12 ms·
Google Ad Disguising Itself as www.gimp.org
- LinuxBender 4y agoApparently the malicious ads are hidden when using uBlock [1] [1] - https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/ublock-origin/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/ublock-origin...
- yibers 4y agoThat's precisely the reason why I use uBlock
- tantalor 4y agoHappens for me. Ad says "gimp.org" but links to "gimp.monster". Reported.
- dwringer 4y agoWell, it just took me to "giipm.org", a remarkable 10 hours after this was originally posted. It shows "gimp.org" in the status bar when I highlight it with the mouse, but of course "copy link address" just gets a link going through www.googleadservices.com/pagead/ with some long hashes at the end.
- kevincox 4y agoIt looks like the Dropbox file at least 404s now. IDK if that is the attacker bailing out or Dropbox actually doing something faster even though it arguably didn't do anything wrong. But Google, the enabler is still sitting on its hands.
- thethethethe 4y agoI just tried it and now it is 'gilimp.org' The site looks legit
- pmoriarty 4y agoTo see the OP without enabling javascript: https://nitter.net/gimp_official/status/1586330082221510656 https://nitter.net/gimp_official/status/1586330082221510656
- Pathogen-David 4y agoThis is also a huge issue with Blender and pops up on /r/blender from time to time. (Here's a few random recent examples: https://redd.it/xxkx5s https://redd.it/xxkx5s https://redd.it/vvrxko https://redd.it/vvrxko https://redd.it/xwkky8 https://redd.it/xwkky8 https://redd.it/vuqu1r https://redd.it/vuqu1r) Ad networks and content providers get up in arms over widespread ad blocking but then allow stuff like this through.
- ilyt 4y agoYeah, blocking ads quickly became security improvement...
- hawski 4y agoAlways was. Does anyone remember the defacto original ad-blockers that blocking popups were? Firefox was marketed with this feature. It is basically a condom for the Internet. It makes maintenance for family computers much easier.
- geoduck14 4y agoBut if you block pop-ups, that web page with Rick Astley's cool video popping up won't play. /s
- axiolite 4y ago> Does anyone remember the defacto original ad-blockers that blocking popups were? I was using the Internet Junkbuster (and later: Privoxy) in the mid-90s, many years before that. https://web.archive.org/web/19961222061917/http://www.junkbusters.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/19961222061917/http://www.junkbu... Of course, back then you could just disable javascript in your web browser to protect yourself from malicious sites and annyances, and practically all sites would work perfectly fine.
- juunpp 4y agoGovernment does: https://www.nsa.gov/portals/75/documents/what-we-do/cybersecurity/professional-resources/csi-blocking-unnecessary-advertising-web-content.pdf?v=1 https://www.nsa.gov/portals/75/documents/what-we-do/cybersec... https://www.vice.com/en/article/93ypke/the-nsa-and-cia-use-ad-blockers-because-online-advertising-is-so-dangerous https://www.vice.com/en/article/93ypke/the-nsa-and-cia-use-a...
- captainmuon 4y agoHow is it even possible to spoof the shown URL?
- johnklos 4y agoPay Google money, and they'll let you do all sorts of things you're not supposed to do.
- kevincox 4y agoIt's just a setting in Google AdWords. The display URL and target URL are not related. You can also play tricks like a "tracking URL template" that is a URL that can be on another domain and receives the "target URL" as a parameter. It is expected to redirect to the correct URL, of course nothing enforces this other than a manual review. I can't believe that Google allows this but tracking is clearly more important to them than user security.
- ilyt 4y agoOf course it is, they live off ads.
- kevincox 4y agoYes, but people don't come to Google for ads, so they need to balance the benefits and harm to the users to avoid losing the traffic.
- meandmycode 4y agoKind of wild they don't require domain ownership proof in this case though, if I'm displaying one domain but actually linking to another, I should need to prove I own the original domain
- dwringer 4y agoI don't have as much a problem with them hiding the display url, but what shocks me is how it also masks the URL in the status bar. If I can right-click and copy the correct URL, then why isn't Chrome* showing me that URL down below? *Yeah, I know, I kind of answered my own question. So I guess it's rhetorical, and less shocking in retrospect.
- yubiox 4y agoPeople still haven't figured out to never click anything in that top ad section in search results?
- forgotpwd16 4y agoThose that have also figured that ad block is essential nowadays.
- 0x00000000 4y agoSome queries return like 75% ads
- tangus 4y agoObviously not, and nobody should have to learn that. Let's fight against fraud and deception and don't normalize them.
