11 ms·
Classic 50mm “Normal” Lens
- podiki 4y agoTitle should be "The Forgotten Lens" though as a fan of the 50mm just "The" Lens works for me :) The 50mm f/1.8 Z lens for Nikon is really magical, I love any chance to use it.
- muro 4y agoSame here, have a bunch of lenses, but this one is almost always on the camera. I'm tempted by the 50mm 1.2, but its price gives me pause and I'm worried about its weight.
- _ph_ 4y agoOne shouldn't get too crazy about aperture. On a modern 35mm camera you rarely need the f/1.4. Certainly not for gathering enough light and usually the DOF is small enough at f/2 already. So you can get a much lighter and cheaper lens by not going for the fastest aperture. A nice alternative are the Voigtländer lenses, which are available or adaptable to modern mirrorless cameras. They tend to be less pricy and quite compact. I personally love my Voigtländer 50/3.5. It isn't the fastest lens, obviously, but lovely, compact and has a great image quality. Steve Huff had a glowing review of it some time ago.
- trap_goes_hot 4y agoIn general I agree, but as you probably know, the answer almost always is - it depends :) So it depends on the focal length. I use both 24 and 35mm at 1.4 pretty much every-time I use them. At those focal lengths, and normal subject distances, they don't have crazy shallow depth-of-field where only one eye-lash is in focus. I can get great environmental portraits where the subject pops a bit more than 1.8/2.0 etc.
- 323 4y agoI have a highly regarded, but old 50/1.4. I also have a cheaper 50-300/3.5-4. Big surprise - the 50-300 zoom looks MUCH better than the 50/1.4 at 50 mm. I'm talking about the colors, they are just better and more natural (less aberrations probably). Of course, if you have enough light since it's slower. I investigated this, and it turns out modern lenses have much better coatings and other optimizations. Conclusion: lens age matters too, if it's an old design investigate.
- writeslowly 4y agoAs someone who got into photography relatively recently, if you’ve only used modern lenses, old (or extremely cheap) lenses can be really interesting to use as well. My 1970s Olympus 50mm f.14 or low budget Chinese f1.2 give me interesting colors and lens flares that I’ve never seen with modern lens designs.
- sanitycheck 4y agoI completely believe you, at f8. I'm not sure I do if both are at f3.5. And of course the zoom can't do f2.8, f2 & f1.4 which are three good reasons to use the prime. (This is without getting into "character", because it's so subjective.)
- skhr0680 4y agoThe Takumar 55mm SLR lens is really interesting to me because over 4+ versions of the lens it kept the same optical design but got dramatically improved coatings every few versions. The single-coated version actually has quite good and natural color rendition in the right light, unfortunately the internal reflections are really noticeable with strong sunlight in the frame. I still consider the version with Zeiss coatings good enough for studio work. Another interesting thing is that the f/1.8 and f/2 versions are both the f/1.8 lens, but the f/2 version has the iris calibrated to be wide open at f/2. Some people prefer the f/2 version because it has less vintage glow wide open while keeping circular bokeh balls.
- solardev 4y agoThese aren't dead! You can still find a variety of fast 50mm lenses, from a cheap f/1.8 for like $150 (which is still way better than most kit lenses) to a very nice f/1.4 upgrade at like $400 all the way to absurdly expensive ones. https://www.kenrockwell.com/tech/comparisons/premium-50mm-lenses.htm https://www.kenrockwell.com/tech/comparisons/premium-50mm-le... Their primary advantages: * Amazing "bokeh" -- the quality and look of the background blur that modern phones mostly try to emulate using computational photography and maybe lidar depth sensing; but the blur effect is simulated in software vs being an actual artifact of the lens construction and aperture * Incredibly fast, good for dimly-lit conditions or action photography * Fine-grained control over depth of field makes the subject stand out beautifully * Teaches you to move your body and camera around to find the perfect framing, instead of standing still in one place and using the zoom. This can often make for more interesting compositions and angles. * Usually much lighter, especially if you go with an APS-C sized sensor in a mirrorless Negatives: * No zoom means you have to be able to get close to the subject. Hard to do with wildlife, some sports, etc. * One more lens to carry around -------------- The 50mm is so much fun to shoot. Get one!
- uniqueuid 4y agoAbsolutely agree, but have to add a small nitpick: 50mm primes used to be lightweight. The trend is towards Sigma Art / Zeiss Milvus/Otus dimensions, and that means much better edge sharpness but ~1kg in weight.
- perardi 4y agoLet me second that. Besides perhaps the Canon 50mm f/1.8, 50mm lens are big now. Like a grapefruit on the front of your camera, to the extent it kinda obviates the size reduction in mirrorless bodies—slimmer body, and a giant lens. There are reasons for that. If you’re buying an interchangeable lens camera, you are probably after image quality, and the new generation of lenses are phenomenal. I am not sure if you’d call this Nikon cheap, but it blows away all their previous offerings. (https://www.zsystemuser.com/z-mount-lenses/nikkor-lenses/nikon-z-mount-lens-reviews/nikon-50mm-f18-s-lens-revie.html https://www.zsystemuser.com/z-mount-lenses/nikkor-lenses/nik...)
- mgrund 4y agoThe “nifty fifty” is certainly not forgotten and absolutely a great buy.
- rabuse 4y agoIt's basically everyone's first lens for the bokeh craze, and then you just keep hunting for even creamier bokeh, until you're broke and wondering where all your money went.
- natas 4y agoIf I had only one lens, it would be a 50mm prime. I have 3, mind you, a 35mm, 50mm and 90mm, but 99% of the time, I only attach the 50mm to the camera; zero regrets.
