21 ms·
CD Projekt is remaking the first Witcher game in Unreal Engine 5
- hassanahmad 4y agoNow this is a remake I can actually see as being worth it. This is a great news for the Witcher game fans and these fans numbers are in millions.
- philliphaydon 4y agoOhhhhhh totally gonna play this!
- jason-phillips 4y agoAs someone playing through Witcher 3 on a Steam Deck for the first time, to say that I'm wildly excited about this is not an understatement. Witcher 2 currently appears to be a no-go on the Deck and I'd love to play the rest of the games in the series.
- Aethella 4y agoWitcher 2 also runs perfectly fine on the Deck. You just need to switch to Proton-GE rather than default version.
- COGlory 4y agoThere's also a native version, right?
- cheshire_cat 4y agoThe "native" linux version of Witcher 2 does emulations. Since it's bundled it's very out of date and technology has advanced since then. Witcher 2 had really bad graphics bugs on my Linux playthrough, none of which appeared on Windows.
- zeagle 4y agoDo you mind if I ask what settings you run it on and how happy you are with the performance? I'm precontemplatively considering a steam deck but haven't really looked into it.
- patrickk 4y agoNot OP but ProtonDB has you covered: https://www.protondb.com/app/20920 https://www.protondb.com/app/20920 Fantastic site.
- jason-phillips 4y agoSure. I left it on default settings and the video/graphics performance along with the playability has been truly remarkable. The stereo surround is also quite good. I suppose some criticisms might be that the battery goes pretty quickly (~1 hour) and it does get very warm, but I find these tradeoffs easy to live with. I've only had my deck for about a month and this is my first game to play through on it. I'm a software engineer with a ton of Linux experience so hacking the Deck doesn't scare me at all; I've read quite a bit about it. But I figured I'd give it a go first with the out-of-the-box configuration and so far have been thoroughly impressed.
- zeagle 4y agoThats great. Thanks!
- efficax 4y agohere's an idea: make Witcher 4 instead
- FractalHQ 4y agoTo be fair, they are also working on the Witcher 4 in Unreal Engine 5.
- 4pkjai 4y agoI don't know why, this makes me a bit sad. You can sort of feel a game engine when you're playing a game. The GTA trilogy lost a lot when they did their remastering project with a different engine. Although I'm sure it can be done well. StarCraft remastered was done really well, but I believe they built on top of their existing engine.
- dragontamer 4y agoAs someone who played a few hours of the 1st Witcher Game... Good. No one seems to care about Witcher 1's engine, because it was hot garbage. Any engine (even an off-the-shelf one like Unreal5) will be grossly superior to the trash that the original game was. This remake can have slow, barely workable controls and pretty bad graphics and still be far better than the original game. They really just need the Witcher 1 remade so that people have an entry point into the story. The actual "gameplay" from the original will _NOT_ be missed. IMO anyway.
- verst 4y agoI played the Witcher 1 when it came out and thought it was a brilliant game. I haven't tried going back to it ever. It felt quite polished to me then. I'm curious what people feel isn't approachable for today's audiences. Is is merely that we are used to different visuals now? What are these engine issues in Witcher 1 you speak of? As a player I did not notice them back in the day.
- dragontamer 4y agoIts not the polish that was bad. I've played many 3d action-RPG games. Zelda, Monster Hunter, Dynasty Warriors, etc. etc. Witcher1's combat is by far the worst of the series. Just... laggy, non-responsive controls. But in a bad way (ex: Monster Hunter is also laggy/non-responsive, but in a way that's "obvious" that the slowdown is purposeful and tactical. You need to be very careful about when you attack or not attack vs various monsters in that game). Witcher 1's combat in contrast, has a lot of repetition and not a lot of depth IMO. At least, from what I remember. Witcher2 onwards had much better ideas of "fun combat" experiences. -------- I can still go back to old PS2 era Dynasty Warriors, mash square and have fun. Its not about "dated graphics". I admit dynasty warriors is a mashy-heavy game with a casual mindset, but I think Witcher couldn't really decide if it wanted to be a punishing slow game (like Monster Hunter/Souls series), or a faster twitch game, and just weirdly plays in this unfun position between the two extremes. Its fine to have a slow punishing game (Monster Hunter / Souls / etc. etc.), but you need a huge variety of bosses to keep interest. Witcher 1 felt pretty stale after a short time, since there's just not as much variety. Somehow, I don't find Dynasty Warriors gameplay stale (despite being a square-mash simulator). I don't fully understand why however. I guess DW is more about positioning of the player-character (the enemy army is always winning where you are _not_ located, so Dynasty Warriors feels more like a firefighter simulator, where you're running around the battlefield trying to fix issues in the army... rather than really being a combat game?)
