3 ms·
In what universe are stock investments not equivalent to cash, for nearly all investors? You buy, you sell, same as forex or gold or turnips. This is real-life
by crazygringo 4y ago
In what universe are stock investments not equivalent to cash, for nearly all investors? You buy, you sell, same as forex or gold or turnips.
This is real-life loss of value. Saying it's "paper value" makes as much sense as saying the money in your bank account isn't cash because it's just "numbers of a screen".
I'm astonished that somebody could think stock losses are somehow less harmful than losing cash. That's just wrong.
- pyuser583 4y agoIt’s only harmful if you buy high and sell low.
- SensoredRooster 4y agoI like where your heads at. Simple yet brilliant!
- edanm 4y agoWhat are you talking about? The almost universal advice before buying stocks is that it's only good for the long term, because at any particular moment it might lose its value. It is always stressed that you shouldn't use money to buy stocks if you might need that money in the next ten years. It is also recommended to move money from stocks to a safer instrument as you get closer to needing to use it.
- izacus 4y agoWhat's a safer instrument in these years though?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIf “in these years” means possibly needing to sell within 0 to 5 years, then safer would be USD, short term treasures, I bonds, muni bonds, AAA corporate bonds (or correspondence bond ETFs), etc.
- qwytw 4y agoThat doesn't change the fact that equity in public companies is basically equivalent to cash (aside taxation etc.)
- lotsofpulp 4y agoPerhaps you mean the liquidity of shares in public companies is “basically” equivalent to the liquidity of cash. But I would disagree there too. There are big differences in liquidity for different companies’ shares, and it varies with time.
- crazygringo 4y agoIf we're talking about liquidity in publicly traded companies, the kind average people are investing in, that doesn't matter for any practical purposes. You might as well say there are big differences in ATM fees depending on where you withdraw money, and it varies by bank. But that's not the point. These tiny details are utterly irrelevant to the fact that stock value is as real as cash. It's not "paper value" where gains and losses are somehow imaginary or don't count.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago>the fact that stock value is as real as cash. It's not "paper value" where gains and losses are somehow imaginary or don't count. Sure, but what is also real is that nominal equity prices can go up or down at anytime, whereas the nominal amounts of cash should not. When VOO price goes down, I think of that as a very different loss than if my checking/savings account balance were to have gone down without me withdrawing from it. One should not expect nominal equity prices to be a certain number, or a certain minimum number, especially single stocks. It is paper value, as far as I am concerned.
- crazygringo 4y ago> I think of that as a very different loss Well you shouldn't. Your net worth is measurably different because it's all liquid. It's a cognitive illusion if you're thinking of them any differently. And if you're making a big financial decision like whether you can afford a bigger house, I sure hope you're treating them the same. And at the end of the day even the nominal value of cash isn't what matters -- it's the real value. Inflation and even currency fluctuation change the real value of what your cash can purchase daily, so the value of your cash is changing too. (The only difference is that cash fluctuations are usually slower and more gradual, and that contracts about future payments are generally denominated in currency rather than equity, but of course not always.)
- crazygringo 4y agoI mean, the universal advice is also not to hold too much cash because it gets eaten away by inflation. But none of this has any relevance to the fact that, for immediate spending purposes, cash and liquid publicly traded stocks are identical. It utterly irrelevant whether you "should" only hold stocks for money you don't think you'll need for 10 years (which is highly debatable, and day traders certainly disagree). The point is, if you need the money next week, your stocks and your cash are identical. That's all that matters.
- ed_elliott_asc 4y agoI can buy turnips but am struggling to find a platform to sell them on
- raverbashing 4y agoSince every turnip is unique, I think that makes them non-fungible. Looks like an unexplored investment avenue.
- georgeecollins 4y ago>> In what universe are stock investments not equivalent to cash GAAP accounting. https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/knowledge/accounting/cash-equivalents/ https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/knowledge/ac...
- funstuff007 4y ago> I'm astonished that somebody could think stock losses are somehow less harmful than losing cash. That's just wrong. People behave much differently if the make or lose $100K in cash, vs making or losing $100K in stock holdings. Wealth effect.
- crazygringo 4y agoNo they don't, not if they have to spend the money now -- like on a down payment for a house. There is literally no difference in wealth between losing $100K in cash or in stock, assuming the stock is liquid. They are equally "real", 100%. And the wealth effect has literally nothing to do with this. (Fine print: assuming your stock is no more than a small fraction of any specific company, and that these might have different effects on taxes. But the general point stands.)
- funstuff007 4y ago> No they don't, not if they have to spend the money now -- like on a down payment for a house If they have to spend the money now, it would already be in cash.
- crazygringo 4y agoThat doesn't make any sense and has nothing to do with the discussion at hand. But if you need to spend the money now, you sell the stocks now so they become cash, which means the stock value is identical to the cash value. That's the whole point. There's no difference between "paper value" and cash value. They're the same. I mean it might take a couple of days for the trade to settle so you can wire it, but that not the point. The value is just as instantaneous and liquid as cash for all practical purposes, for publicly traded companies generally.
- funstuff007 4y agonobody's buying your model of the world and its infinite series of instantaneous of nows.