- mav88 4y agoI have the 50mm 1.4 from Canon and it's gorgeous. I also have a 50mm Summicron on my old Leica IIIf and it could have been made yesterday.
- Nav_Panel 4y ago50mm was pretty much the only lens I used for ages when I was shooting film. I had an old Pentax KX SLR (like the K1000 but with a few more bells & whistles), and a regular f/1.7 50mm manual focus lens -- and I loved it. Shot rolls and rolls of film. I highly recommend shooting old-school like this, as practice. After a while, you stop needing to meter, even, because you understand the light conditions and can pre-emptively configure the camera to do exactly what you want. Then, focus and shoot. The other thing shooting on film taught me is that one perfect photo is better than 100 bad ones. I find that digital photography natives tend to rely on burst features in an attempt to capture the right moment. But in my experience, especially with portraiture, waiting and then grabbing the precise moment can produce better results.
- wiredfool 4y agoSite says 2022, but I could have written this in 2007. With the addition of -- get the flash off the camera, and set the power manually. Off the camera makes the flash light define the shape of what you're shooting, and setting the power manually means no preflash -- so no blinks. Personally, I went from the 50 to a 40/2.8 which had a much faster focus speed and better build quality -- and I basically never shot wide open anyway because the focus plane would be so narrow as to be unusable. And the 100/2, which was just an awesome lens, good color, shape, everything. But in the intervening 15 years, DSLRs are now dead, mirrorless is hanging on, and basically, it's computational photography from phones. Best camera is the one you have and so that's where it's done. It doesn't hurt that Apple has more R/D budget for their phone than the entire legacy camera industry. But given the prices of the 5d on ebay now, I might must pick up the camera I lusted for then and couldn't afford, so that it can spend time gathering dust on the shelf like the other DSLRs.
- jeffbee 4y agoThese are still useful on a micro four-thirds body, just not in the way you might expect. With a speed booster, you reverse most of the magnification and throw a huge amount of light on those small sensors. A Nikon 50mm AF-D on a .71x speed booster and an m43 body is a disturbingly fast setup at ~70mm equivalent field of view. All that said, the state-of-the-art fast primes for the m43 systems have left the classic 50/1.4 in the dust. The performance of the Olympus 25mm f/1.2 is utterly amazing. The only quibble with the lens is it's huge.
- trap_goes_hot 4y agoModern lenses will always benefit from modern materials, design and manufacturing techniques. That said the benefits of M43 as a format are shrinking with the advent of small compact FF cameras. Your 25mm f/1.2 lens is equivalent (from a field-of-view and depth-of-field standpoint) to a full-frame 50mm f/2.4 lens or thereabouts.
- jeffbee 4y agoThe size of the m43 kit was never the benefit, to me. The first thing I did was add a grip because the Olympus body was too small. Then I added another grip so I can hold it the other way. Now it's as big as any 35mm I owned.
- trap_goes_hot 4y agoFair enough, but I'd wager most articles written about the benefits of the M43 format do bring up the size and weight savings compared to full frame systems. To me, the smaller sensor in M43 does have a few unique benefits over FF. * faster readout (less rolling-shutter) * less power-consumption and therefore less heat-generation (longer record-time limits, more power for computational photography) * less inertial mass for the sensor & assembly (better sensor-stabilization for hand-held video) * higher wafer yield in manufacturing (hopefully lower cost , if economies-of-scale allow for it)
- _ph_ 4y agoYou can get very compact 35mm bodies now, but lenses tended to grow in recent years to cope with the growing pixel counts. So overall a mFT kit will be significant smaller than 35mm unless you talk about a Leica M :) The Olympus 25/1.2 is a stunning lens, but certainly large for a mFT lens. it is still slightly smaller than a Leica 50/2 L-mount lens.
- throwaway290 4y agoIt's not the only take on the subject, and I actually think it's quite mistaken. 50mm is great for street portraits or fashion shots. This is where you 1) can't come too close to not spook the subject, 2) want tighter framing, 3) want to put your subject on a little bit of a pedestal so to speak, or 4) want to make a huge print out of your shot. However, for candid "photos of your own loved ones" as in the article, I think you'll find it a pain. In these circumstances I can't recommend enough a wide lens instead. Try both and make your conclusions. - On the surface a wide lens makes things look "farther away", but in fact what it does is emphasize the actual distances in the scene-- meaning with close-up shots it gives a strong sense of presence, which is presumably what you want. 50mm might be good for fashion portraits, but for shots like in TFA it's IMO way too long and puts unnecessary emotional distance between you and the subject (this was my first feeling when I looked at author's photos). - The article sidesteps the fact that F-number is not the only factor in motion blur. 1/8 second with a 21mm lens is not great but it'd look loads better than 1/8 with a 50mm lens that would be very unforgiving as far as any shake. - Framing and focusing is much less finicky. For casual snaps most of the time you don't even need to look at the screen: with close-ups it's self evident where the camera is facing, and if something is happening right now a little distance away just point your camera in the general direction and you'll most likely have it in frame. And if you have some time to frame for aesthetics, it's still easier because unlike a long lens with background separation a wide one wouldn't over-emphasize every object that happens to be near your subject. Get a prime lens compact like Ricoh GR, it's too wide for street portraits but your loved ones will not object if you occasionally use it in close proximity.
