5 ms·
In this particular case, I suspect a trademark complaint against Google would make sense. Google misrepresented the ad as the product of the Gimp project, and
by hedora 4y ago
In this particular case, I suspect a trademark complaint against Google would make sense.
Google misrepresented the ad as the product of the Gimp project, and were paid as a result. They usually use an "obeying the law would not scale" type argument in court, but that would clearly be bullshit in this case. They have a business relationship with the ad buyer, and should have verified their affiliation with gimp.org. Also, a simple string match on the URL would expose the attempted fraud on Google's end.
I'm not sure how to check if Gimp is a registered trademark in the US. This page kind of implies it might be (or that the author of the page does not understand trademarks):
https://www.gimp.org/about/selling.html https://www.gimp.org/about/selling.html
- dist1ll 4y ago> obeying the law would not scale I don't know why, but that sentence terrifies me. It's like the silicon valley version of a dystopia.
- henrydark 4y agoSome laws were put into place before the current internet scale was imagined and would probably not be made today
- harvey9 4y agoThat's still the exact same dystopian take: complying with the law is too hard for Google so the law should change to the detriment of smaller entities.
- plasticchris 4y agoSo it’s a valid defense to say complying with the law is hard, that’s why I didn’t? Shouldn’t the right course be to change the law before taking such actions?
- dbcurtis 4y agoIndeed. Saying: “Obeying the law doesn’t scale.” is an admission of guilt with pre-meditated intent to break the law. I keep hoping the courts will drive that point home at some point.
- pessimizer 4y agoIf you lead with the big ask, you frame the entire conversation around it. One should always start one's argument with question-begging, and disqualify people who don't accept the question begging as not serious about having a discussion. "The laws are impossible to follow at scale. How do we fix that." Or as a thinktank feeds it to a speechwriter to a politician: "Our antiquated laws have failed to keep up with the speed of technological development, and are now becoming an active handicap on progress. We need a set of laws that are as forward-thinking as our best selves hope to be, and a set of legislators that are responsive to the energy and creativity of the young while respecting the intelligence and hard-earned wisdom of the old."
- Aerroon 4y agoI think politicians might even be willing to try to do that, but I doubt that regular people would be on board with that. This would most likely involve permitting a lot of things in society that we consider immoral right now (or at least objectionable to some extent).
- Firmwarrior 4y agoIf you tried to buy ads claiming to be Google.com but pointing to shadyweb.xyzjsiebsk.net you'd find out real quick that Google's legal ability scales just fine
- dist1ll 4y agoWaiting for the law to change doesn't scale. Gotta be an asynchronous call. Just epoll the legislators.
- 4y ago
- femto113 4y agoInternet scale companies like Google happily embrace intellectual property laws when it's their IP on the line, they just don't care about anyone else's. And it's not an issue of "can't scale": Google's ad revenue is bigger than the entire GDP of Kentucky--they could literally hire 1% of the US population to work in fraud management and still turn a profit.
- badcarbine 4y agoHow would you manage a fraud department of 3 million people?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- duped 4y agoYour business doesn't have an inherent right to scale
- sweetbitter 4y agoThen your business is not actually scalable.
- j16sdiz 4y ago> I don't know why, but that sentence terrifies me. It's like the silicon valley version of a dystopia. because it is true. We have seen the same pattern in copyright infringement handling, spam or fake news control, user support...
- MereInterest 4y agoIt may be true, but why a judge or jury would accept it as justification is beyond me. "My business model requires me to break the law." is a condemnation of the business model, not a justification.
- Nextgrid 4y agoThe problem is that the legal system is flawed in such a way that the wronged parties rarely have the time & resources needed to actually put the issue in front of a judge. If it actually does get in front of a judge (in reality it would get settled out of court if it actually gets anywhere close) I would indeed expect their argument to fall apart. This is something that ideally the government (its consumer protection branches like the FTC) should be policing proactively, filing suits preemptively against systems that are trivially exploitable.
- ISL 4y agoAgreed -- there's also little recourse for many forms of online fraud, as there's no capacity for law-enforcement to investigate at scale.
- MereInterest 4y agoDefinitely agreed. I think it also stems from laws that define explicit and measurable harm as the only types of harm. For false advertising and fraud, it usually requires proving that they was financial harm done as the result of the false statements. Because creating an environment in which fraud is cheap and easy doesn't count as "harm". Because false advertising doesn't count as "harm" in itself, even as imposes the burden of scrutinizing all claims from previously trustworthy sources.
