7 ms·
Actually it's not. Constitution design is an academic field, a very niche area of political science, and nobody would ever implement anything like the US Const
by crazygringo 4y ago
Actually it's not.
Constitution design is an academic field, a very niche area of political science, and nobody would ever implement anything like the US Constitution today. It would be like using ALGOL for a new project today instead of Python or Java.
The US Constitution was very much a version 1.0 project, written before people even knew political parties would be a design constraint. Constitutions are on like version 5 or 6 now. (I'm making up numbers but you get the idea.)
- ETH_start 4y agoYou can't compare Constitutions to programming languages in terms of the prevailing consensus on their utility. While the latter has a vast test bed of real world utilization that reveals PL efficacy, the former can only be evaluated from the standpoint of theory, with a heavy heap of ideology.
- crazygringo 4y agoYou don't think academics are constantly comparing the real world utilization of constitutional forms...? Allow me to introduce to you, comparative politics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_politics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_politics Lest you think this is ideological or theoretical, no -- it's entirely about collecting data of real-world political operation, how similar or different constitutional structures result in similar or different outcomes given similar or different populations and histories.
- ETH_start 4y agoThe real world data is extremely limited, given there are only ~200 countries in the modern era, and the huge span of time over which the full impact of a constitution is seen. It's incomparable to PLs, which have perhaps billions of case studies on which comparative analysis can be done.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoRemind me how many PL's there are again.
- funcDropShadow 4y agoNot GP here. I would estimate the number of programming languages is in the thousands, but the number of languages with multiple implementations and long-term maintained programs written in it is probably below one hundred. All the others do not contribute a meaningful body of real-world data for the purpose to learn from programming language design. But they might have contributed knowledge of about the design space of programming languages.
- crazygringo 4y agoActually the more I think about it, the more useful I do find the comparison between constitutions and programming languages. Because there are probably only ~200 PL's with truly significant usage, and they tend to have a variety of purposes and be used in historically different contexts -- much like constitutions. The same arguments that programmers have over declarative vs imperative is much like the arguments political scientists have over parliamentary vs presidential. Static vs dynamic type checking is much like civil law vs common law. Perhaps the rise of congressionally-created federal agencies is akin to the rise of object-oriented programming? And there's similarly nothing "scientific" in proving that one programming language is "better" than another, but people have strong opinions, and experience will tell you which ones are good ideas to pick for a project and which ones are not. By the way, I'm not sure you know what a case study is -- it's a report written by a person. Nobody's written billions of those. And you don't do comparative analysis on case studies -- a comparative analysis is a case study, where the cases are countries (or programming languages).
- edgecasestdio 4y agoI'm also wary to use programming languages as a metaphor to advance a view about writing constitutions. I can agree with the broad point that inertia is a major cause for constitutions to stay the same over time. But I disagree with the original commenter's implication that more recently-written constitutions tend to be better than older ones due to lessons from the past, because of the idea (perhaps relating to yours) that contemporary political and ideological considerations can introduce weaknesses into more recently-written constitutions, which overlook potential lessons from the past.
- WalterBright 4y agoPeople don't learn very well from the past.
- trelane 4y agoAh, interesting. How many have they tried experimentally?
- kelseyfrog 4y agoParliamentary systems are generally considered more stable than presidential systems and tend to more naturally express multiparty politics (Australia and UK not withstanding). Even while many people in the US might like the things a parliamentary system has to offer, there is no viable way to transition to one culturally. As much Americans hate how politics works presently, they hate the idea of replacing it even more. The socio-cultural hesitancy is real, paradoxical, and cannot be ignored.
- epicureanideal 4y ago> Australia and UK not withstanding ..cites two of the most important examples
- sidewndr46 4y agoOne of the key features of a lousy theory is when you need to ignore the most prominent data points in order to have it be applicable.
- tomp 4y ago> Parliamentary systems are generally considered more stable Hm... Germany's system changed at least 3 times in the 20th century. France is on its Fifth Republic. Italy is a shitshow. To me it seems that the oldest democracies (UK, US) are the most stable (even today!) and they're majority systems (first-past-the-post).
- kelseyfrog 4y agoTo actually do comparative politics, you need to regress over regimes not just call out counter examples. This is a quantitative problem, not a logic problem.
- PinesOfRome 4y agoElaborate on this. How do political parties affect the equation here, and what would the more modern approach be? Any texts you can recommend regarding this?