- klodolph 4y agoI cannot recommend a 35mm for close-up pictures of people. The perspective is too weird. I have a 35mm lens, I used it a lot, and it has its uses--and the main way I use it is to capture more of the room or more people when I'm taking pictures indoors. Going too close with it results in distorted pictures which is fine as an artistic choice but it's not the choice most people want to make. The Ricoh GR III has a 28mm equivalent, which puts it well into the "wide angle" category. You may like shooting with a 28mm FOV, or you may absolutely hate it. If you want to buy a camera like that, try it out first and see how you like it. > Meanwhile 50mm is good for fashion, It's really not. I would start at like 90mm equivalent for fashion or general portraiture (i.e. not candids).
- zokier 4y ago> The 50mm lens, once the mainstay of 35mm photography, has been all but forgotten by today’s photographers. > Before falling to its current level of disfavor, the 50mm lens had a long and distinguished pedigree umm, I'm pretty sure nifty-fiftys have been top recommendation always for people wanting to explore beyond the kit zoom. And quickly checking some camera stores, indeed, they are one of the top selling lenses around. Not really sure where author is getting the idea that it is some obscure forgotten relic.
- combatentropy 4y ago> I'm pretty sure nifty-fiftys have been top recommendation always for people wanting to explore beyond the kit zoom. His article isn't addressed to "people wanting to explore beyond the kit zoom". It's addressed to people who just finished unwrapping "that new 35mm camera kit you bought to document your child’s early years", who accepted the default lens and have only a foggy awareness of the pros and cons of different lenses. His article is meant to turn these people into "people wanting to explore beyond the kit zoom".
- uniqueuid 4y agoI could not agree more, and the reason is an empirical one: Looking back over the past 10 years, the best and most photos that I've taken were with a simple ~$300 Sigma 50mm f 1.4. I do have Canon L glass, but the bokeh and low-light speed just dominate most other considerations. There's also one super important benefit/limitation that I love: With a prime lens, you zoom with your feet. That's not actually bad, you just need to get in people's faces to have them close up. And that in and of itself (often) yields great shots.
- leephillips 4y agoThis first appeared no later than 2007¹, and is replete with mild anachronisms. I personally find this kind of silent re-purposing of old articles offensive; it adds chaos to scholarship and seems at least somewhat dishonest. ¹https://sunbane.com/gary-voth-photography-the-forgotten-lens/ https://sunbane.com/gary-voth-photography-the-forgotten-lens...
- Lio 4y agoI've had a couple of Fujifilm X100 cameras with their fixed prime lenses over the last few years. For me I've grown to love the 35mm eqv. focal length they provide. I have 50mm and 28mm eqv. converters for it but hardly ever use them. Recently I've really got into shooting landscapes with it, which is daft as no one shoots landscapes at 35mm. It would generally be regarded as not quite wide enough or not quite long enough. Still I think that's part of the appeal for me. Limiting yourself to just one fixed prime is, in a way, very liberating. It's one less thing to think about and it forces you to walk about to get the framing you want. Having said that if I was taking money to shoot someone's wedding again I would definitely break out my old Nikon DSLRs and a pair of zoom lens.
- isatty 4y agoI use A Fuji body as well (xe3) and also find the 35mm f/2 my go to lens (52mm FF equivalent). Fujinon glass is excellent so if you want to walk around on a vacation instead of a wedding I’d definitely just grab the 18-55 zoom instead.
- oktwtf 4y agoAgree 100%. I shoot on an xt3 and cannot believe the consistent sharp and clear images through the Fuji glass. Also the kit lens is fantastic, only thing I'd love is if it could reach a bit farther. I'm sure there is an upgrade out there for and arm and a leg... I have some old glass for my Pentax SP1000 which I was able to adapt to shoot on the new mirrorless. Some of the bookeh really is magical on those Super Takumar lenses. The crop is a bit of a mess, but photos are nice.
- pixelfarmer 4y agoOver time I ended up with 21, 35, and 90mm as my go-to lenses. I used the 35 for many years now, which includes landscape pictures. With that said, I also use 90mm for that, because landscape pretty much covers the whole focal length spectrum, not just wide angle. 50mm is only stuffed into the bag for when I don't have to optimize for weight and it makes sense to have it around (portraits in tighter spaces). In return, 50mm is usually cheaper than even 35mm options. On APS-C cameras this ends up being 75..80mm, which is already in the realm of portrait lenses, i.e. somewhat more restricted in its use than on FF bodies.
- azhenley 4y agoMy favorite normal lens is a Helios 44m-2 58mm f2. It is an old Russian knock off that produces a swirly background and glow effect. I bought two on eBay 8 years ago for maybe $30 each and connect it to my mirrorless body with a $9 adapter.
- Wistar 4y agoMy go to 50 is an odd, but extremely (razor) sharp, Canon 50mm f/2.5 compact macro. Sadly, it is no longer made. AF is slow and loud and prone to repeatedly hunting and missing focus but the images it makes, particularly portraits, are really good. On full-frame, it does have some loss of sharpness at the edges but on a 1.6 crop sensor camera it is simply great.
- oldstrangers 4y agoI love a good prime lens. Took this with a Sony FE 24mm f/1.4 (https://roambyland.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/ss-1-of-1-21.jpg https://roambyland.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/ss-1-of-1-...). 50mm is probably too 'in the middle' for my uses, as a 24 + 70-200 has really replaced my need for a 50, and the ability add in a little compression of the foreground with the zoom is really nice. If I had infinite space in my bags I'd have a 50 for sure. If I was just using one camera I'd still probably want a 24 or 28 prime (ie: Leica Q2).
- ghaff 4y agoYou could historically get pretty fast 50mm lenses with good optical quality for relatively little. Not sure of technical reasons why 50mm fell into that standard role. If I had to pick one standard prime lens it would probably be 35mm.
