7 ms·
Our Federal constitution is fairly concise Concise to the point of vacuous. It says practically nothing. It describes only the barest outlines of government, a
by jfengel 4y ago
Our Federal constitution is fairly concise
Concise to the point of vacuous. It says practically nothing. It describes only the barest outlines of government, and effectively all of the actual implementation has been a matter of legislation, judicial decisions, and tradition. Individual words are scrutinized as if they will somehow be unambiguous if we stare at them long enough, or bring in enough cherry-picked outside context.
The section on the courts is especially hilariously short. It basically says "We should have one". Everything after that -- included the vaunted ability of the Supreme Court to "interpret the constitution", is a matter of them deciding that it was something they were going to do and everybody else going along with it.
- tptacek 4y agoI don't think this is true. For instance, compare US defamation law to UK defamation law. The distinctions, which are large, are entirely because of the structure of our constitution. Or look at the rules of evidence in Europe, where you don't necessarily have a right to avoid self-incrimination, or to exclude evidence gained unlawfully.
- hammock 4y agoAll distinctions which were created by amendments
- Rebelgecko 4y agoIMO we should probably differentiate between the BOR and amendments which came later
- dragonwriter 4y ago> IMO we should probably differentiate between the BOR and amendments which came later Of the 27 amendments that have been ratified, the most recent was one of the twelve submitted as the Bill of Rights, so there are literally none that have come later. Sixteen have come in between (one from the BOR was never passed.) Also, the most relevant amendment to the issues upthread, for most purposes in US law (since things like defamation law and most of the cases where the evidence differences matter are state, not federal) is the 14th, which is not part of the BOR.
- lupire 4y agoSilly nitpicks don't change the fact the first 10 amendments were passed in 1791.
- humanrebar 4y agoUniversal suffrage amendments came later and we like those too.
- prottog 4y ago> It says practically nothing. Is that not the whole point? "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."
- nathanaldensr 4y agoThis basic fact eludes the intelligentsia who all assume that federal power is The Way Things Are (or Should Be). They assume it's the default position, when in fact the Framers intended it to be a bare-bones fallback for only basic things like the national defense.
- jdmichal 4y agoThey found a nice workaround with federal taxation though. There's a lot of instances where the states technically have the power to pass different laws than what's federally blessed. However, they'll lose federal funding if they do. And the majority of the time, that's just not a good trade-off. So the federal government is essentially taxing the state's citizens, then giving some amount of it back to the states in exchange for rowing the boat in the right direction. States that increase their own taxes to compensate for refusal of federal funds would become noncompetitive to other states who don't.
- lupire 4y agoThat's because the SCOTUS is inherently Federal, and so is biased toward Federal power.
- jquery 4y agoThe biggest strike against states rights in recent memory was the removal of the SALT deduction, one of the strongest protectors of state power. Now states with higher tax burdens are much less competitive, because the citizens of that state don’t benefit nearly as much for what they pay.
- 4y ago
- WalterBright 4y agoThe Bill of Rights is particularly brilliant in its conciseness. A lawyer once said that "show me a contract that's one page, and I won't be able to break it. Show me one 20 pages long, and I'll break it."
- the_only_law 4y agoYet somehow it still gets broken.
- dragonwriter 4y agoSo, by your standard, the Bill of Rights can’t be “broken” by a lawyer, that is, they can’t get a court to apply it in something other than the intended manner. But virtually every significant phrase in the Bill of Rights has been applied in multiple different ways by different courts over the years, so clearly lawyers have had no trouble breaking it.
- stale2002 4y ago> so clearly lawyers have had no trouble breaking it. You are missing the point. The point is comparing it to a hypothetical constitution that is 20 pages long, instead of 1 page long. So, the 20 page long constitution, is probably easier to break, despite you misleading focus, on the irrelevant point, of the exact way the statement was phrased.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe BoR has been under continuous and relentless assault for well over two centuries. It is battered and bloodied, but has held up surprisingly well.
- candiddevmike 4y agoThe recent abortion ruling disagrees with you. Same with the Patriot Act.
- 4y ago
- torstenvl 4y agoIt may appear that way, especially if someone doesn't make it their life's work. But although concise, it is rich in meaning. You call out Article III, for example, so I'll focus on that. It doesn't say "we should have a Supreme Court and other courts Congress may establish." It says the judicial power of the United States shall be vested in them, and that judges shall be appointed. It isn't magisterial or clerical power. It clearly establishes the United States as a common law system. That's further reinforced by the use of the term jurisdiction — literally the power to say what the law is. It's clear that any and all courts established by Congress are "inferior" to the Supreme Court, which is a significant protection of judicial independence. It's also clear that Congress can't reduce their pay as retribution - ditto. And that's just the first section. It's a much richer document than your previous comment gives it credit for.
- HaZeust 4y agoYour entire argument falls under when you take into consideration that the very judicial power that's "vested" to the Supreme Court in its jurisdiction is solely delegated to Judges that Congress appoints. Congress should not get to seat its own checks and balances, and it doesn't particularly matter if Congress is only allowed to establish and ordain inferior courts to that of the Supreme Court, if they already effectively establish and ordain the Supreme Court's delegations - and thereby its power.
- PubliusMI 4y ago
- HaZeust 4y ago
- dang 4y agoPosting like this will get you banned here, regardless of how wrong someone else is or you feel they are. I'm not going to ban you right now because (unlike with the other account) I didn't see a lot of this in your history—but please don't do it again. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html