- dvngnt_ 4y agonothing new same thing happens with crypto searches. solution is to install adblock on every device
- indymike 4y agoNot to defend Google but this has been against Ad Words terms for as long as I can remember. It’s surprising they found a way to evade auto detection for this.
- kevincox 4y ago> against Ad Words terms Oh great, they'll get their account closed and need to make another one to continue scamming people. How about Google fixes this by displaying the URL that the ad actually goes to? Of course they don't want to do this because the URL with all of the tracking parameters looks ugly and it would hurt conversion rates. $$$ > user safety.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoTerms is just a document Google uses to absolve itself of all responsibility. Look! On this document nobody really reads it says we don't allow this. See? Not our fault that our advertising platform linked you to malware or to scam websites. The proper response is of course to ignore their excuses and block all advertising unconditionally.
- johndfsgdgdfg 4y agoThis is outrageous. We need to find a way to stop Google. Google invades our privacy. Google holds us hostages for more money. Now this? When is enough is enough?
- forgotpwd16 4y agoAs outrageous as a site having a leak or being hacked. As for what someone can do. It's simple. Don't use Google.
- qull 4y agoEasier said than done. It seems like 40 precent of sites or better use some sort of google service. Even if you arent 'using' google, you are being used by google.
- forgotpwd16 4y agoYeah, that's true. But you cannot do much about what a site decides to use. Maybe block every connection to Google servers which may break them. Can also stop using those sites as a protest.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoNot using google doesn’t mean they aren’t using you. Kind of like the mafia.
- pixl97 4y agoOne of the big problems here is when you cut out the big tech abusers you find out how hollow the internet has become.
- juunpp 4y agohttps://adnauseam.io/ https://adnauseam.io/
- theden 4y agoIMO checksums more or less offer a false sense of security for users if they're stored/shared on the same page/domain as the download, since it'd be trivial for a bad actor to change them if the files are compromised. Linux mint, for example, the attacker updated the checksums for the ISOs on the page when it was compromised https://www.infoworld.com/article/3036178/lesson-from-linux-mint-breach-trust-is-not-enough.html https://www.infoworld.com/article/3036178/lesson-from-linux-... I don't really have a solid solution to this, besides searching the checksum on google to see if it's listed anywhere else as a soft 3rd party check
- forgotpwd16 4y agoChecksums are meant to verify data integrity. Who ever said otherwise?
- theden 4y agoIt doesn't matter, people still use checksums as a signal to verify if a download has been tampered with
- segfaultbuserr 4y agoOpenPGP signing keys have similar problems. Web of Trust is useless if you don't know any developers to begin with, dates on public keys can be forged, and false signatures can be forged by creating a large number of other false keys. False keys can be made more misleading using 32-bit short Key ID collision (and don't blame OpenPGP for this, OpenPGP is notorious for its complexity but at least it tried, meanwhile alternative tools like OpenBSD's signify does not attempt to address this problem - these tools of course are simpler). Surprisingly, I think no attacker has ever forged a OpenPGP signature in a real-world security incident, likely because there's a lack of overlap between crypto nerds and crackers. Though, public keys do not change often and leave somewhat of an "audit trail". I usually search the key fingerprint on the web to see if it has been mentioned elsewhere as a quick check. Some projects store signing keys in an official upstream git repository. It's somewhat of a higher guarantee, but one can still creates a false upstream page for phishing... But I guess it's too much of an effort so nobody has tried to do this, yet. Thankfully, for distro users, it's only something for packagers to worry about, end users always receive verified packaged via the distro package manager.
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoIf it says gimp.org it should go there and nowhere else. Or at least validate ownership of the target domain.
- ahurmazda 4y agoAlso timely https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33383494 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33383494
- dehrmann 4y agoRemind me why Google even allows ads in rank 1 on brand terms? I remember when "don't be evil" Google would talk about how ads are in a different color on the right sidebar.
- lolinder 4y agoNot only do they allow it, they actively encourage it. They tell businesses that it's really important to buy ad space on searches for your own brand name so that a competitor doesn't. The way they say it really comes off like a protection racket. "Nice number one spot for searches for your brand name you have there, would be a shame if anything were to happen to it." They make people feel better about it by giving a steep discount over normal ads, but that doesn't make it less of a racket.