- _ph_ 4y agoOn the other side, the neutral way, the 50 renders szenes is the appeal and the challenge for the photographer. A wide-angle or strong tele lens add a lot to the picture themselves, by their extreme angles of view. The 50 does nothing like that, puts all the burdon on to the photographer. Yet, a lot of the most iconic pictures have been taken by a 50.
- oldstrangers 4y agoI'm not sure I'd call using a 50 a burden on the photographer, I think they're probably a lot more intuitive for most photographers. A 50 was the first lens I bought during school, and it was widely regarded as the preferred lens for photography classes from beginner to advanced. I love the 50, I just personally don't have much use for one currently.
- _ph_ 4y agoI haven't said burden, but a challenge. Because the lense won't create fancy effects on its own. It is purely the task of the photographer to make something out of it. That was in answer to the post which preferred wider and longer lenses because of their effects. Yes, a 50 should be intuitive to use.
- FortiDude 4y agoMy brain sees in 4:3 40mm, 50mm on 3:2 cameras feels too crammed
- aimor 4y agoWhat's limiting new digital cameras from becoming faster? A decade ago a friend showed me his digital camera with an ISO setting in the thousands and I was amazed at how little noise there was. I've since been a little disappointed that I'm still balancing noise and aperture shooting indoors. Phones take on the problem with heavy image processing, but I'm interested in hardware solutions.
- excite1997 4y agoWhat do you mean? The current crop of high-end cameras is absolutely amazing in that respect. Take Canon R5, where usable ISO settings extend at least to 32,000 (and the upper limit is 102,400).
- astrange 4y agoIs the a7s not fast enough for you? Shooting indoors is unfixable because there isn’t full spectrum light; you’ll have to make up some of the missing colors eventually.
- adrr 4y agoYou need lower pixel counts on the sensor for better ISO performance. Larger the sensor pixels, more light they get. Sony A7S have low pixel sensors and have performance better than a human eye. Night time shots with a full moon look like it’s a day time shot.
- aaronbrethorst 4y agoIf you have an SLR or mirrorless camera, don't yet own any prime lenses (a lens that doesn't zoom), and you want your photographs to get a lot better very quickly, go buy the 50mm f/1.8 lens your camera manufacturer makes and only use that for a couple months.
- astrange 4y agoMirrorless cameras don’t care what brand their lenses are and 50mm is easy to manual focus. You can get an old Canon FD lens anywhere.
- The_Colonel 4y ago> 50mm is easy to manual focus It's not. Especially at f/1.4.
- jetrink 4y agoHave you ever used a manual focus lens on a mirrorless camera with focus-peaking[1] on? It's so easy to focus, it feels like cheating. It makes a 50mm usable wide open. (This is assuming your subject is relatively static or at least cooperative. Small children and animals really benefit from autofocus or a smaller aperture.) 1. For those unfamiliar with the term, focus peaking is a feature of most mirrorless cameras that highlights areas of the image that are in focus, usually in bright red. It makes it very intuitive to adjust the focus precisely, so much so that you soon find yourself subconsciously making fine adjustments by leaning slightly forward or back, rather than manipulating the lens.
- The_Colonel 4y agoYes, I used many manual lenses on my Fuji XT-10 and XT-2 - 12mm f/2, 35mm f/1.2, 56mm f/1.4 (all crop of course) among others. The only one I would say was easy was the 12mm (for obvious reasons). > This is assuming your subject is relatively static or at least cooperative. Well, there you go, that's a pretty important caveat. It makes e.g. candid photography pretty challenging.
- rkuska 4y agoMy favourite portable cheap full frame lense is 40mm summicron (yeah cheap and summicron, weird right?) https://www.35mmc.com/02/04/2016/leica-40mm-summicron-review/ https://www.35mmc.com/02/04/2016/leica-40mm-summicron-review...
- Finnucane 4y agoBecause I am old I grew up when zoom lenses generally were not good. So I always used prime lenses. Even now, when intellectually I know that thanks to fancy glass and cad-cam methods, zoom lenses are much better than they used to be, I still tend not to use them. But lately I tend to use either a 28 or 85 rather than the 50.
- hengheng 4y agoI've outgrown it, personally. For that "natural" perspective, 35mm is still wide enough to shoot a scene "the way you see it", but it can still be surprisingly intimate. And for the "portrait" thing, anything 70-100mm is a sweet spot. 50mm is trying to split the difference between both scenarios but doesn't really achieve either. So personally, I'm more likely to carry a 35+85 duo. Or in fact, a 50mm f/1.8 on an APS-C crop camera along with my smartphone. Or, a smartphone with a portrait lens. I just zoom in from the default 24mm a lot of times, that's it. From a tech point of view, 50mm is the easiest lens to build. That's why they used to be on everything. Not because they're useful. A symmetric double gauss setup with six lenses is kinda straightforward and it works okay, it even becomes excellent once stopped down. Sharp 35mm lenses that are also fast can only be built with aspherical lenses, so traditionally it wasn't really possible to build fast ones that are also good. Recent ones are excellent, but as always, many photographers refuse to go with the times, and they'll repeat decade old advice. (TL;DR: Smartphones do a lot of things right, and their evolution was backed by data. They first went from 28mm to 24mm, added 16mm second, then added 75mm third, and only then did they add 48mm as a 2x zoom into the 24mm camera. It's neat, but not essential.)
- adrr 4y ago50mm is my least used lens. I don’t even bother carrying it on trips. Like you said portrait is 70mm or higher. Landscape I use 24mm. 24 to 70 2.8 is the best lens because it can do landscapes and portraits. I may carry a fast prime lens if I am shooting indoors.
