11 ms·
No Copyright Intended
- bambax 15y ago> What happens when a generation completely comfortable with remix culture becomes a majority of the electorate, instead of the fringe youth? What happens when they start getting elected to office? (Maybe "I downloaded but didn't share" will be the new "I smoked, but didn't inhale.") Yes, that's exactly what happens: nothing. The US has had (publicly confessed) former drug users as presidents for over a decade and a half now, and look at how it changed the "War on drugs": if anything, it intensified. This is just wishful thinking.
- joejohnson 15y agoThe War on Drugs is not a good analog for IP laws. As difficult as it is for the government to effectively ban substances, it is much, much harder to prevent people from sharing files over the internet. The War on Drugs is incredibly ineffective, but not nearly as ineffective as any technical "solution" to piracy that would make it impossible for people to share files. Sharing files _is_ the internet. As long as people can connect their computers, almost at will, there will be ways for them to share copyrighted material.
- notatoad 15y agoIt's a perfect analog, politically. The war on drugs is fought much more vigorously than it should be, considering how much good it does or how much public support it has, because it is very profitable for some powerful lobby groups. The fight against piracy, same thing.
- herge 15y agoHow many people in the 60s smoked pot? Just because a majority does something does not mean it will become legal.
- rickmb 15y agoUhm, yes it does. It may take time, but in most societies, that is what eventually happens. Only corruption and religious or political zealotry slows down the process, but eventually people will realize there's no real crime here, just a desperate reactionary attempt to maintain the status quo in a way that does more harm than good.
- tptacek 15y agoCorruption and religious zealotry aren't what's preventing legalization of weed. The majority of the country doesn't support it yet. The attitude of legalization advocates (I support legalization) that anyone who disagrees with them must be corrupt or in the thrall of some megachurch preacher harms the movement to legalize. The recent California initiative is a good example of this. Rather than respecting people's reservations about legalization and finding the baby-step measure that would do the most good (e.g. keep the largest number of people out of prison or at least spare them career-destroying criminal records), California legalizers instead proposed a wish list policy that voters rejected. There's a parallel in here somewhere with copyright legislation; it doesn't help that copyright reform advocates on the ground (ie, not Lawrence Lessig) are schizophrenic about the issue, sentimentalizing a position that reduces to virtual abolition of copyright while at the same time barking at people about GPL and working in jobs that more or less depend on copyright themselves.
- mechanical_fish 15y agoYeah, but there are lots of alternatives to pot. Also, pot-smoking is smoking. It is (and I say this in the nicest possible way, as one who supports the legalization of pot) literally a smelly habit; it affects everyone around you, even when pursued in moderation. You can't be in the same suite of rooms as someone who is smoking pot without noticing. The experience of second-hand pot is one hell of a lot better than second-hand cigarette smoke (and not just because I get to worry less about cancer or strain on my heart; it just smells better), but still not one I go out of my way to enjoy. Such a habit is easy to culturally stigmatize compared to, say, alcohol, which is orders of magnitude more dangerous than pot – in all kinds of ways that would take an hour to enumerate – but which bothers others not at all when consumed in small amounts. Finally, there's a European cultural tradition of alcohol consumption (even excessive alcohol consumption that bothers other people!) that is alive and well in the USA. Pot, not so much. That feature is probably what made it so hard to make alcohol prohibition stick, compared to marijuana prohibition. There's not a lot of alternatives to learning music by mimicking other musicians, and the act of extensively reading and quoting existing published works is called scholarship and is held in high regard. Quoting creative works doesn't harm the people around you; indeed, people generally enjoy well-played cover tunes, and routinely pay people to play them. And needless to say quoting stuff is a far more fundamental cultural tradition, in Europe and everywhere else, than taking any particular drug.
- Palomides 15y agowhat is this piece arguing for? the abolition of copyright, or a revision of fair use law? copyright can be a very useful tool for keeping things free, such as using open source licenses for software and the creative commons licenses for other works. edit: though clearly to be good for free purposes, people need to actually understand copyright. I would say that the rather modern "everyone can create" (or remix) thing, rather than just people with a background in a creative field (which would probably include some education on the topic of copyright) has created a bit of a problem. Some sort of effort to educate the public would be pretty beneficial, in my view (imagine if everyone knew what creative commons was).
- Lagged2Death 15y agowhat is this piece arguing for? Why does it have to be arguing for something? Isn't it posing a question?