- yieldcrv 4y agoI couldn't get myself to play the first 2 Witcher games due to the dated mechanics but I watched other people stream their play throughs at the time. > [removed] the playing cards players can earn that depict pinup art of Geralt's various sexual partners. The system has been criticized over the years for treating women's bodies as a reward for player progression. This pin-up card collection of your sex partners was edgy in 2007 and 2011 as well. Its not like it was an especially unenlightened age of days bygone. The Pin-Up card system is definitely what put it on the map. Its really funny that CD Project [may] opt to launder its reputation now to reach a broader audience after only getting on the map for being absurd and over the top. I'm not advocating for anything, only observing. The lesson broadcasted is that you have to do "degrading" and shocking things like that to stand out at all. Kind of like how many individuals get started in many industries to support themselves.
- wilg 4y agoI'm not sure "laundering reputation" is how I would frame "re-evaluating including potentially objectionable content in a remake".
- yamtaddle 4y agoMeh. Steam's got a billion games now that do that exact thing. Tons and tons of games did before it, too. The only notable thing about it was having that kind of thing in a game that was otherwise good enough and had enough else going on not to be categorized primarily as a porn game. I'll just wait for it to be modded back in. [EDIT] Actually a few other mainstream non-porn games have done almost the same thing, since, too. The Saboteur comes to mind. Some whole series are all about that sort of thing, like DOA.
- ramosu 4y agosounds like bad news for their internal engineering team
- Tade0 4y ago> Now we know that it's a ground-up remake of the game that introduced Geralt of Rivia to Witcher fans outside of Poland. I was always of the impression that it was Witcher III that achieved this. I'm Polish so I genuinely don't know. Were the previous two installments popular outside of Poland?
- dragontamer 4y agoWitcher 2 was popular in my social circle in the USA. A lot of us went back to Witcher 1 afterwards to get a better idea of the story. So I'd say Witcher 2 was when the series started to get popular. Witcher 3 was riding on 2's coattails. Now that the Netflix show is popular, Witcher1 does deserve a remake.
- AmalgatedAmoeba 4y agoI can only speak for Czechia and here the Witcher II definitely made a splash.
- t0bia_s 4y agoI would say W1 was successful too. At least for me it has stronger story telling then W2 which is too political for me.
- brunoqc 4y ago> Were the previous two installments popular outside of Poland? I would guess so, but the third one was even more popular. Maybe 3 is a bit like Skyrim. I only played the third one. One of my friends was already a fan of the other 2 back then.
- monocasa 4y agoThey were moderately popular games in the US for those that didn't constrain themselves to the AAA powerhouses (no judgement either way). I didn't play them at the time, but knew of their existence and that they were supposed to be good.
- IceWreck 4y ago> Were the previous two installments popular outside of Poland? Witcher 2 was the first time I heard of the franchise.
- vexatus 4y agoRemember: no preorders!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tester756 4y agoCan't wait, Witcher 3 was unparalleled
- haolez 4y agoI've played Witcher I a lot and it's really fun, but I gave up on finishing it after I got stuck in a quest where I was in a cave fighting an infinite horde of enemies (with infinite respawn) and nothing happened no matter how many of them I killed. I hope they fix these kinds of glitches as well.
- hardware2win 4y agoCdpr must release something great to recover their stock which is kinda low now
- agilob 4y agoHas CDPR run out of ideas, but still had a bag of promises to make? They promised CP77 extensions and multiplayer, The Witcher 3 in 4k, now remaking Witcher 1? I'm kindof disappointed with this news and not hearing updates about previous "updates".
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoOn the other hand Geralt waves his sword above his head like an idiot in Witcher 1. I hate remakes but if I had to have one this would be one. https://www.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/rkdbnv/started_playing_witcher_for_the_first_time_whats/ https://www.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/rkdbnv/started_play... But yeah I want new stories more.
- sylens 4y agoYes, this is actually a game that would be well served by a remake that makes it more accessible.
- hbn 4y agoThe top comment in that thread you linked explains that sword movement is something from the books. No one's to say that'll be removed in a remake.
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoI don't remember him doing that in the books haha. He was a beautiful swordsman not a goofball.
- tester756 4y agoIf you're interested in their strategy check out this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5EJmgTQ0O8k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5EJmgTQ0O8k
- nomel 4y agoAnd, it seems like a fantastic way to learn a new engine.