- _HMCB_ 4y agoI very much agree with this article. As someone relatively new to photography (less than four years), prime lenses have allowed me better quality for less money with a wider variation of lenses/applications. 20mm for architecture and interiors; 50mm for street or environmental portraits; 85mm for beautiful rather close-up portraits; 105mm macro for product shots and mid-range portraits.
- adrian_b 4y ago> "The 50mm lens is called a “normal” or “standard” lens because the way it renders perspective closely matches that of the human eye." This sentence is confusing and wrong. A perspective that "closely matches that of the human eye" has nothing to do with the focal distance of a lens. Such a perspective is obtained whenever you look at a photograph from such a distance so that you will see it under the same angle under which it has been seen by the photo camera. For a normal 50 mm lens, that means that you must look at a 4:3 photograph from a distance about twice the height of the photograph, e.g. from about 60 cm when looking at a photograph whose height is 30 cm and whose width is 40 cm. The normal focal length of around 50 mm has been chosen after some experiments about which is the maximum vision angle under which a painting or photograph can be seen, when looking at the complete ensemble, and not at details, while being able to perceive correctly the perspective relationships inside the image. The conclusion was that the aspect ratio must be around 4:3 and the viewing distance about twice the image height. So it is a distance that feels comfortable for humans when looking at the entire image. Being much farther away diminishes the perception of small details, while being much closer makes difficult the perception of the complete image simultaneously. When a photograph is taken with a wide-angular lens, one would have to look at the image from a too small distance, to match the original perspective. When a photograph is taken with a long-focus lens, one would have to look at the photograph from too far away, to match the original perspective. N.B. The correct viewing distance for the normal perspective is from about twice the height of the image. I have no idea who has originated the very widespread myth that the right distance is the diagonal of the image. A computation for either 4:3 or 3:2 images would show that their diagonals are much less than 50 mm, when viewed from the corresponding angle of a normal lens (e.g. the diagonal of a 36 mm x 24 mm image is 43 mm). Moreover, 50 mm is at the lower limit of the normal focal lengths. Many normal camera lenses had slightly longer focal lengths, up to 54 mm, or even 56 mm, which were even farther from the diagonal lengths of the images.
- petargyurov 4y agoThis is good timing -- I am literally in the middle of researching lenses and film SLR cameras for a beginner -- I'm looking to get into film photography. Anyone here have recommendations? I am currently reading about the Olympus OM-1 and it all sounds great apart from the lack of exposure compensation (but that might just teach me the hard way).
- wuyishan 4y agoHave a look at the Fujifilm X-S10 https://fujifilm-x.com/en-sg/products/cameras/x-s10/ https://fujifilm-x.com/en-sg/products/cameras/x-s10/ I like it a lot.
- q-base 4y agoGet a Nikon FE! There are tons of cheap Nikon glass. It has exposure compensation as you mention. It has a brilliant way of turning of the light meter so it won't drain your battery, when not in use and is just an overall pleasure to use. Some of my best photographs has been captured on my Nikon FE. https://www.35mmc.com/10/02/2022/appreciating-what-you-already-have-with-nikon-fe-and-fuji-c200-by-jesper-reiche/ https://www.35mmc.com/10/02/2022/appreciating-what-you-alrea...
- copperx 4y agoI have a Nikon FE with a 50mm prime, it's great. Would you mind sharing how do you process and scan you photos?
- q-base 4y agoI have a 50mm prime as well, which is what I shot the images with. I have a lab locally process and scan the images. So unfortunately I do not have any further details about ingredients etc.
- twic 4y agoI bought a Canon A-1 in order to (re)learn shooting with film. I haven't used it intensively, but i have been happy with it. It's a bit later than the OM-1, so has electronic metering, including exposure compensation. I was drawn towards a Canon by the abundant supply of second-hand old lenses for it. Nikon's old lenses are still (somewhat) compatible with their modern cameras, so they are more expensive; other manufacturers' lenses are a little harder to come by.
- combatentropy 4y agoThis article was actually published more than 20 years ago, https://web.archive.org/web/20020603153119/http://vothphoto.com/spotlight.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20020603153119/http://vothphoto.... Some of its advice is timeless, but its context is back when your phone did not take great pictures. Instead, most people carried around no camera at all, and events went undocumented. Then, among people who decided they wanted to take pictures of wherever they were going, they bought point-and-shoots, which did not let you change the lens. Then, for those wanted to get serious, there were entry-level DSLRs, which often were sold with a bag and a kit lens, and for the vast majority of these owners, the thought of buying another lens seldom crossed their minds. In short, this article is meant to expose the problem to people who did not even know they had a problem, and to offer a solution that was last thing they would have guessed. (I don't think the author meant to mislead us about the original date of publication. It looks like he recently moved everything to Wordpress and may not be savvy enough to fix the date.)
- hellisothers 4y agoArguably your phone still doesn’t take great pictures in the situation the author is describing: indoors, medium to low light. In this situation the advice is still timeless, a camera with a 50mm ~f1.4 can create a truly great photo (skills outstanding), while the best phone will still produce a “good” photo.
- sunsunsunsun 4y agoThe biggest difference is that most phone cameras are still far too wide, they are just terrible for portraits. A few cameras have 50mm equivalent zoom lenses but most seems to go wide+ultrawide.