- sp332 15y agoCopyright isn't a normal, naturally-occurring thing. It's an artificial construct made to incentivize people to make more things. So people aren't going to understand it instinctively. You have to explain it to them from scratch, show them the difference it makes, and show them their place in the system: If you want to incentivize creators, you shouldn't copy their stuff. That's the message that never got communicated to these "kids".
- rickmb 15y agoOr, these "kids" figured out the message is a lie.
- HotKFreshSwag 15y agoOr, these "kids" understands copyright and did some economical analysis and figured out that the increased spending power that comes from the money saved by copying content at zero cost was more beneficial to the economy than any benefits gained by having content protectionism.
- georgieporgie 15y agoAs the creator of intellectual property, my first priority is putting food on the table. The macro-economic benefit of trading my intellectual property is irrelevant to me.
- access_denied 15y agoIndeed, these OSS / free content advocates come off to me as people staing the obvious. So, you doing work and making it available for free to the community will result in greater riches in the community, than, now hold your breath, doing the work and charging the community for it. Wow, who would have thought of that?
- guard-of-terra 15y agoBut why shouldn't you remix and derive their stuff?
- corin_ 15y agoSurely the fact that all these people have no understanding of the law means they are less likely to do anything to get it changed than if they were posting videos with "disclaimer: this is copyrighted material but I don't give a shit". And that scares me more than anything. Not that they're breaking the law, but that so many people are this ignorant. Every time I read one of those disclaimers I want to literally rip my hair out, how can anyone not realise that it's the equivilent of shoplifting while holding a sign that says "no theft intended" is beyond me.
- Swizec 15y agoBecause it's not the equivalent at all. It's more similar to going into a store. Looking up the ingredients on a box of cookies and writing them down to make your own batch at home, while holding up a "no theft intended" sign. The basic premise of theft is that you are taking something away from the original owner so they don't have it anymore. The only thing you are "stealing" with copyright infringement is fictitious profits that may or may not exist at a potential time in the future.
- corin_ 15y agoI wasn't comparing the crime, I was comparing the excuse. It's the equivilent of punching someone while holding a sign "no pain intended". Theft no longer comes into it, happy now?
- nextparadigms 15y ago
- _delirium 15y agoIt's an interesting phenomenon, not so much that many people are ignoring copyright, as that they genuinely seem confused about what it is. My guess is that it's partly actually caused by the rhetoric around intellectual property, which can backfire: 1) The ubiquitous trademark-ownership disclaimers ("All trademarks are the property of their respective owners") combined with the conflation of trademark/patent/copyright under the umbrella term "intellectual property", leads to confusion about this area, and a misbelief that a disclaimer like the one used to avoid trademark infringement can also be used to avoid copyright infringement. 2) The rhetoric around "stealing" causes people to apply a more intuitive understanding of what it means to "steal" someone else's work, which then gets interpreted as being a question of plagiarism or profiting, so uploaders make sure to clarify that they aren't "stealing" the work in the sense of claiming it's theirs or trying to sell it.
- derleth 15y ago> "All trademarks are the property of their respective owners" This is another piece of folk-law voodoo, in that, one, it is not required by any law, and, two, it does not make anything legal that would be illegal otherwise.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoIt indicates you're not using the disclaimed marks to indicate origin of goods and services you are offering. If the marks are shown alongside a notice disclaiming ownership then a registered trademark owner can't (mitigating circumstances excepting) claim that you're attempting to pass-off using their mark. I'd be surprised if it wasn't implemented to avoid claims that mere presentation of marks were uses of the trademark. Of course if the language works then there may not be caselaw to support this as litigants could have been put off suing in cases using such a disclaimer. Are you working in TM law in some form in some jurisdiction? IANA(IP)L (nor working in IP presently). As a related aside the UKIPO practice on RTM in patent specifications is of interest [to me]. Generally the examiner would [I'm a little out of date], IIRC, attempt to [get the applicant to] excise all registered trademarks that weren't essential to the understanding of the piece. Any remaining marks were to be labelled in the spec with "RTM" (for Registered TradeMark). So far as I could ascertain there was no legal requirement to do this it was just pushed as best practice. Note RTM in the UK was the legal manner and not use of ®. Labelling a mark as "ExampleTrademark RTM" is pretty much the short-hand equivalent of saying "this trademark belongs to it's owner [and not us]".
