5 ms·
Somali Law (2013)
- AntiRemoteWork 4y ago
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agohttps://archive.ph/mMi2e https://archive.ph/mMi2e
- jiscariot 4y agoI read much of this a while back and really enjoyed the section on "pirate law". http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Legal%20Systems/LegalSystemsContents.htm http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Legal%20Systems/LegalSystemsCo...
- O__________O 4y agoRelated Wikipedia on Pirate Code: https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirate_code https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirate_code
- bewaretheirs 4y agoThis is part of his "Legal Systems Very Different From Ours" which was originally a college-level course and is also available as a book. See also: http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Course_Pages/legal_systems_very_different_12/LegalSystemsDraft.html http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Course_Pages/legal_sy... It was subsequently parodied here: https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/03/30/legal-systems-very-different-from-ours-because-i-just-made-them-up/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/03/30/legal-systems-very-dif...
- texaslonghorn5 4y ago> https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/03/30/legal-systems-very-different-from-ours-because-i-just-made-them-up/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/03/30/legal-systems-very-dif... > Finally the authorities handed down a change to the system: the plaintiff and defendant would agree on two lawyers to conduct the trial. Then the judge would flip a coin, and one of the two would be assigned at random to each party. This seems very interesting...I wonder what the game theoretic optimal strategy is and how the analysis would change if 1. the coin decides who picks first 2. the coin had a known bias and so on.
- bombcar 4y agoThis is a variation on the "splitting cake" - one child cuts the cake, the other has first pick.
- Drakim 4y agoHere is how I'd game the system: I'd sue somebody (like a neighbor) for violating my rights in some way. Then I'd bring a really bad lawyer to court, and take a 50/50 chance on giving that lawyer to my opponent. If I end up with the bad lawyer, I lose the case, and move onto my next victim.
- notahacker 4y agoIf lawyers have different levels of skill with respect to defence and prosecution, picking a strong defence lawyer with weak ability to prosecute is a pretty sound bet If I get my lawyer, I get a great defence lawyer to get me off all charges. If the other side get my lawyer, a great defence lawyer is doing a pretty inept job of trying to prosecute me.
- notahacker 4y agoI enjoyed that parody, but it kind of misses the most parody-able bit of all of the libertarian polycentric law research project; the general assumption that these systems are superior for not involving a state (not explicit here, but certainly true of David Friedman and Van Notten in general) "Examples throughout history prove the state is not only inherently evil, but also unnecessary to provide satisfactory legal resolutions. For example, in U̵t̵o̵p̵i̵a̵ Somaliland satisfactory resolutions are ensured by independent judges free to make up their own legal principles, murder is deterred by having suspected murderers' family members executed (if they're too poor to pay the fine), clans claim the right to extract larger fines for the same offence if committed by outsiders and judgements may either be accepted or enforced by vendetta"
- pessimizer 4y agoMight be interesting to note that the Somali courts united as a network (officially after 2000 or so) and became a real legal system that could have been the basis for a stable government, until the CIA destroyed the network for excluding its favorite warlords. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_Courts_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_Courts_Union
- notahacker 4y agoNot really, since the sharia-based Islamic Court Union that briefly established control over the Mogadishu region in 2006 in between the "Transitional Federal Government" periods was separate both conceptually and geographically from somewhat-secular Somali clan law in Somaliland/Puntland that Van Notten wrote about. (And much as there's a certain school of thought that's determined to make literally everything about the USA, I suspect the 30,000 Ethopian troops invading in support of the TFG had more impact on the ICU's collapse - and subsequent assimiliation into the new government - than anything the CIA or Bush government did)
- eyuelt 4y agoFor the record, Ethiopia's 2006 invasion of Somalia was US-backed. The US even participated in the conflict with airstrikes.