- karaterobot 4y ago> With the game being rebuilt in Unreal Engine 5, Fool's Theory will also have plenty of opportunity to revisit the somewhat clunky combat mechanics of the first game Hopefully they will revisit them just long enough to throw them in the trash and implement an entirely different combat system than the bad ones they had in Witcher 1.
- bitwize 4y agoI get the feeling that a lot of these game remakes are sort of IP normalization moves. Get all the studio's IP onto standard modern tools so that new game devs won't be surprised by custom engines to make maintenance and rerelease easier, especially as the studio transitions from a small boutique studio to a bog-standard AAA sweatshop. I also think this is the reason for Naughty Dog rereleasing The Last of Us on PS5. Though the engine itself was written in C++, it used a lot of Scheme code to generate game data and components and I think they want to move off that because it's baffling to the new devs they want to onboard. I'm waiting for Id Software to throw in the towel and rerelease Unreal versions of Doom (2016) and Doom Eternal.
- sylens 4y agoRemakes are also used to train development teams on new tools. It takes the pressure of a team learning to grapple with a new engine if all of the content is already completed - there's a better scaffolding to build off of.
- jlouis 4y agoFWIW, Id Tech 7 is built to support a game like Doom:Eternal, and nothing more. And the game itself is shaped around the capabilities of the engine. That's why it works. Note Id had a texture streaming system in Rage in order to support a large seamless game world, but they cut that large open world for Doom:2016 and Eternal. In contrast, CDPR's games just grew with each new Witcher release.
- ok_dad 4y agoI am so glad that there are so many avenues for independent game devs now, because large-ish studios seem to have dug a nice little rut in their old IP.
- plsbenice34 4y agoI already played it, so I'm unexcited. Remakes these days generally seem like lazier ways to try to make money compared to making new art from scratch. I thought Cyberpunk was abysmal (though i loved the witcher games) so I wouldn't expect much from them anymore in any case.
- wmichelin 4y agoWhat about Cyberpunk was abysmal to you? I really enjoyed the atmosphere and the gun-play. NPC animations left some to be desired, but overall I thought the graphics were super engaging and Night City was super fun to run around in.
- snuxoll 4y agoNot OP, I wouldn't call CP2077 "abysmal" but even looking outside the bugs the game just wasn't anywhere near the quality I expect from CDPR. The gunplay was actually pretty mediocre, "better than Fallout" is not high praise and that's the best I could give it; the environment was pretty but lacked depth; I, personally, do not care fo * The gunplay was mediocre, in my opinion. "Better than Fallout" is the rating I'd give it, and that's a "you did better coloring inside the lines than the kid with a motor disability" on my scale. * While I'm talking about gameplay, driving ranks as "Better than GTA4", and see above for where that falls on my scale. * The environment was pretty as all hell, but it felt shallow and unlived in due to a lack of unique characters that weren't copy-paste NPCs populating the world, a few fleshed out characters relating to the main story, and some uninspired side mission fillers. Witcher 3 may not be as shiny, or as dense, but the world feels more alive due to the detail put into it. * This is a personal gripe, but I really did not care for the story and ludonarrative dissonance it creates. I'm also not a fan of being given an illusion of choice, when all the endings ultimately play out the same way with a different skin (see: Mass Effect 3). There's more, but those are my biggest issues with the game, even discounting the AWFUL state the game was in for a long time.
- badpun 4y agoI watched some footage of cyberpunk and the characters in it seemed so offputting that I never bought the game. Everyone in the game seemed to be some sort off money-grubbing primitive sociopath or a selfish asshole otherwise. I never bought GTA4/GTA5 for the same reason - I don't want to spend many hours in a game where I interact with characters I detest.
- pipeline_peak 4y agoMore and more it’s looking like the future of game development is Unreal / Unity mods. I think we’re at the point where it’s virtually impossible to make a modern looking game from scratch. We’re already there with browsers.
- Arubis 4y agoI don't want to get my hopes up, but already know they can have my money.
- lakomen 4y agoI, for one, am tired of consuming warmed up content I've played through before. Be it Diablo 2 Resurrected or Mass Effect or or or. Create something new, don't refurbish old stuff. Such a waste.
- pavon 4y agoMany other people enjoy long running series, and CD Projekt is perfectly capable of doing both. CP2077 was a new IP, and they are planning yet another new IP, code named Project Hadar to follow Witcher 4 and the next CP.
- dkersten 4y agoIt’s a 15 year old niche game running on an old janky engine. A lot of people haven’t played it before, so personally I think a remaster is actually warranted in this case, given the popularity of the later games in the series.