- tomjen3 15y agoI grew up in the tail start the generation who doesn't understand copyright (though I do, having been a rapid FSF supporter). The thing is copyright no longer makes sense. It used to, but today we have so many movies, tv shows, albums and books that you couldn't possibly read/watch/hear just one tenth of one percent of them in your entire lifetime even if you did nothing else. Copyright was supposed to enable society to be enriched. The constitution doesn't demand that congress make a copyright law, it merely enables it to do so. The moment the public no longer believes that copyright is likely to benefit it, it can simply stop offering it. So that nobody makes the argument that you take away their property or that the owners somehow has a moral right to it. Nobody is taking their property away from them. What we take away is the (temporary) monopoly they were granted. And we could properly still put limitations on the commercial use of copyrighted works -- if that had been used as an example, a lot more hands would have gone up among the students.
- muuh-gnu 15y ago> The thing is copyright no longer makes sense. From a democratic point of view, it doesnt even _matter_ whether it makes sense or not. The only thing that matters is whether we, as a society, collectively _want_ private, non-commercial copying (i.e. filesharing) to be illegal or not. Knowing that "we" probably would make non-commercial copying legal, "they" simply do not let us vote on it. Copyright is basically locked out of any democratic decision process, worldwide. Basically all existing political parties shield copyright away from democratic influence like a sanctum. Only in the recent 2-3 years, in a number of european countries, people have realized that voting on this issue in the current system will basically forever be impossible and have formed pirate parties focused solely on getting rid of the filesharing prohibition.
- Jugglernaut 15y agoSeeing as it is legal to share files non-commercially in Switzerland I'd say that worldwide is a stretch. It's also getting there in other countries. The momentum is behind the sharing, not behind the institutions upholding the barricades.
- 15y ago
- ChuckMcM 15y ago"What happens when — and this is inevitable — a generation completely comfortable with remix culture becomes a majority of the electorate, instead of the fringe youth? What happens when they start getting elected to office? (Maybe "I downloaded but didn't share" will be the new "I smoked, but didn't inhale.")" If there is any way I can encourage these young people to run for office and do public service I will do it. We need to turn this thought experiment into reality, get people into the gears and sockets of our society that have 'grown up' digital and understand it. I agree with the author that this would really help rationalize some of the copyright and patent madness.
- muuh-gnu 15y ago> encourage these young people to run for office Which is raising another, more underlying problem: Why do we as a society have no means to change stuff by voting on it, like in a, as it is called, "democracy"? Why is the only practicable way to change something like the filesharing prohibition, as you suggest, to give up everything else and run for a political office? > We need to turn this thought experiment into reality, get people into the gears and sockets of our society What you're suggesting is basically trying to inject "our" people into the ruling caste because it is completely decoupled from the ruled one. I'd rather say that we simply need significantly more democracy.
- ryandickherber 15y agoConsider agorism.
- flyt 15y agoAfter seeing the California initiative system up close for the last few years I would disagree that this improves matters.
- Karellen 15y agoHow about if you run for office and do public service? Encourage by example. Even if you don't encourage that many people, you can be a part of "turn[ing] this thought experiment into reality".
- georgieporgie 15y agoPeople like to say that "kids these days" don't understand copyright, but the fact is that hardly anyone of any age understands copyright. Back in the 90's, people in their 40's and older blindly retold the fable that you didn't have to pay for shareware, regardless of what the EULA stated. I had a friend whose father was a lawyer, who had the largest collection of illegally copied VHS tapes I've ever seen. They insisted it was legal because they weren't distributing, which is nonsense. The only thing new about the phenomenon is the ease with which a greater variety of media is now shifted around digitally.
- derleth 15y ago> the largest collection of illegally copied VHS tapes I've ever seen. They insisted it was legal because they weren't distributing, which is nonsense. To expand on this: The only legal way to record copyrighted material is to do it to time-shift, meaning you record it, watch it once, and then destroy the copy. That is it. This was settled in the Supreme Court case Sony v Universal, back when 'Sony' meant 'Betamax', as detailed in this page: http://www.law.cornell.edu/copyright/cases/464_US_417.htm http://www.law.cornell.edu/copyright/cases/464_US_417.htm
- drewcrawford 15y ago> The only legal way to record copyrighted material is to do it to time-shift, This is simply not true. It's the same type of ignorance the OP is complaining about. Just to start with, fair use exceptions. Not to mention we've carved out custom exceptions for education, disabled people, etc. etc. Or just read Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limitations_and_exceptions_to_copyright http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limitations_and_exceptions_to_c... Granted, they're a lot narrower than normal people believe they are. But they're a lot wider than "only one exception", and both mental models are equally incorrect.
- Nick_C 15y agoInteresting that a format change such as in large print or braille is an allowable exception. My local lending library has a huge number of large print books and I've often wondered why, especially when it seems out of proportion to the size of the aged population. Perhaps the library gets them cheaper.