- taubek 4y agoBut if you have trademark for brand name you should be able to prevent others from using it, right? https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/2562124?hl=en https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/2562124?hl=en
- lolinder 4y agoI don't think that someone could actually use your brand name and get away with it long-term (though, short-term, as the original post evidences, isn't guaranteed) but a competitor can absolutely buy ad space trying to steal your customers. Like, if you search for "Nike" and Nike hasn't bought the branded ad space, you might get an ad for Adidas as the top result, with Nike's homepage the fourth item in the list.
- mnd999 4y agoTrademark law likely requires you to do so.
- kweingar 4y agoI noticed this on the App Store the other day. I searched for YouTube and the first result was TikTok.
- hddqsb 4y agoEDIT: There is definitely a mismatch between the display URL and the landing page URL. It's not clear to me how that can happen; for example https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jx-gl6K2zQw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jx-gl6K2zQw shows that only the display path can be edited (not the domain), consistently with the wording on https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/2616010 https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/2616010 and https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/2375287 https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/2375287. On the other hand, https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/6368661 https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/6368661 talks about destination mismatch as if it is technically possible and just forbidden by policy. The ad's ID is DChcSEwiPvfuL-YX7AhVmkmYCHUXQC1wYABAAGgJzbQ (displayed when reporting it), the display URL is https://www.gimp.org/ https://www.gimp.org/ and the final location after clicking the ad is https[:]//gilimp[.]org/ (with no intermediate redirects via gimp.org). Update: The DNS records for gilimp.org have been deleted. Archived snapshot: https://web.archive.org/web/20221029152445/https://gilimp.org/ https://web.archive.org/web/20221029152445/https://gilimp.or.... ------------- Original comment: The Reddit user says the ad's display URL was different from landing page URL. If that's the case it is particularly concerning. I believe Google Ads only allows the advertiser to set the path component of the display URL, and takes the domain from the landing page (real) URL; so it's unclear how the mismatch could happen. Maybe the Reddit user took the screenshot on a separate occasion from when they clicked the malicious link, and the ad changed in that time (currently I can see an ad for GIMP, and it links to the official domain, and the linked Twitter thread linked by @pmoriarty says the attacker is actively changing things). The only other explanation I can think of is that the official GIMP website has an open redirect vulnerability.
- weird-eye-issue 4y agoYou can just set any URL you want
- austinpena 4y agoYou can’t set the domain. Just the path.
- 4y ago
- adam1210 4y agoThis has been happening to a smaller project I am affiliated with for years. You can report it to Google - typically they ignore the reports. Occasionally they'll remove the offending ad, but they are just replaced with more ads the following day. I don't think it's preventable.
- TheMiddleMan 4y agoScammers also create ads with fake support contact phone numbers for businesses. People call the scammers and they act like the company and run their scam. Google also allows many deceptive AdSense ads, I constantly have to block ads that run on my website that are nothing but a big "Download Now" button which lead to some malware.
- circular_logic 4y agoAnother variation is for scammers to update the number on google maps to their premium number. Calling it still forwards to the real call center. You can often spot people complaining about a free call to X org costing them hundreds of dollars in google reviews of the company.
- mosfets 4y agoFor anyone who actually wants the issue resolved and help innocent people -- Report the ad. Click the 3 little dots.
- readthenotes1 4y agoIt would be quicker to make ad platforms and ad presenters liable for damages, and pay for fees and fines. Old school ads only threatened to stink up the room with the scratch and sniffs....
- Lonestar1440 4y agoReported to Google, for whatever that's worth. Currently (12:42 Eastern, 29 October) the ad is #1 hit and links to www...giimp...org which further links to some very sketchy looking downloads off the discord CDN. I've been using Bing for a year now. Not perfect, but 1) never seen something like this on it and 2) if Google feels less like an invincible monopolist, perhaps they'll have some incentive to provide an acceptable service.
- Genghis_9000 4y agoyeah part of google worship has created common misconceptions like that things that appear in its automatic index are true answer to whatever question you have in mind (computers cant read minds). "this is the official link for some product" being only one possible question. then theres also the fact that a search engine cannot know the answer to "this is the right link for this software". i miss when search engines were just grep for the web and didnt pretend to be something more this is a good example of how chicken shit design leads to security vulnerabilities. google probably lets the user post one link and make it lead somewhere else when you click it, as a "UX" feature. in reality it makes phishing much easier. this could have been avoided by not being a chicken shit and making links behave as one would expect, at the cost of 1% of use cases no longer working. the whole idea of treating URLs as a UX object is a misconception anyway, URLs should be opaque bit strings.