- ranger207 4y agoI haven't played it, and 3 was pretty great, so I kinda want to, but I've heard the original is garbage, so I'm excited for a modern release
- lakomen 4y agoIt's not garbage, but how often can you read one and the same book? For people who never played it, meh ok, for me who has consumed pretty much every game since the c64 in the golden days. It's like this "West" vs Russia thing, we had a cold war already, the 90s were awesome but I'm not looking forward to history repeating, 10 steps back into the cold war and hopefully not hot war. Life is about making new experiences, repeating old experiences with better graphics is not exciting at all. It's also lazy.
- impulser_ 4y agoPeople complaining about this being a remake, but I'm assuming they made the remake as a way for their developers to get use to Unreal 5 before making Witcher 4 which is also built using Unreal 5. Easier to build a game you already know in a new game engine than to create a completely new game. Especially if you don't want the game to be filled with bugs. CD has always used in an house game engine for their games.
- nvrspyx 4y agoI don't think that holds if you read the first paragraph of the article. Fool's Theory, a separate studio, is doing the remake in UE5; not CDPR. With that said, this will allow Fool's Theory to help as a support studio for Witcher 4 after the remake since they'll be using the same toolset.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mortenjorck 4y agoExactly; while CDPR and Fool's Theory will be working on different games, they'll be able to share resources extensively given the common platform. I wouldn't be surprised if they divide up work on a lot of the Witcher-specific extensions to Unreal's scripting, AI, and so on.
- whack24 4y agoThis reminds me of how Game Freak sent their recent Pokemon remake out to another studio to work on with different technology while Game Freak makes new franchise IP. 2 examples doesn't make a pattern but is this a known business strategy within game development?
- peruvian 4y agoNot only is this common but it's how some companies have built their reputation and money, see Bluepoint: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bluepoint_Games#Games_developed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bluepoint_Games#Games_develope...
- danschuller 4y agoRemakes make business sense. Every game is a risk. A portfolio of products that includes remakes reduces that risk. A game that was previously popular is easier to remaster than trying to make some new that's less tested. There are always brand new gamers to introduce to your IP as well as existing gamers who may have missed or want to replay earlier games. If you're a mature studio it's almost irresponsible to not do this. The more interesting part of the story is Unreal is being used. For a while Unity and Unreal have been pushing out in-house engines. Again standard tools make it easier to hire expertise and use existing solutions and assets, they're also far cheaper than running a full engine team. Supporting a custom engine is a massive undertaking at the high end (ignore the tech, on-boarding people, docs, QA, surrounding tools for artists, sound designers, localisation etc. And then making it work on a wide variety of hardware and working around any graphics bugs etc).
- _the_inflator 4y agoI agree with you. And it is still hard to get it wright in order to be sold. If you want to stand up to competition, you need a cash cow. I don't blame any independent studio to do just that. They have to balance risks.
- smoldesu 4y agoIt's also a really good time to get into the remake business, tech-wise. We have a bunch of fresh new consoles optimized for the latest game engines, and tons of ML-based upscaling tech to play with. If you make a well-designed remake of your game optimized for solid-state storage, you should have a version that lasts a couple decades into the future.
- WorldMaker 4y ago> The more interesting part of the story is Unreal is being used. For a while Unity and Unreal have been pushing out in-house engines. This is exactly the case for CD Projekt Red. They built their own engine (RED Engine) for Witcher 1 and built on top of it for the two Witcher sequels and also pushed it to its very limits for Cyberpunk 2077. A lot of useful criticism of the technological pains (delays, marketplace reception issues) they experienced with Cyberpunk was that they were using an in-house game engine unprepared for that genre (jumping from a game series where the fastest vehicle was a horse to one with cars and flying cars and planes is maybe not the easiest straight line). CDPR responded to that criticism, especially from their shareholders, that they would be minimizing that risk in future games development and externalizing that dependency and moving to an out-of-the-box game engine moving forward (including in that announcement that it would be Unreal). This announcement for the Witcher 1 remake seems like a proper and interesting "full circle" for this story: CDPR's last engine was built entirely for Witcher 1. Using off-the-shelf Unreal to remake Witcher 1 sounds like a smart way on paper to get their feet wet and move on from the old engine to the new one using a project they are already familiar with and can help them realign from old pipelines to new ones.
- bergenty 4y agoIt needs to be exactly the same with better graphics and sound design. I’m going to be very mad if they start covering up boobs, introduce some hamfisted woman protagonist or something along those lines.
- shmerl 4y agoI'd like to see a native Linux version this time, since UE5 supports it. That said, original game with customized Aurora engine is very good. No big need for a remake, but if they'll make it fully open world it might be adding something interesting, besides simply improved graphics.
