4 ms·
I see some practical challenges in that for university admissions. What measures of poverty and income would you use and of whom? The high schoolers themselves
by sokoloff 4y ago
I see some practical challenges in that for university admissions. What measures of poverty and income would you use and of whom? The high schoolers themselves will all look similar (as could be arranged at least). Many could arrange their income to look how would be most advantageous in a specific admissions year.
What’s wrong with using measures of merit of the applicant? GPA, standardized tests, application including essays, letters of recommendation, etc. The desire to find ways to improve upon direct measures and the hubris to believe placing these thumbs on the scales will make things globally better is somewhere between puzzling and mystifying to me.
- Retric 4y agoThe issue with using measurement X is that it quickly gets gamed. Having a freshman class filled with people who’s parents wanted their kids to get into a good school isn’t the goal. Standardized tests for example are surprisingly gamble especially when you consider things like bribery. Elite collages for example want their student body to look a specific way. One slice for ultra wealthy, one slice for foreigners, another slice for XYZ.
- scarmig 4y agoLow income and (to an extent) wealth are also gameable. Especially if you're well off and privileged.
- foogazi 4y ago> Having a freshman class filled with people who’s parents wanted their kids to get into a good school isn’t the goal. Interesting - what is the goal according to you ?
- pwpw 4y ago> The issue with using measurement X is that it quickly gets gamed. Goodhart’s Law[0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- bradleyjg 4y agoWhat exactly is meritorious (adjective: deserving reward or praise) about any of that?
- sokoloff 4y agoAre you asking what is meritorious about GPA, standardized test scores, or an essay they wrote? Or something else?
- bradleyjg 4y agoYep, those things. Are kids like trained animals, we praise and reward them when they do tricks for us?
- sokoloff 4y agoIf admissions to an elite or selective university is a reward, then yes, we do (and IMO should) reward them for strong performance in terms of GPA, SAT, or admissions essays. More broadly, I absolutely praise and reward my kids when they do things that I believe are worthy of such feedback. Sometimes that's for achievement; sometimes that's for effort. It's part of the feedback process inherent in raising children; if you have a different approach that you prefer for your children, I don't have any objections to you using your approach.
- rayiner 4y agoThat’s a great analogy, and also summarizes why it’s so problematic to make race a factor for college admissions. It makes minority kids engage in performative diversity in order to appeal to mostly white college admissions officers.
- WithinReason 4y agoWhat would you call your job and your salary if not reward for tricks you do for others?
- bradleyjg 4y ago
- david38 4y agoWe already measure income for Pell grants, etc. Race is massively harder and more biased. You’re black = assumed excess difficulty in life? What about white but just came from a refugee camp? What if your family has been poor for many generations? There were reasons to say a black person’s life at $50k/y income is harder than a white person’s, and the same with boys vs girls, but things have changed quite a bit. Specifically society has mixed a lot more, immigration and interracial children have significantly changed the landscape, to say nothing of the fact that girls outnumber boys in college!
- sokoloff 4y agoA family of 4 making $100K in Des Moines isn’t the same as a family of 4 making $100K in NYC either. Maybe two families are making the same, but one has their housing paid for. I think the hurdle should be high for including adjustments to the applicant’s demonstrated ability, and looking at a year or two of tax returns isn’t going to give you a reliable picture. I have a deferred compensation system available (and I’m just a schmoe employee). If it was critical to their application, I could make those two years of tax returns look however I needed.