- pie_flavor 4y agoNote that a more recent edition of this page can be found here (warning, docx download): http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Legal%20Systems/Somali%20Law.docx http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Legal%20Systems/Somali%20Law.d... The index of updated docx chapters: http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Legal%20Systems/LegalSystemsContents.htm http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Legal%20Systems/LegalSystemsCo... The index of HTML chapters this link is for: http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Course_Pages/legal_systems_very_different_12/LegalSystemsDraft.html http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Course_Pages/legal_sy... My favorite chapters are probably the ones on Irish and Jewish law.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AS37 4y ago> If a fact is disputed, or supported by fewer than three witnesses, parties may be required to swear one of several different oaths to the truth of their position. One such oath consists of the oath-giver swearing by his marriage; if it later turns out that his oath was false, the marriage is dissolved. I hate to think what happens if you swear on your mother's life...
- kepler1 4y agoIsn't it interesting how the social or traditional rules of a people, the software, if you will, are a big factor in whether the country will be successful or not?
- seneca 4y agoThat seems like the obvious null hypothesis. To me, the interesting thing is how many people are in denial of that basic fact.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoso the "null hypothesis" specifically is the opposite of that.
- rayiner 4y agoWhat’s especially interesting is that so many people in Silicon Valley who know culture matters for companies purport to believe that culture doesn’t matter for social groups.
- wumpus 4y agoThat was the basis of "Social Darwinism", which turned out to be a terrible fit to reality.
- pr337h4m 4y agoBy the same author: http://www.daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf http://www.daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf
- analog31 4y agoIt would be interesting to know how successful the system was. I read a translation of the Icelandic Njal's Saga which deals with the traditional Icelandic legal system. What the book describes is basically a decades long blood feud. They had a system of fines for offenses including murder, but the verdicts never settled anything and they just kept killing one another as bags of money went back and forth.
- nkurz 4y agoAn acquaintance on another forum suggested this relevant passage from Friedman's "Machinery of Freedom" [1]: There is a scene in Njal's Saga that provides striking evidence of this stability. Conflict between two groups has become so intense that open fighting threatens to break out in the middle of the court. A leader of one faction asks a benevolent neutral what he will do for them in case of a fight. He replies that if they start losing he will help them, and if they are winning he will break up the fight before they kill more men than they can afford. Even when the system appears to be breaking down, it is still assumed that every enemy killed must eventually be paid for. The reason is obvious enough; each man killed will have friends and relations who are still neutral— and will remain neutral if and only if the killing is made up for by an appropriate wergeld. Our main sources of information on the Icelandic system are the sagas, a group of histories and historical novels written in Iceland, mostly in the late thirteenth and early fourteenth centuries. On first reading, they seem to describe quite a violent society. That is hardly surprising. At least since Homer, the spectacle of people killing each other has been one of the principal ways in which writers entertain their audience. The chief innovation of the saga writers was to spend as much time on law suits as on the violent conflicts that generated them. The one error in the quotation from Bryce with which I started this chapter is the claim that the chief occupation of Icelanders was killing each other. The chief occupation of the characters of the sagas appears to be suing each other; the killings merely provide something to litigate about. A more careful reading of the sagas tells a different story. The violence, unlike that in contemporary accounts elsewhere in Europe, is on a very small scale. The typical encounter in a saga feud involves only a handful of people on each side; everyone killed or injured is named. When two such encounters occur in consecutive chapters of a saga it seems as though the feuding is continual—until you notice that a character not yet born at the time of the first encounter is participating in the second as an adult. The saga writers telescope the action, skipping over the years that separate the interesting parts. [1] http://www.daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf http://www.daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf
- dang 4y agoRelated: Somali Law - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11318156 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11318156 - March 2016 (28 comments)
- slater 4y agoObligatory: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Ul-Efi1Xys https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Ul-Efi1Xys /s
- stevebmark 4y agoNo one here has commented on the content of the link, leading me to suspect none of the commenters have read it. Which makes sense, this is a short book’s worth of content. It doesn’t make sense for a HN post. For the 0.01% of folks who read it, what’s in it? Is it interesting?
- aamoscodes 4y agoTurns out it's actually a longer book: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11318933 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11318933 tldr political systems in other countries are different > Judges are not officials with a position and salary but arbitrators accepted by the disputants. A judge has no special rights,16 such as the right to summon or cross-examine a witness. Nor is the judge viewed as an authoritative source of law. His job is to settle conflicts by applying the rules that people in the community normally observe. A judge who produces verdicts that meet general disapproval is unlikely to be asked to judge cases in the future. > Neither politicians nor religious dignitaries are responsible for developing or interpreting the general law, and, as a rule, neither can function in the law as judge, witness, or enforcer. Folk wisdom includes the sayings “One can change one’s religion; one cannot change the law” and “Between religion and tradition, choose tradition.” It further goes into the intricacies of how conflicts are meant to be handled.
