (10) filled out his g+ profile, in which they ask for date of birth, his gmail was blocked. I could reopen it by confirming (lying) he was older, and paying a small fee by credit card.
- lifeformed 15y agoHow did Google find out her age?
- joebadmo 15y agoGoogle is less flexible and less responsive on this and similar issues than they could or should be. But. This discussion should be about COPPA. See danah boyd's illuminating research and analysis on the subject here: http://www.zephoria.org/thoughts/archives/2011/11/01/parents-survey-coppa.html http://www.zephoria.org/thoughts/archives/2011/11/01/parents...
- cscheid 15y ago(Yes, this is a little cynical, but) The distinction between Google making money from you vs. Google having you as a client seems to explain some of what happened. But did they simply not see this sort of problem arising after their family ads? That's astonishingly short-sighted. Is this kind of problem widespread with google products? That is, could it be explained by a small number of bad calls from somewhere inside Google's innards?
- mapster 15y agoMy kids use my account. Unless Google can somehow tell that it is a child writing and sending the email they would assume it is me. Making an email account specifically for my child (with his/her name, age, etc.) seems dangerous to me anyhow, and for good reason, since Google will lock the account.
- 47 15y agoWhere were you when the COPPA law was introduce? Did you write a single letter to your legislators? Did you write a single blog post against COPPA?
- anxrn 15y agoThis post hit me with a serious case of deja vu. And then I dug this up: http://sunpig.com/martin/archives/2011/07/03/google-made-my-son-cry.html http://sunpig.com/martin/archives/2011/07/03/google-made-my-...
- atarian 15y agoI'm glad I'm not the only one.
- whiletruefork 15y agoTo my knowledge complying with COPPA is a difficult and tedious process. Common sense does not apply, and in fact, in my understanding, can often put you in violation of the law (for example: stating that you are going to remove someones access for being underage , because then they can reasonably understand that lying is in their best interest). Blame your own government, not Google.
- flexd 15y agoA bit late to the party but wasn't this exact text posted somewhere else at least 6 months back? If not more. I am 100% sure I read something like this with the exact same title before. On topic: What on earth does a child really need Gmail or anything for anyway? I would like my future children to learn about technology and be interested in how things work but on the other hand giving a 8 year old a cellphone or something seems ridiculous.
- theseanstewart 15y agoWill someone please explain to me how Google knows the age of the person using the account? Just lie about the age of your kid when you create them an email account. It's really that simple.
- zachinglis 15y agoI believe I've seen similar a post with this exact name here about a year ago. Nice to know Google have fixed it -_-
- moondowner 15y agoI think that I've already read this somewhere? (Google made my son cry) http://sunpig.com/martin/archives/2011/07/03/google-made-my-son-cry.html http://sunpig.com/martin/archives/2011/07/03/google-made-my-...
- buff-a 15y agoIn case you missed it, bean counters, not geeks, have been running google for a while now.
- Egregore 15y agoIt's why I haven't switched to any online service and still have e-mail addresses at my own domain also I'm still using an e-mail client, so I'll e-mail backup both at client side and at server side.