- GHFigs 15y agoWhy not make your own film?
- Tycho 15y agoYou can rip-off the labour of hard-working artists, but eventually something has to give.
- zokier 15y agoI think this is a failing of society (parents and schools) to educate children of basic ideas off laws that govern them. I don't mean that the copyright code should be explained in full for every child, but the basic premise that you shouldn't distribute anything you haven't created yourself from scratch.
- billpatrianakos 15y agoWoah! Watch out! You said something unpopular around these parts with that last sentence. I'm seeing so many people believing that it actually is okay to distribute something you haven't made from scratch. I don't know why but I do suspect that they don't think of is as "distributing something you haven't created yourself from scratch". I've seen so many times in these discussions people defend pirating and saying that all software should be free and then there's excuses like "pirated works are just free marketing" and "well they wouldn't have bought it anyway". It's very hard to explain why copyright infringement is not okay to people these days because the physical analogies no longer apply. People think theft is when you take something and deprive someone else of that thing. With digital media you're taking something but the creator still has it and that's where things get messy. But just because the author still has the original copy that doesn't mean that it's still okay to take. Then you get into the whole argument about how whichever industry (music, movies, whatever) are so rich and greedy and screw people that it's okay. True or not, it still doesn't change what's wrong with this stuff.
- zokier 15y agoActually what I meant was that legally you shouldn't distribute stuff that's not made by you. While I myself am somewhat pro-copyright, I also respect other peoples anti-copyright opinions. But I think that even anti-copyright people should follow the law, and keep advocating changes to the law if they feel that law and their views do not align. That doesn't mean that I think people should blindly follow laws, but rather see following law as a temporary concession.
- Zirro 15y ago"True or not, it still doesn't change what's wrong with this stuff." There's something missing here. What's wrong with this stuff?
- rospaya 15y ago> What happens when — and this is inevitable — a generation completely comfortable with remix culture becomes a majority of the electorate, instead of the fringe youth? What happens when they start getting elected to office? (Maybe "I downloaded but didn't share" will be the new "I smoked, but didn't inhale.") Just like the generation that smoked but didn't inhale changed everything about that, right?
- jamesbritt 15y agoJust like the generation that smoked but didn't inhale changed everything about that, right? It brings to mind the saying, "People become conservative as soon as they have something to conserve."
- joejohnson 15y ago>> Judging by his username, I'm guessing crimewriter95 is 16 years old. I wouldn't be surprised if most of those million videos were uploaded by people under 21. That's a pretty lame assumption.
- esrauch 15y agoThe assumption is because of the 95 on the username, which is a strong indicator that the author was born in 1995. It sounds like you misunderstood and thought he was merely saying that it sounds like a childish username, which he was not. If the username was crimewriter65 it would be strongly indicating that he was 46 years old.
- tibbon 15y agoWhy do schools and parents teach nothing about copyright laws? We're so obsessed with teaching our kids about drugs and drug laws (DARE), yet the potential punishment for intentional copyright infringement is much higher than being caught with a joint. I do not agree with current copyright laws, but they do exist. Citizens need to have a better understanding the laws if we ever hope to have them changed. Many people seem to be incredibly willfully ignorant about copyright stuff.
- freehunter 15y agoI know that personally I would be happier (as a relative term) being charged in a criminal suit such as having a joint than to be tried civilly as a file sharer. Having to pay a $250,000 fine would do just as much damage to my future as trying to get a job as a convicted felon. I'd be paying the price for the rest of my life anyway.
- morganw 15y ago> Why do schools and parents teach nothing about copyright laws? Copyright was one of the topics covered in an elective my 6th grade son took last quarter. Public school in California.
- cmcewen 15y agoIf anybody has the time, I suggest reading Against Intellectual Monopoly. http://www.dklevine.com/general/intellectual/against.htm http://www.dklevine.com/general/intellectual/against.htm. It's a fairly well thought out and well researched argument for the abolition of copyright. There are a few examples of how people can still make money off of content that anyone can access. The basic premise is that the content creator has the advantage of releasing the material, and therefore can leverage it for profit even though others can copy the material.
- njharman 15y agoIn regards to "kids these days" and > What happens when a generation completely comfortable with remix culture becomes a majority of the electorate Not shit. I grew up several generations ago. We all made mix tapes, violated copyright with our VHS and Betamax recorders, Xerox machines, etc. Then we grew up and most of us discovered we liked money and so sold out to anyone including copyright cartel who would give us a share of their take.