- Tomte 4y agoThis is medium-sized article (and about a fifth of its length are footnotes). What are you talking about? Have you ever seen long-form articles from the New Yorker or so?
- josephcsible 4y ago> For intentional murder, the penalty is a life for a life The death penalty for murder is understandable, even if you don't agree with it. > if the murderer succeeds in fleeing abroad, a member of his family of equal status may be put to death in his stead > if the killer escapes, his family owes two lives instead of one But killing other innocent people as a penalty for murder is indefensible, even if they are from the same family as the murderer.
- DuskStar 4y agoIt depends on perspective. We in the west generally have a "no innocent lives lost ever" perspective. But sometimes "minimize total societal damage" looks pretty good too. Is it better to live in a world where 1000 murders happen a year and half the murderers escape punishment because they ran, or one with 100 murders where 10 ran and family members were killed in their place? That's a lot less deaths! Nuclear MAD is an extreme example of this - it's very obviously immoral to kill a few million civilians in retaliation for the murder of other civilians. But that's what MAD is! And in practice, it's likely prevented millions of deaths due to war.
- captainmuon 4y agoThe problem is, it is not clear that deterrance works for very serious crimes like murder. AFAIK murder rates are the same or higher in countries with harsher penalties. I could imagine it is very difficult to determine how the causality is. To maximize societal peace, it might be more beneficial to completely tabooize killing another person (including death penalty) and deal in another way with murderers. It is also not clear if nuclear MAD actually "works". It is a convenient story to justify cold war security measures and military spending. The deterrance value of promising a second strike is high, but the actual military gain of performing the second strike is small. States are strongly incentivized to announce MAD, but to not actually go through with it. If you are defeated by a first strike and cannot win the war conventionally, it is more logical to surrender unconditionally than to render the world uninhabitable. When it was clear that Germany would lose WW2, Hitler issued the Nero Decree and ordered the self-destruction of German infrastructure, but even the radicalized Germans didn't go though with it. To add to this, the actual war plans of NATO and Warsaw Pact were centered around swift tank warfare in central Europe. Nuclear weapons were supposed to be used tactically, to deny ground and to destroy groups of tanks. But of course the US military preferred to talk about their awesome power to hit Russian cities, rather than about their plans to deploy nuclear mines in the middle of West Germany.
- yorwba 4y agoRe: "Dealing With Foreigners: A Case: The state of Ethiopia dealt with as a clan" The opposite also happens, with Ethiopia treating Somaliland as a centralized state and trying to find a single counterparty for cross-border cooperation to make things legible. E.g. when one private utility operator in Somaliland wanted to import electricity from the Ethiopian state-owned power company, the Ethiopian side urged the many different Somali utilities to form a single entity for the deal: https://www.capitalethiopia.com/2022/09/25/somaliland-forms-one-power-unit-to-receive-ethiopias-energy/ https://www.capitalethiopia.com/2022/09/25/somaliland-forms-...
- tomcam 4y agoIntroduces the term “Jiffo paying group“ without explanation, although it does explain the term “dia paying group“ or did I miss something
- camelboy 4y ago> The dia-paying group’s membership and internal rules are defined by explicit contract.12 In most cases it is made up of a number of jiffo-paying groups, each of which may consist of the descendants in the paternal line of a single common ancestor, or several such. The jiffo-paying group is a subset of dia-paying group
- tomcam 4y agoThat helps my comprehension a ton, thanks! Not sure why I missed it.
- lekanwang 4y agoBroadening out, this reminds me of one of the most eye-opening classes I've ever taken (and it was back in high-school!) -- Comparative Government/Politics: https://apcentral.collegeboard.org/media/pdf/ap-comparative-government-and-politics-course-and-exam-description.pdf https://apcentral.collegeboard.org/media/pdf/ap-comparative-... Was one of the few "see-the-matrix" moments I've had in my life.