- AdmiralAsshat 4y agoSometimes remakes can actually improve accessibility to an older game with a dated engine/mechanics and make it more enjoyable for newcomers to experience the earlier entries. See: Yakuza Kiwami and Yakuza Kiwami 2 (remade using the excellent Yakuza 0 engine/mechanics). I do own Witcher 1/Witcher 2 (bought no-doubt during some Steam sale for like $5-$15, tops), and I vaguely recall playing W1 for like a half hour, then put it down and never touched it again. But somehow I then put 90+ hours into Witcher 3. So yes, the idea of Witcher 1's story remade into a modern engine sounds great. Heck, I would've settled for just Witcher 3's engine. I don't think I'd plop $60 for it--especially considering I waited until I could grab W3 GOTY Edition for like $20 before buying--but it's definitely something I'd eventually want to check out.
- jdaw0 4y agoI think yours is a pretty common experience considering that Witcher 3 was a huge mass-market success and Witcher 1 was a niche product made both by and for insane people. I say this as a shameless Witcher 1 apologist.
- Ntrails 4y agoI really wanted to play the games in order, but I found the gameplay in 1 un-fun and quit. I almost regret how long it put me off 3
- duped 4y agoWitcher 1 has a decent story and world (in no small part due to the source material). But the gameplay itself is some of the worst that you experience. They could have redone it as a Carmen San Diego style dialog game and it would have been better than the turd they shipped. It's really quite bad.
- jpgvm 4y agoThis is true. The story carried Witcher 1. Gameplay was vastly improved in 2 and I have mixed feelings about 3, the game was definitely more successful and I think you can partially attribute that to changes that made it easier to play and thus much more console friendly. I for one welcome a UE5 remake of Witcher 1 and will purchase it for sure, if only for nostalgia sake.
- ianbutler 4y agoWitcher 1 wound up being an unexpected hit for me. But I have a thing for the game play style of that game, being a WoW player for a long time. I totally get how it doesn't appeal to a lot of people and I hope this increases the reach of a game with a good story with otherwise dated gameplay.
- generationP 4y ago"Canis Majoris" hehe, they sure know who the main boss of the game is.
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y agoThis is a smart move imo: they can gain xp and build tooling for unreal 5. Part of what killed their last game is their engine. Now they can learn how to use a real game engine with a lower stakes game and prepare for witcher 4 or whatever comes next.
- tonymet 4y agoremakes are great and appeal to gamers who may have missed out on a generation. I loved Witcher 3 and never played witcher 1. I'd rather keep my existing hardware and play a remake than pay for upgraded hardware and play a dud.
- jlouis 4y agoWitcher 1 is a game in a number of acts, where each act is a relatively small closed space. It would be a really great way to get some UE5 knowledge to transplant into other games. By keeping those parts static in development, you get to use all the interesting new UE5 tech such as Lumen and Nanite.
- ezekiel68 4y agoI'll play it, of course. But I'm still enamoured with the perfect imperfections of their first effort.
- pmarreck 4y agoOften the only thing that dates a game are the graphics (and sometimes the UI), so I'm all in favor of good graphical remakes where the original mechanics and story were sound
- sombragris 4y agoI began to play games more since the onset of the pandemic. One of the first games that I played was The Witcher 1. I actually played all three games in the series, but started with the first. Of all three series, TW1 combat is the one I liked the best (seriously). Once you got the hang of it, it felt quite natural. On the other hand, TW2 combat felt like a stupid regression. TW3 combat was good but not as good as the first installment of the series. Other things I liked from the first game and I honestly think are the best in all three games: - lore system and content - signs - alchemy - potions - character progression and development. Also, it is quite playable on Intel onboard GPUs. I'm excited to learn that a remake is in the works, but I am afraid that all the above (and also romance cards, due to stupid PC stuff) will be gone in the remake.
- glanzwulf 4y agoA hill I will die on is that Witcher 1 had good combat and should remain as is. But I can just feel that they will change it, and I already hate it.
- ajuc 4y agoCD Projekt is outsourcing this to another company to be precise. I wonder if they will give them their cut-scene creation technology. It was one of the best parts of The Witcher 3 - the cinematography was great and showed the emotions much better than in any CRPG I played to this day.
- casey2 4y agoHope it fails hard, fuck remakes.
- adaga 4y agoI'm both excited and terrified. Excited b/c the Witcher is amazing and should be brought back for new players to experience. Terrified b/c it gives Bethesda another way to put Skyrim out into the void - "The Unreal_edition_final_we_promise."
- zelphirkalt 4y agoI hope they build in jumping and do not change the combat system too much.