- yakubin 4y agoI have an iPhone 13 Mini and in those conditions it will never take even a good photo. To make anything even half-decent excellent light is needed. When I look online at those articles-ads about phones being great at photography now they use a combination of great light and a boatload of RAW editing. Plus you need to mind that it’s the standard problem of people saying they don’t hear the fans of their computer, don’t see the tearing in X, and finally don’t see the loads of noise and loss of sharpness in phone photos. Discussing those things is basically futile. As a side note, a touch screen is never going to be able to compete with the comfort of physical buttons on my DSLR.
- noncoml 4y agoI have a tons of cameras and lenses from Nikon, Sony, and Canon, but yet I find myself just picking up the x100f no matter what the occasion is.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- TomK32 4y agoIt's an old piece and maybe not of of the famous lenses, but all I could afford in the late oughts: A Konica Autoreflex T4 with the 50mm/1.8 pancake and I did some great photos with it. Nowadays I often use it on a modern 4/3rds with an adapter (not so pancake) and still gives me a nice handling.
- Marazan 4y ago50mm prime is like a cheat code for photography. Slapping one on my camera improved my shots by an order of magnitude
- regular 4y agoIt should be noted that if you're using an APS-C (or Super-35mm for motion pictures) sensor, the 35mm is your "normal" lens.
- ISL 4y agoIf pointing someone to a single "normal" lens as a prime, I'd point them to a 40mm, not a 50. When I work with a 50 (which I very much enjoy; used one yesterday), I find that it is tighter in composition than my normal field of view. The 40 much-better matches my own perception and experience. The 50 is a more-careful tool. 35 is a little wide for me (but perfect for human/photojournalism work). If you want to try out a 40, there are great pancake lenses out there at relatively low cost. The Canon 40mm STM (recently discontinued) and Fuji 27mm are the smallest lenses made by their manufacturers -- cheap, sharp, fast, flexible. Edit to add: For the specific case of environmental portraiture of kids, I'd probably trend toward a 35 and perhaps even a 28 (the focal length-equivalent on the Google Pixel 3a and 4a and the Q/Q2). The perspective with which we perceive the experience of being a kid is a close and intimate one.
- SECProto 4y ago> If pointing someone to a single "normal" lens as a prime, I'd point them to a 40mm, not a 50. The article does have a section on exactly the issue (FOV) you note - it identifies that the 50mm lens is not the same with modern cameras (which have smaller sensors than 35mm film cameras), and recommends a 35mm lens for these cameras. Personally, I have a 35mm prime lens and quite like it, and I think it did help me improve my skills when I can't just zoom to get what I want in frame.
- exmadscientist 4y agoThere are two issues here. One is just the usual crop factor stuff. Photographers seem to have real problems dealing with this (probably thanks to the original sin of some marketer somewhere), but they have always and will always suffer from that. If you quote focal lengths in "mmeq" (35mm film frame equivalent focal length) then this problem goes into the background and stays there, out of focus, until the next thread of people talking past each other on a photography forum. The second issue is that the normal lens focal length for a 35mm film frame, by the most common definition, is actually 43mm. There are, of course, other definitions. https://medium.com/ice-cream-geometry/what-is-a-normal-lens-35mm-50mm-43mm-compared-to-the-human-eye-cf7e43cc3366 https://medium.com/ice-cream-geometry/what-is-a-normal-lens-... seems like a good discussion but I admit to having just skimmed it. So neither 35mm nor 50mm is particularly great. My X100V has a 35mmeq prime lens and I often find myself wishing it was a little narrower. (Though of course I might be saying the opposite if it were actually 50mmeq....)
- cat_plus_plus 4y ago> As your spouse proudly holds the baby up you raise the camera to your eye. How did you just happen to have the camera with the right lense right at the moment? For truly spur of the moment, have to use whatever you have at hand and not worry about tech, usually a cell phone. > The viewfinder seems a little dim in the room light On the other hand if you have a little more time, just click live button and tap viewscreen to focus (or get a camera with electronic viewfinder that brightens things up for you, though good ones are expensive). In time sensitive situations, larger F stop is your friend because your main subject is likely to be reasonably focused. Might get noise from high ISO, but these days noise removal / shadow brightening is pretty powerful in post-processing providing you shoot RAW. > There is a difference of approximately 3.5 stops between f/1.8, the typical maximum aperture for an entry-level 50mm lens, and f/5.6, the typical maximum aperture at the portrait end of a “consumer” zoom. This is a huge difference in practice. I love a couple of old manual lenses I have, but these require careful scene planning to ensure focus is on the correct thing and background is far away to be properly blurred, the opposite of "kid is smiling" situation in the article. For those, I keep 18-135 lens on by default so I can shoot a large group of friends from short distance or a bird on the tree at short notice.
- hef19898 4y agoA 50 mm is one of my special occasion lenses, the others being a 80-200 and a 300, the latter often combined with a TC. The 50 is great for low light, for street photography and small enough to carry with you. Street ohotography because you stand out much less with a DSLR without battery grip and a lens as small as a 50 mm. Low light, because of f1.8. The one lense that is on most of the time, especially when travelling, is a 24-120. I still would recommend a 50mm, simply for its convenience, low light performance, small size, incredible sharpness, speedy AF and beautiful image characteristics from backgrounds to sun stars.
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoSure, I can live with a 24mm (38.4mm translated from crop sensor) if I know for sure I am going to be indoors or in close quarters / shooting large objects. But distance quickly becomes an issue, not always possible to access interesting areas or walk there in time. So for unknown situations helps to have a decent zoom range, even at the expense of having to shoot with higher ISO.