- juunpp 4y ago> a search engine cannot know the answer to "this is the right link for this software" You would think keeping a curated list of well-known software projects (and others) would be low-hanging fruit. Instead, it is apparently better to throw money into complicated systems... that can't even catch the most basic form of linkjacking. > this is a good example of how chicken shit design leads to security vulnerabilities. google probably lets the user post one link and make it lead somewhere else when you click it, as a "UX" feature. I have always found a bit of subtle arrogance in this kind of thought process. It's like they've never bothered learning the basic functions of the web and how it is meant to work and think they know better than the original creators.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> and think they know better than the original creators. This. Gmail freely warps the email standards when they feel like it. If AMP is a "standard" (I haven't checked) it's a standard that only Goo uses.
- beckingz 4y agoI was able to find this by searching for 'gimp download', and the gimp.org displayed ad redirected to 'gimp dot monster' and looked pretty good otherwise. This is amazingly frustrating because I've wasted weeks of my life trying to deal with how google usually makes this impossible.
- superkuh 4y agoGoing to www.gimp.org and attempting to render that webpage immediately crashes my entire X.org desktop.
- TheDesolate0 4y ago
- hedora 4y agoIn this particular case, I suspect a trademark complaint against Google would make sense. Google misrepresented the ad as the product of the Gimp project, and were paid as a result. They usually use an "obeying the law would not scale" type argument in court, but that would clearly be bullshit in this case. They have a business relationship with the ad buyer, and should have verified their affiliation with gimp.org. Also, a simple string match on the URL would expose the attempted fraud on Google's end. I'm not sure how to check if Gimp is a registered trademark in the US. This page kind of implies it might be (or that the author of the page does not understand trademarks): https://www.gimp.org/about/selling.html https://www.gimp.org/about/selling.html
- dist1ll 4y ago> obeying the law would not scale I don't know why, but that sentence terrifies me. It's like the silicon valley version of a dystopia.
- henrydark 4y agoSome laws were put into place before the current internet scale was imagined and would probably not be made today
- harvey9 4y agoThat's still the exact same dystopian take: complying with the law is too hard for Google so the law should change to the detriment of smaller entities.
- plasticchris 4y agoSo it’s a valid defense to say complying with the law is hard, that’s why I didn’t? Shouldn’t the right course be to change the law before taking such actions?
- dbcurtis 4y agoIndeed. Saying: “Obeying the law doesn’t scale.” is an admission of guilt with pre-meditated intent to break the law. I keep hoping the courts will drive that point home at some point.
- lob_it 4y agoAd-blocking just shows how "the digital naive divide" evolved without them. I can't say enough nice things about gl.inet deviced and switched to a cellular model when ad-blocking on a 4G ipad was too much trouble. I orginally setup a Spitz gl-x750v2 and removed the ec25-af lte and put it in an external enclosure and move it between better spec'd gl.inet routers to run adguard home. "Halt" is a good browser on IOS to block all YT ads, but a portable router workes well with a dedicated sim or tethering a phone. Ads are soooooo 1980's TV :p
- birken 4y ago> dig +short gimp.monster 194.110.203.75 > whois 194.110.203.75 ... role: IT Resheniya LLC nic-hdl: ITR30-RIPE address: ul. Novoselov, d. 8A, of. 692 address: 193079 Saint Petersburg address: Russia abuse-mailbox: abuse@rentaserv.su ...
- oliwarner 4y agoWhy is this allowed? I know Google will do anything for money, but why is Google allowed to signpost a link to gimp.org which actually takes you to g--imp.org (sanitised)? I mean, if nothing else, how do they not share the liability for damages done by the spyware they're literally promoting? For the businesses squatting on the names of more notable ones? AdWords goes too far.
- missedthecue 4y agoIt's not allowed. It'a a violation of Google advertiser policies.
- asddubs 4y agoI feel that what they meant was, why is this even possible to do
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoIt empirically is allowed, though. Google is welcome to claim that it's against their rules, but they still let it through.
- missedthecue 4y agoDo you know how many they ban on a day to day basis? You don't see those, you only the few that get through.
- oliwarner 4y agoBan? They shouldn't need to look for bad actors or ban anyone†, they just shouldn't let people spoof the domain on an advert. At all. What's happening is Google would rather accept the cash up front and keep it if and when someone reports an ad. No forethought is given to people tricked by this. † Obvious exception for unicode squatters but even they should be filtered out entirely automatically. Invisible or misleading characters in your domain should be automatically blocked.