- crazygringo 4y agoWell, checks and balances in the American constitution were founded on the idea that there would be no "factions" (parties), and so the three branches (legislative, executive, judicial) would balance each other without any single group ever taking over. In reality, when Democrats or Republicans capture all 3 branches, it utterly defeats the entire premise of the Constitution. The modern approach is generally a parliamentary system rather than a presidential system, and multiparty proportional representation (sometimes with multi-member districts) rather than two-party first-past-the-post single member districts. Some places to start: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentary_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentary_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_representation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_representation If you want to look at more "advanced" constitional forms, then consociationalism is a good place to start, although much less widely adopted and more controversial as to whether it's progress or not: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consociationalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consociationalism
- akiselev 4y ago>* Well, checks and balances in the American constitution were founded on the idea that there would be no "factions" (parties), and so the three branches (legislative, executive, judicial) would balance each other without any single group ever taking over.* I’m not a constitutional scholar but I take issue with that characterization. Federalist #10 by James Madison is all about factions, how they are inevitable, and how the system of government should be structured so that their self interests balance out for the good of the nation. Madison wrote the Virginia Plan which proposed the three branches of government and he wrote down exactly what his thinking was at the time. For most of the 18th century the British empire was a single party state ruled by the Whigs which is what they were trying to avoid by explicitly allowing room for many factions.
- briantakita 4y agoIt depends on whose interests are being served. In software, version 1.0 could be what made the project successful with the user-base while subsequent versions introduce features which help other entities such as advertisers & the interests of anonymous share-holders to extract profit & control from the user-base. Sometimes, popular features, such as an open api, are removed to consolidate the market as well. I'll take a version 1.0 which is focused on reifying the natural God-given rights of man vs version 3.0 which reifies power of the State & Corporate "persons" over man.
- briantakita 4y agoA corollary, which I have discovered with Philosophy, maintaining software, performing large-scale refactoring, etc. and many have discovered before me... The primitive low-level tech opens the space to what is possible. Improving low level components opens up a large space of possibility that is often inconceivable at the time the improvement is done. The reverse is disimproving low level components restricts the range of possibilities. This is why we have seen so much churn in the front end & application libraries. More recent programming languages and front end & application libraries have sought to improve the low level apis to improve the development context of complex software. A more evolved system (e.g. version 3.0) built with worse components is bound by the lack of quality of it's underlying components. So if version 3.0 Constitution is built with disimprovements in version 2.0 or earlier, it could be rendered worse than a version 1.0 built with quality components & quality first principles.
- ralph84 4y agoIf the newer versions are better why do they end up being so short-lived?
- Rexxar 4y agoIf we continue the programming language metaphor: the same reason that nobody want to change the Cobol program on the old mainframe but is ready to rewrite more recent projects.
- whatshisface 4y agoBecause the constitution is nothing compared to the intent to follow it.
- walleeee 4y agoif fictional explorations of this idea are worth anything, le Guin's Dispossessed are a people whose determination to abide by a set of principles led them to write their constitution not just on paper but directly into the human language faculty
- nohaydeprobleme 4y agoThis is a good question that motivated a feature-length article published in The Economist this summer (which I've also referenced elsewhere in this comment section) [1]. The article argues that newer versions of constitutions are often overly lengthy due to attempting to include too many laws within the constitution, which can cause problems. The article argues: "Overly long constitutions often create conflicts between articles that can only be resolved with further tampering. And “if everything is highest law, then nothing is highest law anymore,” points out Dr Versteeg. Omnibus amendments require voters to balance the merits and drawbacks of many changes at once, making it harder to generate consensus." In brief, the article's view is that the inclusion of too many laws in more recently-written constitutions leads to greater incentives for constitutional rewrites as times and political views change, which is why the article favours shorter constitutions that guarantee fundamental rights, and are thus difficult to rewrite. [1] (Paywalled, though I've included a summary above): https://www.economist.com/international/2022/08/25/dictators-and-utopians-are-fond-of-fiddling-with-constitutions https://www.economist.com/international/2022/08/25/dictators...
- pyuser583 4y agoThe v5 or v6 would be Canada and South Africa - which have widely praised (by legal scholars) Constitutions. But neither are really great or terrible. Canada didn’t really change much, and South Africa hasn’t been doing great. The “West German Basic Law” was widely condemned: * it was unrealistic to have strong privacy protections for a nation filled with refugee camps and few private homes * the protections for the family were meaningless when so few nuclear families survived (something like 70% of the country was female) * the mandate to reunify was unrealistic and possibly undesirable * there were no provisions for the victims of Nazi Germany * it favored the establishment of strong, stable leaders - which brought back memories of Hitler * many of the civil liberties - such as abolishing the death penalty - were just excuses to prevent punishment of war criminals (which was true) * claiming the lands East of the Oder as part of Germany was unrealistic Buy it turned out to be an extremely effective Constitution that lead to the transformation of Germany and its eventual reunification (mostly).