- simonblack 4y agoI paid a lot of money for a super-duper zoom lens, way back when. But I kept leaving that zoom lens in my bag and using only the 'standard' 50mm lens because it was a far better lens. Today we use crappy phone lenses and force ourselves to think that they're wonderful, but I have very fond memories of that Canon 50mm lens on my Canon film camera.
- CydeWeys 4y agoA few caveats to this. One, the recommended 50mm focal length lens here is specific to full-frame cameras with 35mm sensors. If you have an APS-C camera, which is quite common, then you want a ~32mm lens, and if you use M4/3 like I do, then you want a 25mm lens, to achieve this same effect. Of course it's a lot simpler to abstract away the camera sensor size and simply look at field of view, which for a 50mm full-frame lens is about 40 degrees. This is actually not that much; it's quite "zoomed-in" in appearance compared to everything you can see at once through your eyes, which is at least 90 degrees field of view plus more for your peripheral vision. So the following quote from the article is definitely inaccurate: > The 50mm lens is called a “normal” or “standard” lens because the way it renders perspective closely matches that of the human eye. To really match the experience of being there, you need an ultrawide lens to capture the full human field of view. The 40 degree field of view of a nifty fifty is like looking through a narrow doggy cone of shame.
- SpaceInvader 4y ago> If you have an APS-C camera, which is quite common, then you want a ~32mm lens, and if you use M4/3 like I do, then you want a 25mm lens, to achieve this same effect. It's not the same effect, far from it. It's different focal length, that will render different image.
- wilsonjholmes 4y agoWould you mind explaining or offering resources on understanding why it is different? I have a M43 camera as well, and I have always just halved the focal length and aperature I want a lens to be on my system to be a roughly equivalent match to the full frame performance I am trying to emulate.
- SpaceInvader 4y agoI'll try :) Generally speaking focal length is a characteristics of a lens which does not change, if you use smaller sensor you're just "cropping" what given focal length would render. For example if you'd have, let's say 100mpix camera and 24mm lens it would give you different perspective than 85mm evn if you would crop 24mm image to have same angle of view as 85mm.
- rixrax 4y agoMy cell phone has become my normal lens. New phones from both Apple and Google take such a good photos that literally all my street photography is shot with them. I'll grab my trusty A7r4 /w either wide or very long variety of lenses if I will be going to some special place etc. with specific purpose of shooting something that is (in my opinion that is) worth recording in the detail only achievable with this gear. But other than some far and few grand landscapes or wildlife, most of my most amazing(?) photos nowadays come from my cell phone. Case in point - was driving last night along the city street and was passing this church/graveyard which just looked amazingly spooky in the dark/fog/street lighting; stopped my car in the middle of the street, rolled down the window, and snapped couple of (raw) photos with the phone before driving away. Because the phone is with me all the time, it has become my new normal lens.
- contingencies 4y agoList of Canon 50mm lenses: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canon_EF_50mm_lens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canon_EF_50mm_lens The cheapest Canon 50mm, EF50mm f/1.8 II, is affectionately called "plastic fantastic" or "nifty fifty" and is super cheap.
- sizzzzlerz 4y agoI've been using 3 'L'-series Canon zoom lenses to cover 16mm to 400mm and been very pleased with their performance as an amateur landscape/wildlife photographer having come to grips with their cost and weight. I recently bought an new, inexpensive 50mm/f1.8 lens off E-bay and spent a day shooting flowers at a local municipal rose garden and had an absolute blast. When I loaded my images onto the computer and had my first real chance to review them, I was very impressed. They're tack sharp, great color balance, and absolutely no vignetting in the corners. It's a perfectly usable lens in the right circumstances and I'll find a place for it in my bag.
- graycat 4y agoI have a sack full of just gorgeous Nikon lenses and camera 'backs'. But the backs are all single lens reflex for 35 mm film. I have nothing that uses CCDs (charge coupled devices, solid state, electronic photon captures). But the lenses are just gorgeous. Is there any way I can get a modern camera back, electronic, with a CCD or some such photon capture means, etc. that will let me exploit my old lenses, including, right, a just gorgeous 50 mm lens, a 108 mm, a 200 mm, etc.? So, the modern camera back need not have a mirror and, instead, show in the view finder what it sees via its CCD sensors.