- 4y ago
- TechBro8615 4y agoPlease use old.reddit.com when linking from HN :( Maybe dang could even make it an automatic redirect?
- TheWoodsy 4y agoDoes anyone have a copy of the exe? Would love to poke it for research. Edit: Here be dragons. Found a source: https://old.reddit.com/r/GIMP/comments/ygbr4o/dangerous_google_ad_disguising_itself_as/iu9tz27/ https://old.reddit.com/r/GIMP/comments/ygbr4o/dangerous_goog...
- dbmnt 4y agoIf anyone is mildly curious but doesn't want the actual EXE, here's the VirusTotal analysis: https://www.virustotal.com/gui/file/acea176b67cb7c77dfd0780f7445791719c58a3ba1246e086be1065ea625af0d/detection https://www.virustotal.com/gui/file/acea176b67cb7c77dfd0780f...
- account42 4y agoThat is a lot of red but don't be fooled - it doesn't actually say anything. Those are mostly generic machine-learning results which are prone to false positives which neither the AV vendors nor the operator of VirusTotal (surprise: it's Google again) care to do anything about. Of course whoever went to the trouble to create the scam sites and ads probably also did modify the executables in some malicious way.
- a1371 4y agoI think people are missing the actual issue here. Google used to have a clear distinction between what's an ad and what is organic. In these screenshots you have to pay good attention to see the top result is an ad. To keep their conversion numbers up they had to constantly reduce the difference between the ads and everything else. The fact that they can do this and we are so used to it that we don't first identify that as the culprit is quite interesting. I have ran a few Google ads in the recent years and the people who come through them, some of them, clearly have no idea that they have clicked on an ad. This might be good for business but I think it does more harm overall.
- jmt_ 4y agoI see people do that all the time - inadvertently click an ad because it's one of the first few results that pop up. Not only that, the number of ads shown before the real result has increased too! Just the other day, my boss did a Google search for a common product and was shown at least FIVE ads before the first real result and had to scroll to see that result. I remember the days when you would see one or two ads and the real result as the first thing you saw after a search, not seeing only ads until you scroll down.
- asddubs 4y agothey used to have a yellow background, then a blue button with a white "advertisement" text in it, and it just got more and more subtle over the years. Now it's two characters of text
- Macha 4y agoOn mobile, the text saying Ad is the same size and position as favicons for regular search results, too.
- satellite2 4y agoIt's not enough. I used to always skip the ad of the canonical site I was looking for to avoid incurring them a cost when I knew what I was searching for. But it's often no longer possible. The actual search reasult you want is the ad and the link is no longer duplicated in the organic search results. So you have to click the ad.
- nyanpasu64 4y ago> Most marketing urls have those long ugly urls to tell the advertiser what campaign/source etc you clicked on. So Google let's the advertiser display a fake url for ads. I expected Google Search ads to be above this. But in retrospect I shouldn't be surprised that ads would lie to you.
- belkarx 4y agoSimilar situation with Brave browser from a year ago: https://therecord.media/google-shuts-down-malicious-ad-posing-as-brave-browser-but-delivering-malware/ https://therecord.media/google-shuts-down-malicious-ad-posin...
- grapehut 4y agoThis is a particularly egregious case, I've never seen a fake domain slip through like that before. However, I have reported dozens of phishing sites for the company I worked for. The phisher would simply buy ads for $BRANDNAME and create a convincingly similar site and phish users. I would report the website to "safebrowsing" and report the ad. Typically it would take 1 to 3 days for the website and/or ad to be removed, which would give them enough time to do countless damage. Then they would simply register a new domain, and repeat. At some point the only thing you can do is outbid phishing sites for your own brandname?! It's a shame google can not self-regulate such evil behavior, but it's clear that it should be illegal for google to allow people to buy ads on brandname searches.
- rrwo 4y agoMany years ago I found something similar with Firefox. I notified them (they had a legal category for bug reports, if I recall correctly), and they dealt with it quickly. It's really important to report thibgs lime this to the developers and owners of the software.
- rossjudson 4y agoIt never ceases to amaze me that people will read something like this article and just assume it's correct. Put on your thinking caps and play the game. What else could be going on here?
- taormina 4y agoIt never ceases to amaze me that people will read something this article or comment and just assume Google is correct.
- ohitstyler 4y agoThere needs to be better enforcement on preventing scam websites.
- diminish 4y agoTwitter similarly is full of ads/phishing attacks disguising as some other brands, banks etc. I've reported dozens, yet they never finish coming at me.