- somat 4y agoIt is the reason for the existence of the dmca. Now I take a rather dim view of the dmca. But the general concept is to move enforcement of the law out of the normal slow bureaucratic channels. Now enforcement is handled directly by the injured party. Much more efficient. If you immediately see how ripe for abuse this system is. congratulations. you are now more far sighted than the originators of this system. Now to it's credit, the dmca limits the enforcement(I think, I have never read the law) to a formalized version of "if you stop doing it we won't press charges" however this is still widely abused.
- nine_k 4y agoThere is a whole genre related to this kind of dystopias, cyberpunk. Its predictions from 1980s and 1990s turn out to be increasingly true, sometimes in the grim parts, too.
- zouhair 4y agoWe are already living in a dystopia.
- bogeholm 4y ago> “obeying the law would not scale” I’d love to see them trying that one out in an EU courtroom
- amscanne 4y ago> Also, a simple string match on the URL would expose the attempted fraud on Google's end. I feel like your general argument is proving too much: Google clearly indicated this is an Ad, and you couldn’t reasonably hold Google or any other publisher of ads responsible for every claim made in every ad. However, I agree that the domain part is troubling, and even seems like a potentially misleading representation by Google — I’m surprised you’re able to set this arbitrarily. However, as discussed in a thread below, maybe you can’t and this is exploiting an open redirect in gimp.org? I think some details would be needed before you can jump to assigning blame so quickly.
- account42 4y ago> and you couldn’t reasonably hold Google or any other publisher of ads responsible for every claim made in every ad. Why not?
- amscanne 4y agoThis simply ends advertising, and publishing generally. I’m not saying that gross negligence is okay, but I don’t think verifying every claim is a reasonable standard (it would be impossible).
- mcv 4y agoHaving the actual url be completely different from the displayed url simply shouldn't be possible. Allowing that invites scams like these. At the very least, they need to be the same domain.
- RamRodification 4y agoYes! This is crazy to me. How can this not be a thing that has already been discovered and instantly fixed?
- londons_explore 4y agoMany ad buyers are not-so-sophisticated... They might work for BigCo, but rather than have the ad point to bigco.com/product they instead have the ad point to tinyurl/bitly so they can track how many people click the ad and repoint it to another URL easily. There is a whole industry of these redirection services that gather stats, direct users different directions based on mobile/desktop or country. It isn't rare to bounce a user via a whole chain of them. To support all those users, ad networks have to allow the apparent URL and actual link target to differ.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoIf google gave a shit (obviously they don't) they could whitelist a few tinyurl/bitly/etc sites then follow those redirects themselves to verify they eventually landed on the displayed domain.
- mcv 4y agoNo, ad networks don't have to allow any of that. And they shouldn't. Ad buyers should either not track, or do it properly. Demanding massive security holes because you can't be bothered to learn the right way to do it is unreasonable.
- detaro 4y agoIt's a "feature". So you can link to blafoo.advertisinganalytics.com/weird-looking?tracking=link but what the user sees looks like normal and "safe" brand.com
- amelius 4y agoHow much money should they bring to successfully fight this case?
- echelon 4y agoAll ad companies need to respect trademarks and allow opt-out of reserved terms as a first class feature. It's disgusting that a competitor can buy an ad for your brand on Google, Apple, etc. and place their result before yours. This is especially harmful for new, up-and-coming companies. I've had competitors buy ads in our name before. It's a shameful tactic. It's beyond unfair when these monopoly-like ad companies spent hundreds of billions to co-opt the web and personal mobile computing and shackle us to this fate. It's the nightmare Microsoft and AOL once envisioned, yet now it's actually come to pass. We already pay for domains and trademarks. We shouldn't have to keep paying protection money to defend ourselves when we're already having to jump through the platforms' obtuse rules and pay their outrageous taxes. Trademarks should be sacred, and no company should be able to profit off of yours.
- BLKNSLVR 4y ago> "obeying the law would not scale" How can anyone argue against blocking ads when this argument is used literally in court as explanation for why they are unable to police the ads they're putting on their own platform?
- XCSme 4y ago> "obeying the law would not scale" Then don't scale...
- jonas21 4y agoGoogle does not allow trademark infringement in ads [1] and provides tools for trademark owners to prevent their trademarks from being used improperly. The issue here seems to be that the Gimp team does not have a registered trademark for "Gimp" (at least not in the U.S). This can be verified at the USPTO website [2]. [1] https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/6118 https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/6118 [2] https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/search https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/search
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- prokoudine 4y agoGIMP is not a registered trademark anywhere in the world. Unfortunately. Which made it possible for a number of scammers to be really bold (and be punished in the end, on one of the occasions).