- graycat 4y agoGee, I didn't get any answers to my question. So, I did some investigating, and, yes, now there is a theme in both still photography and movie making: Don't use any film. Instead, detect the photons with an electronic sensor, i.e., a thin little rectangle of CCDs (charge coupled devices). And for what used to be a view finder, just use the data from the sensor. So, these are all digital cameras (camera backs), that is, use an electronic sensor and use no film. Now a big example of this theme is the smart phone, either iPhone from Apple or an Android phone. It's possible to make movies with a smart phone. But now an example of a high end camera for movie making is from a company Red (this investigation today was the first I ever heard of it), and one of their cameras can cost $30,000. Apparently compared with a smart phone, a Red video camera can have more pixels in the sensor, more dynamic range, and a higher frame rate. And, yes, there are digital camera backs by Nikon, some of the other, old still image camera makers, and even Sony as I recall relatively new to cameras. For my question about my old Nikon lenses: The old lenses were designed to work with the famous SLR (single lens reflex) Nikon F camera of 1959. The SLR meant that for the view finder, a mirror moved down, behind the lens, and in front of the film, and kicked the image up to a prism and into the view finder. So, this way the view finder showed essentially exactly what the film would see when a picture was shot at which time the mirror pivoted up and out of the way of the light to the film and a shutter over the film moved and exposed the film. So, the many lenses for the Nikon F camera were called F series lenses. Well, my collection of Nikon lenses are all Nikon F series. Now Nikon has some digital camera backs that can still use F series lenses. These cameras are called FX or full frame cameras, and, yes, the sensor is about the same size, width and height in millimeters, as old 35 mm film. Some of these are SLR, that is, have a mirror. The Nikon D650 is an example. But Nikon also has a new series of digital camera backs with, right, no mirror, called their Z series. These are also full frame and can use F series lenses but to do so need a tube between the back of the lens and front of the camera back. So, to use my old Nikon lenses with a digital camera, I could buy a D650 digital SLR camera back or a Z series camera back with an adapter tube. The sensors commonly have either ~24 million pixels or ~48 million pixels. And there is some question about the dynamic range of the pixels. It appears that there is an engineering problem of handling the data rates of 48 million pixels per frame, with a lot of dynamic range (bits) per pixels, at a high frame rate, say, 60 or 120 frames per second for slow motion. Another theme for these digital still cameras is to be able to take enough frames (exposures) per second to become essentially movie cameras. It appears that this engineering problem is slowing progress of these former still image cameras to being good movie cameras. It appears that the Nikon Z series camera backs have little or no traditional optics, that is, lenses, mirrors, or prisms, and, instead, are all electronic or nearly so. E.g., the view finder is replaced by a small video screen. Well, IMHO, any such all electronic device is highly vulnerable to rapidly falling prices. So, I would guess that the Z series prices will have to fall. Soooo, if I get a digital camera back that will accept my F series lenses, I should go for a cheap one; for something more capable I should wait until prices come way down.
- coldtea 4y agoI think 35mm is even better, as it's more versatile in both wide and close scenarios (and 40mm is closer to actual human angle of view than 50mm).
- oliwarner 4y agoThe Nifty Fifty is a forgotten lens? Since when? It's a classic, super cheap and usually very fast prime that's a recommended starter prime on every photography website I've ever visited.
- mig39 4y agoI use my 50mm on a Canon full frame SLR for video. It's really great for "interview-style" videos.
- girvo 4y ago> It's a classic, super cheap Tell that to Fujifilm's X-Mount 33mm (APS-C so 50mm equiv.) haha -- but man its fantastic glass even if it is $1400 AUD Though they have their 35mm WR lens thats a third the price, which is super cheap for the glass quality in my opinion. And you can always slap some older 35mm glass on it with adapters, if you don't mind giving up autofocus.
- dividedbyzero 4y agoThere is also a 33mm/f1.4 from Viltrox that has autofocus. I haven't used it (my Fuji 35/1.4 has to do) but I own their 56mm/f1.4 and I'm very happy with that particular lens.
- girvo 4y agoOooh I hadn’t seen the Viltrox! Good shout, I might get one.
- LegitShady 4y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20020606074506/http://vothphoto.com/spotlight/articles/forgotten-lens.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20020606074506/http://vothphoto.... Title should be updated with the original year of publication (2002)
- bambax 4y ago> Many of the world’s most evocative and best-known images were made under natural light with fast lenses and film. Creating such images is nearly impossible with “slow” zoom lenses, which are harder to focus and inadequate for use indoors without flash. When I started doing photography 40 years ago, 400 ISO was considered crazy fast. I used Velvia 50 ASA most of the time for its amazing colors and depth. Nowadays with a digital camera, 10 000 or even 12 000 (16 000?) ASA can produce usable pictures, if a little grainy. "AI" post-production tools can add bokeh or even refocus something after the fact. I too love the 50mm. But times change.
- lm28469 4y ago> 10 000 or even 12 000 (16 000?) ASA I'm happy up to iso 32k/50k with my m10 monochrom
- kloch 4y agoMost 50's, at least down to f1.4 were designed or based on designs from the 1960's. They have really awful optical qualities by modern lens standards. Of course a good photographer will tell you great photographs have little to do with the camera/lens and everything to do with lighting, framing, subject etc but still...
- lm28469 4y agoI'm using a 60 years old lens on a 41mp monochrome sensor and it resolves skin pores and the micro hairs you have on your face from 5 meters away wide open 50mm lenses design didn't change much for decades because it was already very very good and still is very good
- kennybrea 4y agoI'm a touch strapped for cash so I can't afford to get a 25mm prime for my MFT. But I have a 20mm "pancake" prime that works in really tight situations where I don't really need people to realise there's a camera pointed at them. I have an older Canon AE-1 that I picked up a 50mm however and it's my favourite "go outside and shoot" lenses. Beyond the benefits that the article is citing, it's missing one of the greatest advantages of these lower focal length lenses is being able to have the lens not extend too far from your body. It's a bit dramatic - but you're kind of part of the action instead of a million miles away.
- werber 4y agoI think a prime is essential and I love that this thread has all the crop factor information already but I think finding the right prime for you is very important. You might want something higher if your shooting style is being more detached from what you’re sitting. I shoot with a 22 because I like being very close to the people I’m shooting but like a wider shot. Some people switch lenses and Whole cameras during a shoot. Experiment with what works with your style
- DeathArrow 4y ago50mm f/1.4 is the first lens I buy with a new camera system. To get good photos of human subjects you need to use a fast enough shutter speed 1/125 or 1/160. Here a fast lens comes handy in dim light. If you direct the subject and he is posing, then you can get away with 1/15 if you have steady hands, optical stabilization and you are willing to take more shots. It's important to have a camera with a fast and accurate focusing system and a fast focusing lens. If the light is scarce, you can use strobes and light modifiers such as soft boxes. Image quality is a function of exposure which is a function of shutter speed, aperture and scene illumination. The more photons are hitting the sensor, the better.