- theluketaylor 4y agoAs a Canadian I'd be surprised to learn our constitution was considered top notch by legal scholars. The amendment process is very onerous. 7/10 provinces haven't ever really agreed on the colour of the sky, let alone something as important as new constitutional rules. It took some very special backroom wrangling to pass it in the first place and I don't see a path to amending it during my lifetime. Meech Lake came close and very nearly broke the country. The notwithstanding clause was necessary to get it passed at all, but really takes some of the teeth out of the charter of rights and freedoms. When parties hold majority control of the House of Commons or a provincial legislature a lot of what keeps their power in check is mostly norms it turns out. One of the few actual laws that would really impede them is the charter, but portions of it can be ignored. Overall I'm very happy we have the 1982 Constitution Act, but I certainly wouldn't offer it up as a blueprint if someone came asking for assistance in drafting a constitution. The Charter itself as a portion of the larger constitution (minus the notwithstanding clause) is a very special piece of law that deserves some recognition internationally, but as a whole it wasn't even 10 years before the real issues were exposed with the whole document.
- 4y ago
- mlindner 4y agoThis speech is a good reference point. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ggz_gd--UO0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ggz_gd--UO0 Just because you wrote a good constitution doesn't make the government good. You can put anything you want into a constitution if you don't have the institutions set up right to maintain it. Further, it's intentional that the federal government at times becomes unable to do it's job in times of intense disagreement. That was an intentional design feature.
- brigandish 4y agoIt's a version of the English Bill of Rights 1689 so I'm not sure where you get the idea it's version one as the 1689 one wasn't even version one for England.
- HaZeust 4y ago1689 was only 4 years into Enlightenment, and the collective recognition of "personal rights" that is most-often cited as the Enlightenments greatest achievement also just happens to be a fundamental aspect of 1789 Constitution - and ALL Constitutions moving forward. THAT'S where the "V.1" honor comes from.
- brigandish 4y agoAside from it being utterly irrelevant when the Enlightenment started as to whether the Bill of Rights 1689 was a precursor to the 1789 ones, how does John Locke fit into that choice of start date for the Enlightenment?
- indymike 4y agoYou don’t write low level, close to the hardware software with Python or Java. You use something like C, Rust or assembler. Constitutions are the firmware. Building nations is an old, old craft and the legal instruments used to define have been being written for thousands of years. In many ways our constitution is the Rust of these documents in that it focused on security of structure and by the time it was ratified, security of individual rights over everything else. Most that seek to change the constitution want to take away rights or add new ones. It is good it is hard to change, especially when many of the change seekers can’t even get the popular support to get a law passed or a veto overridden.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> individual rights over everything else I used to admire the US constitution. I've grown up now. Who could possibly be opposed to human rights - i.e. human beings having rights? And indeed, the US constitution does appear to be largely about rights. Over the years I've increasingly leaned to the view that these rights are mostly a legal fiction, and that the things that are supposedly rights are highly subjective political footballs. Nowadays I think of a constitution as a largely non-political set of rules for how government works; i.e. it's a description of a mechanism, not a description of an outcome. From that point of view, the US Constitution is an awful constitution.
- tomp 4y ago> Who could possibly be opposed to human rights - i.e. human beings having rights? And indeed, the US constitution does appear to be largely about rights. What do you mean? US citizens have pretty much the most rights of any people in the world. Can you list the countries that guarantee freedom of speech, freedom to bear arms, freedom from unreasonable searches and freedom to stay silent (not incriminate yourself)? (Of course, the implementation of these rights is ... imperfect.)
- kasey_junk 4y agoThat’s begging the question. If you define rights specifically by enumerating how they are defined in the bill of rights of course the US comes out on top. That’s before your hedge about implementation. In practice the US performs rather badly when scores on civil liberties. Here is one methodology https://knoema.com/atlas/ranks/Civil-liberties-index?mode=amp https://knoema.com/atlas/ranks/Civil-liberties-index?mode=am... but you can find similar results across many others. Just take our prison population per capita if you want a glaring metric on how poorly we do at freedom.
- knewter 4y agoI have a friend who, when he was younger, dearly wanted to write kernel drivers in JavaScript.
- denton-scratch 4y agoJava? I wouldn't dream of writing the software equivalent of a modern constitution in Java.
- antikneejerk 4y agoCan you give an example of a version 5 or 6 constitution that is working well in the world?
- naasking 4y ago> The US Constitution was very much a version 1.0 project, written before people even knew political parties would be a design constraint. Constitutions are on like version 5 or 6 now The mistake here is thinking that "political science" is actually a science, and so being on "version 5 or 6" is actually some kind of objective marker of progress in knowledge. That's a dubious assertion at best.
- TurkishPoptart 4y agoI don't think these are comparable fields.